50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Irondequoit

“We did an honor flight event that sends veterans to to washing DC to see monuments made in their honor. Mozzeroni’s was so generous. They donated pizzas for our event and fed our riders. We are so grateful for their generosity. What great neighbors. The pizza is always fantastic. Thanks again They will always have our business“

“With so many pizza choices in Irondequoit, this is my favorite. Pizza is always delicious, hot and made how I like it. Staff is always friendly when I go to pick it up. I have also used them for parties and never had an issue.“

“This little ceasers is the best in the Rochester area. Everytime I go there they always have stuff hot n ready to go. I’ve been to multiple others and never do they have stuff hot n ready to go like advertised and make you wait at close to a half hour for one item. The one on Lyle ave never has anything and when I said something as to why they don’t I was yelled at and told to leave if I don’t like it and their wait times were crazy and it has a drive thru so it makes no sense not to have things ready and at the same time there was no customers but still had no item hot n ready to go. Don’t go to Lyle ave location for it is thee worse service and expect to wait a long time to even get one pizza or any small item. The place should be closed down for how poorly they treat customers just because they are not doing what the company advertises which is not the customers fault so the customer has a right to complain especially since they never have anything hot n ready. I went there different times and each time it was the same result that I stopped going there. It get very little business due to that fact.“

“Absolutely love the food! I am the only vegan in my family and we finally found a place we can all eat at and enjoy together! The pizza is so good and the Milkshakes are Awesome!“

“Very good pizza. We had 3 12in pies, all were enjoyable. Thin crust, good toppings.

The selection of toppings is not as widely varied as dome places, but we had no trouble making satisfying choices. Stuffed garlic cheese bread very good, pie sauce outstanding.

We would happily go back.“

“The best pizza I've ever tasted in Rochester and nearby areas. It's worth every penny. You can feel the good quality of the products.Definitely my new favorite pizza spot. Continue with the tremendous service and your good quality products.“

“Best pizza the original roni!“

“Had a 12 inch cup and char pizza today and it was instantly added to my top five local pizzerias in the area. If you’re in the area and looking for a good meal, stop here!“

“absolutely some of the best pizza and wings I've ever eaten. staff was so friendly as well. I highly recommend them. So delicious and cooked to perfection.“

“I LOVE this place. Create a pizza is my all time favorite spot. I’ve been coming here for years and I recommend it to every person I come across. Especially those with dietary restrictions. The food is always delicious, there are always friendly smiles behind the counter, and the prices are pretty unbeatable. Hands down, best pizza joint in Rochester.“

“Awesome awesome awesome food. Loved the meatball and cheese garlic bread appetizers. Lot of flavor and lot of cheese! Also had chicken parm sandwich and meatball sandwich. Bread was great, not a tough or super thick ciabatta. Also placed a to go order and had no wait upon arrival. Very much looking forward to returning!“

“Food was good. Had wings and beef on weck. Service was not good. Sat at a booth in the bar area. This was a Saturday at 4pm. Not busy at all. Took 15 minutes for a waitress to even acknowledge us even though there was at least 3-4 that we saw wandering around. Definitely not as good as the original, but hoping they’ll work out some of the kinks.“

“We stopped in last night everyone was so welcoming and nice and the food was great!!! It was hot and fresh and soooo good!! 10 out of 10 for us 😋“

“SERIOUSLY?!?!
This place is close to where we live but just tonight we ordered pizza for a party for the first time! We're seriously kicking ourselves for not trying this place sooner. This pizza seriously blows away all competition. It's seriously delicious!!!
YOU SERIOUSLY MUST TRY IT!!!!“

“Wow! Had an awesome plate of Chicken Riggies! And the staff are all amazing! Well done Team Capone! 🖤“

“This is the best pizza in Western New York. I've been going there for 46 years and never been disappointed! Tony & Mike are amazing and I always look forward to the time w/ them. Prices are beyond reasonable.“

“Met the owner of this location and have to say, I’m impressed. He’s a young professional with a lot of pride in his work, and it shows. I stopped here with my two boys for a quick slice and it was delicious. Best of luck to you, Mike and family. We’ll be back.“

“nothing there nasty the place is nasty the food is spoiled rat infestation health department has violations food poisoning cases owner is a supposedly a Christan but a compulsive gambler“

“Incredible food will definitely be back“

“Very good tasting pizza, but it was disappointing that they don't have specialty pizzas such as supreme, meat lovers, veggie lovers, etc. Creating your own supreme costs extra for each topping. Great for Carbone's revenue, but not a good deal for customers.“

“Ordered a pizza. Loved the light crust and all the cheesy pepperoni and mushrooms, and the rest was history. I would pick up next time and eat in the car so I could enjoy the still crispy crust edges. Another reviewer described it as pillowy.“

“I tried once, and now I’m obsessed 🫶🏻 HIGHLY recommend!!“

“I ordered the Buffalo Bills pizza for the playoff game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. First off, they contacted me when the game was rescheduled and offered accommodations so that I could get the pizza and bake it myself as they weren’t open on Monday when the game would be played. THEN called back again to let me know they were going to open on Monday after all and scheduled a time for me to pick up my pizza. Awesome customer service and only outdone by the delicious pizza!! Fair price as well!! I would highly recommend Savastano’s , give them a try you won’t be disappointed!!! 5 ⭐️’s“

“I have celiac disease and it’s hard to find safe and yummy options when I don’t feel like cooking. We ordered for the first time tonight and we are beyond impressed!!! I had a GF buffalo chicken sandwich with fries and the rest of my family ate pizza, wings and chicken tenders. Everything was so delicious! We will definitely be back again, im so happy we tried it!“

“Our neighbor recently recommended Pizza chef so we gave it a whirl after some other very well respected pizza places in the Fairport/Bushnells basin area have REALLY fallen off. Pleased to say after ordering a couple times from here that we have a new favorite for NY style pizza. It’s been consistent each time we’ve ordered so far and tastes great. The style of pie is very reminiscent of the classic slice shops on the corners in Manhattan. Not overpriced either so the value proposition is great! Definitely worth trying if you’re craving that style of pizza. And the people working there have always been nice and pleasant. Looking forward to trying the sandwiches and other menu items in the future too.“

“Yesterday's Pizza was Delicious and the Wings Crispy really Good.Love it Service was Excellent.Thank you! so much.😊My Sister and Nephew's Love it ♥️“

“Family owned and operated... they always provide great tasting food and always trying out new things and that always taste great. I try to go at least once or twice a week.“

“whether it's a huge lunch slice or an entire pizza, they are my favorite by far. Family owned and operated, clean, consistent and always fresh!“

“If I could give more than 5 stars, I would! Rhino’s Pizza is hands down the best pizza place in town. Every time we order, the food is fresh, hot, and absolutely delicious. Their classic pepperoni pizza is unbeatable. The crust is perfectly crispy, the cheese is just the right amount, and the pepperoni has that amazing flavor you cannot find anywhere else. But the real showstopper is their pickle pizza. At first, I was not sure what to expect, but it has quickly become a family favorite. The balance of tangy pickles, creamy sauce, and melted cheese is pure perfection. It is unique, memorable, and worth the trip on its own.

The quality here is consistently excellent, and you can tell Rhino’s puts real care into what they serve. Portion sizes are generous, toppings are always fresh, and the crust has that perfect texture, chewy on the inside with just the right crunch on the outside. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, and service is quick whether you are dining in or taking out.

We have tried plenty of pizza places in the area, but Rhino’s stands out every single time. If you are looking for the best pizza in town, look no further. Rhino’s is our go-to spot, and once you try it, I bet it will be yours too!“

“Delicious food with reasonable prices, friendly and knowledgeable staff, beautiful interior design!“

“Very pleasant prompt service, quick delivery of a “build your own” pizza, piping hot, lovely thin and crisp crust. Pandora soft rock radio playing while we dined. Highly recommend!

Parking: Right near door, at least 12 spots

Kid-friendliness: Family friendly space

Wheelchair accessibility: Bathrooms are both wheelchair accessible“

“BEST PIZZA ANYWHERE ***** !!! Dave's the best“

“I had driven by this pizza place for many years and not tried it. I read the reviews and my bestie was in town and we decided to try the pizza and wings. It was the best on both accounts. It is very old school. Got to meet Nino and chat with him how he got in the business. Both the atmosphere of caring about the food he makes and the people he served is revealed in an excellent product. I would highly recommend!!!“

“I love Pudgie’s pizza and especially their chicken wings….cooked so nice and crunchy….the customer service was great and it’s nice to dine inside again❤️“

“Don’t listen to the people talking about wrong coupons or getting the wrong order, because that’s normal for small business. Honest mistakes are normal in this world. The bottom line is the food here is good and the people are great; support your small businesses!!!“

“Best wood fired pizza in Rochester. All fresh ingredients artfully prepared by Freddie himself. It is a must try, you will be hooked. I know I am!! Definitely five ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“The staff Friday at 5 was awesome. Polite, friendly and helpful. My 7 y/o son like to contribute and ordered our pizza. Great service for such a young team. Manager did a great job organizing her team!“

“Just found Tom and Nancy's again after years of thinking they closed, they just moved. Best pizza ever! Highly recommend.“

“Erin is outstanding! She made our Blaze experience amazing. Thank you Erin G.reat service. Great food“

“The Sicilian pizza is amazing! Best we ever had! The owner is authentic and brings a piece of Sicily here! A must try! Thank you for a slice of Heaven“

“By far the best pizza in Rochester! My , “go to” place. If you love thin slice , you will love this place ! Owners are always present and take pride in their pie ! More than reasonably priced, can’t say enough good things about this place!“

“I had a review show up on my page a while ago. I followed up by following their page on FB. Today I couldn't put it off any longer "A LARGE CHEESE PIZZA FOR $12.00" are you kidding me. typically I like to add some toppings when ordering a pizza but I wanted to see what the bare bones have to say and by the way when they say large they mean it. It reminded me of the way it used to be instead of the large size other shops typically offer today which don't come close. I went to pick it up and when I entered the shop it immediately presented a very nice "Vibe". There were several pizzas ready with a variety of toppings for purchase by the slice. The room smelled amazing. The environment is welcoming and clean. I spoke with the woman at the counter who may have been the owner and I meant to ask but was engaged with other questions since it was my first visit. The pizza was cooked perfectly and was so flavorful I truly did not miss having other toppings added, although I am anxious to try them with my next order. As a result, I ate more than I should have and had to force myself to stop. Still we all know how nice it is to have some leftover for later. If you have not tried them yet, don't hesitate. I also notice so many other great items on their menu. Oh well so much for my weight goals.“

“Love them hot fresh food food, special's, conveniently located. They often have specials like six wings and a slice with with with a drink for like 8 bucks different different specials but they're always good and even at the end of the night when they started doing like a lot of people do this this responsible for the food they are you know sell it to the public for a cheaper price you know what I'm saying just to get it out of the store you know what I'm saying so that people can eat the ones who are less fortunate .“

“Beyond impressed! This pizza was the only pizza my family would order when I was a kid. We moved to Florida and over the years people have started away from them and we were always disappointed. We tried it twice and we're so impressed I had to review! Wings are cooked to perfection and the pizza is on point! ESPECIALLY the GLUTEN FREE!!! It actually looks, feels and chews like a pizza, not just a glorified tortilla. We will always order from Marks when we come to visit!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free“

“it’s called the goner… so light and airy!“

“This was our first time trying The Gate House and we were impressed! We came on a Thursday afternoon with no reservation and were seated right away. Our server was prompt and attentive immediately and continued through the duration of our meal. We tried the Xerox pizza as well as the Duffy burger and both were 10/10! Absolutely delicious. I would highly recommend!“

“I need to make you aware of a wonderful diamond in the rough on Rochester’s west side. My wife and I visited this quaint Lower Manhattan style eatery with my brother-in-law and his wife. This unassuming place from the outside pleasantly surprises once you enter with its quaint bar area, blacked out ceiling and twin open kitchen stations. First litmus test is the quality of bread with a full complement of spices to prep your own dipping oil. Check! Special of the day, Seared Halibut on a bed of risotto, didn’t disappoint, nor did my samples of homemade Rigatoni à la Bolognese (just like Mom’s Sunday sauce) or the Chicken Milanese! Completed the meal with an ample slice of homemade Ricotta Cheesecake with Berry Compote. The owner checked in with us several times. The table service was perfect. The glass enclosed wine cellar in the middle of the dining area completed an impressive ambience and dining experience. Run don’t walk to this most pleasant gastro treat!“