16 Best American Restaurants near Mongaup Valley

“My husband and I have been here at least a half dozen times and we enjoy the food and the service...the waitress refers to herself as "Salty Maryanne"...is she a little salty? Sure but that doesn't bother us...she and my husband are both from Brooklyn so they talk about the old neighborhood. Bottom line is anyone can have an off day...you have no idea what other people are dealing with and they have to come to work and do the best they can do. As a former waitress, I guess I'm just a little more sympathetic than most. I certainly wouldn't trash a restaurant after one experience there but that's just me.“

“Very family orientated and the food is so delicious“

“The best chicken bacon ranch sandwich in town!!!!!“

“My wife and I were looking for a quick stop for a beer after a day on the lake. Found this place and the friendly greeting sold us right away. Handshakes and introduction from Tom and Jerry who we’re working behind the bar. We have never experienced before. We ended up sharing an appetizer from their specials and it was delicious. We will definitely be back. Definitely worth a trip for all.“

“Excellent service, very, very nice staff.. prices are extremely reasonable & the atmosphere is always fun! food is ready quickly & delicious!!! 1000% recommend 🤗“

“Had an amazing lunch on our way back to Ithaca. Everything was fresh, homemade and so flavorful! Folks were very friendly and welcoming, too. This place is a gem!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A Perfect Family Dining Gem in Monticello!
Our family stayed at the Kartrite Resort and found this absolute treasure of a restaurant! From the moment we walked in, we were enveloped in such a warm, wonderful family atmosphere. The heart of this place is truly the family running it. It was so special to see the father working side-by-side with his sons—some warmly taking orders at the front with big smiles, and others diligently preparing food in the kitchen. You can feel the pride and love they put into their business.

And the food? ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. Every single one of us, from the adults to the kids, cleaned our plates. The kids are still raving about the fries (some of the best we've ever had!) and their meals. The menu is incredible, with unlimited choices to satisfy any craving. Whether you want a hearty comfort meal, a fresh salad, or something delicious for the little ones, they have it all.

If you're visiting the area or staying at Kartrite, this is a must-visit. Delicious, generous food served by the kindest, hardest-working family. We left with full bellies and full hearts. We can't wait to come back on our next trip! Thank you for an exceptional dining experience.“

“Ok, so since i last visited, the price went up 4x. Parking was almost full, and people were still coming in. It was my first time launching my own boat, on a very busy day.On the launch, my friend was guiding me, but when the time came to pull the boat out, i struggled a little. The owner came out and helped me by guiding my steering. No one got upset, and we managed to be quick about it without unnecessary stress.I can recommend that if you are there on a busy weekend, use the marina, pay the fee, and remove stress from your life.“

“Hungry for a quick lunch or dinner? They have more than just ice cream. Not to mention a liquor store next door as well. Tables are available again(they were removed during Covid). And during the warmer weather you can sit out on the porch and watch the world go by.“

“This place is the best hands down.“

“I just love this place! I haven’t found a bakery this warm and friendly in decades! Not only do they have a mouthwatering selection, the owners are just about the friendliest people ever. This place is a gem!“

“Food and atmosphere is amazing. Try the Spring rolls and sweet and spicy bone in wings! A definite must. Raymond was an absolute wonderful Host along with his attention to detail Staff. I cant wait to go back. Enjoy , I am sure you will.“

“food was delicious, our server was very cheerful and friendly“

“I stumbled upon Miss Monticello’s on a trip upstate from NYC. It’s just a classic good ole diner with plenty of options, I personally got the patty melt and it was really good. The service is great and my server was so kind and attentive. I also ordered a piece of the peanut butter chocolate pie thing and it was delicious. Can’t wait to come back on my next trip upstate! :)“

“We were there twice once last nite for Dinner June 29th and June 30th for breakfast. Both times the food was good and the staff were very friendly.“

“I must say that we were very pleasantly surprised at how good this place was. Our waiter had that old school style to him. Not some unhappy, underdressed person, but he had class and good service.

As for the food. The burger and fries were really good, but the gems of the meal were the tea, yes the tea, and the pastrami reuben. That sandwich was one of the best I have ever had.

Will definitely go back on my next trip.“