50 Best American Restaurants near Mamaroneck

“Title: A Spicy Delight: Chili Dog with Peppers and OnionsI recently had the pleasure of trying the chili dog with peppers and onions from my favorite local hot dog joint, and I must say, it was a true culinary adventure.From the first bite, the flavors exploded in my mouth. The chili was rich, hearty, and had just the right amount of spice to give it a kick without overwhelming the taste buds. It clung perfectly to the juicy, grilled hot dog, creating a harmonious blend of textures and flavors.But what truly set this chili dog apart was the addition of sautéed peppers and onions. They added a delightful crunch and a burst of freshness to each bite, balancing out the richness of the chili and adding a touch of sweetness.The combination of savory chili, juicy hot dog, and the vibrant crunch of peppers and onions created a symphony of flavors that left me craving more. It's comfort food with a zesty twist, perfect for satisfying those chili dog cravings.Whether you're a die-hard chili dog fan or just looking for a delicious, satisfying meal, I highly recommend giving the chili dog with peppers and onions a try. It's a taste sensation that will leave you coming back for seconds, guaranteed!“

“My friend and I went into Jill’s on a busy Wednesday evening. A very nice crowd filled the bar and seats. We started off with the Birria Tacos which were amazing and ordered a steak sandwich each. When I say that the sandwich was amazing, it was really amazing!!! I would recommend Jill’s to anyone looking for a very nice, casual restaurant!!“

“Some of the other reviews on this page make me smile. Opinions about this Mamaroneck institution are as strong and mixed as their cocktails, but as various bars open and close all around it, this place stays true to itself. It's a neighborhood dive bar of the sort that are ubiquitous in my native Wisconsin, but rare gems in the NYC metro. Craft cocktails and small batch IPAs will not be found here, but simple mixed drinks and domestic drafts are always on hand. Darts and a few other bar games are cheap or free, and the beautiful original window storefront opens up wide to let the warm air in on summer nights. I have had some great memories here and it always feels like a sip of home.“

“Friendly atmosphere and the food was great.“

“We were able to snag a table for two at the last minute with the help of a very accommodating hostess. We spent 10 minutes waiting at the bar, where the bartender was quick, efficient and friendly. Our table was a cozy (not cramped) corner booth for two and the seating was very comfy. Laraine was our sever and she was great. Attentive without intruding. Quick without being frantic. Excellent excellent service. The food was delicious and served hot. There is nothing that we would change about our visit except we should have tried this restaurant sooner!“

“I would definitely recommend the ceviche pescado (fish only) or mixto (mixed with seafood. Light and refreshing. The chicken is very good and moist. You can order a quarter chicken which is convenient for a child. The portions are generous.“

“Tried for the first time and it’s out favorite go to restaurant. What yummy juicy hamburgers. Thank you Dan and Victoria for your wonderful service Kathe and Dan“

“What an amazing, hidden treasure! Excellence in dining, experience, and atmosphere. Perfect from start to finish! Looking for a place to have a great experience… this is it!!!“

“Stopped in for a late lunch.. Usually have the Fajitas, but opted for the Taco's instead.. Split 16 Chicken Wings with my friend Paulie... Everything was Great.. Our waitress Michele who was very friendly and pleasant, made sure everything we ordered was ok... Thank you Michele...“

“I came here on a wednesday night with my wife after a day of travelling and our waitress Nia was very helpful. My wife had some questions about the menu and Nia was very knowledgeable. We don't eat out often and Nia helped us understand the promotions on the menu. The drinks were strong and did not taste watered down. Overall I am very happy with this experience. This was a very filling and cost effective date.“

“Fantastic local spot, gets quite busy during peak lunch and dinner/weekends. Nice salads, burgers and wings. Lots of interesting patty choices (elk, bison, etc). Also, one of the best (most diverse, interesting) rotating domestic crafr tap lists in the county. They're always playing great rock, blues & funk.“

“Everything was so delicious the first time I ate there. I recommend going there all the time“

“I have been to some great places but this is the best place I've been to in New York, hands down. Every single menu item was AMAZING! Farm to table at its best. And the chef is a super friendly great guy and the waiter was awesome. My new go to spot!“

“We frequent Tuck'd Away often and they never disappoint! We just celebrated my son's 30 birthday here with friends and family. Mike and staff did an amazing job. Food, drinks and service were amazing!! I highly recommend!!!“

“Thank you. Guys for showing great hospitality two Maine boys who came down for work. Your staff was very friendly and hospitable,food was great. Thank you too the Lady and Gentleman who served us and recommended our meals. You made our trip back to Bangor, ME better. Thank you for the dessert.“

“First-time visit. Food was delicious and the bartender/server, Peter, was friendly and efficient. Observing other patrons, all seemed to be quite pleased. I’ll be back😊“

“New unique restaurant with a cool vibe. The menu offers many tasty treats that will excite your palette. Our server Vanessa was excellent and attentive. The Owner Brian stopped by and made sure we were enjoying our experience. His personality is warm and inviting. A true Gem in a crowded field.“

“A group of us were recently treated to an evening out at Milton Provisions, a hidden jewel in Rye, NY. The food was exceptional with a healthy farm to table vibe. We were fond of the cozy rustic atmosphere & the warm nature of the staff. Looking forward to returning!!“

“Our server Matt provided us with a great experience. He was super patient with our family of 6 plus my sister in law. He even gave us a great suggestion that saved us a couple of bucks.

We included a few pictures.

The food came out fast and was great. This really would’ve been a 5 star review had it not been for the manager/supervisor Jose. We had asked the hostess for a high chair and never received one. I had made eye contact with Jose for a minute or two and finally just flagged him down. Rather than just grabbing it himself he went to find the waiter who was busy punching in our order…just one suggestion Jose, lead from the front….support your staff and help fill in the gaps rather than talking up clients at the bar.“

“Went to a party there. Felt bad that we had one waitress who had little help, but was really amazing regardless! The food was great! Can’t believe I have never been here! Definitely will be back. Have to try that Bloody Mary!“

“This is my 4th time at Foster's. Our Mimi's meatballs, Burrata Salad and Margherita pizza were all delicious. Last time I had the vegan bolognese they was delicious as well. The place has a great vibe. Everything looks and smells delicious. We'll be back.“

“It really just doesn't get any better“

“One of my favorite restaurants. Food is just like homemade. Menu options are different and creative, alongside of the standards. Pecan soup is to die for. My husband and I are frequent customers who enjoy the cosy atmosphere both outdoors and indoors. Don't ever close!“

“Food was delicious i got the crispy chicken and bacon waffle slider/w fries chicken empanadas and beef empanadas food was hot and cooked thoroughly me and my mother happened to be the only ones in the restaurant and a young man with locs served us wish i got his name he even cooked out food ?“

“The restaurant offers an impressive variety of vegan options. While they do serve chicken and some meat sandwiches and eggs, the staff ensures a safe dining experience by using dedicated grills specifically for plant-based items to prevent any cross-contamination. As always it is advised to ask again when ordering. Additionally, they have a delightful assortment of vegan pastries, like banana bread and blueberry scones.“

“Upscale but not too posh place in Greenwich with a menu that will please almost everyone! It was our first time in the area and this place stood out. The staff was very friendly and food was very good. We didn’t get any starters and I ordered the pork cooked well done so it took a while to get our food, that’s not a complaint just a warning. I would recommend getting a starter, especially if you are drinking because my margarita was stiff! Wish they had some mocktails. It’s a lovely place. Great place for a date night.

Vegetarian options: They had multiple non-meat forward dishes, tofu, mushroom. Etc.

Dietary restrictions: The chef was extremely accommodating to an onion allergy.“

“We had a fantastic dinner at Sweet Grass tonight. The food was perfection and the service was impeccable. Our first time here, but will not be our last.“

“the food, the service, old music“

“Went to a party there. Felt bad that we had one waitress who had little help, but was really amazing regardless! The food was great! Can’t believe I have never been here! Definitely will be back. Have to try that Bloody Mary!“

“been going for about 9 year's.. Best wings in town.. goes with the waffle fries 🍟 😋 👍🏽“

“Excellent Alpine omelette and hash browns, coffee, and great service. My mom enjoyed her homemade corned beef hash and toast. Great place to which we will definitely return when we come back to town!!“

“There ribs are second to none“

“Great food and happy hour specials“

“Wings Robs way and Thai salmon salad“

“Wow. A new treasure. This is a wonderful cafe. First time ordered and wow. My egg and cheese sandwich was amazing. The roll so fresh. Soft and yummy. My home fries perfect. My iced frappe cappuccino was the best ever. Great delivery and wonderful experience. Will order again. Thank you so much.“

“Our waitress appeared to be in a bad mood, not welcoming at all. The food was awful. My burger bun was hard as a rock, the bacon was hard and cold, my kids' broccoli was swimming in some weird oil like liquid, inedible, the chicken Mac& Cheese bowl tasted warm and seemed microwabable.....and we literally had to send back the wine carafe, it was BITTER!!! Needless to say a waste of money! Sorry, I wouldn't recommend, cute place but that is all.“

“Wonderful place, warm ,inviting and great food !!! Been a loyal customer for many years !!! Highly recommend!“

“the food was very delicious and the stars 🌟 🤩 😋 ✨ 😍 👌“

“A very cool place with very good burgers and sandwiches. The pizza also is amazing. I did find the prices somewhat high for what it was though.

Wheelchair accessibility: There are 3 doors just to enter. It is extremely difficult to get someone in a wheelchair into the restaurant as you need multiple people just to open and keep open the multiple doors.“

“Great food great customer service“

“Here’s the thing—Season Bistro is the best restaurant in Long Island. I know how big a statement that is. Go eat there and tell me I’m wrong though. The chef is brilliant, creative, and does things with pork belly that normal chefs would rave about! The entire menu is amazing. And that menu changes 4 times a year—depending on, yes, the season. A+“

“great bartenders... and things of the to watch what you want.“

“I’ve been going for 7 years now, and I’ve never had a bad dinner. I bring my friends and family! I give it 5 stars The staff is always warm and welcoming“

“Beautiful view we sat right by the water The food was very good“

“Always a perfect experience. The staff is friendly and professional and pleasant. Food delicious and they go out of their way to make it special. Exactly what one wants in a dining experience. I took my grand daughter for the second time and she loves it too.“

“Fantastic dining, service and entertainment at Pete's Saloon! 5 stars are in each category! We always enjoy the high energy and meeting friends in a friendly dining atmosphere. Thanks to all the staff and the owner, Anthony, for always an excellent time! You Rock!“

“Joe and Brunie recommend City Island Diner. Stop in 7 am to 3 pm. Brunie had a delicious western omelette and hash browns with a coke. I enjoyed a turkey burger and a big fresh salad with good coffee. Lots of choices on the menu including specials. Really enjoyed walking city island avenue.“

“Fantastic! Just how a quiet town Cafe should be. Quick and friendly service. I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese, everything bagel. I could tell just by how they wrapped it, it was perfect. Unwrap the paper and there it is. Perfectly stacked with perfectly cooked everything! Melt cheese, tender eggs, crisp bacon, and a pillowly soft bagel with just the right amount of chew. Great selection and range overall on the menu. Would highly recommend and will be coming back!“

“Stick to breakfast food and you will be fine. Do not order salads and other items in the menu. They make good bagels, waffles, pancakes, eggs, bacon and fries. The pastries and desserts are also really good. Make sure to only order those things.“