20 Best Seafood Restaurants in Montauk

“Great service by all.Food was amazing and the bartender offered exceptional service.“

“Great lobster rolls !!! - Good service!“

“Great food and service Ana the restaurant is beautiful“

“LOVE! The view (sunset side)& the chill vibe 💙💙On the sand dining if so desired, lounging couches in the sand & also picnic tables/plastic patio table outdoor-see video) large indoor bar & dining area. Families welcome. We just loved the relaxed atmosphere. Can dress up or not. Food great, service slow, ( Monday night-indoor empty. Servers were nice but slow and had to ask others for drink, etc. enjoy the view, about the view, but get your drink order in quick cuz you might be waiting. Such a great area. Quiet quaint. On Navy beach. My hubby had the cod special. Very good!(but if your hungry order a side)I had the Buddha bowl. Came dry-had to ask for a dressing. Just ok. They had a vinaigrette. Would definitely go back. We were a walk in for 2, so got a great porch bar seat and were there early. If you want to sit outside, make a reservation. In a weird area, but don’t let that deter you. Loved.“

“We LOVE it here!!! The food is AMAZING and fresh, the staff are welcoming, and so polite! Tables are spread out and you feel 100% safe. Service is top notch and the owners are the NICEST people. We come out here every Summer and you bet we are here atleast once or twice on vacation. It’s that good! My daughter loves the shrimp and lobster. 🍤🦞“

“The Beach Club is a fantastic way to spend your afternoon. Our server Luna, went above and beyond to ensure we had a great time. I've been coming to Gurneys for many years and service has been mixed but today was great and I'm looking forward to visiting again next season. Happy Labor Day!“

“Great porterhouse and considerate and friendly employees“

“excellent service.. excellent food../ amazing fluke sashimi!! and that burger!!! yum“

“My favorite place in Montauk . Sunset 🌅 is the best there“

“We have been going to see Tom at Star Island Grill for quite some time....whether we have fish or not....
He and his crew have treated us to an amazing meal and friendship, each time...
Tonight, he had time to prepare something a little different.... the night before, we were talking about things we like.... and tonight, he prepared 3 dishes with all we talked about... absolutely over the top flavor and quality!
All dishes were Fluke....
1) Fish in Sambuca sauce with zucchini over asparagus.
2) Panco Crusted with tomatoes, onion and peppers in wine sauce over vegetables
3) Shrimp Stuffed filet over risotto
And the most delicious brownie, custard, ice cream as dessert...“

“Delicious 2-for-1 lobster rolls! Lots of lobster and not too much mayo. Extensive fresh, prepared and "frozen-fresh" seafood and desserts.“

“We came across this place, and took the first table available. I like that water refills are self served to quench my thirst on a hot summer day! The fish were fresh, service attentive, and the atmosphere upbeat. No frills, excellent food.“

“The fries were amazing, they only had one working bathroom while we’re were here and it is a tight squeeze. There was a line and the sink was not draining well. The lobster roll was delish but the kids chicken quesadilla was amazing! I stole quite a few bites. My husband had the fish sandwich also good! The drinks were cold and delicious. We got sat right away but the food took a bit long to come out.“

“great place, great owners! it a must to go here and try the food and drinks! 5 STARS!“

“I look forward to coming to eat here every year when I visit my relatives in Long Island, NY! The food is so delicious and filling and the servers are super friendly and helpful! Recently, I ate here with some family members and our server, Alexis, was the sweetest! She was super sweet, smiley, friendly, and beautiful. I had a wonderful dinner, and the sunset looking out on the water was a beautiful setting for dinner. Can't wait to come back again next year!“

“Great lobster broil! Busy but given COVID they did great with service. Lean and nicely spaced apart tables.“

“Absolutely delicious food! You hook, they cook!!
It was just another amazon dinner in one of my favorite place! Huge portions for three people! We brought seabass and lean cod and that all what we got!!! Super cool and great service! 50% occupancy due to COVID restrictions which made us feel safe! Definitely highly recommended by me as being picky gourmand ?.“

“This is a review for the restaurant! We had a fantastic meal here. Our server was friendly and attentive. Ambiance was quiet and relaxing. We had a great table with a beautiful view of the ocean (and we even saw whales jumping out of the water)! The food was fresh and delicious. We had the Caesar salad & tomato mozzarella salad to start and the shrimp pasta & ribeye steak special for our mains. While it wasn’t a cheap meal, we were prepared and happy to pay for the high quality meal we had. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Pricey but worth it. The quality was amazing. Had the peel and eat shrimp, mussels, lobster Mac and cheese and poke bowl. Service was amazing. No outdoor seating available but since it was cool it was fine. Highly recommend this place. Going back once more before we leave since it is our favorite place in town.“

“Topside...my very favorite Montauk dining spot!“