23 Best Sandwich Shops near Rye Brook

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Sandwich Shops near Rye Brook.

Showing 23 of 23 restaurants

  • Lenny's Bagels 172 South Ridge Street, Rye Brook Sandwich Shop · $

    1 Lenny's Bagels

    3.4 Good 155 Reviews

    172 South Ridge Street, Rye Brook

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Bagel with Cream Cheese
    • Bagel with Butter
    • Chicken Salad

    “A good place to get a bagel, muffin, some lunch salads, etc. Lots of other goodies as well. A very popular place, you usually have a wait but it's short. Would like to see a redesign of where to order and pay as it's all crammed into one space. Other than that, you'll enjoy whatever you get there.”

  • Casa D'italia Sandwich Shoppe 265 Halstead Avenue, Harrison Sandwich Shop · $

    2 Casa D'italia Sandwich Shoppe

    4.8 Superb 126 Reviews

    265 Halstead Avenue, Harrison · 3.84 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Fresh Mozzarella Roasted Peppers
    • Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
    • Chicken Alla Nonna
    • Melted Mozzarella

    “Steve, Lucy and their amazingly attentive staff are so genuinely friendly. Every order is made with care and is always so fresh and absolutely delicious. Casa is a long standing 5⭐️ local favorite 😊”

  • Melt Sandwich Shop 277 Mamaroneck Avenue, White Plains Sandwich Shop · $

    3 Melt Sandwich Shop

    4.5 Superb 225 Reviews

    277 Mamaroneck Avenue, White Plains · 4.21 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Jerk Chicken Sandwich with Spice Combination
    • Turkey Sandwich with Mushrooms and Sauce
    • Classic Grilled Chicken with Mushrooms
    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

    “Chicken Curry soup is 🔥..”

  • The Sandwich Spot NY 160 Legion Drive, Valhalla Sandwich Shop · $

    4 The Sandwich Spot NY

    4.5 Superb 214 Reviews

    160 Legion Drive, Valhalla · 6.11 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Part of an Almost 20 Filet Mignon Sandwich
    • Mortadella & Burrata on Foccacia
    • Smoked Mozzarella Ciabatta Bread
    • Mortadella & Burrata on Foccacia

    “The House Beef was the best roast beef ever! The food always exceeds my expectations! Thank you! 5 Stars!”

  • Stillwater Sandwich Shoppe Inc 242 Stillwater Avenue, Stamford Sandwich Shop · $

    5 Stillwater Sandwich Shoppe Inc

    4.5 Superb 156 Reviews

    242 Stillwater Avenue, Stamford · 7.03 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Russian Chicken Cutlets
    • Bacon Egg and Cheese
    • Chicken Cutlet Wrap
    • Italian Combo

    “Food was great! I had a breakfast sandwich and my husband had a club, both were huge portions (great price), fresh and delicious. It’s a welcoming atmosphere, fast and you can tell the food is made with love. We will definitely be back.”

  • Firehouse Deli 265 Mill Street, Greenwich Sandwich Shop · $

    6 Firehouse Deli

    4.5 Superb 143 Reviews

    265 Mill Street, Greenwich · 1.83 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • The Nameless One Sandwich Combo
    • Turkey Bacon Wedge
    • Chicken Fingers
    • Italian Combo

    “When I moved to New York, I lived upstairs to an Italian Deli. After moving to Greenwich, I have been looking for a deli that would match it. A friend recommended Firehouse...and THIS IS IT! We have been ordering now for several months. You can taste the pride. Prices are more than fair and the portions (especially the wedges) are outstanding. This is the real deal. Love their meatball Parm wedge, the Mr. G's wedge...hell, everything I've tried has been good. My wife loves their fish sandwich, too, so it's a winner all around...it's all great.”

  • Mason Sandwich Co. 33 Mill Road, Eastchester Sandwich Shop · $$

    7 Mason Sandwich Co.

    4.3 Superb 214 Reviews

    33 Mill Road, Eastchester · 7.97 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • French Onion Meltoe Porchetta
    • Steak and Cheese Sandwich
    • French Onion Sandwich
    • Flank Steak Sandwich

    “Their sandwiches are outstanding. Also great fries! Very friendly staff.”

  • Crotty's Cheesesteaks 8 Eastchester Road, New Rochelle Sandwich Shop · $

    8 Crotty's Cheesesteaks

    4.2 Good 219 Reviews

    8 Eastchester Road, New Rochelle · 8.42 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Traditional Cheesesteak Slider No Onions & Scoop of French Fries
    • Chicken Fingers & French Fries
    • Cheesesteak Cheesesteak
    • Cheesesteak Disco Fries

    “Had them for my first time today. Amazing!!!”

  • The Press 35 Spencer Place, Scarsdale Sandwich Shop · $$

    9 The Press

    4.3 Superb 79 Reviews

    35 Spencer Place, Scarsdale · 6.75 miles

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • The Lead Story
    • Editor's Pick
    • The Tony Pec
    • The Wilson

    “This was a fantastic place. Now granted, I've only came here for the Lead Story sandwich, which is a Philly Cheesesteak, but man is it super flavorful. They do have cooper sharp cheese, so I'd recommend asking for it with the cooper sharp. Hands down, this is the best Philly I've had in Westchester. Tried a number of places, but none compare. I will be back some day to try their other sandwiches, but I've just been on a personal question for this type of sandwich close to home. If their other sandwiches are anything like this one then I'd 100% say this is a highly recommended spot to visit. All are reasonably priced too compared to most places for what you get. All in all, this was a really good spot.”

  • Jersey Mike's Subs 247 North Central Avenue, Hartsdale Sandwich Shop · $

    10 Jersey Mike's Subs

    4.0 Good 195 Reviews

    247 North Central Avenue, Hartsdale · 5.75 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Provolone on Parmesan Bread
    • California Chicken Cheese Steak
    • Jersey Mike's Famous Philly
    • Chicken Philly Cheese Steak

    “Delicious delicious 😋 food”

  • Subway 231 East Main Street, New Rochelle Sandwich Shop · $

    11 Subway

    4.0 Good 118 Reviews

    231 East Main Street, New Rochelle · 8.57 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Oven-Roasted Turkey Combo with Your Choice of Side and Drink
    • Auntie Anne's Footlong Pretzel
    • Double Chocolate Cookie
    • Chocolate Chip Cookie

    “Been here with my husband for 10 years and have been coming here since it opened. The food is always amazing and the service is great. Food is always fresh and the restaurant is always clean. I love all the options you can pick from and how you customize to anything you want! It also has options for picky eaters (like myself) because I dont have to get a pre-designed sandwich! Its perfect!”

  • Subway 482 Bedford Road, Pleasantville Sandwich Shop · $

    12 Subway

    4.1 Good 46 Reviews

    482 Bedford Road, Pleasantville · 9.71 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Meatball Marinara

    “I really enjoy this subway location. There is very easy street parking on the corner of the building, and their food is excellent. The subs are very tasty and all of the ingredients are very fresh. I also love their chocolate chip cookies! They also have some very friendly staff as well.”

  • Marina Deli Inc 416, 10805 (1 W Pelham Road, New Rochelle Sandwich Shop · $

    13 Marina Deli Inc

    4.4 Superb 26 Reviews

    416, 10805 (1 W Pelham Road, New Rochelle · 9.87 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Halal Chicken over Rice
    • Chopped Cheese
    • Turkey Wrap
    • Pastrami

    “This place is an awesome and convenience spot and that has great hours. I believe they are 6 or 7:00 a.m. until midnight which is rare these days. And being that my boat is in a marina right down the block it is a truly wonderful place to have. The store is extremely clean. The food is fresh. The beverage selections are great and they even carry ice. What more can you ask for”

  • Loupino’s 111 Pelham Road, New Rochelle Sandwich Shop · $

    14 Loupino’s

    3.8 Good 116 Reviews

    111 Pelham Road, New Rochelle · 9.24 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Hot Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich
    • American Cold Cut Sub
    • Hot Pastrami
    • Pasta Salad

    “great food”

  • Jimmy John's 182 Saw Mill River Road, Elmsford Sandwich Shop

    15 Jimmy John's

    4.6 Superb 12 Reviews

    182 Saw Mill River Road, Elmsford · 7.43 miles

    • Delivery

    “Delicious sandwiches. This place recently opened (summer 2026) so the staff are still being trained. Please be patient with them during training and enjoy the delicious food, they will become Freaky Fast as is their trademark service. I had the Italian on sliced whole wheat and definitely recommend it!”

  • Subway 73 Main Street, Tuckahoe Sandwich Shop · $

    16 Subway

    3.7 Good 106 Reviews

    73 Main Street, Tuckahoe · 8.87 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Oven Roasted Turkey & Ham Footlong Regular Sub
    • Turkey Cali Club Footlong Regular Sub
    • All-American Club 6 Inch Regular Sub
    • Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki

    “Must share that the people who run this subway are top tier. So nice every single time I come in. Today I was helped by Pria who told me all about how I can save if I’m coming to subway often. Every other time I come in I’m greeted with a smile and prompt service and always leave feeling like I was cared for at A Subway! Great job tuckahoe Subway”

  • Subway 262 Boston Post Road, Port Chester Sandwich Shop · $

    17 Subway

    3.8 Good 47 Reviews

    262 Boston Post Road, Port Chester · 1.68 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
  • The Country Table 1 Glenville Street, Greenwich Sandwich Shop · $

    18 The Country Table

    3.6 Good 86 Reviews

    1 Glenville Street, Greenwich · 1.66 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Grilled Chicken Breast
    • Roast Turkey Sandwich
    • Breakfast Burrito
    • 'Wich Came First

    “Outstanding new gourmet and sandwich shop in Glenville. Long overdue. The owners/chefs have worked in some of the best restaurants in NYC....and they have brought their creative and exceptional talents to Greenwich.”

  • Subway 65 South Central Avenue, Hartsdale Sandwich Shop · $

    19 Subway

    3.6 Good 78 Reviews

    65 South Central Avenue, Hartsdale · 5.89 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “I wouldn't have imagined describing a Subway as lovely, but this location is so welcoming and nice to go to. I've come here for lunch a handful of times throughout the year and the staff are always friendly, polite, and upbeat. The sandwiches are delicious and the extra cookie brings a smile to my face every time. The place is clean and fresh. The lot is small but I never have trouble finding a place to park. I love this spot!”

  • Subway 923 Broadway, Thornwood Sandwich Shop · $

    20 Subway

    3.6 Good 38 Reviews

    923 Broadway, Thornwood · 8.86 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery
  • La Fortune Deli Inc 174 North Main Street, Port Chester Sandwich Shop

    21 La Fortune Deli Inc

    3.7 Good 13 Reviews

    174 North Main Street, Port Chester · 1.58 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “I stopped in for the 1st time on May 4, 2022. My 7 year old granddaughter saw the photos in the window and led me in! The staff could not have been friendlier and more accommodating. She ordered a cheeseburger with fries (!!!) and a pina colada smoothie.I had coffee which was fresh and a nice blend. The experience was pleasantly unexpected. We’ll be sure to return. ☺️”

  • Jersey Mike's Subs 341 Halstead Avenue Unit 11, Harrison Sandwich Shop · $

    22 Jersey Mike's Subs

    3.7 Good 13 Reviews

    341 Halstead Avenue Unit 11, Harrison · 3.7 miles

    • Delivery

    “Pleasantly surprised! Service was very nice and they made the sandwich right there “Mike’s Way,” prices are genuinely reasonable (which is rare for a chain, even though they can’t beat Anthony’s in Mamaroneck in value) The store is brand new, so it’s clean and pretty. Not important but possibly worth mentioning: they do not support swiping your card, only tap or insert. So if you have one of those prepaid debit gift cards, it can’t be accepted. This is a non-issue for most and doesn’t affect my review. Overall happy with the lunch! Recommend stopping by.”

  • Market Sandwich 110 Bloomingdale Road, White Plains Sandwich Shop · $$$

    23 Market Sandwich

    4.0 Good 4 Reviews

    110 Bloomingdale Road, White Plains · 3.98 miles

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

Sandwich Shops Nearby

You May Also Like

  • Buffalo Wild Wings Go and Jimmy John's Now Share a Roof in Florida

    Buffalo Wild Wings Go and Jimmy John's Now Share a Roof in Florida

    Floridians north of Sarasota can order chicken wings and a sub sandwich at the same counter. Quality Foods Restaurant Group opened the first co-branded Buffalo Wild Wings Go and Jimmy John's on Aug. 18 at 5241 69th St. E in Palmetto. The franchisee runs three other Buffalo Wild Wings in Florida and chose fast-growing Manatee County for its game-day calendar, from high school football to Pirates spring training.