13 Best Seafood Restaurants in Hampton Bays

Cowfish Seafood • $$$
258 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Brussels Sprouts
Blackened Fish Sandwich
Reuben Like No Other
Jumbo Diver Scallops
Iron Skillet Cookie
Banana Cream Pie
Clam Chowder Soup
Skillet Cornbread
Seared Ahi Tuna
Salmon Romesco

“Great location on the water. The service was impeccable, the waitress took order for 6 people without taking notes and nailed every meal and drink. Amazing. The clam chowder was delicious although the NY steak was a little tougher than I expected, but the side of truffle fries almost made up for it.Would return and recommend as all the dishes looked great.“

4.5 Superb124 Reviews
R.AIRE at The Hampton Maid Spanish
259 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays

Customers` Favorites

Wagyu Steak over Paella
Patatas Bravas
Creme Brulee
Paella Meat
Duck Breast
Rare Ros
Ceviche

“This is a follow up to our 2023 review of R., Aire at the Hampton Maid in Hampton Bays. As superb as R. Aire was during the past eighteen months, recent visits underscore that the restaurant continues to reach new culinary heights under Chef and Owner Alex Bujoreanu. In a landscape of high priced and often mediocre restaurants on the East End, R. Aire is a unique venue - a chef driven restaurant which offers sophisticated cuisine inspired by the classics of Spain - in an elegant, serene setting - and at moderate prices.Although we have previously taken note of R. Aire’s outstanding signature paellas, the “non rice” sections of the menu offer a range of equally delicious dishes - all made with the finest (and often local) ingredients and reflecting the chef’s masterful synthesis of both classical and modern influences.For example, Chef Bujoreanu offers an amazing Fideua - a short grain pasta dish cooked in the method of paella (in a paella pan) in a richly flavored sofrito. R. Aire’s Fideua is a textural wonder, served two ways - as a seafood and squid ink classic or a rustic wild mushroom and duck version. Fideua is rarely offered in the U.S. - these renditions are authentic and superb.R. Aire’s appetizers and small plate “pinchos”offer an array of delectable choices, from flavorful morsels of grilled lamb (Morunos), aromatic grilled Shishito peppers, succulent octopus, airy meatballs and a lovely heirloom beet salad. One could construct a deeply satisfying dinner from these perfectly composed small plates.In addition to the Fideua and traditional paellas for which R. Aire is known - the paellas have a perfect “socarrat” base and are cooked to order and served in individual paella pans - the non rice dishes are equally impressive. Memorable main courses include pristine local sea scallops, breast of duck, Iberico pork and a filet mignon of Wagyu beef. This is cooking at a very high level.The service at R. Aire is warm and inviting. The restaurant’s gracious manager, Grigore, provides an attentive hands on presence in the dining room; he is clearly focused on delivering the service and hospitality which has been the restaurant’s credo since it opened.It should be noted the restaurant’s wine list has continued to evolve, offering a range of wines from Spain and the U.S. and other wine regions from excellent producers - and at fair prices.In a world of formulaic restaurants and homogeneous food, R. Aire stands out for its warmth, value and brilliant cooking. Bravo to Chef Bujoreanu and his team for creating a special venue in Hampton Bays.“

4.5 Superb80 Reviews

3
Rumba

Rumba Caribbean • $$
43 Canoe Place Rd, Hampton Bays

Customers` Favorites

Dominican Ribs with a Sweet Chili Ginger Soy Glaze and Fresh Herbs
Shrimp Taco and Smothered Pulled Rib Taco
Award Winning Key Lime Pie
Oconut Risotto Island Slaw
Jerk Chicken Taco
Grilled Artichokes
Fried Plantains
Coconut Shrimp
Chicken Wings
Duck Empanadas

“You cannot beat their Happy Hour! Half priced cocktails and appetizers from 3-6 on weekdays. My personal favorites are the ahi tuna, duck empanadas, and shrimp. For drinks, I recommend the rum punch and the margaritas. Their jerk chicken sandwich and tuna salad are great entrees. The staff is also incredibly friendly!“

4.6 Superb98 Reviews
Villa Paul Italian • $$
162 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays

Customers` Favorites

Oysters Rockefeller and Oysters Casino
Roast Long Island Duckling
Chicken Parmigiana
Almond Joy Sundae
Veal Saltimbocca
Eggplant Tower
Fried Calamari
Onion Soup
Baked Clams
Escargot

“Food was excellent and service was very attentive. I think prices are reasonable. Was disappointed that we had to sit in the other room on Valentine's Day...it was bright and no fireplace. No real decor. The main dining area was much nicer.“

4.7 Superb39 Reviews
Fins and Forks American • $$
78 Foster Ave, Hampton Bays

Customers` Favorites

Fried Calamari
Chicken Wings
Key Lime Pie
Scallops

“What an adorable spot! The servers were very kind to allow us outside seating and turned the lights on for us. Our server was super helpful and cheery and enjoyed the night with us. The seafood penne a la vodka had plenty of lobster in it and they were kind enough to oblige our request for a different sauce for the steak. The merengue key lime was also delish! I’m surprised this place doesn’t have more reviews, such a nice gem in Hampton Bays!“

4.5 Superb51 Reviews
The Station Bar Bar & Grill • $$
22 Shinnecock Rd, Hampton Bays

Customers` Favorites

Teriyaki Tuna Tidbits
Baked Clams
Clams on the
Burger
Fries

“Love this place! My husband & I come here sometimes. Everybody is so nice, great menu & the food is delish! Great outdoor space with nice canal views!! Gets super busy in the summer & they have live music as well!! Check out their FB page!!“

4.5 Superb35 Reviews
Edgewater Restaurant Italian • $$$
295 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan
Blueberry Waffle
Side of Risotto
Fried Calamari
Shrimp Risotto
Lobster Pasta
Garlic Bread
Crab Bisque
Lamb Chops
Tiramisu

“Came here for a bridal shower and couldnt believe the view and food! The spaghetti and meatballs was extraordinarily delicious and they kept the amazing bread coming! I even asked for extra to take home. They did an amazing job hosting the bridal shower. I have it on my radar to go back for dinner in the near future as well. Great experience here.“

4.3 Superb100 Reviews
Canal Cafe Seafood • $$
44 Newtown Rd, Hampton Bays

Customers` Favorites

Double Coleslaw Instead of French Fries
Steamed Littleneck Clams
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Guacamole and Chips
Fried Shrimp Tacos
Fried Shrimp Hero
Fish and Chips
Fried Calamari
Fish Sandwich
Lobster Roll

“I recently ate at this restaurant with a good friendYou look out the window and can see Shinnecock canal beautiful view in summer you can dine outside tooI like fish and chips and the cod was fresh battered and the sweet potato fries great tooMy friend had the steamed razor clams in garlic sauce along with breaded calamari he managed to eat the clams but had to take the calamari home to his wifeDraft beer fresh dessert“

4.2 Good77 Reviews
Lighthouse Seafood Seafood Markets • $$
36 Lighthouse Rd, Hampton Bays

“we still miss the days of Cor-J but fortunately little has changed and this is still our #1 choice for seafood on the east end~ best product/selection + knowledgeable staff. they'll do #littlenecks on the halfshell (when we dont have time to shuck at home) it's a dream and reasonably priced. the blackfish was write-home-about level delicious“

4.2 Good21 Reviews
Sundays On The Bay American • $$
369 Dune Rd, Hampton Bays

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
New England Clam Chowder
Steamed Mussels or Clams
Baja Style Fish Tacos
Tempura Battered Fish
Classic Lobster Roll
Flounder Sandwich
Steamed Lobsters
Fried Flounder
Hamburger

“We came here for my mom's birthday lunch. Our server was very friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. Mom had the lobster and enjoyed every bite. My granddaughter had the chicken fingers, she ate some, but decided my fish and chips was better than her chicken. My daughter had the burger, which came out the exact temp she asked for. The views are beautiful, parking was easy. All in all we had a very nice day. Price wise it's what you would expect for the Hamptons. But not over the top.We will most likely be back“

4 Good55 Reviews
Shinnecock Bay Fishing Station Bar • $$
22 Shinnecock Rd, Hampton Bays

“Love this place! My husband & I come here sometimes. Everybody is so nice, great menu & the food is delish! Great outdoor space with nice canal views!! Gets super busy in the summer & they have live music as well!! Check out their FB page!!“

3.5 Good11 Reviews
78 Foster Restaurant & Bar Seafood • $$$
78 Foster Ave, Hampton Bays

“The bartender Shawn was the best. Such a hustling guy he was able to handle the entire bar on his own and it was full. I will go back when I'm in town. The folks next to me had chicken sandwiches, one grilled and one fried. They said they were excellent. A nice spot on the water, but unfortunately it was raining otherwise deck seating would be awesome.“

3.6 Good18 Reviews
Out of the Blue Seafood Seafood • $$
252 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays

Customers` Favorites

New England Clam Chowder
Manhattan Clam Chowder
Flounder Sandwich
Fish and Chips
Lobster Bisque
French Fries
Seafood Combo
Fish Tacos
Steamers

“A wonderful casual dining restaurant with simple, well-prepared fresh fish (there are meat options too), potatoes, vegetables and salads, as well. I am always impressed by the attentive, helpful, knowledgeable friendly young men who work here. Great place!“

3.9 Good74 Reviews
Loading...
map Map