11 Best Ice Cream Shops near Holmes

“Superb, friendly staff! Food taste, quality and presentation are well above average also very reasonable. We are fortunate it is close by.“

“Absolutely love this new ice cream shop (new name same ice cream) that moved into Pawling. Not only are they family owned and operated but everything they do is made naturally only using natural colors!

It’s the cutest little fun ice cream shop serving up ice cream, ice cream flights, sundaes, milkshakes, ice cream sandwiches, stuffed bubble waffles and more!

They even have boozy ice cream (21+ only) and rotating flavors with the ice cream shop being open all year round.

The seasonal cocquito boozy ice cream was DELICIOUS and I can’t wait to get my hands on the nesquik next time they have it. My favorite part about this place is that they make all thei ice cream using plant based colors that come from
butterfly pea powder, spirulina, turmeric, purple sweet potato and beet juice! How cool!

Not only do they keep it fun with colorful flavors but also safe with natural ingredients and that’s a win.

Be sure to check them out!“

“First time here. 80 degree weather. All of a sudden a line. Bam, 4 workers at the window helpful and pleasant. That’s my kinda of business. Kudos to the owner. Enjoyed the ice cream. Clean area. What more could a customer ask for. I’ll be back!“

“Excellent AND fresh baked bread daily! Everything is delicious. This pizzeria is definitely our new favorite.“

“Really good tacos and milkshakes!“

“Stopped in here for a quick bite on our way from PA to Massachusetts. The outside looked questionable but inside was a great atmosphere and the food was amazing. Glad we made the stop and might consider stopping again on the way home!“

“Huge shoutout to Uncle Louie G’s. We had my son’s First Communion today and the ice cream truck was a HUGE hit with both the kids and adults! Will definitely be using them again!!“

“Great local place- dependably delicious!“

“Every Thanksgiving, Baskin Robbins offers a festively bizarre ice cream cake shaped like an actual turkey! They start with a giant MOUND of your favorite ice cream flavor, mold it into a turkey shape, cover it in cake frosting, add cones as turkey “legs,” and douse the entire faux bird in caramel praline glaze to give it a fresh out-of-the-ovenesque sheen.

The sheer spectacle and concept of such a cake entrance me every year! I normally resist the temptation to buy one of these magnificent looking dessert creations each holiday season to spare my wallet (and waistline). However, my buddy Rick was kind enough to front the cost of a turkey cake for me to finally try this year…. On one condition 😈… I devour one entire cake in a single sitting. I could not turn down such a awfully generous offer and promptly took him up on his ice cream cake challenge.

I immediately called up Baskin Robbins and asked for a cake filled with with eggnog ice cream for the light “breast meat,” and chocolate peanut butter stuffed in cones for that dark “leg meat” 😂. The Baskin Robbins team took careful note, filled my order precisely, and even had it all ready for me to pick by the end of the day! Huge kudos to the staff at the Patterson location for their impressive speed in “cooking up” this bird the week of Thanksgiving!

I brought it home and let it harden up in my freezer overnight before I giving this turkey cake its final rites. Clocking in at a mere 3.75lb, I was able to ram the whole thing back effortlessly and casually in a quick 10 minutes and ONE second 😆. Despite my rapid gorging, I still savored each and every spoonful that passed my lips.“

“Food is delicious, service is a bit slow but it’s worth the wait I promise. Lots of yummy opinions and prices are good. They also have a buffet style service if you are in a hurry on you want something quick to go. Bread is yummy, they have conchas and a lot of sweet bread that you can get. Love that this is local and I can have a yummy cheap meal anytime.“