23 Best Italian Restaurants near Poughquag

“Pizza to go only. You can't have pizza in the dining room. Pizza is outstanding. Too bad we can't have it there along with the rest of the menu. It seems like it's about to close due to the lack of menus available and the fact that the menu was poorly stapled. Best pizza !“

“Always my go to place!! But it’s now sold to a different owner and they are absolutely horrible and the food is gross!!! I would not even go to get a slice of pizza!!!! PS:The New owner thinks he a GOD in the kitchen!!! to add a update.....it takes them hours to cook anything I mean anything! we order 2 things of chicken fingers and fries and it took them over a hour!!! PS they put Parmesan cheese on French fries for kids!! That's nasty that's nasty!“

“All I can is WOW....great service/great food + awesome family = GREAT MOTHER'S DAY DINNER !! Thanks to Josh and Alyssa for making this afternoon a huge success....my Dad had one of Josh's fresh cannolis and could not believe what he had been missing his whole life...“

“Exceptional food. Take out and dine in has been a 10/10. Their pasta is cooked to perfection. Their sauce is phenomenal. I highly recommend villa nigrelli. I come from Long Island where I’ve had my fair share of amazing Italian food and this is definitely in my top 5 places. That’s a big compliment. Seafood was fresh.“

“My wife and I recently found this place about a year ago. Have gone 4 times and have had nothing but exceptional service and food. I sort of want to keep this place a hidden gem. They recommend reservations, but walking in should be no issue for a small party of 2-4. However, every time I make a reservation, we are greeted and seated immediately with our table prepared and water already served, which is a nice touch. Not many restaurants actually prepare the table for the reservation that was made previously.Each time we have had the same waiter which has been great. He is always accommodating and polite and attentive. Other staff have also been friendly and kind.Soft butter is always served to go with the delicious bread. The fried calamari is great. The chicken parm is good. My favorite has been the NY Strip with Gorgonzola cheese melted on top. Cooked perfect each time. The cheese gives it a great flavor that just works well together. Had it twice and my wife also had it and it’s delicious each time. And for dessert the tartufo is probably the best I’ve had. Highly recommend.We have decided to make this a place for special occasions such as birthdays or anniversary’s. It’s a place that we truly enjoy and look forward to coming to for years to come. Highly suggest it. Prices are very reasonable. Much more expensive places with mediocre food. This place is worth every penny.“

“Just had the most amazing salad! Romana Salad with grilled chicken and balsamic dressing. So good!!!!“

“Had my wedding here and Frank and the staff were amazing and the food was great!“

“We celebrated our mothers 100th birthday - and sweet and kind Christina gifted us the cake for her big celebration. It was absolutely beautiful and delicious. Our family thanks you immensely for your kindness!“

“Friendly, fun atmosphere with all the Italian favorites. YUM!“

“Fantastic pizza and friendly staff!“

“Delicious pizza! Highly recommend!“

“Hot and fresh to our table! So delicious! Just what these out of towners were expecting from a New York pizza place! Thank you! 😊“

“delicious food, good service, and kind people“

“MADISON'S PIZZA CAFE in the heart of Pleasant Valley is a warm and friendly place with great pizza and many other dine in or take out menu options. There's a definite local neighborhood vibe here and the owners and staff make you feel like family. I will be back soon to work my way through that fun menu“

“we order all the time so delicious tonight chicken marsala pizza, yummy!!“

“I’m currently on a salad kick! Mediterranean Salad with grilled chicken ~. And a fresh filled cannoli 😘“

“1st Time here, Love The Atmosphere, Great Food & Very Family Oriented As Well!!“

“We drove 50 minutes from Woodbury CT to your restaurant because we know your food is Awesome 11/19/23 And once again it was delicious as Ever Thanks to you all and compliments to the chef It was well worth our ride See you Again Erik and Lisa“

“Best pizza“

“Great good and hospitality 🥰“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ From Me and My Fiancée – An Unforgettable Pizza Experience

My fiancée and I had the absolute pleasure of visiting Mike & Joe’s Pizza in Hopewell Junction, and we both agree—it’s hands-down one of the best pizzerias in all of New York.

From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with that classic, warm New York charm and the incredible smell of real, wood-fired pizza that instantly made us feel at home. Every bite was a reminder of what true, traditional pizza is supposed to taste like.

The crust was perfectly crisp with a soft center, the sauce was rich and flavorful, and the cheese? Melted to perfection. We shared a Margherita pie and a Meat Lovers, and both were out of this world. You can tell everything is made with love and real passion for quality.

The staff treated us like family, the service was fast, and the atmosphere was cozy and welcoming—exactly what you want from a great neighborhood spot.

Whether you’re a local or just passing through, do yourself a favor and stop by Mike & Joe’s. It’s not just a meal—it’s an experience. We’ll absolutely be coming back.

— Gjergj & Carla 🖤🍕“

“This is a very nice pizza place, I live down the road and can walk there. The people working there are nice, respectful and are willing to help out their customers. (I was even offered a ride home by the delivery driver when it was raining the other day) The food is delicious and made right, and I get pizza here a lot. Not only are they a pizza place, but they're your typical gas station store where you can get chips, soda, beer and ice cream. They also have a deli.

The only complaint I have is the prices, a large plain pie costs ~$30.00 and the chips are ~$2.70 for a small bag and ~$5.30 for a large.

Still a very nice store and I hope to work there!“