50 Best Bakeries near New City

“All I have to say is wow! Kimmy did such an amazing job on my son’s cake. It came out way better than I expected. We gave her a vision and she excelled! The cake was so moist and flavorful. We did vanilla frosting fill and chocolate cake 8 inch. Her shop in New City is super cute as well! I have already recommended to others and plan to use her again for future cakes! Thank you! :)“

“I purchased a personalized gift for my son’s girlfriend who was running in a half marathon. My husband and I couldn’t be there to cheer her on. So we sent a personalized gift down to her with my son. When I asked if it was possible to make it that same day, the owner was beyond helpful. He made sure my pretzel was ready to pick up by the day’s end, recommended great dip choices, and even had a little extra dough left over to include 2 hearts. My son’s girlfriend LOVED her gift!! Thank you to the owners of this wonderful shop…I WILL be back!!“

“We love the unique design of the bakery and the beautiful flowers on the window. My daughter always wants to takes pictures out front. The cake pops are my son’s favorite and mine are the macaroons. Their cupcakes and cakes are beautiful and always leave everyone happy! Denise, the owner is amazing and so hard working! We love this bakery on Main Street!“

“Great service when my family and I visited! The staff took the time to assist with food allergies. The food is delicious, authentic Guatemalan and all pastries are baked in-house in their impressive bakery! Emilio was gracious enough to explain the Guatemalan food to us. Truly felt welcomed☺️“

“I absolutely love leaving positive reviews, especially when I come across businesses like Susan's. She operates on a whole different level of excellence, and her unwavering commitment to detail and high-quality products surpasses all other establishments. When it comes to bakeries and restaurants, Susan's place puts them to shame in the best way possible. Her team is simply outstanding, and their dedication to providing top-notch customer service was evident throughout my entire visit. The food was nothing short of exquisite – it was incredibly fresh, unbelievably fluffy, and wonderfully delicious. Every bite was a scrumptious delight that left me in awe. In fact, it was so amazing that I can only describe it as "AMAZBALLS"! I have no doubt that Susan's bakery is the best in the state, and I wholeheartedly encourage everyone to pay a visit and savor everything they have to offer. It's an experience you won't want to miss!“

“Beautifully decorated and simply delicious custom order cake. Everyone asked where the cake came from. pleasure to work with staff.“

“The fresh off the rack help yourself bakery was a cool experience but the eating of the huge everything bagels, pretzels and pastries was heavenly 🥯🙏🥰“

“Vilma’s created the perfect Mr.Met cake for my husband’s 60th birthday! It looked amazing and tasted even better! Highly recommend!“

“Such helpful and wonderful staff . Picked up a valentines cookie cake for my daughter’s class and they decorated it wonderfully. I was given a free sample of the caramel crumb cookie and it was divine. Did I mention they were super friendly and kind ???? 100/10

They have many treats and I saw some gorgeously decorated chocolate strawberries and I thought the price was amazing for the presentation. I think a dozen strawberries were $36 which is a bargain compared to other places who make subpar looking strawberries . I would have loved to receive them as a gift myself !

Can’t wait to try the banana pudding next time !“

“Fantastic, good quality gf options! Lovely store front with both amazing gluten free options (scones, cookies, bread, sandwich’s, and other goodies!) and a cafe with coffees, teas, matcha). I always look forward to visiting.“

“Excellent sitting inside,A/C very comfortable.Excellent food as well.Love this place.“

“In 2024, the Monsey area is filled with catering establishments, take-out store, and bakeries, and yet Glaubers, which has been here forever, is still the best. They have catered kiddushin and a wedding for us and we were always greatly satisfied. When you go to the store you will find fresh and delicious food, and the people serving you are even more delicious! If you haven't been to Glaubers yet, go tomorrow.“

“Let me start with I am not one to write reviews however this one is worth the occasion. It was an absolute pleasure working with Wildly Cakes to get a cake for my bridal shower. We had a traveling themed bridal shower and Wildly Cakes was able to make this beautiful world map on the side. But it doesn’t just end there the cake itself tasted delicious. We got a vanilla cake with cookie butter filling and all my guests ranted and raved on how good it was. We actually have our wedding cake being made by them too and we cannot wait to see and taste it especially after this great first impression.“

“This place is just amazing! There were 5 of us and we all ordered something different. Everything we got was delicious- we all tried each other's dishes. There's a little bit of everything to satisfy even the pickiest eater. I would just drive her (over a 2 hour drive for me) just to come eat here. I need this place closer to home, lol.“

“Delicious one of a kind desserts! Their chocolate mousse cones are my favorite!“

“Every thing I’ve ever tasted from this bakery elicits a reflexive “mmmmm!”. Can’t wait to go back!!!“

“If you're looking for a delightful culinary experience, look no further than Taam Eden Bakery in New Square! This hidden gem has quickly become my go-to spot for fresh baked goods and mouthwatering treats.

From the moment you step inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked bread and pastries envelops you, setting the stage for an incredible experience. The selection is impressive, featuring everything from traditional challah and bagels to an array of delicious pastries that are hard to resist.

The quality of the ingredients is evident in every bite. I particularly recommend their signature babka—it's perfectly rich, moist, and beautifully braided. Each slice is a heavenly combination of chocolate and cinnamon, making it an absolute must-try. Their rugelach is also exceptional, with just the right amount of sweetness and a flaky texture that melts in your mouth.

The staff at Taam Eden Bakery are friendly and welcoming, always ready to help you choose the perfect treat or answer any questions you may have. Their passion for baking shines through in their customer service, making each visit feel special.

Whether you're stopping by for breakfast, a midday snack, or to pick up treats for a gathering, Taam Eden Bakery is the place to be. It's a fantastic spot to indulge your sweet tooth or enjoy a savory bite. I can't recommend it enough—definitely a five-star experience! 🍞🥐✨“

“How much do I love their bakery? I drove from Orange County, NY to pick up 3 dozen Black and white cookies to bring to a party in Massachussets. That is how yummy this bakery is!!!! The staff is just as sweet as the desserts.“

“"Blend the most delicious freshly baked pastries, cakes, and their signature rugelach with a touch of Geshmak. Add a dash of excellent service, infused with the irresistible aroma of Sander's Bakery, and you’ve got a recipe for pure indulgence."

Dietary restrictions: Kosher to the strictest standard.

Kid-friendliness: Everything little kids (and the kid in you) would enjoy.“

“Tasty food, great art, wonderful proprietor! 😁“

“Love my mornings at First Village Coffee. It's like my daily recommended dose of good vibes all around!“

“I would like to recommend Amato bread, I ordered the Eggplant, Mozzarella and Prosciutto on a fresh roll with Balsamic glaze. It was delicious and Joe the owner was very friendly and accommodating.“

“Tried the USR location this morning as it's located around the corner from my office. Front staff was friendly, attentive, and helpful with assisting me to navigate options as a first time visitor. There was no line and I quickly received my to-go order. The ham, egg, and cheese croissant was delicious- fluffy and flaky, not at all greasy, and the perfect cheese pull. Can't wait to return to try desserts and coffee!“

“The best place to order for any occasion!! All are very good in taste picture perfect!!! Beautiful decorating!! Fantastic service!!! Whenever I buy all gets eaten up in minutes not a pc left!!!! If I order it’s ONLY ONLY from GREENS DELIGHT!!!!!??“

“They make the best cinnamon raisin babka I ever had.“

“Absolutely FAVORITE spot in North Jersey! Better than most other Paris Baguettes I've been to, this place sits in a wonderfully cozy area with other shops with various food and shopping needs. I've been going here for well over two years and I LOVE how friendly the baristas are, not only are they great with the customers but it's always so fun to walk in and see them smiling and working together behind the bar.
I love going on tuesday mornings and seeing Denise or Evie or Colette. 10/10 best day of my week, always the absolute friendliest and most efficient staff.
Highly HIGHLY recommend the palmier and the plain brewed coffee.“

“Being From Waldwick And Midland Park My Whole Life, I have been going to Reinholds my entire life. There is not a local bakery that even comes close to being as good as reinholds. 5 stars all day long. The Meltaways are the absolute best“

“Mimi’s cookies support during Girl Scout week was awesome! She was ready for 150 Girl Traffic! The cookies are delicious and BEAUTIFUL! Thank you Mimi!“

“The most delicious mother daughter dynamic duo! Always delicious and cant get enough of everything they make. It’s too good!“

“This place is amazing... it even smells amazing but, if you are a tourist you have to know what you want before you get there. The bakery is frequented by locals who are in a hurry and know what they want. The only list of bread items is on the website so I suggest you check that out before going. The pastries and cookies are magnificent, especially the Italian assortment This is a must for food lovers!.“

“HAVING JUST MOVED TO OSSINING, NY ONLY 7 MOS BEFORE, IT WAS A MIRACLE TO DISCOVER DEL SOL SWEET BAKERY, 10+++! WHEN I COULDNT DECIDE BETWEEN TWO FILLINGS, OWNER, LUCIO SUGGESTED COULD DO BOTH- PRODUCING THE MOST FABULOUS, GORGEOUS, MOUTHWATERING CAKE ANYONE HAD EVER SEEN OR TASTED! ???????????????? PLUS WHEN COULD ONLY TAKE DELIVERY FOR THIS VERY SPECIAL HUGE BIRTHDAY EVENT DATE ON A MONDAY- HE FOUND A WAY, BECAUSE FINISHED CAKE SO FRESH, BUT PRRISHABLE -TO DELIVER ON A MONDAY- AND SO MADE ALL MY DREAMS COME TRUE!?❣️? + A MILLION ?sOs!“

“So it turns out every single babka I've ever eaten in my life was a disappointment until I had this babka. I cannot thank you enough for bringing this into my life and setting the bar so high. I wish ya'll nothing but great business and many years of success because ya'll are baking beautiful things. How do I order more babka? Can you bake me a house made of babka?“

“What a wonderful place. First of all, the cakes and cookies are out of this world - pure indulgence. I've bought them as gifts for friends and they've been blown away. Even better, though, is that everything is lovingly baked by adults with special needs and volunteers. I can't wait for them to have a regular retail space.“

“The one person show was nothing but great on a holiday. Place was kept smelling amazing and cleaned. It’s a cute spot to relax a bit. The chicken pie so good and the cherry pie yum. I am not a huge pie person but this was really pretty good pies! They have a market stand at 79th and Columbus Sunday farmers market in Manhattan as well.“

“Beautiful modern store with gorgeous interior and wonderful floor tiles. They had all popular PB bakery items on display. Lots of sitting area, all clean and well maintained.

We went to get a cake. It was evening hours, so a lot of the popular ones were sold out, still we had 5-6 kinds to pick from. Cake was packed precisely in the box, got knife and candles with it. Staff were very friendly and got our order ready super fast.

The mini strawberry soft cream cake was pure quality. Fluffy soft cake with delicious cream all around it topped with glazed strawberry.

Vegetarian options: Hot and cold drinks, salads, fruit pastries

Parking: Lots of spots in front and around the store“

“The best Haitian patty store in spring valley PERIOD. Not too crispy just the right amount of softness. Cooked to perfection. And their soup is really good too. And that's where you can get all your leafs for haitian tea(for my fellow Haitians). So enjoy your patties and let the mommy know Dynaa sent you. Lol 👋“

“Great to shop at shloimy's bakery in Rockland kosher, always fully stocked freshly baked, their rugelech is the best in the universe, their babka is also heavenly, service is the best part, always so accommodating, knowledgeable and friendly staff.“

“We had food delivered this week. Everything was beyond expectation - food was delicious, portions were great and everything was packaged well. I love that heating instructions were included. We will be ordering again in the very near future.“

“I've come here for many years and the quality of the food is always great, the expansion of the store and products is great to see and the pricing is fair so this is a must go

I have been coming to this store for many years and the quality of food is very good, the expansion of products in this store is a good variety to choose from and the prices are very fair, so I recommend that you stop by here“

“Bro the cookies here are out of the world. If you're looking for a cheap cookie this is definitely not the place to come, at about $3 a cookie. But they're legit insane. Also not exactly sure how kosher are they are? Fingers crossed 🤞“

“our wedding cake was from here and the whole process was super smooth and easy! the samples were delicious and we had a tough time choosing our cake. we got a beautiful tiered cake and it was so tasty! the bakery was very communicative and professional, as well.“

“Muy bueno el pan el morocho las muchachas muy buenas personas buena atención“

“I've been here before but just after staying in Winchester Bay for 8 nights this July I thought I'd do a review of the place. 2 years ago when I was there they had many more things to sell, but this year I was told a new owner-manager? 2 years ago I bought some jam from them and they even mailed it to my house, of course I had to pay. This year I did get jam and just walked across the street to the post office and did it myself. They don't do the mailing thing anymore. No big deal. The day before I left I bought one of their huge cinnamon rolls and boy was it good!! Cost $7.25 but it was enough for 4 people! Still a nice place but was better 2 years ago,in my opinion.“

“Samantha is business owner. Wish her lots of success! She goes out of her way to make her desert so special & my family loves it!“

“My family has been enjoying Anna's Bakery for as long as I can remember. We have never been disappointed and everything is always delicious!“

“Got the sausage and cheese on ciabatta & cappuccino. Ciabatta was very soft and the sandwich had a good amount of sausage and egg. There are a lot of baked goods and it's next to the MNR station. So it's a good spot for eating & train spotting“

“I could eat an insane quantity of the mojito sorbet. Please oh please make it all summer long! Also, pigs are my favorite animals. Thank you for existing, The Blue Pig Ice Cream. I heart you.“

“Best donuts . Extremely fresh and tasty“

“Great sandwiches and pastries.“