Colombian Restaurants near Hicksville, NY

Punto Rojo Bakery Hicksville 2 Colombian • $
228 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville

Customers` Favorites

Rice & Beans Arroz Y Frijol
Churrasco a La Barbacoa
Pollo Chicken Empanada
Asopado De Mariscos
Calamres Fritos
Bandeja Paisa
Mini Bandeja
Beet Salad
Parillada
Frijoles

“Came here for a quick lunch during my break. After moving to Long Island it is quite difficult to find a Spanish restaurant. I found this restaurant on google. When I arrived, I was immediately greeted. There are some people behind the counter that speak English but they speak mostly Spanish. I do speak Spanish, but it was good to know that there are other people that can speak English, because I wanted to share this restaurant with my colleagues at work and they do not speak Spanish. Everyone was friendly, kind, and helpful. I ordered the special of the day which was caldo de res (beef soup)- there is an option to order it "Complete" which comes with rice topped with beef stew, macaroni salad, and plantain. I got a Colombiana soda to go with it and it was perfect!!! it was nice, clean, bright inside and the bakery is to die for. I didn't get to take pictures of the empanadas and pan de queso I bought, but it's a MUST have. I would love to try their cakes next time, it looked so good!! they have a whole pastry/bread section. Definitely recommend this place“

4.1 Good49 Reviews
La Finca Restaurant Colombian • $$
170 S Broadway, Hicksville

Customers` Favorites

Bandeja Tipica Con Arroz Frijoles Huevo Frito Chicharron Maduro Y Arepita Con Carne Asada
Seafood Casserole with Espaguetti Cazuela De Mariscos Con Espaguetti
Churrasco Grilled Flank Steak
Grilled Steak Carne Asada
Steak with Rice
Mojarra Frita
Noodles Soup
Skirt Steak
Tostones
Sancocho

“What a great little place! I had to go to the dentists next door and I thought I'd try it out! The staff is super nice, the food is really good and they even have some nice drinks. They had an afternoon drink special. I like how the owners decorated the place too. Que lugar pequeña pero bonito y buenisimo!“

3.9 Good49 Reviews
Mamma Gina's Colombian Kitchen Seafood • $
2453 Jerusalem Ave, North Bellmore - 5.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pechuga De Pollo Empanizada Breaded Chicken Breast
Plato Tipico Paisa Con Entrana Platter
Desayuno Mamma Ginas Colombian Kitchen
Bandeja De Pollo Chicken Platter
Bandeja Paisa
Grilled Beef
Carne Asada
Empanadas
Arepitas
Fried

“My brother moved by this spot like a month ago and I know this place OH SO WELL. ? I’m in Freeport and I haven’t found empanadas as good as Mamma Gina’s. When I tell you the food just hits every time, they’re honestly so consistently great.Parking: It’s a small lot, so just take it slow turning into it.“

4.8 Superb84 Reviews
Sabor a Colombia Restaurant & bar Franklin Square Colombian • $$
700 Hempstead Turnpike, Franklin Square - 8.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bandeja Paisa
Baked Beans
Tostones
Mar Y Mar
Carpaccio

“Beautiful Decor & Ambiance ???The Restaurant Is Full Of Light & Colors??Delicious Appetizers ? & Main Dishes ?Definitely Recommended & Coming ?P.s The Aroma ? Of The Sizzling Steak ? Passing By My Table When I am Hungry Is Out Of This World ?❤️“

4.5 Superb205 Reviews
Ceci's Arepa Joint Venezuelan • $
503B Newbridge Rd, East Meadow - 4.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Arepa Con Queso
El Poco Loco on Cachapa
Passion Fruit Juice
Tequeños Flight
The Joint Arepa
Pulled Chicken
Rice & Beans
Black Beans
Yucca Bites
Empanadas

“Off the hook!!! Best authentic arepas I've found all around. Am so glad I found this spot. The food is so tasty ?. Omg I love their green sauce that goes with the arepas. This got the spot 4me. ??❤️ I love how clean the place is and the home-feel atmosphere which includes a cool music reel. Thank you ? (sorry have no photos because I ate it all)“

4.6 Superb58 Reviews
Arepalicious express Colombian • $
182b Maple Ave, Rockville Centre - 9.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pollo Chicken Arepacone
Grilled Chicken Breast
Carne Beef Arepacone
Chicken Empanada
Green Hot Sauce
Guacamole Arepa
Surf and Turf
Grilled Steak
Arepa Trio
Guacamole

“Very fresh food - tastes homemade and the place is so impeccably clean - I felt like I could eat off the floor. They were even cleaning the windows when I walked in. I had a chicken arepa, which was delicious, as well as some empanadas (chicken and guava), also delicious. And the sauces were so flavorful. I look forward to going back to try more of their menu.“

4.6 Superb53 Reviews
Makondo Restaurant Hempstead Colombian • $
140 Front St, Hempstead - 7.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Carne Asada O Empanizada
Chaufa De Carne Full
Cazuela De Frijoles
Chaufa De Pollo Full
Bistec Encebollado
Morcilla Con Arepa
Paisa Bandeja Paisa
Chaufa Mixta Full
Empanada Hawaiana
Chicken Fingers

“Great please, food and service. Diana made our day!!! Great place, clean, fresh and great food. They cook your food as per your requests. Great prices. Cartagena present!!!!!!! Thank you very much and the beautiful guava chicharrones ❤️Kid-friendliness: You will feel at home ❤️“

4.6 Superb41 Reviews
Pollos El Paisa Colombian • $$
989 Old Country Rd, Westbury - 2.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grill Steak w White Rice N Pinto Beans
Bandeja Paisa Country Platter Huge
Tilapia Frita Con Tostones
Whole Fried Red Snapper
Yellow Rice and Shrimp
Pechuga a La Plancha
Bistec Encebollado
Rotisserie Chicken
Chuleta Empanizada
Mountain Platter

“It's date night but we've got a plus .5 with us. Not gonna stop me from giving you my honesty about this diner. It's crazy packed in here but service is moving very fast. Delicious hot plates sizzling left and right if you. The menu looks huge, but don't be alarmed it's the same menu just in both English and Spanish side by side. The ambiance was very diner style but a high performing one. The owner/manager was coming around like clock work. Service was outstanding. Food quality was stellar, the waiter quickly explained the menu. We opted for steaks that came with a side salad, rice and beans, and maduros. Steaks arrived on a sizzling cast iron plates and they were smelling phenomenal. There were juices running down my side right after the first bite. Perfectly seasoned and even better with their home made Chimichurri. Although I did feel a bit rushed to leave, I was still pretty impressed with the food quality and service. Will definitely be back to try more of the menu. PS - the tres leches was fantastic, not as good as the Mofongo place, but definitely very good decision for dessert. Happy yelping and enjoy this recommendation.“

4.4 Superb132 Reviews
Pecosa Bakery & Restaurant Bakery • $
2055 Front St, East Meadow - 3.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Colombian Style Tamale with Corn Cake
Grilled Steak with Corn Cake
Sandwich & Salad
Empanada De Carne
House Breakfast
Grilled Chicken
Cheese Bread
Hot Milo
Tostones
Sausage

“Kind of a hidden gem. Food is good. Prices are reasonable but if you're looking for something trendy this is not the place. At first glance. I don't think most people would even realize that they serve food it just looks like a small bakery. Don't let that intimidate you sit at one of the tables. Look through the menu and give the food a try.“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
Las caleñas bar Restaurant Colombian • $
719 Fulton Ave, Hempstead - 5.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Papas Rellenas Stuffed Potatoes
Quesadilla
Empanadas

“Excellent place, food, wonderful service, I ordered a chicken combo, and I was surprised by the amount they served, up to 3 people can eat, best of all at a very good price, I ate a stuffed potato and I loved it, highly recommended, they have very good variety of food.“

4.6 Superb22 Reviews
El Patio Colombiano Colombian •
27 Carmans Rd, Massapequa - 7.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicarrones Y Gara Con Arepa Y Arroz Y Frijoles
Bandeja El Patio Colombiano 22
Paella El Patio Colombiano
Bandeja de Pollo Al Carbon
Tostones Con Guacamole
Frijoles Con Garra
Empanada Con Salsa
Bistec Encebollado
Consomé De Pollo
Empanada De Carne

“My mom and I came to eat breakfast as it was recommended to us by a friend. I had huevos pericos con arepa y queso and it was delicious. My mom had the soup of the day and she said it was delicious & perfect for the cold weather. The portion are pretty big so the pricing seems fair. Although, it did seem a little pricey but everything in NY is. It nicely decorated inside. The service was great, everyone was super nice. All in all, had a great experience and will definitely come back again!“

4.2 Good79 Reviews
Colombia Cuyabros Carniceria Colombian • $
52A W Merrick Rd, Freeport - 8.45 miles

“If you want Home Cooked Colombian Meals and variety of colombian goods and snacks come here! Food was Great, the attention was perfect, and they had a great variety of authentic colombian products. It felt like i was back in colombia! I suggest you come here.“

4.3 Superb13 Reviews
Punto Rojo Bakery and Restaurant Colombian • $
1666 New York Ave, Huntington Station - 7.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tres Leches Cake
Bandeja Paisa

“Great Colombian bakery with great food, pastries, cakes and natural juices. Me wife and I come here at least once or twice a week. It's our go to spot. The have a full menu for breakfast and lunch and the food is delicious. I always get the tres leche pastry, it's probably the best I've ever had. All the other colombian pastries are amazing as well. The fresh orange and carrot juice is another favorite of mine. In the summer I get the cholado's all the time.“

4.2 Good27 Reviews
La Calidad Bakery Bakery • $
48 S Main St, Freeport - 8.33 miles

“My family found this gem. It's a small little shop with reasonably priced, delicious food. There is a pretty expansive menu and plenty of desserts. The place is in a pretty busy area, but there is a lot in the back. Bring change for the meters. There is parking in the front, but that is hard to comeby. There are tables inside, but we are more of a take out people lately. The staff was friendly, place seemed clean and the food is good. If you like Columbian, give this place a shot.“

4.1 Good10 Reviews
Sabor a Colombia Restaurant & Bar LEVITTOWN Colombian • $$
2953 Hempstead Tpke, Levittown - 2.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mojarra Frita Con Arroz Tostones Y Ensalada
Pechuga Apanada Breaded Chicken Breast
Bandeja Sabor a Colombia
Sabor a Colombia Platter
Whole Fried Red Snapper
Bistec Encebollado
Empanadas De Carne
Rotisserie Chicken
Caramel Custard
Arepa Con Queso

“Delicious breaded fried chuletta served with salad, rice and beans, and maduras. Service is good. Wish I knew I'd be charged $9 for hot sauce though. Was there on Thursday night unaware it was Karaoke Night so it was very loud. Food never disappoints.“

4.1 Good185 Reviews
La Sevillana Bakery & Restaurant Colombian • $
481 Maple Ave #3351, Westbury - 3.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Empanadas

“Looking for a local place to grab a cup of coffee and something sweet and google gave me this nearby bakery! Went in and the employees were all welcoming and the place was clean! I ordered a coffee and a piece of cake with dulce de leche on top. The coffee was delicious and the cake was so fresh and delicious!! I am glad I stopped at this little place on my way home to QUEENS! I would definitely return when back in the area. The only recommendation I have is that the staff should prepare and serve the coffee for patrons. I put together two cups of coffee and the coffee is scalding hot, if it were to spill it would burn really bad. Especially because of COVID, the staff should handle the coffee instead of having patrons touching everything. Aside from this one thing, the coffee and cake slice was amazing and I would recommend!!!“

3.8 Good16 Reviews
Punto Rojo Cafe Glen Cove Colombian • $
209 Forest Ave, Glen Cove - 8.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Torta De Tres Leches
Colombiana Soda
Guava Guayaba

“My husband and I had had very busy weeks and when I got home at 7:30 Sunday night we wanted to go to dinner. At someone's suggestion we went to Punto Rojo. We loved it. The salmon dinner was delicious as was the steak with avocado. Very generous portions. We brought desert home but haven't eaten it yet. The service was friendly and helpful and the restaurant is very clean. We will definitely be back.“

3.9 Good38 Reviews
El Paraiso Restaurant Colombian • $
44 N Franklin St, Hempstead - 6.79 miles

Customers` Favorites

Caldo De Res

“My girlfriend and I would have never come here based on the reviews alone since I’m reading them just now as I’m leaving this review . But we came inside without knowing anything and honestly the food was so delicious the drinks were so good too. I’m so happy we came here without reading the comments and had our own experience. I’m not saying the comments are wrong as I don’t know the experience everyone had. But I do see that they are a bit outdated so I will say that this place has improved itself with wonderful staff and amazing food. They speak both English and Spanish. The portions of food really good for the price too. I say 5/5 review because of all these reasons. And I think it’s a bit sad they don’t have more reviews :) so come and have your own experience“

3.8 Good25 Reviews
Punto Rojo Bakery Uniondale Colombian • $
1049 Front St, Uniondale - 5.33 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mojarra Fritta Fried Porgie
Empanadas Colombianas
Frijoles
Cupcake

“I've never had authentic Columbian food before...... this was absolutely scrumptious. My daughter has been here but this is my first but definitely not my last time coming here. They have a bakery section that is beautiful and almost tooooo pretty to even contemplate eating......Almost The restaurant is clean, inviting with very friendly & helpful employees. There's plenty of cute tables throughout the restaurant. The menu is well planned without being large & intimidating. They have a nice selection of breakfast, appetizers, pasta, salads, soup, sandwiches native dishes, empanadas along with beef, chicken & seafood dishes. There's even a kids menu. Theres a nice selection of shakes, juices & other beverages. We both had the #2....Calentado Paiso which is a very large plate filled with grilled steak, fried pork belly, white rice with beans, egg, corn cake with cheese, sweet plantain & avocado. I had a wonderful blackberry mora en agai. We also shared a large slice of coconut cake which was moist, flavor& delicious. I highly recommend this restaurant and can't wait to come back“

3.7 Good42 Reviews
Punto Rojo Bakery Freeport 3 Colombian • $$
85 S Main St #3841, Freeport - 8.36 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mini Bandeja Paisa
Salmon Al Horno
Almojabanas
Cake

“Excellent business, high quality bond bread, fresh empanadas all day, you can't miss the Thursday special, completely original and warm Santafereño ajiaco, I recommend going for a cold winter day and a hot summer day, a must-see placeParking: fifty“

3.5 Good34 Reviews
Noches de Colombia Colombian • $$
204 Jericho Turnpike, Mineola - 6.36 miles

Customers` Favorites

Margarita Frozen De Maracuy
Bandeja Paisa Paella
Mini Empanadas
Rice and Beans
Mojarra Frita
Passion Fruit
Mar Y Tierra
Churrasquito
Skirt Steak
Frijoles

“It was awesome fresh food with a great service...my family loved it!! It is a bit pricey though...but totally worth it!! 100% Recommended!!Parking: It gets busy after 6pm, after that time is a bit challenging to find parking. Parking is free after 6pm.“

3.7 Good93 Reviews
Mi Tierrita Restaurant Colombian • $$
31 N Franklin St, Hempstead - 6.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pargo Rojo Frito Whole Red Snapper Fried
Bandeja De Frijoles Tray of Beans
Orden de 3 Empanadas
Rotisserie Chicken
Breaded Chicken
Bandeja Tipica
Country Platter
Grilled Salmon
Breaded Steak
Bandeja Paisa

“I wish I had been able to resist eating this delicious food before I devoured it, so there was proof that I ate here. But I will say that eating here one time while visiting the area wasn't enough, so I went twice, and both times were just as amazing in every possible way.Food is bountiful, the service is great, and the atmosphere is just perfect.Prices are just right for everything.Plan on eating like a king, so do not ear for a whole day before you come here.“

3.5 Good58 Reviews
Loading...
map Map