34 Best American Restaurants near Oakfield

“Fantastic jambalaya! A hidden gem in Oakfield, New York, and I can’t wait to try the catfish!“

“An unexpected lunch stop, pleasantly surprised by the quality of the food & prices. We tried the Turkey Ruben, Philly Cheesesteak, fries & homemade chips… they were cooked perfectly. We’re not typically impressed eating out, this was really a good choice!“

“This was an amazing spot to be! Truthfully, I was here for a tour I had hosted, due to my creative endeavors. First, the food. Their speciality milkshakes are no joke. Some places would cheap out, do some flavor packet- no. No they don't do that, it was actually specialty made, and freshly made. It was incredible, and delicious- not some product, but an actual drink. Next, I had a Rueben Sandwhich. Everything I said about the milkshake could be applied here too. The food is worth the price, and an amazing dinner for later in my stay. Over all, the food is amazing and worth the price. A nice oasis of quality and passion in an monotonous desert of corporate, soulless product. This also serves as my first introduction to Medina, and the staff where very down to earth. They where very sweet, and the managers/owners took care of their staff very well. You could tell everyone liked their job and where passionate about what they do- a sign of amazing management and great treatment. An amazing Medina Diner and a great example of what local business would be. If your in the area, STOP BY! Thank you - Narcissia Netal“

“We hired Zambistro to cater our wedding. The food was absolutely amazing, our guests are still talking about it, especially the steak! The servers the day of were so sweet, and Summer kept checking in on my husband and I to make sure we had everything we needed. She truly made us feel cared for. Mike and Kara were also wonderful throughout the planning process, always quick to answer questions and make sure every detail was perfect. We couldn’t have asked for a better catering team. Highly, highly recommend!“

“My husband and I just got married there on Saturday, and he loves golfing there. The course is in great shape, but thanks to Danielle the day was absolutely perfect. Food was amazing, venue was beautiful, clean, staff was so kind. I wish we could repeat the day over and over and over again. Thank you Terry hills!!“

“Went to the Burnin' Barrel BBQ (Homestretch Grill) at Batavia Downs with Dad and Mom. Tried the Half-rack of Smoked Ribs while my parents had the Pulled Piggy (no bun) & onion strings. Absolutely delicious. Portions were generous and the BBQ sauce was amazing! Very beautiful mural in the dining area too!“

“My guests and I took advantage of Fortunes Valentines dinner special last night. 159.00 for a great meal for 2 that included dessert and a glass of wine. Also included in the price was 90.00 in free play. We had the shrimp cocktail ( 6 huge shrimp) Our main was 2, 14oz prime rib slabs with a baked potato. The ribs were cooked to perfection. The desserts were Raspberry cheesecake and a deluxe chocolate cake.
The pinnacle of the meal was the great service. Our server Ryleigh was fun, quick and super personable. She took excellent care of us.
The photos here don’t do the meal justice.“

“Chef Isaac is a master of his craft. Megan did a wonderful job as our server. I highly recommend trying Harvest in Medina NY.“

“Arrived at 7:55 unaware that this establishment closes @8 pm. I asked what time they close and the owner said 8 pm. I went to leave and he said wait where are going. We close at 8 but as long as you sit before you have time. Waitress was friendly and wasn't acting as we bothered her. Even the other waitresses were talking to us and joking around! phenomenal service Definitely do not find this hospitality or customer service now days! Sport of Kings you are top notch in our book. We appreciate and thank you so much!“

“Found and will return Great place. And fast too“

“This place has been and remains a solid staple in Batavia. The food is always good and the staff are personable and attentive!“

“amazing food and great people! ❤️“

“The staff is what makes this place great! Foos is excellent as well. Room for small groups or even a single, you will feel welcome. You will of course find yummy Shepherd's Pie, Reubens, unique drink specials, and creamy desserts, but we'd even go back again just for the chips and dips! Set this place as a Favorite. 🍀“

“Great fish fry and Beef on Weck.“

“The fall menu is my favorite. The butternut toast is amazing! The boozy milkshakes are fun and different. Always a great place for a casual night out with the girls.“

“Their puffed pastries are amazing! Melt in your mouth delicious. 🥰“

“The corn chowder today was just perfect. Didn't need anything else for lunch. Awesome!“

“This place has that home-cooked meal feeling. Food is ALWAYS good. And the prices are very reasonable. Highly recommend 🥰“

“Great place to eat , large portions great prices, always busy“

“Sicilian style pizza is worth the price. Cup and char, sweet sauce with garlic crust. Seasoned well so if you’re not a garlic fan go with regular crust. Eggplant parm sub is great, like the steak and cheese. The Royal will be the next one I try. Always have my order ready on time. Thanks Tim“

“Great place for music. A lot of fun was gad!“

“It’s very family friendly atmosphere, but there is a lot going from multiple TVs to large groups on a daily basis if you are another person have anxiety of large groups or get overstimulated easily I do not recommend going here. It is a lot going on. I counted nine TVs in my view playing multiple different things with multiple different volumes. It’s a lot to take in but other than that the service is great the staff is incredibly nice. The food is good for what it is. And for the price of the food, it’s a good place for if you’re on a budget.“

“Dark and Quaint would best describe the atmosphere. Service was friendly but it did take 25 for 2 burgers and some fries. But alas, the Bourbon Burger was delicious. And worth the wait. Price was Excellent to top it all off. Just go, you won't be disappointed“

“My favorite place to eat when I'm in town! Every meal is delicious and every waitress has been pleasant. The white pizza and wing flight are my favorite items on the menu. Yum!!“

“Stayed at the hotel and chose this moderately priced option. We were invited to sit at any available table. Had to wait a few minutes for waitress to come to table and ketchup was empty but quickly replaced. All seats have a good view of TVs. Waitress took our food and beverage orders together. Drinks were well poured. Food came out fast and hot. Steak was grilled as ordered. Waitress checked on us frequently.“

“first time visit last week for lunch,I have eaten all other places in Medina but never here. What a great lunch (shepherds pie) was delicious and shared fries with my friend and they too were very good. I loved the atmosphere, truly a hidden gem. Prices we perfect!“

“Stopped here on the way to a show in Niagara Falls. Reasonable prices, good food.“

“I went here as a party. Overall the atmosphere was pretty relaxed. My party attended for lunch, so it wasn't too busy. It was a good experience in terms of atmosphere and service. Our waitress was phenomenal and super attentive. The restaurant was pretty empty, so we had our section to ourselves to enjoy our experience. The food was decent from my experience, but the drinks brought it down. I got a single glass of cabernet sauvignon, and I could tell from the first sip it was cheap. It tasted like rubbing alcohol instead of wine. It honestly brought down the overall experience for me. IMO 3.5/5, but since half ratings aren't allowed they get 4/5. As of now, it's not somewhere I would run back to, but it was better than some other places.“

“My grandfather took me there when I was 6 years old now I am 77,a very good place to have an enjoyable meal“

“First time there and we loved it!!! Food was amazing and our server/bartender took very good care of us. If you haven’t tried it you should! It is on our regular places list. Great food, reasonably priced and great service. 5 stars.“

“thank you Cusimano's for the awesome service and fixing us up with a few slices to go! you made my pregnant wife very very happy as always! highly recommended if you are in the area.“

“I ordered a fish fry at this fine establishment. Upon entering the parking spot I was immediately greeted by a magnificent woman with decadent black hair and high spirited attitude. Without a quibble of time my food ascended into the palms. Hot and ready! She flashed me with a smile of pure sincerity. The fish fry tasted as if caught on the morning bow. Mouth watering goodness enough for one! Would come again 11/11“

“Cherri was the best waitress I have had in a long time. Very personable and fast and helpful on the menu and options. She is a great asset and cheerful and should be a manger !!!! She needs a raise for the customer service and her personality over all!!!!“