8 Best American Restaurants near Narrowsburg

“Very cozy and intimate. The cocktails exceptional. As was the wine too! The food delicious from appetizers to entrées. And the roaring fire on a rainy night was beautiful. My husband and I loved the atmosphere and the service. We lingered and were not rushed. True gem!Food & drinks: Exceptional!“

“I've been at The Heron 5 times over the past 7 years, 3 of them in the past half year. The quality of the food is really good and the portions are large. It's a bit pricey, but they don't skimp. The service is efficient and friendly. The atmosphere is nice, but a bit cramped since it's very popular. The hours are somewhat limited--it stops serving food by 8 p.m. Reservations are recommended!“

“This place is 5 stars squared. Best wings I've ever had and the burgers and sandwiches are just as good. If you're ever up here, I highly encourage you to give this place your time, its one of the best places to get food in the area.“

“Food, when the kitchen is open, is absolutely amazing!! The prime rib sandwich is the best I've ever had! Everyone I brought there has been impressed by the unique, historic beauty of the building and unbelievable quality food. They have an old school bowling alley that's almost a hundred years old on the upper level of the building that is a must to check out“

“This roast beef sandwich was fabulous! We needed a snack . My cousin who lives in the Catskills told us about this sandwich. I had not idea a place in the middle of the forest would be so good . The meat was tender and slices so fine . The service was good . The ambiance was rustic as it should be .“

“Traveling through this area with family and was lucky to find this restaurant. The place was packed but all the workers hustled and were on top of everything AND friendly. My baked ziti was perfect...my sister insists it was "the best gluten free pizza" she ever had. 10 out of 10 for Il Castello!“

“We went here for pre- dinner cocktails and didn't want to leave. This place is full of old school charm. The staff made us feel at home immediately. You could certainly tell who the regulars were and they too made us feel welcome. This place will continue to be in the rotation for fun while at the lake.“

“I don't know why I never wrote a review...have been here dozens of times and have brought many of my visiting friends and NO ONE has ever been disappointed! In fact,,,I think they visit me just so they can go to Duttons! ????Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian friendly, for sure!“