American Restaurants near Bayville

Mill Creek Tavern American • $$
275 Bayville Ave, Bayville

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Parmigiana & Ricotta Cheese Ravioli
Skirt Steak with Mushroom Rigatoni
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak
Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls
Angus Cheeseburger Sliders
Country Chicken Pot Pie
Crispy Chili Pop Shrimp
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
Jumbo Shrimp Française
Kung Pao Cauliflower

“The food was delicious and many entrees to choose from we were a group of six“

4.6 Superb222 Reviews
Mill Creek Catering & Events Caterers • $$$
275 A Bayville Ave, Bayville

“Been going to Mill Creek Tavern frequently over the last 10 years and was never disappointed. They have a great menu with numerous choices and also have daily specials. The service is above expectations. Always pleasant and efficient. The service staff stops by frequently to remove dishes and anything else on the table that you are done with. One of the best if not the best restaurant I ever had the pleasure of going to.“

4.7 Superb91 Reviews
Hidden Harbor Restaurant Cocktail Bar • $$
341 Bayville Ave, Bayville

“The Hidden harbor has a fresh modern look with a great casual atmosphere. Chef Charlie Murphy has created a outstanding menu delicious appetizers entrees and bar food with his brilliant culinary knowledge. Service is outstanding and very friendly . A must for everyone to try . Two thumbs up“

5 Superb12 Reviews
Ship Wreck Tavern Bar & Grill • $$$
10 Bayville Ave, Bayville

Customers` Favorites

Classic Caesar Salad
The Shipwreck Burger

“Good food and drinks Recommend“

2.8 Average34 Reviews
Wall's Wharf Seafood • $$$
18 Greenwich Ave, Bayville

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Fried Calamari
Oysters on Half Shell
Mussels in Wine Sauce
Watermelon Beet Salad
Mussels Red or White
Mussels Fra Diavolo
Firecracker Shrimp
Seafood Mix Broil
Sesame Tuna Salad
Fried Shrimp blt

“Great place to get some beach time and have a great meal with an awesome view“

3.4 Good151 Reviews
Foster Restaurant American • $$$
39 Roslyn Ave, Sea Cliff

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken with Mashed Potatoes and Spinach
Bacon & Caramelized Onions
Miso Glazed Bone Marrow
Brussel Sprout Salad
Butter Lettuce Salad
Charred Broccolini
Gambas Al Ajillo
RW Bananas Foster
Bavette Steak
Bread Pudding

“We love going to Foster—at this point, you could say we’re regulars. We typically sit at the bar. We especially love their specials, and I’m still thinking about the elk burger I had last year (please bring it back!).The oysters are always fresh and delicious, and the fried chicken is absolutely amazing. Recently, I’ve been loving the salmon with corn and shishito succotash and blueberry teriyaki. Honestly, everything is consistently fresh and delicious.

John, the bartender, makes excellent cocktails—many with fun names like Silence of the Lambrusco. He puts a lot of care into his craft, from house-infused ingredients to thoughtful presentation. He also always keeps you hydrated with their house water, which I truly appreciate.

Happy hour is a great deal and is available at the bar only, Wednesday through Sunday from 5:00–7:00 pm, and all night on Mondays. We love ordering the wood-fired Margherita pizza and fried chicken wings for $12.36, along with their house margarita at $10.30—delicious and affordable.

When we do get a table, the service is always spot on.

We feel lucky to have such an amazing restaurant in our neighborhood.“

4.5 Superb227 Reviews
Grasso's American • $$$
134 Main St, Cold Spring Harbor

Customers` Favorites

Prince Edward Island Mussels
Bacon Wrapped Dates
Classic Cioppino
Bananas Foster
Tiramisu

“The service and the food at grasso’s is always amazing.“

4.6 Superb320 Reviews
Golden globe diner American • $
365 Main St, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Souvlaki with Greek Salad & French Fries or Rice Pita and Tzatziki Sauce
Jumbo Shrimp Stuffed with Crabmeat
Corned Beef & Cabbage
Mushrooms and Onions
Chicken and Veggies
Sunnyside Up Eggs
Huntington Salad
Mexican Omelette
Chocolate Cake
Grilled Cheese

“The only thing missing here are the customers. Breakfast is better than any diner around. Spread the word…“

4.7 Superb162 Reviews
Cafe Testarossa American • $$$
499 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset

Customers` Favorites

In House Made Potato Gnocchi with Crumbled Hot and Sweet Sausage San Marzano Tomatoes
Baked Apple Turnover with a Warm Caramel Sauce and Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
Caesar Salad with Homemade Garlic Sourdough Croutons
Grilled Marinated Octopus with Escarole Ceci Beans
Salmon in a Pinot Grigio Capers Wine Sauce
Tiramisu Cannoli Tartufo & Sorbet
Poached Pear and Red Beet Salad
Veal Meatball Sliders
Chocolate Mousse
Branzino Filet

“Absolutely delicious food and good service. Nice atmosphere.“

4.6 Superb251 Reviews
Milton Point Provisions American • $
615 Milton Rd, Rye

Customers` Favorites

Rotisserie Chicken Club Sandwich
Wood Fired Rotisserie Chicken
Food on Bread with Chicken
Olde Rye Classic Burger
Chicken Pesto Press
Crinkle Cut Fries
MPP Falafel Pita
Famous MPP Chips
Halloumi Salad
Classic Bec

“Stopped by for dinner with my partner, this place feels like a great hidden gem. Everything on the menu looked delicious. Our server Carlos gave us great recommendations and was mindful of my allergies. My partner and I ordered the Halloumi Salad and a cheeseburger. The service was great, our server Carlos made sure we were comfortable. Will definitely come back to try the other items.“

4.7 Superb78 Reviews

You May Also Like