32 Best Mexican Restaurants in New Rochelle

“Mom and pop FRESH Mexican. Come! You will not be disappointed. The tacos!!!“

“IT WAS HORRIBLE. AS A MEXICAN I DO NOT APPROVE, THIS PLACE HAD BAD BAD FOOD, FIRST OF ALL THEY SERVED ME AN ORANGE WITH TACOS, WHO DOES THAT? WHO IN THE RIGHT MIND GIVE ORANGES WITH TACOS, NUH UH. ALSO, I FOUND OUT THAT THEIR GUACAMOLE IS NOT EVEN MEXICAN RECEPIE, IT TASTED LIKE WASABI WITH TOO MUCH MAYO EXPECT IT WAS NOT EVEN WASABI, AND ALSO THERE WERE NOT ONLY HAIRS IN MY FOOD BUT THERE WA A FRAKING ROACH SINGING LA CUCARACHA WITH MEXICAN HAT AND LITTLE TINY MARACAS. THIS PLACE IS OUTRAGIOUS“

“Delicious food every time!!!“

“Everything is perfect there“

“The birria tacos are delicious, the consome was the best I have ever had. The nachos are fresh and delicious, light and crunchy. I cannot wait to taste more food from Rebecca’s Cafe. Delicious two 👍 👍 up!! The guacamole was just as delicious yum , delicioso“

“Tucked away in the heart of New Rochelle’s predominantly Mexican community, this little hole‑in‑the‑wall spot turned out to be a gem. I ordered the steak tacos and the birria tacos, and both were surprisingly delicious — tender meat, great seasoning, and portions that actually feel generous. You can tell it’s family owned and operated from the moment you walk in. Definitely worth stopping by if you want authentic flavors without the frills.“

“What seems to be a nondescript takeout joint located in a strip plaza belies a charming, homestyle spot with flavorful food made with care. Guacamole with fresh chips was so fresh with the just the right amount of onions, tomatoes, salt and lime. Beef flautas, as simple of a dish as they are, were some of the best I’ve tasted. Finally, the Pancita soup hit the spot - warm, spicy and velvety. On top of the food, the waitress was so friendly and welcoming. Top tier recommendation for great Mexican food. Tables are limited (I think about 5). If they had a liquor license, this would be an A+ spot.“

“Mexican food like grandma used to make, including homemade tortillas and non-menu items like (the best) mole (you will ever have in your life, and chilaquiles that will kick your a*** The milder green sauce is spicier than most places' red sauce. Connected to a Mexican bakery located next door.“

“Best tacos in New Rochelle. Authentic, mom and pop shop. Been going here for years, never disappointed. It has the ambiance of a pizzeria but I don't go there for that. I go for the delicious and inexpensive burritos. I spent $70 to feed myself, my wife, and 3 hungry boys aged 17, 19, and 19. And there were still leftovers for lunch the next day.“

“the food was very delicious and the stars 🌟 🤩 😋 ✨ 😍 👌“

“This is the best kept secret in New Rochelle. There's close to 20 Mexican restaurants in New Rochelle and this is the best one by far. Parking was a problem because of construction but now there's enough spots to stop by and grab some tacos.“

“los mejores tacos y atencion“

“I was there this weekend, the restaurant is a splendid spot with adorable decor. My only complaint is that its feels very hot inside, making it hard to enjoy the meal under those conditions. Their other location in Mamaroneck Town is always cold and cool but I honestly prefer the flavor here. I hope they can resolve this issue soon, because in the meantime, I think it's better to order takeout. I can also add that the drinks are truly excellent; The Cantarito is a must-try. And the service is always great, they are very attentive. I highly recommend you don't miss this gem.“

“😘👍🏼 Son deliciosas las bebidas🍹“

“Drinks are really good and the food really yummy 😁“

“This place is a hidden gem in Westchester. The best burritos since California.. the meats here are so flavorful. I loved the torta too. The Birria taco is outrageous. The broth is delicious. The younge taco, carnitas and beef tenderloin out of ten. I love how flavorful everything is and yet not salty. Fresh. Nice staff.“

“Got a bacon egg and cheese saltpepperhotsauce on a roll and a large coffee for $7 before tax.

Sandwich was fine, nothing exceptional, light bacon, but it was $5 so no complaints. She put a lot of hot sauce which I like, some might not.

I asked how much it would be to add a hash brown and they said $3 extra. For a hash brown? Maybe they thought a side of hash browns or something idk but 3 bucks for a fried potato patty was kind of insane to me so I obviously skipped it.

Also, the coffee had so much milk. I asked for “just a little little bit of milk” while holding up my pinched fingers as I always do, and this coffee is creamy my dude.

While waiting for my order, an older Italian man came in and asked for a small coffee, and he said “please not too much milk just small milk” and the guy said ok but the Italian man said again, kind of intensely, please not too much milk. At the time I didn’t think anything of it, I was kinda like chill pops I think he heard you, but after sipping my coffee in the car I think the dude just puts way too much milk in the coffee and I get where Nonno is coming from.

Anyway random bodega I hit while passing through and needed a quick breakfast.

Cheap decent no real complaints. Would rather the coffee have been black tho.“

“We had a great experience dining at this cozy spot! While there’s mainly street parking, there is a parking lot conveniently located nearby. The atmosphere was charming and intimate, with seating for about 50–60 guests.

The staff were incredibly sweet and welcoming, which really added to the overall positive experience. Since this was a smaller location there were fewer staff members however we got seated within 5 minutes. We were served complimentary chips and salsa to start, which was a nice touch. For our entrees, I ordered the dinner combo and my husband had the fajitas. Both meals were delicious and came in generous portions. The only small drawback was that the fajitas came with fewer tortillas than expected.

One thing to note is that some basic items like napkins and sauces weren’t readily available at the table—we had to ask for them, but the staff was quick to bring them once requested.

Overall, it was a lovely dining experience!“

“Since moving to New Rochelle from New York, I was worried about missing out on the city’s food scene. But Mexico Lindo quickly became my go-to spot! The food is outstanding—I’ve tried the tacos, nachos, tortas, and fajitas, and everything has been delicious and authentic. Each dish is full of flavor and made with care.

The staff is incredibly friendly, and the whole place has a welcoming, family vibe. As someone practicing my Spanish, I really appreciate how everyone is so patient and kind. The owners are always attentive and make you feel right at home.

If you’re craving authentic Mexican food and a warm, inviting atmosphere, look no further. You won’t be disappointed!“

“Los tacos y el waffle que pedimos muy ricos el agua de horchata también… para llevar pedimos paletas y también muy ricas de sabor… las muchachas muy amables.. exelente servicio 100% recomendado el lugar“

“Everything I tried and ate for breakfast was amazing And friendly staff“

“Had an amazing time here- food was absolutely delicious and huge portions! Cocktails were just as great. 5 ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Its always the littlest, off the beaten path, unassuming places that surprise the heck outta you! Great food! Desserts top notch...oh yeah the chef is a riot!..check them out.. its a lil diner, a lol restaurant and a lil bar all rolled up into one!“

“The food was so Fresh and Delicious, The Lentil Soup was perfect for the weather Also had an Italian combo sandwich, with Her special homemade hot sauce 😋 will definitely be back THANK YOU LUPE“

“This place is great!

The food was amazing with a fair cost. I was happy with the meal and the varriety I was able to get. It was my first time eating tacos and the waitress was super helpful with recomendations. I was able to mix and match and try 3 different types in one meal.

the wait was short and the food was fresh. I forget the name but one of them had pinaples in it and it was great!

The atmosphere feels great with good music.

If you are looking for a place to grab a quick bite id deffinetly recommend it here, andif you are a local id stop by, its worth it.“

“Best Store In The Longwood Area Enough Said“

“Excelent service and tasty food“

“The Shrimp Burrito was AMAZING; I'm so in love 😍 Definitely recommended!“

“Went there for my sister's graduation last year and the owner was very attentive and even gave us free shots and took one with us because we spent $. He was really nice. The food is delicious and the drinks are also very good. I definitely recommend this place !“

“Best Mexican food in new rochelle!!“

“Great food. Decent price. Very nice and helpful staff. Made me feel at home when I went in to order food for my daughter's birthday meal. Two of us had Birria tacos and one of us had a veggie burrito. We all enjoyed our food.

Vegetarian options: My daughter had the veggie burrito. She is a picky eater but she loved it.

Parking: Found a couple of empty spots on the street. It was around 5 pm during the week.“