7 Best Ice Cream Shops near Pine City

The Fair Shake Ice Cream Shop • $
1509 Penna Ave, Pine City

“After a very disappointing trip to another ice cream shop we stopped at Fair Shake. I felt bad as there was 11 minutes to closing and I wanted something special. The lady helping us went above and beyond. With a quick "I got you" she made the BEST Sunday I have ever had.“

4.7 Superb17 Reviews
Serendipity Ice Cream and Coffee Ice Cream Shop • $
2335 NY-352, Elmira - 4.34 miles

“Serendipity is an awesome ice cream shop that offers more than ice cream. Everything tastes great and the customer service is the best. The shop is clean and offers seating inside and out. They accept credit and have public restrooms unlike so many other places. It is worth the drive to go to serendipity.“

5 Superb17 Reviews
The Dairy Barn Ice Cream Shop • $
107 Hibbard Rd, Horseheads - 8.22 miles

“$ Cash Only $ Atm inside.They have a huge variety of ice creams! Wine (& alcohol) infused ice creams as well. They also have fresh produce cart, flowers & pumpkin on sale as well.Pint of ice cream is approx (approx. 1/2 litre) $5 and Quart (~ 1 litre) $10.“

4.9 Superb19 Reviews
The Lilly Pad Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt •
627 Pennsylvania Ave, Elmira - 4.14 miles

“The way they serve the soft ice cream is cute - the softie on a dish with the cone on top. They have a good selection of flavors. Some of them I hardly saw around viz. Kahlua, Rum, Tiramisu. I personally like more flavor, so their regular was a bit less flavourful for me (Next time, I'll ask them to add more). Had the Kahlua and Tiramisu. Around $4.5 per soft ice cream.“

4.9 Superb7 Reviews
King Kone Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1315 College Ave, Elmira - 5.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Twist with Sprinkles in a Cup and Cone
Ice Cream Cone
Hot Fudge

“he double dole whip flavors are so very good and the only place to get it i give you 5 stars for your work and kindness to all that come to your place .and the the other flavors of fruit and coffee to best wishes to all and thank you king kone .everyone should so very try .have a great summer to all“

4.5 Superb28 Reviews
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
2614 Corning Rd, Horseheads - 8.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ice with Creme

“Very helpful recommendations, everything looked so good I wanted to get it all. Decided on a milkshake and it was to die for. I went for the strawberry shortcake and my friend got the Oreo milkshake. He said his was amazing as well. Would recommend 5/5. Didn’t disappoint. Anytime I’m in horseheads in the future i will be sure to make a pit stop here.“

4.4 Superb24 Reviews
Big Top Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
2354 Corning Rd, Elmira Heights - 7.52 miles

“Every time we come to NY to visit, we always make a stop at Big Top. Best ice cream around. My size in the pic is a kiddie (great sized portions) for only 1.95, reasonable prices overall, friendly staff. Love the soft serve flavor options here, can’t find them in Virginia.“

4.4 Superb19 Reviews

Pine City’s Other Flavors