Custom Cakes near Merrick, NY

1

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
Merrick Mall &, 2144 Johnston Pl, Merrick

“Their ice cream cakes are great“

2.5 Average13 Reviews
Bread in Oven Bakery • $
13 W Marie St, Hicksville - 7.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tower Wedding Cake with Fresh
Fresh Flower Wedding Cake
Customized Birthday Cake
Customized Theme Cake
Gulab Jamun Pastries
Red Velvet Cup Cake
Butterscotch Pastry
Gulab Jamun Pastry
Dried Fruits Cake
Butter Cream Cake

“My wife was looking for a bakery who made eggless cakes and she stumbled upon this bakery by chance. She ordered a custom made gulab jamun flavored eggless cakes and. It was definitely one of the best cakes I had especially for my birthday. My folks also grabbed a few puffs - mixed vegetable and paneer puffs while they went to grab the cake. Those were spicy and delicious as well. We will be ordering regularly from this bakery moving forward. Definitely want to try all their different flavored items. Highly recommended!“

4.9 Superb62 Reviews
The Sweet Peace Bakery • $
26A Atlantic Ave, Lynbrook - 6.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

Full Size Cupcakes
Smores Truffle
Mini Cupcakes
Wedding Cake

“We had the best experience ever with this bakery - the cake was included in our venue pricing through this bakery, and I can definitely see why! Working with Alison to schedule and have our tasting, which was just down right fun...(because of COVID we had to take our samples home... and she loaded us up with some extras to share with friends) to showing her our vision for the cake on the day of, and then actually SEEING and EATING it at our wedding was perfect all the way through. They really incorporated everything we asked for, and it was simply delicious!!! We even asked for an extra birthday cupcake for our nephew to have on the day of the wedding, and they made it sooo cute! (wish I could figure out how to add a picture here... It was SO pretty!!!)“

5 Superb31 Reviews
4

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
301A Bedford Ave, Bellmore - 1.36 miles

Customers` Favorites

Reese's Peanut Butter Sundae Dasher
Square Ice Cream Celebration Cake
Mint KitKat Duos Sundae Dasher
Cookie Butter Sundae Dasher
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Heath Sundae Dasher
Cookie Butter Shake
Cookie Puss Cake
Chipsters 6-Pack
Flying Saucers

“I had the best experience at Carvel today! My server-extraordinare Jessica gave me world-class service and kindly helped me pick out the perfect Fudgy the Whale cake! Def coming back! Her boss Amanda was stellar as well! Best Carvel in Nassau!“

4.8 Superb43 Reviews
Sunflower Bake Shop Bakery •
346 Hempstead Ave, West Hempstead - 5.77 miles

“I ordered a specialty cake for my mother and it was FABULOUS! The cake was unique, 2 - tier choc and vanilla with a hazelnut cream filling. It was covered in a lovely lavender frosting with lace flowers and unique lettering. It was fresh and special!“

4.9 Superb29 Reviews
Agrigento Bakery Bakery • $$
4032 Austin Blvd, Island Park - 6.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sfogliatella and Cannolis
Croissant
Pie

“Excellent baked goods. Delicious pastry and the CANOLI“

4.7 Superb51 Reviews
Nita's Pastries Inc Bakery •
Holly Ave, Hempstead - 4.17 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake Chocolate Chip Cookie

“Thank you Nita's Pastries for being so accommodating on such short notice. You went above and beyond to make sure that my grandson had his superhero Spiderman cake. The excitement on his face was priceless. And the cake and cupcakes tasted just as amazing as they look. My daughter was beyond pleased.“

4.9 Superb23 Reviews
Baked by Emily Rose Bakery •
518 Broadway Suite B, Massapequa - 4.41 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gift Basket

“I highly recommend Baked by Emily Rose! They made a beautiful cake for my mom’s special birthday. Mom loved it. Very delicious!“

5 Superb15 Reviews
Sydney's Sweets Bakery • $$
465 Hempstead Ave, West Hempstead - 5.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake Cake Slice
Apple Crumb and Key Lime Cupcakes
Southern Red Velvet Cake Jar
Chocolate Nutella Cake Jar
Caramel Apple Pie Cake Jar
Cake Pops and Cupcakes
Wedding Dessert Table
Cupcake Variety Pack
Custom Fondant Cake
Sweet Potato Swirl

“Thank you so much for the beautiful cupcakes for my daughters bridal shower! Everyone was Ravi g about them. Not only were they gorgeous but they were delicious ! I gave your name to a few of guests“

4.6 Superb41 Reviews
Moscato Bakery & Cafe Bakery • $$
546 Stewart Ave, Bethpage - 6.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Lobster Tails
Cheesecake
Cupcake
Cannoli

“Delicious sfogliatelle, cannolis, napoleons, and Italian bread 🥖“

4.6 Superb40 Reviews
Pure Sugar, Inc Patisserie/Cake Shop • $$
5 Broadway, Amityville - 7.1 miles

“Amazing cakes, and it’s not just about looks, the cake tasted amazing!!! Will def use again and already have him booked for my sons birthday party. 10 STARS“

5 Superb11 Reviews
Capri Bakery Bakery • $
3434 Merrick Rd, Seaford - 2.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pistachio Cannoli Chocolate Chip Cannoli
Chocolate Pudding Eclair
Black and White Cookies
Chocolate Pudding Tarts
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Lobster Tail Cannoli
Cream Puff Cannoli
Cream Puff Custard
French Cream Puff
Rum Baba Custard

“Family bought the rainbow cookie cake for my birthday today! Was the best cake I have ever had! Everyone was obsessed with it!! Thank you Capri Bakery for making my birthday extra sweet!“

4.5 Superb58 Reviews
13

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
392-A N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage - 5.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“Carvel ice cream cakes bring out the childhood nostalgia in me!I did not spend much time in store but the older gentleman who attended to me was super helpful. He made suggestions for best results before serving and offered to decorate the cake further for us.The cake was as I remembered and I was transported back to my childhood and savoured each mouthful.Carvel has my heart!“

4.7 Superb17 Reviews
Cakes By Renee J Bakery • $$
6 Glover Cir, Lynbrook - 6.4 miles

“I had a last minute request for my daughter's 8th birthday. Allison @ Sweet Peace was more than accommodating. Her customer service on the phone made me feel as I though I was a long time family friend. Impeccable customer service! The cake I ordered and the one my daughter ordered for my birthday was as awesome as the impeccable customer service Sweet Peace exhibited. I told Allison she is my family's pastry shop for life!“

5 Superb7 Reviews
Vin’s Bake House Bakery • $
1030 Park Blvd, Massapequa Park - 5.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Cookie House
Wedding Cake
Cakes

“Visit Date: January 17, 2025

I came here with my friend, I wanted to try it because I'm currently dating a Vin and it looked like a good bakery. My friend and I were impressed with what we bought. I got the peanut butter square to try and it was so delicious, a good amount of peanut butter and chocolate. I got the linzer tart which I split with my family later on that night and the jelly inside the linzer tart was amazing, a crisp fruity taste! The coffee was also good I didn't expect the coffee to be good but it was a good cup of coffee. This is a bakery worth visiting.“

4.4 Superb37 Reviews
The Chocolate Duck Custom Cakes • $$
310 Main St, Farmingdale - 7.32 miles

“Great Kids Party… Highly recommend for children,“

4.5 Superb12 Reviews
Layers Bakeshop Bakery •
20 Meacham Ave suite g, Elmont - 7.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

3 Milk Sundae Tres Leche
Triple Chocolate Cookie
Dark Chocolate Brownie
Lotus Biscoff Sundae
Strawberry Cupcake
Red Velvet Cake
Cadbury Brownie
Vanilla Cupcake
Chocolate Mouse
Ferrero Rocher

“We had a cake made for my daughter’s birthday party. She loved their vanilla iced cupcake, so I asked for half vanilla and half chocolate icing. It was simple and elegant and most importantly delicious. Everyone raved about it! It’s so hard to find a good bakery these days, but this place is amazing.“

4.3 Superb130 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
297 N Broadway, Jericho - 8.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cupcake Variety 6-Pack - Ready Now
Founder's Favorite - Freezer
Peanut Butter Cup Perfection
Create Your Own Shake
Oreo Overload

“I have visited this store unexpectedly, and I must admit, the staff’s were very friendly and helpful, the atmosphere was very pleasant and extremely welcoming. This store is very tidy and make anyone feel they’re being treated right and they have a great selection of products to choose from.
Jason- Queens- NYC
Attorney- In- Fact!“

4.3 Superb86 Reviews
Sweet Karma Desserts Custom Cakes
136 Manetto Hill Rd, Plainview - 9.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Funfetti Cupcakes
GF Funfetti Cupcakes
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
GF Tiramisu
Bakery

“Brian designed our dream cake for our October Friday the 13th wedding. We went in with some ideas, bits and pieces from multiple photos and what was created blew our minds. Everyone was speechless when it came out. Aside from the delicious taste of the cake itself the details and time that was poured into it is one that we truly appreciate and love. We been to the shop multiple times before the wedding just to grab some goodies because everything is tasty and above the typical/traditional desserts you’d expect. Highly recommended bakery for sure.“

4.3 Superb44 Reviews
Sweet Serindipty Bakery • $$
Online, Lynbrook - 6.31 miles

“Ordered a pull apart cupcake cake for my daughter's 1st bday. All the guests enjoyed. Tasted fresh and delicious. Thank you !!!“

5 Superb1 Reviews
Spiga Bakery Bakery • $
2680 Merrick Rd, Bellmore - 1.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Great Tasting over the Top Flavored Doughnuts
Assortment of Cookies
Maple Bacon Doughnut
Homemade Doughnut
Pizza and Pastry
Blueberry Glazed
Cakes and Cakes
Assorted Donuts
Chicken Panini
Pepperoni Pizza

“The best Bakery around!! Everything from the food to the staff, They’re fantastic💯“

4.2 Good92 Reviews
Cardinali Bakery & Pastry Shop Bakery • $
465 Westbury Ave, Carle Place - 6.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Red Velvet Cake Carrot Cake Tres Leches Cake
Strawberry Shortcake
Rainbow Cookies
Cheesecake
Apple Pie
Doughnut
Cupcake
Bakery

“Rainbow cookies Cannolis Napoleon Cheesecake A MUST !! The bread… best in the world“

4.1 Good70 Reviews
Zio’s casa di dolce Bakery • $$
3649 Merrick Rd, Seaford - 2.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Assorted Italian Cookie Tray
Lemon Meringue Pie
Rainbow Cookies
Almond Biscotti
Semolina Bread
Birthday Cake
Italian Bread
Cream Puffs
Cannolis

“Great Italian bread the pastries/cakes are good as well. Keep up the great quality“

4.1 Good91 Reviews
24

Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
270 Hillside Ave., Williston Park - 8.19 miles

“Uhhhh, it’s carvel, of course it’s amazing in every way!!! Love it there, yummy and the staff is great. The owner is such a nice person... we love him.“

3.9 Good25 Reviews
Polito Bakery Bakery • $
3365 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park - 8.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Custard Filled
Birthday Cake

“Such amazing pastry, breads and cakes. Great service and kind and welcoming staff.“

3.5 Good24 Reviews
Gennarris Italian & French Bakery •
465 Westbury Ave, Carle Place - 6.74 miles
3.2 Average20 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
6 Broadway, Lynbrook - 6.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oreo Overload

“EXPENSIVE!!!!! I purchased a pint of watermelon sorbet (DEE-LISH-OUS!) and a scoop of strawberry cake batter ice cream. The total was $23! Listen... I'm all for a GREAT time when it comes to food/beverages/desserts. But I must admit; I was looking for the flecks of sterling silver in the ice cream after the server told me how much I owe... WOW!!!

Would I go again? More than likely--
But fair warning... Bring your Black Card!

Parking: Very strange parking situation in that area-- It's in the 5 corners area of the town. So be careful/make certain you're going the right way as two of the streets are one-way running north and south... and the main avenue runs east and west.“

3.3 Good38 Reviews

Merrick’s Other Flavors