16 Best Seafood Restaurants in Montauk

“Great service by all.Food was amazing and the bartender offered exceptional service.“

“Great lobster rolls !!! - Good service!“

“Delicious 2-for-1 lobster rolls! Lots of lobster and not too much mayo. Extensive fresh, prepared and "frozen-fresh" seafood and desserts.“

“hands down the best restaurant in Montauk - no need to look any further. extremely fresh and creative dishes that are amazing every single time. most of the ingredients for their menu items are local!! either coming from local fishermen or farms, which is amazing and so unique. it really makes all the difference in the food quality. any restaurant that has seasonal menu items i trust!! i love that they change their menu and specials based on the seasons. staff is 10/10 and family vibes are 10/10. you feel like a real part of MTK community here. will always be back!!“

“I had my daughter and her fiancés Welcome Party the night before their wedding at Cap’s last weekend. I booked while Sammy was still owner. He graciously handed my party over to the new owner Amy as she took over the restaurant. While they all were doing the work for their opening, Amy worked with me and together we made the final plans for a party of about 107 people plus a few children!!! Food was fresh and delicious. Atmosphere was very nice. Thank You for a memorable night. Every one enjoyed the night.“

“Such a lovely venue. This charming yacht club offers a respite from the more heavily touristed areas of Long Island and has a more local feel. The staff were very welcoming and the chef was brilliant too. The restaurant has been recommended to us by Viking Fleet, as somewhere to bring our catch for cooking. We had caught around 5 good sized Porgies and a couple of Sea Bass. The chef turned these into dishes from around the world. Tempura, fish tacos, bang bang salad and a Chinese style rice dish.
Highly recommend.“

“My daughter and husband had their wedding reception at Navy Beach restaurant recently. Service, food and venue were first rate. Was asked multiple times if all was well and communications with Franklin were great through the planning process and day of wedding. What a fun and festive vibe on the beach for the cocktail hour then dinner in the restaurant overlooking the beach! Bar service was polite, friendly and very helpful. All servers were polite and responsive. The food was fresh, well presented, perfectly seasoned and expertly cooked. Best meal I have had in a very long time! Guests were raving about the seafood appetizers and main meal. I loved the quartered perfectly cooked burger appetizer! A perfect venue for the wedding! Weather highlights its beauty. Fun vibe!“

“Great porterhouse and considerate and friendly employees“

“Wonderful bar or tavern with some excelled pub grub. I had the scallop sandwich. Delicious. Others in the group had the open tuna sandwich and a pair of hearty looking salads.
I liked it so much that we came back the following day for lunch, but they’re closed on Mondays. In hope to come again one day.“

“Great lobster broil! Busy but given COVID they did great with service. Lean and nicely spaced apart tables.“

“Absolutely delicious food! You hook, they cook!!
It was just another amazon dinner in one of my favorite place! Huge portions for three people! We brought seabass and lean cod and that all what we got!!! Super cool and great service! 50% occupancy due to COVID restrictions which made us feel safe! Definitely highly recommended by me as being picky gourmand ?.“

“great place, great owners! it a must to go here and try the food and drinks! 5 STARS!“

“Best Restaurant in Montauk by far. From the chef in the back to the staff in the front. We stayed in Montauk for 3 weeks and this is the only place (besides Shagwong) where we went 3 times. Food was fantastic from the Duck, to the German Night Sauerbraten, to the BEST clam chowder around. Thanks for great food and service...“

“Our experience was absolutely phenomenal at the Igloos!!! We were on an overnight trip to Gurneys and it was the perfect addition to a couples night out. We had nice alone time + the food, service, drinks and vibes were top tier. We enjoyed the artisanal platter, the pretzel, the salmon & filet mignon. I was so beyond happy we made the decision to eat here! So well worth every penny! The board games and awesome music in the igloos were a phenomenal touch!“

“So impressed with the service at Salivar’s - we took a chance and our big party rolled in with no reservation on a summer Friday night and Mimi at the front desk was so accommodating, offering us several options without batting an eye. We then were sat at a great table and our server Kelsey (along with several other staff members) juggled our chaos with grace. She was so sweet and totally made our night. Food was also delicious, from seafood specials to chicken and burgers to the kids options - we ordered everything on the menu and no one was disappointed. Thank you Salivar’s!!!“

“Topside...my very favorite Montauk dining spot!“