50 Best Burger Restaurants near Pittsford

“We make several trips to Tom Wahl’s during the year. Best burgers and fish fry. We have a family tradition of many years to go there on Christmas Eve. Merry Christmas to all at Tom Wahls!“

“Late-Night Gem: Hungry in Pittsford, NY

After 9:30 PM, finding a spot for a quick and delicious bite can feel like a challenge, but Hungry in Pittsford delivered beyond expectations. I ordered their Hungry Wrap, Italian Sausage, and Platter Combo, and they whipped everything up in no time!

The Platter Combo was a crispy, indulgent medley of fried treats, cooked to perfection and paired with tangy sauces. The Hungry Wrap was a cheesy, flavorful delight—each bite was a symphony of fresh ingredients and bold seasonings. The Italian Sausage was packed with hearty flavors, perfectly balanced by caramelized onions and peppers in a soft, crusty roll.

Every dish was freshly prepared and absolutely delicious. Hungry not only nailed the taste but also the speed—an ideal spot for late-night cravings. If you’re ever in Pittsford and need a quick yet satisfying meal, don’t miss this place.“

“This was so great! Celebrating my best friend Birthday 🎂 🥳!
We all had different things.
I had pizza that was so good!
Birthday 🎂 girl got egg plant!
There was so much she had to take home!
Of course I took my pizza home after giving birthday girl some to take home to her boys!

It has a bar & stools to sit at!
Big area for others in booths or tables 4 -6 plus could put more tables together for a crowd!

I will be going back!.
I highly recommend Salvatores!“

“10/10 recommend! Had the best time with our kids this afternoon. Food, games, fun drinks. Everything was amazing! Thanks for a great Saturday afternoon 🙌🏻“

“I’ll preface this by saying that I’ve had garbage plates from Dogtown & Nick’s (the OG). I got a half-plate, which was still a huge portion weighing probably four pounds, with mac’n’homefries and cheeseburger topped with the cinnamon (mild but tasty) meat sauce and “a little bit” of onions, mustard, and ketchup. This was BY FAR the most delicious garbage plate I’ve ever had. I will ABSOLUTELY be coming back here. And it’s less than a 10-minute, quick’n’easy drive from Rochester General Hospital (so skip the Wolfgang Puck despite the convenience). I will add that the young woman who took my order was kind and friendly. The meal “to-go” was ready in less than 4 minutes. And the food was delicious, not at all greasy—literally PERFECT“

“We dined for the first time last night and it was fantastic! The wings were large, crispy and very flavorful. We tried a few different sauces and loved each one. We also ordered their pizza special and it was also really good. Helpful, friendly staff and a fantastic view of the river. We will definitely be back.“

“This was our first time trying The Gate House and we were impressed! We came on a Thursday afternoon with no reservation and were seated right away. Our server was prompt and attentive immediately and continued through the duration of our meal. We tried the Xerox pizza as well as the Duffy burger and both were 10/10! Absolutely delicious. I would highly recommend!“

“Moo’d Burger Bar is an amazing spot! Each burger my group got was phenomenal. I got the 585 burger which I would highly recommend if you like garbage plates. The garlic fries as a choice of side was a good addition to the meal as well. After our meal we had to get dessert since that is what this place is truly known for and it definitely did not disappoint! Their ice cream desserts are second to none in the area and I would go again just for that.“

“We always try to go to Tom Wahls when passing thru the Rochester area, even going out of our way a little we make a point to go atleast once or twice a year. I have been to a few other locations over the decades, and always found them clean, organized and a friendly staff. First time at this location did not quite live up to the standards of the others had set, but to be fair I think we just came at a bad time. It was loud and chaotic when we came in with several messy tables. The cashier seemed impatient with us and to not be paying attention as we kept having to repeat our order as he stared off to the side unsure we were heard (just 2 people getting a burger frie and drinks nothing crazy. My burger had an insane amount of mayo, not sure what happened there but it was almost a comical amount on both sides, easy to scrape some off and still enjoy the burger. My spouce really enjoyed his mushroom burger.

I do have to give them some credit as there was a group from a baseball team leaving as we parked and when we came in a dozen todlers with only two adults for supervision who didn't seem to have any control of them running around by the order counter and dineing room and that is clearly not the staffs fault and was probably very overwhelming for the staff also and it wouldn't be fair to judge under those circumstances, service industry can be unpredictable and overwhelming.

If your thinking of checking out this location know there may be loud messy kids there but its worth it because Wahls has really great unique burgers, the best creemy rootbeer and a fun retro vibe....and mabey order your mayo on the side. I wish there were a location closer to Buffalo.“

“Every time you come home, have to go to Bill Grays“

“Ordered beef and cheese empanadas, jerk empanadas, shrimp fried rice, and baked and stoned mac and cheese. Absolutely delicious, filling, fresh comfort food“

“awesome food and fresh rite off the grill. love the root beer 🥰🥰🥰“

“Definitely will be going back. Great staff, good food, and a great dining experience.“

“My husband and I have lunch here every Wednesday. The food is always great and we love Natasha, our regular server. She’s so sweet and so accommodating. We love her!“

“Im not a sports guy and I dont think ive ever actually sat down in this restaurant. BUT, they have the absolute greatest chicken tenders in all of rochester. They're honey mustard is an excellent and original taste. The food always comes out hot and fresh. I get take out here all the time because these are my girlfriend's favorite chicken tenders, hands down.“

“The menu never disappoints. Creative and fresh. The dishes are inspiring and delicious.“

“A++ all around, staff knows what they are doing“

“I have only been to your location twice but I've been impressed both times. Everyone is busting their hump to get everything out quickly and the food is great!! You were very busy both occasions but I didn't wait. Great friendly staff and extremely hot food. Very impressed.“

“We stopped in last night everyone was so welcoming and nice and the food was great!!! It was hot and fresh and soooo good!! 10 out of 10 for us 😋“

“Extremely delicious burgers and chicken sandwiches. Despite being basic crinkle cut, the fries were surprisingly good, too. Unfortunately, the pricing is out of range for what many would expect (>$20 per person), and as a result, I can't justify going here on more than just a rare occasion.

Edit: since writing this review, Shake Shack has came out with many promotion codes that can be used to either order on the app or the in-store Kiosks. Definitely helps with the affordability.“

“Peppermints Restaurant located at 4870 WEST HENRIETTA ROAD is the best!! Service is EXCEPTIONAL and the food is AMAZING!!“

“Grew up in Rochester and this is was a really good, classic garbage plate. Add a bit more seasoning the mac salad and it would be 10/10“

“We went here for a date night and could not have chosen a better place! The food was absolutely amazing and the staff was attentive but not too much so. We will definitely be back!“

“Good service, good food, good prices. The bacon was crispy, but not overcooked, and the blueberry pancakes were delicious.“

“I only counted 4 guys... but the food was great!“

“Every time my fiance and I go to Rochester which is pretty far from us we try to stop at Nick Tahou's. They are always so friendly there. One of the workers was talking to my toddler and making him laugh. Love everything about this place. And the food is always a 10/10“

“Best Bill Gray's meal I have ever had...service a little slow but the burger and fries were hot,hot,hot!“

“I work here and try to provide the best service and love my job!“

“Visited from out of state and was told I needed to try a plate. Quite the culinary experience! I’ll definitely be back again when I’m in the area.“

“Bill Gray's is legendary and there food still proves it after all these years. I was at one of ther locations during my early military service and the food quality, wasteland customer friendly environment is outstanding. Im from buffalo and this place is worth the travel. The manager even spoke to us about our experience and encouraged an awesome desert. We'll done bill Gray's well done. Also your garbage plate should be sold everywhere.“

“They care about making their customers happy here. We had a lot of fun and the food was awesome!!“

“Great location! If you’ve had Five Guys before, you know what you’re getting and this location does not disappoint.
It wasn’t very busy when we stopped in. The food was perfect, the bathrooms and dining area were clean. The employees were friendly.
The double cheeseburger is a classic. Perfectly seasoned patties with melty cheese. With everything on it, it’s perfect.
The fries have a delightful saltiness and are a little fluffier than other fast food fries.
Always the perfect place to grab a burger with a friend and just enjoy a quick meal together.
I always know what to expect and I love it.“

“Impossible Whopper is very good; better than any other non-meat burger we’ve had. This BK location is very clean and well kept!“

“So good!!! Huge portions at great prices. Super friendly staff, clean facility, well done.“

“A "neighborhood bar and grill" with much better food, drinks, and service. I've been there over a hundred times and love the consistency in the experience. The dining room is separate from the bar area if you want a quieter environment, but there are also tables in the bar area and outside. It's also great for take-out - the online ordering is a little flaky (hint: check out as guest and don't try to make an account) but you can always call your order in as well.

Kid-friendliness: Great for kids“

“great burger reasonable prices“

“Absolutely delicious breakfast - beautiful, fresh and so so tasty! Service was fantastic - will definitely return!!“

“The best vegan pizza and fried dough! And friendly service. Can't wait to go back!“

“Krystin was an amazing server! She was kind, attentive, and considerate of our needs throughout our entire visit. She checked on us often and made sure our needs were met: her personality and spirit were so bright and joyful! We loved eating off of the 2 for 25 menu and got drinks as well: all of which were fantastic!“

“Fairport Hots is amazing! I hired them for my daughter's grad party and they were so delicious, efficient, and wonderful to deal with. We have zero complaints. Will hire them again.“

“I am so impressed and appreciative of the honest employees and patrons of this establishment....I left my purse on a counter and a graciously kind patron turned it in and the employees kept it safe for me to retrieve....this says a lot about the integrity of this service and it's community! By the way, we had a lovely meal in a pleasant atmosphere too! Just wanted you to know...“

“Our server was fantastic and food was awesome but way to cold 🥶 in the building !!“

“Burger was still really pink in the middle, fries were either wayyyy to mushy or wayyy to hard. They put fries in little brown sandwich slips now instead of the nice white cups in the brown paper bag. And they also didn't put my sauces on the side with my no bun burger... we love 5 guys but as of late its not been the same.“

“My family of 7 celebrated my daughter's birthday here on Friday, March 4.... a large variety of food choices were ordered by us and everyone was very pleased.Our server was great and very patient; even considering that it was Friday! The staff were happy to help us with the birthday cake and a song, too.? The menu is quite diverse and we all look forward to going back to sample some fish or veal.“

“I love the food here, but it really is never ready... I order an hour before I need it and go in 20 minutes after it says it should be ready and I still wait 30-50 minutes every time. This last time I got food I ordered for pickup at 6:15 and when I got there at 7:00, It was just being put on the shelf.

It is also so cold in there, I swear they always have their air conditioning on 10 degrees. Lol“

“the atmosphere and drink prices“

“The Really Philly was phenomenal! I would definitely get this again. Will be back for more.“

“Great people, great food. Definitely our new sports bar when we come North.“

“This place is so clean. Staff is great! Food is great! Will definitely add it to my list of favorites. 10/10“

“You are our new #1 go to now for pizza and more! Thanks for such an amazing experience. Staff ROCKS! Hot and fresh delivery!! Saved to my phone contacts. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“