33 Best American Restaurants near Phelps

“Always love to go to gooneys awesome food and ice cream“

“One of the best places in town with an inviting, classy atmosphere, where locals Don and JoEllen Miller, the owners, have taken “family & friends” to a whole new level! They offer indoor seating in the bar area around a beautiful fireplace, or the front banquet room overlooking the beautiful Flint Creek waterfalls where many events take place. The tranquil outdoor patio and meandering seating under a canopy of trees is our favorite, where you can enjoy live music with dinner and friends. A great experience every time!“

“What we had was good, ribs and a Cuban sandwich with sides. When I go to a “BBQ” joint I always order their brisket! It’s my standard for judging the quality. This place didn’t offer any. Chicken, Pork and Beef. The waitress was great!“

“The absolute best restaurant around- and by around I mean most of NY. This place is extraordinary in both food and service, and it is impossible to be disappointed here. I promise- try it. You’re welcome.“

“The food is outstanding! Super fresh, local ingredients, cooked properly. Ordered the specials of the day: grilled rainbow trout and ribeye with potatoes. The ingredients itself was so high quality-beef that tasted super beefy, medium rare done at exactly medium rare… the sides… the sauces… nothing was overly seasoned or salty, all the accompaniments were done well. Ordered seasonal local veggies as an appetizer… omg, so fresh, so good! Atmosphere is comfortable and airy, service so nice and friendly!“

“Stopped by after walking main st for somewhere to eat. The staff was so friendly and accommodating. The food came out super quick and it was delicious! Made our way up front to pay and that was that. I love the set up, casual atmosphere and really friendly staff. 10/10“

“The best BBQ in Geneva! 🔥“

“Never had a bad experience. Great place to eat, enjoyed every meal.“

“Very good food. Loved the atmosphere. Helpful and friendly staff. If you can serve a grilled cheese and soup lunch with a hot English breakfast tea I’m in“

“very great service and great portions! great place!“

“The steak dinner was amazing and great night out, thank you Chuck and staff.“

“The experience was incredible. The knowledge of the staff, service and food was impeccable‼️🥰❤️❤️We will be backl‼️“

“Good atmosphere, quick service, friendly staff and food is tasty“

“Great food and staff! Great place!“

“Stopped with my sister in law for coffee before a trip to Rochester. My nephew was in the back yelling because he thought it was an ice cream place…. They were so sweet and gave him a little cup of whipped cream and sprinkles as an ice cream substitute. This was the best customer service ever ❤️“

“Do NOT miss out on this gem of a quick eatery and pub hang out! My friend and i had traveled from out of state, it was late and we were hungry and exhausted. Even though it was close to closing we were welcomed in by the main bartender Blake and Angie who was in training. She did great btw. The chef Juan was out in the main area since it was late and gave us not only great recommendations for our food but also for our trip around the wine trail we had planned for tomorrow. We both had sandwiches with their roast beef. The meat was tender and flavorful and the bread was so good! Our meal really hit the spot after such a long day and what made it even better was the amazing and welcoming service we received. If you live in Geneva, make this your regular hangout!!!“

“We went as a family, clean, very friendly staff and cosmic bowling is such fun. Great atmosphere and up to date equipment. Can’t wait to visit again“

“It's been a little bit since I have been able to dine here but the food is fantastic; I mean the breakfast, lunch, dinner, and they also cater for part of my fraternity every winter not a bad thing to say there at all. My favorite is thier seafood bisque and they used to have fried cheese curds, out of this world. Only reason I gave them four stars is sometimes the staff seems to forget they are working at a resturant and feel like their at home so the conduct is a bit less than professional; now I personally have no problem with it I enjoy the atmosphere it feels like Newark to me but it may rub many the wrong way so I have to "star" accordingly.“

“Excellent food and very kind people. I had the half chicken dinner and it was delicious, especially the mac and cheese. I added a slice of sweet potato pie for later and I'm glad I did! I will definitely be back“

“Dana hit a Grand Slam with us last night. As always the food was delicious. If you haven’t already had a meal and you’re hungry Dana’s won’t disappoint you. Thank You for the great food and service.“

“Love this place and the ladies behind the bar are excellent at what they do!“

“Had a very good meal with friends“

“Kinda expensive for what you get. It's about $12 for a sandwich and chips and an extra $2.50 for real sides like fries, tots, or even more for onion rings so that's a little nuts. They toasted the sandwich bun which was way good. The onion rings were good and I don't like onion rings. The pizza rolls were meh, the waffle fries were good. And the hamburger was pretty good. All in all the food was good the prices were high so we may or may not be back.“

“Had a Chill Out Stout. .. it was delicious!“

“This is a busy bar with a surprisingly extensive menu. We drove about nine miles off 91 to find the place. My wife said the grilled cheese and tuna was amazing. My sausage sandwich was good. It is kind of a run down place but no one cared. We ate at the counter which was crowded. The owner came over and we had a nice chat. I might stop there again on our way down from Canada. The prices are very reasonable.“

“Best fish fry in town!!! Great food, great service and amazing atmosphere.“

“This was my first visit to Bellhurst Castle. I'd heard about it for years but never went until now. My husband had the Toasted Italian Panini and was very satisfied with it. I had the Grilled Chicken Caprese. It tasted great with a mix of chicken, pesto mayo, balsamic dressing, tomatoes on a toasted garlic bun. Just a fair warning, it's messy and the bun got soggy. Dessert was scrumptious. It was a chocolate chip cake and I would recommend it. The atmosphere felt a bit stuffy with dark walls and carpeting. We ate at the bar and I thought they had the most comfortable bar chairs I've experienced. Yes, it was pricey. Over $60 before tip.“

“Food was amazing, very busy waitress had an attitude, very rude“

“My family came here for a birthday brunch for Grandma. It's a great little diner. The food was decent but not exceptional. You know you'll get a good meal here. I had small pieces of pepper in my ham and cheese omelet. I ate it without complaint. My potatoes were room temperature. Again, edible but not perfect. I know we will eat here again and I'm okay with it.“

“excellent food and service“

“We frequent this restaurant alot. Love the New England Clam chowder and fish fry. My husband loves the club sandwich and ham steak. The turkey dinner is very good too. Prime rib is excellent but recommend having it on Friday if you like a baked potato with it.“

“We went to the mother's day brunch and found the food to be great and the atmosphere friendly.“

“very expensive and horrible service…the waiter had to be told what we needed instead of asking us first,food was COLD not warm but COLD…we were sat down without plates or napkins when given our appetizer and when asked it took almost 15 minutes to recieve them the waiter also never asked how the food was or anything else…FIRST AND LAST TIME GOING HERE!!!!“