19 Best American Restaurants near Mayville

Webb's Carryout + Cafe Coffee Shops • $$
115 W Lake Rd, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Iced Caramel Macchiato

“Amazing staff, service, food and atmosphere, love this place…“

3.5 Good106 Reviews
The Parkview Restaurant American • $
3 East Main Street, Westfield - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gourmet Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Soup
Tomato Bisque and a Ruben
Fantastic Chicken Salad
The Parkview Cold Plate
Chicken Pesto Sandwich
Chicken Caesar Salad
Citrus Shrimp Salad
Neptune Benedict
Breakfast Burrito
Chicken Pot Pie

“Chicken Caesar wrap was amazing! Haven’t had grits this good since being in the south. Highly recommended“

4.8 Superb223 Reviews
Bemus Point Inn Restaurant American • $
4958 Main Street, Bemus Point - 9.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Steak & Eggs w Hash Brown Casserole & Toast
11 Eggs Bacon Home Fries Toast
Jumbo Cinnamon Roll
English Muffin
French Fries
Cinnamon Bun
Creme Brulee
Hashbrowns
Sandwich
Homefries

“Great people great food 😎“

4.8 Superb150 Reviews
The Cornerstone - family restaurant and bakery American • $
104 E Main St, Sherman - 8.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cherry Cobbler with Vanilla Ice Cream
Rodeo Burger and Fries
Breakfast Pizza
Homemade Bread
Western Burger
Mashed Potatoes
Sausage Gravy
Sandwich
Fish Fry
Salad

“Cute establishment and friendly people, they even remember your crazy haystack salad requirements ;)“

4.9 Superb72 Reviews
Brazill's on Main American • $$
7 East Main Street, Westfield - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pan Seared Scallops with Asparagus and Risotto
5 \u0026 20 Beer Braised Short Ribs
Maple Brined Grilled Pork Chop
Maple Mustard Grilled Salmon
12 Oz Steak Dinner Special
Honey Glazed Grilled Pear
Braised Beef Short Ribs
Steak with Whiskey Sauce
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp

“ABSOLUTELY amazing tonight .Tyler and another gentleman ran the entire house flawlessly. and tables were pretty steady.. a couple beside us was passing through from Toronto to Cleveland and their young children sat beside us . every plate of food that came out looked delicious!! they had chicken Alfredo on special Their calamari is on point! We had the strip steak and the scallops with risotto. lobster bisque. was rhe soup. you get a great dinner starting from $25-$40. includes soup or salad and bread with house made dipping oil. AMAZING This new chef is off the charts !!! The restaurant is so very clean as well. price point in my opinion is under priced for portuon sizs and dining experience. This is a gem. get to Westfield“

4.7 Superb109 Reviews
6

Splash

Splash American • $$
60 Lakeside Dr, Bemus Point - 8.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Salmon Strips

“Outstanding wine selection and phenomenal desserts, not to mention the fantastic service, I highly recommend a visit to a unique and worthwhile establishment. We were able to impress our out of town guests with delicious wine and delectable desserts. Thank you, Splash!“

4.6 Superb101 Reviews
Quagliana's Bark Grill American • $$
14 East Pearl Street, Westfield - 6.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms
Chicken Parmigiana
Veal Parmigiana
Select a Pasta
Select a Sauce
Fish and Chips
Dinner Salad
Lasagna

“Found this gem last night by accident and I was blown away by how great the food was. Love the old building and classic atmosphere. The history of the building and the staff was fantastic. We will most definitely be back“

4.6 Superb87 Reviews
Bemus Point Ferry. And Casino restaurant American • $$
Bemus Street, Bemus Point - 8.67 miles

“Great people great food 😎“

4.8 Superb10 Reviews
Ready About Sailing at Long Point State Park American • $
4459 NY-430, Bemus Point - 7.27 miles

“Great customer service price about right ght 46.00 dollars with 3% tip totaled
Video of store/restaurant very clean

Parking: You could even come there by boat at the marina

Kid-friendliness: Great place to take kids to eat well watching boat ⛵? come into the marina even rentals ask cashier about the rentals“

4.5 Superb16 Reviews
10

14 Main

14 Main American • $
14 Main Street, Bemus Point - 8.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Pie Ala Mode
Enjoy a Cocktail
Home Made Chips
Bistro Burger
Beef on Weck
Fish Fry

“Everything on the menu is fantastic!“

4.5 Superb110 Reviews
Gather at the St Elmo American • $$
1 Pratt Avenue, Chautauqua - 3.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Burrata on Toast
Shrimp Cargot

“We just had a phenomenal dinner at Intermezzo and we could not be more pleased. The service was the best we have experienced in Chautauqua ( and outside of CHQ). The specialty cocktails were all delicious and well crafted. We had an appetizer of tuna tacos that was huge and flavorful. One of us had the shrimp “cargots “ (also a app)which was accompanied by two huge slabs of bread for dipping. Two of us had the shrimp and grits which was divine. One person had the buratta on focaccia and it rocked. I had the pizza of marinara, truffle oil, mushrooms and cheese which melted in my mouth and it had cauliflower crust that was the best I have had. The wines were also great. To top it all off, it was comparatively inexpensive to other places on the ground. Totally worth a visit.“

4.1 Good10 Reviews
Jacks Barcelona Drive In Italian • $
8249 1st Street, Westfield - 7.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sausage Hoagie and Curly Fries
Fish Fry and Onion Rings
French Toast Platter
Black Bean Burger
Soup and Sandwich
Veggie Omelette
Elderberry Pie
Grilled Veggie
Seafood Salad
Perch Sandwich

“Fantastic stop on a journey! The food was stellar, the staff was wonderful, and the atmosphere was supreme!“

4.7 Superb99 Reviews
Larry's Cantina Restaurant Bar & Grill • $
11-13 North Portage Street, Westfield - 6.05 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries
Clam Strip Basket
Bernies Wings
Pickle

“The shrimp basket is my faveeee.“

4.6 Superb36 Reviews
Nickel Plate Depot Bar • $$
131 Central Avenue, Brocton - 10.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Two Dollar Tacos

“Excellent food, friendly staff, great service - we’ll be back!“

4.5 Superb53 Reviews
Main Diner Diner • $
40 East Main Street, Westfield - 6.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheeseburger with Fries
Breakfast Sandwich
Grilled Cheese
Egg Meat Toast
Cinnamon Roll
Chicken Philly
Home Fries
Hash Browns
Pancakes

“Have historical interest in old diners with this diner being the hometown diner. Could anyone tell me why the diner does not have its original green marble glass above each window?“

4.5 Superb198 Reviews
Guppy's Restaurant & Tavern Seafood • $$
4663 East Lake Road, Bemus Point - 6.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger with Steak Fries
Beer Battered Haddock Fish Fry
Steak Salad with French Fries
Meatball Sub with Fries
The Buffalo Chicken
Mussels Appetizer
Lime Margherita
Broiled Haddock
Chicken Pot Pie
Chicken Alfredo

“We've been going to Guppy's for years. ALWAYS great food & service very attentive, the drinks are also good. We I've in Ohio but never miss Guppy's when we go to Chautauqua Lake, it's amazing.“

4.5 Superb323 Reviews
Bridgeview One Stop Deli Pizzeria C-Store Pizza Takeaway • $
4910 Main Street, Bemus Point - 9.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Famous Boli and Bronco Burgers
Garden Pizza with Pepperoni
Pepperoni Pizza
Pastry Case
Sheet Pizza
Doughnut
Ribs

“The nicest people you could meet, and some of the Best food for miles. I live nearby and have enjoyed the Bridgeview for years.“

4.4 Superb46 Reviews
Bemus Point Golf Club & Tap House American • $$
72 Main Street, Bemus Point - 8.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Medium Rare Steak and Frited
Fried Brussel Sprouts
Fried Chicken PO
Flight of Beers
Tap House Salad
Club Sandwich
Burrito Bowl
Tuna Bites
Fish Tacos

“We love the Taphouse. Great people and always trying to improve Bemus!“

4.4 Superb93 Reviews
19

2 Ames

2 Ames American • $$
2 Ames Avenue, Chautauqua - 3.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Charcuterie Board
Shrimp and Grits
Oxtail Poutine
Cheese

“Just had the pork snitzel with red cabbage and potato pancake. Amazing!!“

3.7 Good168 Reviews

Discover More In Mayville

You May Also Like