17 Best American Restaurants near Monticello

“Very family orientated and the food is so delicious“

“The best chicken bacon ranch sandwich in town!!!!!“

“This place is the best hands down.“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A Perfect Family Dining Gem in Monticello!
Our family stayed at the Kartrite Resort and found this absolute treasure of a restaurant! From the moment we walked in, we were enveloped in such a warm, wonderful family atmosphere. The heart of this place is truly the family running it. It was so special to see the father working side-by-side with his sons—some warmly taking orders at the front with big smiles, and others diligently preparing food in the kitchen. You can feel the pride and love they put into their business.

And the food? ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. Every single one of us, from the adults to the kids, cleaned our plates. The kids are still raving about the fries (some of the best we've ever had!) and their meals. The menu is incredible, with unlimited choices to satisfy any craving. Whether you want a hearty comfort meal, a fresh salad, or something delicious for the little ones, they have it all.

If you're visiting the area or staying at Kartrite, this is a must-visit. Delicious, generous food served by the kindest, hardest-working family. We left with full bellies and full hearts. We can't wait to come back on our next trip! Thank you for an exceptional dining experience.“

“Ok, so since i last visited, the price went up 4x. Parking was almost full, and people were still coming in. It was my first time launching my own boat, on a very busy day.On the launch, my friend was guiding me, but when the time came to pull the boat out, i struggled a little. The owner came out and helped me by guiding my steering. No one got upset, and we managed to be quick about it without unnecessary stress.I can recommend that if you are there on a busy weekend, use the marina, pay the fee, and remove stress from your life.“

“We were there twice once last nite for Dinner June 29th and June 30th for breakfast. Both times the food was good and the staff were very friendly.“

“I've lived in Monticello for years but for some reason never got around to trying the diner. Well, I finally did last night & I was not dissapointed! I tried the country fried steak with sausage gravy. It was delicious! There was a lot of gravy on it which I didn't expect but it still tasted fine. I had some broccoli and home fries on the side, they were yummy as well. The service was great too; the employees were kind. This is a nice little place, I would definitely be returning in the future!“

“They were very short on staff and had to wait very long to get my food... I made the reservation and couldn't get seat where I wanted because of area closed due to no waiter/ waitress....end up seating by the bar which was very uncomfortable! Sad...“

“The New Munson Diner is hands down one of the best places around, not just for the food, but for the atmosphere and the people. From the moment you walk in, you're treated like family. The owners go out of their way to make everyone feel welcome and respected, and the staff always greet you with a genuine smile. The food is consistently delicious, fresh, and made just the way you like it. Whether you're there for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, you can count on great meals and even better service. It’s the kind of place where you don’t just come for a bite to eat—you come because it feels like home. Highly recommend the New Munson Diner to anyone looking for a warm, family friendly spot with great food and even better people! 😀 -The Muthig Family“

“The burgers were great! The blue cheese was just right- didn’t swallow the taste of the meat. Service was excellent and the view really lovely“

“Just tried out some amazing food😏 boy's loved the smash 🍔 stuffed clams are awesome and the dinner pasta great favor and delicious 😋 great comfortable atmosphere 😏plus they have a pool table😀“

“Had an amazing lunch on our way back to Ithaca. Everything was fresh, homemade and so flavorful! Folks were very friendly and welcoming, too. This place is a gem!“

“My sister and I frequent Brew Rock Hill almost every Wednesday. We love it. The food and beer are great. The atmosphere is cozy and relaxing. And we just adore Amanda and Leah who always give us top notch service! They are a big part of what makes our visits so enjoyable. Simply a very nice place. Thank you! Christine (and Patty)“

“got one of the amazing burgers with fries and I was amazed at how fresh the food was 10 out of 10 recommend and more beer choices then I could recommend“

“Best wings in the area!!! We come from Middletown to get these babies!“

“food was delicious, our server was very cheerful and friendly“

“My husband and I have been here at least a half dozen times and we enjoy the food and the service...the waitress refers to herself as "Salty Maryanne"...is she a little salty? Sure but that doesn't bother us...she and my husband are both from Brooklyn so they talk about the old neighborhood. Bottom line is anyone can have an off day...you have no idea what other people are dealing with and they have to come to work and do the best they can do. As a former waitress, I guess I'm just a little more sympathetic than most. I certainly wouldn't trash a restaurant after one experience there but that's just me.“