8 Best Seafood Restaurants near Amagansett

The Stephen Talkhouse Seafood • $$
161 Main St, Amagansett

“had a great time when I was there last May. unfortunately one of the apparent regulars, an older drunken woman, punched me in the head unprovoked after harassing/pushing other groups of girls at the bar. I only stepped over to politely say “violence is not the answer” and her response was a punch to my dome. we told the bartender and she was kicked out but she should’ve been arrested. she needs to be permanently banned and they shouldn’t over-serve/admit people that are that belligerent.“

4.4 Superb40 Reviews
il Buco al Mare Wine Bar • $$
231 Main St, Amagansett

Customers` Favorites

Whole Roasted Branzino
Black Garlic Steak
Rosemary Focaccia
Margherita Pizza
Grilled Prawns
Chocolate Cake
Fluke Crudo
Duck Breast
Burrata

“We had an excellent lunch at Il Buco.. the chicory salad was delicious and the margarita pizza on Foccacia was very good. It was a little more bready than I would have liked but it was yummy. The service was some of the best we had while visiting the area and they treated our service dog very kindly unlike other restaurants and shops in the area where people were very rude. Highly recommend. I didn’t get a picture of my salad but it was beautifullly presented.“

3.8 Good66 Reviews
Clam Bar At Napeague Seafood • $$
2025 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
New England Clam Chowder
Sweet Potato Fries
Hot Lobster Roll
Fish and Chips
Clam Strips
Onion Rings
Fried Clams
Sandwich

“Clam Bar is so busy that we had to come back the next day early to give it a try. It's out with the hype? Absolutely! Not fancy and you feel like you're at the beach, but the seafood choices and service is very good. There are so many choices that I would advise coming multiple times to do the menu justice, but we did enjoy the fried choices by going with fried tuna bites, fried clam strips, and fried onion rings. The only exception was the Manhattan clam chowder. Parking is very challenging so I would recommend going early or going later otherwise the crowd is crazy. Def worth a trip.“

4 Good59 Reviews
Multi Aquaculture Systems Seafood • $$
429 Cranberry Hole Rd, Amagansett

“We bought the French board for 2 which had lobster salad, scallops, shrimp, asparagus, tomatoes, arugula, seaweed salad, and sweet potato fries. All made fresh and stayed fresh until we made it home 2 hours later because they gave us an ice pack to keep the container chilled. The setting is not for everyone but the food was top notch. The owners are wonderful, friendly people.“

3.6 Good13 Reviews
Bostwick's Chowder House Seafood • $$
277 Pantigo Rd, East Hampton - 1.29 miles

Customers` Favorites

1 1 2 Steamed Lobster GF
New England Clam Chowder
Lobster Fritters
Lobster Bisque
Lobster Taco
Fish Tacos
Flounder
Bostwick
Fish

“Why give a small roadside restaurant in Eastern Long Island five stars for lunch?The Food! And, The Fable.Somewhere deep in the wilds off Montauk Highway sitting in a clearing where Gatsby meets Talent lies a small fish house. Here, The Fishermen prepare fresh entrees for The Hungry.It’s really good!Thus, when Your Spirit yearns to see where convertible Porsche’s, Botox and the Eastern sea shore summer elite converge for mealtime, drive two or three hours and eat here. The fish is fresh, the vegetables are local and the one per cent puts their pants on one leg at a time just like us.I loved eating here!“

4.3 Superb78 Reviews
Smokin' Wolf BBQ & More Barbecue • $
199 Pantigo Rd, East Hampton - 1.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brisket Pulled Pork Pulled Chicken Garlic Mashed Corn Bread and Mac and Cheese
Salad

“I love this place! Food is amazing and service is friendly and top notch. Salads are fresh and delicious. Tables comfortable to enjoy your meal and the place has a super chill vibe. Lots of beers to choose from. For desert you absolutely have to try the carrot cake. It is the best anywhere period. Highly recommended!“

4.6 Superb39 Reviews
The Palm - East Hampton Steak House
94 Main St Suite 1800, East Hampton - 2.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Colossal Lump Crabmeat Cocktail
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Calamari Fritto Misto
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
Classic Caesar Salad
Chicken Parmigiana
Steakhouse Wedge
Creamed Spinach
Potatoes

“Food ordered was overcooked. Both the lobster and steak. We have been to many outstanding restaurants and never had our food overcooked when we ask for medium-rare. Considering this is suppose to be a high end restaurant and we expect prices to be considerably high, you would think you would get what you asked for. The Palm restaurant has changed since its earlier days when the food was outstanding.“

3.9 Good136 Reviews
The Living Room American
207 Main St, East Hampton - 2.9 miles

“Great shrimp cocktail. Amazing guacamole. Fantastic brunch entrees. We had many drinks, and they were all great. Best of all, Jeremiah, really took care of us, was very attentive, a lot of fun, and really cute. Can't wait to come back!“

3.7 Good20 Reviews
Loading...
map Map