15 Best American Restaurants in New Shoreham

Winfield's American • $$$
214 Corn Neck Rd A, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Atlantic Swordfish
Roasted Garlic with Bread
Roasted Garlic with Rolls
Tuna Tartare Appetizer
Winfield’S Salad
Garlic Dipping Sauce
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Pan Seared Snapper
Swordfish Entree
Seared Scallops

“Fabulous date night destination! Fantastic service! Reliably delicious!“

4.5 Superb240 Reviews
The Barn At Spring House American • $$$
51 Spring St, New Shoreham

“We went to The Spring House for our 25th wedding anniversary. This was the best vacation we have ever had. The hotel is amazing. We had a corner room facing the ocean and the view was perfect. We loved sitting on the lawn in the white Adirondack chairs. The view was spectacular, the live piano music was wonderful and it was great that you could order drinks and food from your chair. The food and staff was also great. We had the same waitress for two of our dinners and she was amazing her name is Kacey. She made our dining experience very enjoyable. We highly recommended The Spring House and we plan on going again.“

4.4 Superb317 Reviews
3

Eli's

Eli's American • $$
456 Chapel St, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Coulotte Steak
Crispy Skinned Salmon
Beef Bulgogi Bowl
Bread Basket
Eli's Burger
Tuna Nachos
The Arugula
Tuna Steak
Empanadas

“The best gourmet burger I’ve ever had!!“

4.5 Superb121 Reviews
Southeast Light Delights American • $$
122 Mohegan Trail, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Roll and Bratwurst

“Still Block Island’s best lobster roll!“

4.8 Superb98 Reviews
Mohegan Restaurant and Bar American • $$
213 Water St, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Beet Salad w Grilled Salmon
Creamy Clam Chowder
Tuna Tataki Salad
Mahi Fish Sanwich
Steak Flat Bread
Norwegian Salmon
Fish and Chips
Chicken Wings
Lobster Roll
Pulled Pork

“We had a delicious and fun dinner at Mohegan last week. Our server was Sheila and she was great! I was craving a burger and it was soooo good 😋“

4.1 Good189 Reviews
Kimberly's Seafood • $$$
238 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Sesame Seared Salmon
Pan-Seared Salmon
Chicken Focaccia
Mussel Appetizer
Stuffed Lobster
Fish and Chips
Chocolate Cake
Shrimp Tacos
Chicken Parm
White Fish

“Love Kimberly’s! Seafood Fra Diavlo is one of the best I have had. Highly recommend:)“

4.4 Superb266 Reviews
Ballard's Beach Resort American • $
42 Water St, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Small Sample of Their Frozen Drinks
Naked Lobster Roll
Fried Calamari
Del's Lemonade
Clam Chowder
Lobster blt
Shrimp Pasta
Onion Rings
Poke Bowl
Salad

“I go with my eleven year old daughter. We enjoy being served lunch on the beach by the fabulous servers. The food is delicious! So much fun to hear the music in the background while enjoying swimming and building sandcastles.“

4.3 Superb446 Reviews
The Oar American • $$
221-A Jobs Hl Rd, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Mahi Mahi \u0026 Crab Cake Platter
Mahi Mahi & Crab Cake Platter
Lobster Club with Coleslaw
Mozzarella Sticks
California Roll
Chips & Salsa
Scallop Roll
French Fries
Lobster Roll
Lobster blt

“Just lovely. Can’t wait to get back“

4 Good402 Reviews
Dead Eye Dick's Seafood • $$
218 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Salad Oysters Clam Chowder
Salt \u0026 Pepper Calamari
Daily Selection of Oysters
New England Clam Chowder
Hot or Cold Lobster Roll
Salt & Pepper Calamari
Lobster Caesar Salad
Salt Pond Platter
Littleneck Clams
Steamed Lobster

“The food was delicious! Shrimp and Grits best I have had since I left the South! Black Sea Bass fresh fish was outstanding!! Martini was top notch!!!“

4.3 Superb277 Reviews
The Atlantic Inn American • $$$
359 High St, New Shoreham

“We had a wonderful stay at the inn. It is prettily maintained and the service is warm and casual. We liked being a little removed from the busy area and yet within a short walking distance. Well worth it for the pastoral view from the porch and the lawn. During the day, the inn provides complimentary coffee and petite pastries which really add to the homey feeling.“

4.3 Superb126 Reviews
Payne's Dock American • $$
133 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham

“After 50 hours at sea, the staff at Payne’s Dock were incredibly helpful when we needed to do a quick stop for fuel. They waited for us, as we were going to arrive late in the evening, and helped us with our lines and offered suggestions for dining if we needed them.“

4.3 Superb82 Reviews
Club soda house American • $$
35 Connecticut Ave, New Shoreham

“Such a great gem on the island… food, drinks, great vibes all around!! Love this spot!“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Ernies Restaurant Breakfast • $
212 Water St, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Eggs and Homemade Corned Beef Hash
Grill Cheese w Choice of Meat
Eggs Home Fries and Toast
Sweet Buttermilk Pancakes
Toasted Bagel- Choice Of
Ham and Cheese Omelet
Breakfast Burrito
Steak and Eggs
Scrambled Eggs
Sausage

“A great old- fashioned breakfast place. Delicious home- made pastries and friendly service. Eggs, pancakes, the works. The locals eat here.“

3.8 Good135 Reviews
The Surf American • $$
32 Dodge St, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Summer Panzanella
Grilled Cheese
Lobster Roll
Potato Salad
Surf Burger
Onion Rings
Pulled Pork
Fish Tacos

“Great atmosphere for sunset dinner … farm to table menu!♥️ love it!!“

3.1 Average116 Reviews
Poor People's Pub Bar & Grill • $$
33 Ocean Ave, New Shoreham

Customers` Favorites

Steak Frites Sandwich
Lobster Corn Chowder
The Local Burger
Brisket Sandwich
The BBQ Platter
Mac N Cheese
Lasagna Dip
Wings
Salad
Ribs

“Good place for drinks and conversation with other visitors and bartenders“

3.8 Good342 Reviews

You May Also Like