4.7
Superb
283 Reviews
9825 Main Road, Mattituck · 8.04 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Sprinkled Ice Cream Sandwiches
- Cookie Monster
- Rainbow Cookie
- Birthday Cake
“My wife an I are late bloomers. We only found Magic Fountain at the beginning of Summer 2025. I can eat any Ice Cream. However, my wife can't have any dairy, specifically casein. We've tried a few other places (we're in Port Jeff Station nowadays) and both grew up in southern Nassau. Any place I would stop by...usually had nothing for her..maybe lemon ice. plus the staff would get screwed up (one time, a local place gave her regular ice cream instead of non,-dairy). Well..we stopped by in Summer 2025, I walked in and said my wife CAN'T have dairy. Every staff member looked and understood. They pointed out the non dairy ice creams they MAKE there, along with Sorbet including a Blood Orange, which she loved. My first time, I tried Kulfi..which was delicious. since then, we average twice a month..taking almost an hour ride, just for ice cream. It's that worth it. Some of the flavors I've had there; Kulfi Guiness Honey Lavender Lemon Ginger Coffee and other assorted flavors. I'm 70..having lived on the Island all my life. Remembering Jahn's of RVC, and countless other Ice Cream Shoppes..but THIS IS THE BEST!!”