4.9
Superb
156 Reviews
357 North Ave, New Rochelle · 2.8 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Matteo's Special Thin Pizza
- Eggplant Parmigiana Wedge
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza
“Mario’s Metro Pizza completely changed what I expected from a pizzeria. We came in for a full tasting and every single dish overdelivered. The chicken scarpariello was the standout, juicy chicken smothered in a sauce with real depth, sausage and thin cut potatoes mixed in, plated like something from a sit down Italian restaurant rather than handed over a counter. The vodka rigatoni with fresh burrata was another surprise, creamy, rich, and not something you expect to find at a pizza shop. The Philly cheesesteak pizza and hot honey pepperoni with vodka sauce were both excellent as well, and the hot honey and buffalo wings are made completely from scratch in house. Beyond the food, the hospitality stood out. The owners, two brothers with over a decade of experience in kitchens across Westchester and New York City, took over a pizzeria that had been a neighborhood staple for decades and elevated it without losing that local feel. You can tell everything is made fresh and with real care. If you are in New Rochelle and think you already know what a pizzeria can offer, this place will prove you wrong. Highly recommend.”
Juice · $
