50 Best American Restaurants near Locust Valley

“There ribs are second to none“

“Good all AMERICAN food in a garden setting. Very pleasant throughout.“

“As always , any establishment owned by Kent has great food and interesting menu. We frequent Heirloom, our local fav, but know BR has varied menu with more fish. We were not disappointed with our choices. Change of scenery always good, and we met someone, our waiter,we recognized from years ago at another favorite local place, Crabby Dan's. A great evening and a fabulous dinner. Thank you.“

“Fabulous evening with our friends at Barney’s last night. Drinks at the bar…delicious shrimp fettuccini, excellent service, wonderful dessert. This place will be in our regular rotation!“

“First time coming here to try the hub it was amazing. The experience for me was top 10. The people at service are very respectful polite and the customer service was top tier. I appreciate them. And the food was banging on top of that loaded fries was amazing. The burgers had a bunch of flavour. The only thing that I’m upset about is that they’re not on Uber Eats And that they don’t have other locations, no restaurant, but hopefully Inshallah they expand great food great service And would love to come here again on many occasions in the future“

“Absolutely delicious food and good service. Nice atmosphere.“

“Just had a Birthday Dinner and we enjoyed from the beginning to the end. The food was amazing! The octopus dish is delicious.. i loved the atmosphere and the service was excellent. I highly recommend this place!!!!“

“I can’t figure out why anyone would give this place less than 5 stars. The food is outstanding!!! The service is always good. And it’s really consistent. I’m also vegetarian and gluten free and both are accommodated there easily! Fantastic place!!!!!“

“The food was delicious and many entrees to choose from we were a group of six“

“First-time visit. Food was delicious and the bartender/server, Peter, was friendly and efficient. Observing other patrons, all seemed to be quite pleased. I’ll be back😊“

“Service is always great and the food is amazing. Love to order 3 or 4 dishes and share. ❤️“

“We actually never went to this location before, but had greatly enjoyed their prior second location in Port Washington. Expectaions were right on point. Food was excellent from appetizer to the main course. Maybe it's weird but I kind of respect even the small things like when a restaraunt offers to chose to serve in house brewed ice tea as opposed to something pre processed. The Brisket from todays specials list was perfect. This restaurant is 45min drive from home and well worth the trip. Thank You, we will be back.“

“Lobster Sunday!!!! We had a wonderful young college student as our server who was outstanding. I had a great cocktail thanks to the attentive bartender. The food is always great.“

“Ate there for the first time after hearing many great reviews about Hilltop. I have to say everything was great… Service, atmosphere and food (Drinks too😁). Can’t wait to go back again… very fairly priced as well“

“We have been dining here for 30 years and its still outstanding! They have great food at great prices and its always a delicious meal. We were here on Saturday Sept 21 with my brother and sister in law. We shared everything. The octopus, tuna sashimi pizza and roasted beet salad were really good! So were the shrimp tacos and our entrees. We had drinks at the bar before dinner and it was very comfortable and friendly. The bartender was quick and very competent. This place always has great food and service at very affordable prices. They also did a wonderful job for our daughters bridal shower when we took over the restaurant on a weekend morning! They are always professional and warm and welcoming too!“

“It really just doesn't get any better“

“This is one of the better Applebees locations on Long Island, and server Angela is the main reason for that. She is very funny, personable, and attentive. She offered great suggestions and made sure we were happy with our meals. If you go to this location, ask for Angela Capy! 😍😍😍“

“This is my 4th time at Foster's. Our Mimi's meatballs, Burrata Salad and Margherita pizza were all delicious. Last time I had the vegan bolognese they was delicious as well. The place has a great vibe. Everything looks and smells delicious. We'll be back.“

“Louie’s has an extensive menu where can’t go wrong with anything on there! The service is quick and very friendly. I tend to get something different every time. It’s bar far my favorite diner.“

“Excellent food and service!“

“Great place for gatherings, food and service is great I bring my singles events here quite often highly recommend“

“We happened upon this gem of a restaurant after a trip to the Rye Children’s Museum. The service was outstanding!!! The food (we all had the cheesesteak, fries and specialty salad) was delicious! The atmosphere was warm and welcoming!
They really want the dinner business so plan on it, you won’t be disappointed!

Parking: Free, right beside the restaurant.

Kid-friendliness: Great selections for the little ones. Gave our 2 and 1/2 year old crayons and paper for drawing and his own special lemonade (no extra charge). Our little one said to the waiter about his meal “delicious “.“

“Beginning with the valet parking and ending with individual French press coffee, this was a magnificent experience! Started with white wine, Fuji Apple salad. Entrée was perfectly prepared Seafood "Paella", finished with coffee and Banana Pudding Wafer Jar. The view of the pond from the window was relaxing. Best dining experience. Recommend the Seafood Paella“

“The food was incredible. Everyone enjoyed their meal.“

“I would HIGHLY recommend Four Chefs for your wedding (or anything else!) Andy, Marla, and their team were on time and professional. The communicated well throughout the whole wedding process. And the food…omg, I have never received so many compliments! The food exceeded our expectations - so delicious and fresh! Thanks again, Four Chefs!! You are all so amazing!“

“I started off looking for “just a bar” and stumbled across Teddy’s. What I found was a modern interior with a pleasant staff that was willing to accommodate anything and everything. Oyster Bay is not the friendliest place for minorities but genuinely, I feel like I am home at Teddy’s. Thank you!“

“Great place to have party“

“went there for lunch today. burger is fantastic. 🤤🤤“

“Great atmosphere , great food and the service was amazing.“

“We had the Harlem world, the Tex Mex and Fresh fries. Tex Mex with Ribeye nice, tasty and you can tell it’s fresh meat not the frozen BS loved it ! my daughters Harlem World (chopped cheese) was also delish bread was soft and also the fresh cut fries arrived crispy on delivery to Roslyn which is hard to accomplish. Great Job Brendo will pass by to enjoy in house !“

“Great new family restaurant with fantastic vibes. Televisions everywhere. Great bar. Staff and owners create a family environment. We have been there twice in 1 week and they remembered us when we walked in the door the 2nd time. Rueben spring rolls were a must both trips as was the shepard's pie. Meals are huge! Prices are great.“

“We go to Seasons 52 often. Food is pretty good. Love the flatbreads. Like the open kitchen. They used to have a piano player at the bar, which we miss. Service is always good and friendly. The only negative is it's sometimes hard to find parking in that giant lot as it's part of a mall and a movie theater. But, they do have valet.“

“Absolutely fantastic! Impeccable food and service and the place is a plus: elegant and unique atmosphere. An added bonus is the outdoor dining area with great view to the golf course.“

“Great food great customer service“

“I was greeted well by the server at the register and she helped me pick a sandwich, chips and drink meal. Prompt, kind, friendly and attentive to whatever questions I had, my experience throughout was good. There was no room for complaints. The sandwich was good not out of this world but I didn't expect to be blown away either. Sometimes you want a simple sandwich, chips and a drink to wash it all down and I think anyone looking for something simple and fresh will enjoy coming here.

Kid-friendliness: Plenty of seats both inside and out, you will not regret bringing your kids along to enjoy a meal here. The decorations inside are also very thematic to the atmosphere and food.“

“Love it; really exquisite“

“Food was excellent. Everything was fresh and well prepared.“

“Sooo frigging delicious, I literally have no critiques. Absolutely the BEST Lobster roll EVER!!“

“Our group had a wonderful experience at Sullivan’s Quay. Delicious food, cocktails and great service. Thank you Brian and crew! We will be back!💕“

“I just had my wedding at the Heritage Club, and the day went perfectly. I met with Mindy when touring the venue, and she was very helpful in explaining all the details, and she remained hands-on throughout the whole process. Everything was set up beautifully, and the events progressed seamlessly. Guests told me that this wedding was the most "on time" and organized wedding they have ever attended. The maitre-d helped make sure everything was going according to plan, and he even made sure we were looking at the right cameras during various events. Janet, the bridal attendant, was also incredibly helpful beyond words. When my husband's button popped off his tuxedo jacket, she sewed it back on within seconds. When lipstick got on my teeth, she appears with a q-tip and some floss. She was always around to help carry my train or give me a glass of water (with a straw!).There was a moment when I was walking with my full train, but by the time I reached the end of a hall, Janet had magically bustled the dress without me even noticing. From a guest-experience perspective, the Heritage Club also went above and beyond. Everyone raved about how full they were from cocktail hour, but then were still amazed by the quality of the seated dinner and passed desserts. The venue itself is also beautiful, with each space having its distinct characteristics. The ballroom in the daylight is breathtaking and airy.“

“The food is 5 star. Just had the grilled pork chops with mushrooms. One of the best I have ever had. The bar staff is awesome. I highly recommend“

“Great service but the highlight of this place is the food! Large portions, affordable prices, flavorful and fresh! I've visited this establishment in the past for their margaritas (also recommend), so I was pleasantly surprised that the food was so good! Limited menu options but the chef will also accommodate if needed, highly recommend.“

“Been there and the pastry and ice cream is one of a kind. Karaoke Fridayz turned up, not to mention the friendly faces and vibes that makes you feel like you belong. Smoothies and green juice naturally blended.“

“Here’s the thing—Season Bistro is the best restaurant in Long Island. I know how big a statement that is. Go eat there and tell me I’m wrong though. The chef is brilliant, creative, and does things with pork belly that normal chefs would rave about! The entire menu is amazing. And that menu changes 4 times a year—depending on, yes, the season. A+“

“great smoothies great wraps great atmospher friendly and polite candy cane smoothie is amazing“

“Went to my great nieces birthday and Baptism; Charlotte is 1 year old! Apparently, Wellington Grill is being rented as a special catering event location.
Very clean, lots of windows, 2 large rooms including a full bar on one side. A couple of areas for hors douerves and buffet or sit down dinner.
Food was amazing! You choose the menu!
I'd definitely rent this place for an event, party!“

“Celebrated a special birthday with friend/family, always a great meal!“

“Excellent food, beautifully crafted cocktails, warm , comfortable atmosphere. I highly recommend the coach Meeting House“

“Been to this Whole Foods several times. They used to have a much better beer selection back in the day but that game has changed since craft beer really started its appearance in 2009. Went today for an assortment of salads and grabbed 2 types of maraschino cherries. I’m done spending $2.99 on the cheap stuff. Life is too short.“