10 Best Seafood Restaurants in New Shoreham

“Awesome muscles and oysters, highly recommend them.“

“Love Kimberly’s! Seafood Fra Diavlo is one of the best I have had. Highly recommend:)“

“The food was delicious! Shrimp and Grits best I have had since I left the South! Black Sea Bass fresh fish was outstanding!! Martini was top notch!!!“

“We stumbled upon Lobster Craft, which shares a kitchen with The Cracked Mug (another highly recommended spot for breakfast and coffee that has moved this year!) and we were blown away! Our crew got:- NE Clam Chowder- best we have found so far on the island.- Heat Wave- absolutely dynamite. Different take on a lobster roll, with a subtly spicy edge. Lobster was cooked perfectly and so tender and flavorful!- Grilled Mahi Sandwich- delicious! Cooked perfectly, and nice and light, yet somehow filling. Also came with homemade chips that we devoured.- Chicken fingers and fries- you really can’t go wrong. Again, though, cooked perfectly and very fresh tasting. Served with a yummy honey mustard sauce.- Key Lime Pie- an unexpected sweet treat for dessert. Not something I typically gravitate toward but it was so creamy and light and zesty.Highly recommend this place. We will definitely be hitting this spot each time we come back to BI from now on!!“

“was a great place my son loved it we all did the fish and chips was great“

“I love this place. Each time I am in BI I eat here. On my last visit I had an amazing lobster. Photo in comments. Waitress was nice and had a good sense of humor. Was happy to eat outdoors with a nice breeze.“

“Love the outside Beach Bar!!“

“We had a delicious and fun dinner at Mohegan last week. Our server was Sheila and she was great! I was craving a burger and it was soooo good 😋“

“Just lovely. Can’t wait to get back“

“Great atmosphere for sunset dinner … farm to table menu!♥️ love it!!“