23 Best American Restaurants in Canandaigua

“Love the atmosphere. Staff is exceptional, especially Jordan, our waiter. Food was delicious! Had calamari and reuben- yummy! Can't wait to go back.“

“Amazing food and coffee! The server was friendly, the dining room is comfortable and cozy. Portion sizes are perfect!“

“We are out of towners and first timers to this spot. It will not be our last. The service was absolutely amazing. Our server had my beer in less than 2 minutes. The food was excellent. You can really tell when you come into a restaurant and people care about it. This place has a vibe that other restaurants should envy. Thank you for being awesome!“

“Went there for dinner before a concert at CMAC yesterday and the food and service were AMAZING 👍! I strongly recommend the Peppers Pot Roast because it was the friggin SHIZNIT!!!!! The owners Abraham & Christie are wickedly talented when it comes to the meals and desserts 😁!“

“We LOVED our first experience here. The homemade bread, sausage and baked goods were on point- along with one of the BEST biscuits and gravy ever- we honestly think this is one of the best places for breakfast in Canandaigua. We can’t wait to come back and try lunch! We loved hearing the history of this family woman owned and operated business! Cheers to a comfortable, cozy atmosphere with delicious food!“

“A canandaigua hidden gem!“

“exceptional food, staff, and service. Never disappoints!“

“Went to Rays for breakfast which was very good. Got the bill and there is charge for toast. Since when do you get charged for toast with eggs. The waitress should tell her customer that there is a extra charge for toast.“

“Love the staff and the food is great too 😀“

“My first visit to Murphy’s Law in Canandaigua was wonderful. Cadance was attentive and kept us laughing and entertained. Definitely ask for her. The tater tots were top notch!“

“My new husband and I came to the Finger Lakes on our honeymoon. We were in Canandaigua and were recommended Wally's by a local for a late-night dinner. What a fantastic experience! We had the wings and the Wally's plate, and we’ll be thinking of both for a long time!“

“We had 8 of us show up and we were served outside with our two dogs while they were also hosting a huge indoor event! Food was delicious, drinks were right on and sitting outside with our dogs was lovely! I thought it would be a much longer wait for everything since they were so busy but it was not at all! They are also offering some kickball league, cornhole, and so much more! There’s live music every weekend and just an overall wonderful place to go.“

“Wonderful baked goods and ice cream! I look forward to trying a meal there.“

“My husband took me for dinner and ice cream this afternoon after a few errands. I was not able to enter the restaurant, as I have a badly broken foot and I rested in the car. My husband brought out a beautifully made sundae for me!! I would have gone inside and thanked the server, but I just needed to rest. Little did that server know, I will be having surgery in two days, and I have been in so much pain, unable to sleep, and hardly able to eat, from worry. That sundae cheered me up SO much!!!! You never know exactly who is on the receiving end of your work -- but that waiter made our sundaes as though they were a gift or from a fancy restaurant! I was so delighted! Thank you! (My husband said the server was young and had tattoos. Thank you for cheering me up!!)“

“Has the best clam chowder!! Great meal and service. Will definitely be a return customer.“

“Delicious!! ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ♥️♥️♥️“

“Went after a CMAC concert. Great place to wait out traffic. Kasey was the best server I had tonight. She recommended that half price apps, and drinks…and wouldn’t ya know…they were half price. Ask for Kasey, she’s a good time.“

“From 24 hours away this is the spot we came to wings are super crispy beers are cold and bartender is super friendly. I thank Cody for all his friendship and hospitality all those guidance on fishing the pier and all those guidance on the best alcohol to drink if you’ve never been to New York, and you decide to come check out Jose and Willie‘s on the pier!!!!“

“Would definitely recommend! Stopped while in town for the weekend and was glad we did. Everything was really good, friendly staff and quick service. Mac plate as is with pulled pork... 👍👍 delicious!“

“Everything was absolutely amazing!! Our waitress was Jenna and she was absolutely incredible, we didn’t have to ask for a refill once she was on top of it! We had two appetizers: Buffalo Chicken Dip and Spinach and Artichoke Dip, they were both incredible! The spinach and artichoke dip had a tasty layer of cheese on top and the Buffalo chicken dip definitely had some heat but in the best way, sooo good! I ended up ordering the Jack’d n cheese after Jenna helped me pick and it was so good! It was spicy, creamy, the tenders were nice and crispy, everything about it was just phenomenal, also the cheese left in the bottom of the skillet is perfect for dipping chips and fries into! My parents and partner got the meatball sub and they couldn’t stop talking about how good it was. We will definitely be back, and really hope Jenna is our waitress again!“

“My wife and I love going to the Hive not only for the food, which is always consistently delicious but the friendly and accommodating staff. We also love the customers because it's like being in an episode of "Cheers" (if anyone remembers that show) Everyone Knows Your Name!!! Highly recommended!!!“

“My boyfriend and I decided to try Nick’s for dinner tonight. We were very pleased from the front door service/seating to our waitress Annmarie. She was fantastic at recommending drinks and our main course. The atmosphere had a cool jazz club with the ambiance and music. We highly recommend the prime rib! We will definitely be repeat customers“

“My husband and I have visited several times, always have enjoyed view“