50 Best Seafood Restaurants near Mamaroneck

“If you are looking for authentic Peruvian food, then look no further. The food tastes like your Peruvian family member just made it. It is fresh, so delicious and very filling. They do not hold back on portions and you get the bang for your buck. Please do yourself a favor and try it out!“

“We chose to dine here based on recommendations from coworkers and it lived up to the reputation. Great service! (Our waiter Yuri added to the experience!)

Great food, ambiance, kid friendly... we will definitely come back!“

“Oh my goodness. Sooo good. You know how you can tell a great fish store? The smell! This place is amazing. Great quality. Fun products. Amazing food. Everything I've had is so delicious. From the sushi, to the poke bowls, to the fried soft shell crab sandwich! All amazing. Seats are inside and outside. What a gem!“

“First time here. The front room of the restaurant is too bright. Almost like a diner. We ate in the large back room that has heaters. Food was really good. House salad great. They brought out flounder francaise instead of shrimp but we ate it and it was delicious!“

“Everything was freshly made and delicious.“

“I went with a group of friends for my birthday last night. It was AMAZING. The service was great, everyone was so friendly. The place itself was so clean and cute, really cool vibe. The Apps were great, Hush Puppies and Fried Calamari, yum. I did a make-your-own Seafood Boil. OH MY GOD. The New Zealand Mussels, King Crab and Dungeness Crab was out of this world in the Cajun Butter Sauce. I HIGHLY recommend this spot and will be going back.“

“The best around service is grestaff is friendly. Food is out of this world. Highly recommended“

“Food is very fresh and excellent. Our server, Sandy was very friendly and attentive to our needs“

“We very recently had my mother's 80th birthday party here at Two25 with 40 attendees. I cannot say enough positive things about our experience. First of all, it has a modern, calming and upscale vibe. The restaurant and restrooms are immaculate. Crisp table settings. Cool jazz lightly cascading through the sound system. Just great overall ambiance. From the moment I walked in to inquire about having a party, I met Caitlin, who deftly and expertly handled every single issue, before, during and after, with ease and grace. She made sure that our experience was perfect. A true professional and a credit to the establishment. From the moment that our party started, the staff was incredibly attentive and intuitive. The appetizers of arancini, wontons, and artichokes were absolutely delish. The salads course was perfect. And the main dinner courses were expertly crafted. I personally had the short ribs which were melt in your mouth deliciousness. My wife's salmon was cooked to perfection. And although I did not taste the chicken Milanese, everyone who had it reported it to be excellent. The dessert of gelato and cappuccino was the perfect complement to the amazing meal. And if I didn't stress this point enough, Caitlin and the staff went above and beyond to accommodate every whim. As an amazing example of that, before the day of the event, I mentioned to Caitlin, quite off-handedly, that although their beer selections were top shelf, they didn't have my go-to beer. Would you believe that the manager, Andrea, went out and personally made sure my favorite beer would be on hand for our event. Now that is what I call service!!!!
All of our guests were thoroughly impressed and everyone, invariably, had nothing but positive reviews for the event.
Two25 has skyrocketed up to our family's favorite restaurant.
Thanks again Caitlin and Andrea for an unforgettable night!!“

“I've been visiting Johnny's for over 30+years. Today I went for a lobster roll which replaced the shrimp roll. last year this lobster was so delicious 😋 couldn't wait till the summer. unfortunately, I was highly disappointed. it is not longer on a garlic bun and now served on a plain hot dog bun :( also flavorless! last yr price was $24 and now up to $28 with no flavor and blah bun. please bring back the recipe from years before. thanks“

“Oxtails, j*** wings, Rasta pasta es muy bueno. Cabbage, collards, rice and peas are great compliments to the mains..Prices are extremely reasonable and staff makes everyone feel welcome“

“Fresh tasting seafood with excellent service in a warm and welcoming environment.“

“I had an amazing experience at Captain Louis! The food was absolutely delicious and served fresh, and the service was outstanding from start to finish. Justin went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect—his attention to detail, friendliness, and professionalism really stood out. The service was truly 10 out of 10. I left very happy and will definitely be coming back. Highly recommend Captain Louis to anyone looking for excellent food and top-notch service!“

“My wife and I went to Coral Seafood for our anniversary dinner and were very happy with the quality of service and food. We were immediately acknowledged by the hostess and seated, our waiter promptly came to our table and took water/drink order. Food came out quick and was prepared perfectly (oysters, crab cake and grilled octapus). The staff was attentive the entire time and very professional.“

“We have been back several times now and each time has reinforced our feeling that it's a local favorite. Last night the oysters were superb—bright, a bit salty, like the ocean. My fish tacos were surprisingly delicious. Others had the seafood Fra Diavolo, and one in our group had a steak. Everyone left happy.“

“Great and affordable food. They did my wedding and all events for my family’s gathering. The owner and staff are very personable. Highly recommend it.“

“Es un lindo lugar para compartir con la familia, los empleados son muy atentos y amable, la comida muy buena y llega a la mesa aún caliente 🔥, lo recomiendo 💯.“

“I attended a surprise party this Saturday evening. The cuisine was preselected, waiter service was excellent, should receive raises. The table arrangement was very poor. The party was downstairs in one of the private rooms. We were 25 people at one very long table, basically the length of the room, which made it difficult for guests to get around the seated persons at the head of the table on either side. Having two tables would have been a better arrangement, but one long table was not conducive for conversation since we were so far from the other end of the table. The food; not many complaints, I really didn’t have a problem. I didn’t have a lot of food, but it was delicious. The dessert, sorry not very good. Those Famous Crepes(palacinkes) sorry not that great. A lot of crepe and not a lot of filling. The dish was served with fruit, unfortunately this fruit was not in season, so the watermelon although it added color to the dish, upon tasting it, left much to be desired. Why not serve fruit that is in season? No offense to my party hosts who selected my menu for the evening, it didn’t lend itself to the 5 Star Reputation of Dubrovnik’s. I would like to make reservations and splurge on a dinner on my own, I have a feeling I would LOVE the experience! Btw, another plus was the parking!“

“Best fried or steamed fish you will ever have from a store front. And seriously maybe the cheapest. My go to is the fried flounder sandwich, $5 today, sometimes $6 cash for two huge pieces depending upon market price. They give you the tarter and lemon and tons of other condiments and spices to put on yourself, just how you like it, before they neatly wrap it up and bag it for you. I always tip them two bucks. Been coming and thankful for them for the last 25 years when they used to be a block south. There are similar looking joints but none nearly as consistently good as Dyre Fish is. I have tried so many, hoping. It is the oil they dont allow to be used too long and the fresh fish picked up daily at Hunts Point Fish Market. And the prices have barely gone up in all that time.“

“I went to a family friend’s 70th birthday party they hosted in the Atlantic ballroom. The space was modern and very clean. The food was DELICIOUS!!! And the workers, Yiselle, Estrellita, and Shorty (blonde) made the event so memorable! They paid attention to every detail, whether it was filling our water cups, collecting unused plates and of course they did it all with a warm smile. They were kind, funny and very welcoming. I had a wonderful time! Thank you Yiselle, Estrellita and shorty!!!“

“we ordered 2 orders of fried catfish, 1 with sweet potatoe fries and 1 with Mac&cheese, and also a side of collards. everything was made FRESH. crispy and delicious fish & fries, super cheesey Mac and the collards we're great! not the first or the last time I will order from here. reasonably priced for fish around here.“

“very good food . definitely recommend it“

“Got my lobster roll before they close for the season. No problem about The hot sun the afternoon was extremely blustery. I’ve always loved this place even though it is pricey for a clam shack.“

“Very good service. Food was very flavorful and had an overall great experience.“

“Prices were reasonable! Food was served quick and was delicious! Valet parking. Staff was pleasant.“

“Gluten free people call early and ask for no crackers. �“

“The Henny colada was a 10/10. Went on a Saturday live Dj although kind of loud was an added vibe to this place. The service was amazing. I got the Deep ocean for 1 58$ definitely NOT worth the price could have been a 25/30$ price. The food portions do not add up. It’s a cute place for a simple outing.“

“Love their fried fish and other foods. Their prices for their number orders are getting ridiculous tho and eventually people are gonna stop buying those. The 4 star is purely cause the food tastes good. The service isn't that good tho either“

“The service is great. Everyone is very nice and the food was delicious. Will be returning again. Thank you so much.“

“Food was delicious as usual. Waitress was very sweet :)“

“Great seafood in a fantastic location.“

“Amazing first time experience at this great restaurant!! Food outstanding, service over the top and ambience and space amazing!! It’s been a long time since we had such a great first experience at a restaurant. Everyone should check this place out, will Be sooo fun and delicious!! Steak over the top!! 🥩🍷“

“This was one of the worst dining experiences I've ever had. Things were screwed up from beginning to end with absolutely no sense of apology or remorse. We had a 630 reservation, showed up on time, but we weren't seated until almost 7pm. The waiter came to our table for the first time at 720pm. We had researched the menu ahead of time to make sure there were kid friendly options, but since it was Mother's Day, they were operating with a different menu which is totally fine. We asked the waiter if they had any kid friendly food that wasn't on the menu and he said no and that all we can get is what's listed on the menu, so we went ahead and ordered. About 20 mins after we ordered, we saw that the kids at the table next to us were eating chicken fingers and french fries, so we asked the waiter why he didn't tell us about that option. He said that we didn't ask and he got a bit of an attitude about it. Luckily he was able to change our order and the kids got chicken tenders. We waited patiently for an incredibly long time for our food to come out, and at about 830, I got up and asked the waiter for an ETA on the food and he again gave me an attitude like I was ruining his night and he said "soon". The food came out about 2 minutes later, so we were hopefully going to get on with our evening. Upon further inspection, the chicken tenders that they delivered to my daughter were RAW. Not just slightly under cooked, completely raw, pink, cold chicken. We called the waiter over again and he again had an attitude when we sent the food back. Again, not even a hint of an apology to be found. When the chicken came back out, it was completely burnt, but we decided it wasn't worth the time to talk to the waiter about it again. At this point we had been at the restaurant for 2 hours with a 5 and 8 year old kid, so we just wanted to be done and get out. Again, at no point during this experience did a single person offer an apology or even show an ounce of remorse for how terrible the service was. They ruined my wife and mother-in-law's Mother's Day dinner and they should be ashamed to call themselves a restaurant. We are a local family, but we will never go back there again. I will also make it a point to tell everyone I know that Caffe Regatta is a terrible restaurant.“

“Great raw clams and great price. Steamers , dogs and burgers and fried seafood. BYOB , great place to stop for a quick bite and yearning for raw clams . Nothing fancy but it’s not supposed to be and for what it is it is 5 stars and 2 👍👍 thumbs up!“

“good food nice atmosphere.geart music.“

“Sehr gute Küche, freundliche Bedienung und angenehme Atmosphäre“

“The food was so good !! This is a place that I would go again!!“

“Wonderful experience at Lenny's, the stuff was phenomenal, they had a table for us at a very private quiet area that was perfect for our business dinner. The food, amazing! Overall excellent experience. Would definitely recommend Lenny's.“

“Wow Wow Wow, Need I say more. My wife and I came down to city Island to try The Famous Sammy's. We traveled from Atlanta Georgia and had the pleasure of meeting the owners. Some of the most nicest people I have ever had the pleasure of meeting. Now let me tell you, This is not your ordinary sea food. This food is above all others. I can go on and on about the food just by the reviews will tell you. Just put it this way I will be back on jan 3 for my Birthday 🎈. See you guys then.“

“Man, I love this place. Was recommended by a friend who knows the area well. Had never been before even though this is apparently an old school staple. Reminded me of some of the seafood places I went to as a kid on Long Island. The fish is fresh and delicious, well priced and well portioned. The sides are simple (e.g. sauteed spinach, baked potato, etc.) but well done. Loved the baked clams and chowder, too. Service is fantastic and incredibly accomplished-- can't speak highly enough of the staff. Can't wait to return!“

“The food was great 👍 love the seafood so much!“

“Nice spot for brunch. Waiter was attentive, menu had great selections, food was tasty. Pancakes, salmon eggs Benedict, chicken wrap and burger were liked by all. Lava cake and gelato was really good as well.“

“I recommend Tony’s Pier Restaurant in City Island, NY it is really good food.“

“Great food, large portions, and great service!“

“Ravine and Jennifer are the best ever“

“Great Bistro experience. Onion soup is excellent, one of the better ones in Westchester, not too alcoholic or sharp salty taste, just right. The tuna BLT and fies were excellent. The mussels in garlic white wine was just Ok. it was very bland tasting and a bit gritty.“

“Great food, dim sum delicious and the staff all very helpful!! Definitely a do over“

“My favorite dish is Chicken martini. My wife loves the Pesto Ravioli and Risotto. Super clean place. Will eat here again and bring family.“

“We had a wonderful meal there - all four entrees were excellent, the service was perfect, and the price is very reasonable. I wasn't expecting such a tasty meal!“