Restaurants near Lake Huntington

“10 ⭐ atmospheric place. Its a place where you become family and friends.”

“This gem is something special and worth the visit. The cider is fantastic and the food is made with alot of love. The staff has always been super cool whenever I’ve been there.”

“I’d been waiting weeks to finally visit Black Walnut and it completely lived up to the hype. We had cocktails in the front near the perfectly curated home store before dinner and were pleasantly surprised with how delicious they were. Highly recommended the melon Negroni and the mint tea cassis cocktail. The actual dining room is small so I’d highly recommend making a reservation, also open concept kitchen which in theory was exciting but the heat wave kept us from enjoying the added heat. Anyway, the food was incredible - do not skip over the blistered snap peas they are truly incredible. Overall we loved our meal and will be back!”

“My son and daughter-in-law had their engagement party at La Cigogne and it was truly a wonderful experience. The ambiance was warm and elegant, making it a perfect setting for such a special occasion. The staff was incredibly attentive, professional and genuinely kind throughout the entire event. Our guests are raving about the fun time they had. The food was delicious; and our guests had a variety of dietary needs, and the restaurant accommodated everyone. We are so grateful to Damien and the entire team at La Cignone for helping make their celebration so memorable. If you're looking for a place to host a special event, we can't recommend this place enough.”

“Good eats, good service, and a beautiful place to enjoy the beauty of our area.”

“Found it through Google maps - great atmosphere, amazing staff - very friendly - You seat yourself wherever you want and get the menu from the bar, place order at the bar and they bring you the food to your table.

Tried their homemade sodas - the ginger one was perfect! Not too sweet. Tried the trout, fried chicken and Lobster Mac and cheese. Both the trout and Mac and cheese were incredible!

Pricing was great! If you are in the vicinity, you should definitely give it a try!”

“Great food! Friendly staff.”

“Nothing exceptional except for the FOOD, STAFF, CHARMING ATMOSPHERE!!! Even if you are from NYC, Louie’s Famous Bagel with a huge amount of bacon and cream cheese will knock your socks off. I will be dreaming of Dutton’s for a long time. Thanks to the great staff!”

“On my yearly canoe trip to Narrowsburg I am never disappointed when I stop into the Tusten. The staff is friendly, the service is good and the food is tasty and fresh. We ate there twice this past weekend. Thank you Tusten....See you next year as well.”

“Had a wonderful Brunch at The Creek House Grill. Food was off the chart and the staff were so friendly. Karen is the ultimate hostess! See you all again soon!”

“Everything on the menu is wonderful and made by hand. This is a micro-bakery, not a coffee shop. That means they don't serve full breakfasts or giant cappuccinos. They serve fresh bread, alongside other delicious baked goods. Everything is made daily. Loaves upon loaves of freshly baked tangy sourdough, pullman loaves for a week's worth of sandwiches, Japanese milk bread (my fave- it's so sweet), and a selection of cookies and smaller items that change weekly. If you are lucky enough to be there when they have the basque mini-cheesecakes, grab one of those too! Callicoon has the largest farmers market in Sullivan County, and a trip to the Sunday market isn't complete without hitting the Callicoon Marketplace for dry goods and pantry items...and a week's worth of bread from Roger That.”

“The atmosphere is alive. Cocktails are good, service is on point, and food even better. Very consistent. Highly recommended”

“I highly recommend coming here. It's an all-around awesome place as well as wonderful friendly people and absolutely amazing food with reasonable prices especially for how good the food is you definitely can't beat it. so at least give it a try cuz I guarantee you'll love it. myself as well as my man sure do. We've been there several times now and some how It's always better than the last. we are big fans 💯”

“Cuppie Cake provided delicious desserts for our daughter and son in law’s wedding. Heather is so easy to work with and we would definitely recommend her services to anyone !!!”

“Buttermilk chicken sandwich, is my favorite. But I had wings for the first time. They were Awsome.”

“My husband and I had such a delicious breakfast here - eggs, French toast, giant pancakes and the best corned beef hash ever! Sarah is as nice can be and we recommend her place 100%!!”

“The food and the hospitality there was OUTSTANDING the last 3 times we went there. I have lived here about 25 years and never been there till recently. I wish I had visited there earlier...”

“Excellent dinner and service! We can’t wait to go back!!”

“We came here 2 days in a row in February 2026 during some super frigid weather. We were staying in the area for a long weekend getaway. We were super happy that they are indoor dog friendly (well behaved/ leashed dogs only! ) The beer was great. I loved Tommy Boy Farmhouse Ale and Amber Waves Amber Ale. We ended up buying a 4 pack of each to bring home with us. I was so pleasantly surprised by their BBQ offerings. It is very easy to mess up BBQ, but this BBQ was so wonderfully prepared. I have been to so many breweries and BBQ joints that serve dried out, over-sauced meat. The offerings from Smok'd were all excellent. During our first visit we ordered the brisket sandwich and the pulled pork sandwich. The brisket was super juicy and tender. The pulled pork was also juicy and tender. They offered BBQ sauce on the side if we wanted. During our second visit, we sat in the vault. This brewery is in a location that was formerly a bank. The vault was a nice secluded spot. We ordered the ribs and brisket with street corn salad, mac and cheese, and beans. The ribs were fall off the bone tender and the brisket had a beautiful smoke ring. The mac and cheese was super creamy and had a wonderful taste of childhood. It was perfect for a day that had a -23F windchill. Overall, great beer, great food, and great staff. We really enjoyed our time here. I love a great dog friendly brewery! We will definitely return when in the area!”

“Buttermilk chicken sandwich, is my favorite. But I had wings for the first time. They were Awsome.”

“Excellent for large parties or an intimate dinner. The backyard is perfect for families with children. The fish tacos are incredible. Service is great.”

“Tom and I stopped at Hectors tonight…. The nicest bartender and owners that we have ever met! See you tomorrow! lol ☮️”

“Egg Sandwich with black coffee. Great fresh Kaiser roll. Fresh egg with sausage m… it was awesome 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻😎😎”

“Fun atmosphere. They had a band and nice couches. We had dessert and the lemon merengue pie was spectacular! They used a perfected recipe or a local bakery. Either way so good!”

“The Blue Fox Motel is a gem! It is fun, relaxing, and clean. We booked almost the whole motel for a wedding weekend and it couldn’t have been better. The staff is kind and generous. I am a business owner and I would LOVE to have staff like the management and crew of The Blue Fox. Everyone went out of their way to make our weekend a success. The location is stunning, the decor is relaxing and fun, and the restaurant was great. Love the people, love the place, love the area.”

“The best server by far is Candice. She is polite and caring.”

“It was very good had a ton of options to pick from. The service was wonderful and I was able to go sit on top on the roof balcony to enjoy my ice cream which was very lovely. And there serving sizes were very big for the prices. Definitely will be going back 👍🍨🍦🥛🍧🥤😁”

“Cheeseburgers are awesome! Just what this small town needs, a place to get a great burger! Keep up the good work!”

“Friendly & fast service with a smile. 😊”

“Highly recommend! Had such a fun time for reptiles night! Plus they have a great menu with delicious food! Will be back!”