16 Best Italian Restaurants near Shelter Island Heights

Léon 1909 Italian • $$$
29 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island Heights

Customers` Favorites

Slow Roasted Chicken
Clams and Sausage
Bone in Ribeye
Roasted Fluke
Roast Chicken
Roasted Pork
French Fries

“We visited on Saturday evening during the Thanksgiving holiday weekend. From the moment we entered through the front door, we were welcomed by big smiles, big smells of delicious food, and what felt like a warm hug from a good friend. Classic and palette awakening cocktails. Try the brandade fritters and the best Caesar salad I have ever enjoyed. Sea bass was fresh out of the waters that surround the east end. The burger and the roasted chicken. For sides we ordered the onion gratin, romanesco and French fries. Surprise banana split for dessert. Delicious! See you again soon. Happy Holidays!“

3.9 Good77 Reviews
2

Isola

Isola Italian • $$$
15 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights

Customers` Favorites

Olives and Flatbread
Chicken Parmigiana
Oysters Rockefeller
Pasta Bolognese

“Kayla and I had an amazing dinner Steak night. Kayla's steak was out of this world delicious. I had the Swordfish which was tasty and delicious. Thank you Brad for treating us like family. We will be back again soon.“

4 Good26 Reviews
Touch of Venice Italian • $$$
28350 Main Rd, Cutchogue - 8.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Shrimp in Scampi Sauce
Linguine Con Vongole
Linguine with Clams
Rigatoni Bolognese
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Stuffed Artichoke
Grilled Swordfish
Veal Parmigiana
Beef Bolognese
Fluke Francese

“The food is amazing and the staff is incredible. We had a blast there last evening. Can’t wait to go back!“

4.6 Superb39 Reviews
Cappelletti Restaurant & Take Out Italian • $$
3284 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor - 6.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Calamari
Marinara Sauce
Eggplant Parm
Garlic Rolls
Lobster Roll
Garlic Bread
Focaccia
Sandwich
Risotto

“This charming roadside take out and restaurant goes way beyond expectations. The dining rooms are proper and attractive. The atmosphere is more European bistro/cafe/trattoria than NY Deli. The service is very good. The Italian/American menu is extensive. And the food is outstanding and a great value. Highly Recommended.“

4.5 Superb55 Reviews
Maroni Southold Italian
54195 Main Rd, Southold - 3.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

Toasted Marshmallows over Chocolate Mousse
Ribs with Gummi Bear Glaze
Chicken Parmigiana
Penne Ala Vodka
Sushi Tuesday

“Maroni's is such a gem in the middle of Southold. The Sushi Tuesdays are INCREDIBLE and the truffle grilled cheese is to absolutely DIE for. Kristen & Amber are 2 of the best on the North Fork and if you've not had their meatball pot yet I IMPLORE you to do so. And this is coming from someone who doesnt eat meatballs outside her Nonna's kitchen.

I can not express this enough but make reservations and enjoy the fact that the place deals in cash/check/zelle only and that the prices on the menu reflect tax & tip so you can know exactly what you're spending in advance.“

4.4 Superb30 Reviews
Il Capuccino Italian • $$
30 Madison St, #PO1438, 30 Madison St, Sag Harbor - 6.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Veal Parmigiana with Garlic and Oil Linguini
Chocolate Lava Cake with Vanilla Ice Cream
Basket of Hot Garlic Rolls
Mozzarella Tomato & Pesto
Pistacchio Gelato Tartufo
Pumpkin Ravioli Special
Baked Ziti with Ricotta
Stuffed Baked Clams
Eggplant Parmigiana
View from Our Table

“I have been going to Il Capuccino since it opened, with bring your own wine and red and white plastic tablecloths. Loved it then and love it now. A superior experience!!! ❤️“

4.1 Good80 Reviews
DOPO La Spiaggia Italian • $$$
6 Bay St, Sag Harbor - 6.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rigatoni with Sausage and Peas
Tiramisu
Burrata
Milanese

“Delicious and great atmosphere“

3.6 Good71 Reviews
Michelangelo Southold Italian • $$
53345 Main Rd, Southold - 4.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Slice Pizza
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Piccata
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Fried Calamari
Eggplant Pizza
Grandma Pizza
Garlic Knots

“The food is excellent and the pizza is even better. There once a week. You will be pleased.“

3.8 Good87 Reviews
Tutto il Giorno Sag Italian
16 Main St, Sag Harbor - 6.47 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Calamari and Fried Vegetables
Ravioli with Wild Mushrooms
Panna Cotta w Berries
Spaghetti Bolognese
Pasta Bolognese
Salmon Nizzarda
Truffle Pasta
Cozze Vongole
Tuna Tartare
Margherita

“Good food 🥘 nice ambience“

3.8 Good100 Reviews
10

Alpina

Alpina Wine Bar • $$$
45 Front St, Greenport - 1.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

House Made Swiss Sausage
Cacio E Pepper Agnolotti
Classic Wiener Schnitzel
Chartreuse Soufflé
Charcuterie Board
Bread Basket
Duck Breast

“Our group enjoyed dinner at the bar with Ava. She was welcoming and offered suggestions for drinks and dinner. The food was delicious and the atmosphere was cozy and inviting. Pork chop special was divine and the dessert was decadent.

Definitely coming back for another visit.“

4.5 Superb50 Reviews
La Capannina Pizza • $
364 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott - 10.96 miles

Customers` Favorites

My Favorite Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Eggplant Pizza
Margarita Pie
Fried Calamari
Chicken Parm

“great staff and great food. The Chicken Franchaise is delicious“

4.5 Superb43 Reviews
Vine Street Café American • $$$
41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island - 2.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hot Bread Fresh Out of the Oven
Spicy Tuna Tartare Tacos
Lobster Bouillabaisse
Crispy Calamari Salad
Sticky Toffee Pudding
Miso Glazed Salmon
Crispy Duck Confit
Rigatoni Bolognese
Grilled Fish
Skirt Steak

“Excellent food and wonderful service! The staff goes above and beyond and is extremely attentive to their patrons. The food was delicious. We cannot wait to go back!!“

4.3 Superb134 Reviews
Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant Pizza • $$
1271 Noyack Rd, Southampton - 8.95 miles

Customers` Favorites

Seared Local Calamari
Meatball Sliders
Eggplant Sliders
Arugula
Pizza

“Restaurant was packed as is usual at this time of the year.However the food,and service was not compromised. Fried artichokes were excellent,as was the arugula pizza,and egg plant pizza as well!
However for me as a gluten free Celiac customer, i needed gluten free pasta.Well they not only had it but it was the best I had ever had!!! It was the shrimp fra diavalo over ziti.Perfect heat to a firm pasta cooked perfectly in a separate pot as not to cross contaminate,now that's customer service !
If you want a terrific meal without stupid Hampton prices, come to this terrific local restaurant ,you won't be disappointed!“

4.5 Superb34 Reviews
Espresso Da Asporto Italian • $$
2 Main St, Sag Harbor - 6.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Focaccia Cocktail Sandwich Platter Catering
Antipasto Platter Catering
Chicken Noodle Soup
Pepperoni Pizza
Garden Salad
Sad Sandwich

“If you know you know! I've been going to Espresso since its original tiny corner spot on Division street.

Their sandwiches are amazing! I get the grilled veggie with their amazing sauce! My sister always gets something different. Their pasta salads are soooo good It's a staple in Sag!

Always call in your order ahead of time!

Tourists stay away jk but not really, lol 😆“

3.4 Good37 Reviews
Roma Pizzeria Pizza • $
31455 Main Rd, Cutchogue - 7.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Pie
Marinara Sauce
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Salad

“Born in New York and grew up in Huntington. This is my First time at Romas and visiting mom from Virginia, my son has never been to any authentic New York pizza joints. So when we tried Roma’s, he had the Sicilian and he told the owner “it’s the best pizza he ever ate”. Coincidentally the owner knows Tony from our local pizza place in Virginia. Real glad we got up for some real New York pizza before leaving to go home in little ol’ Virginia.“

3.4 Good20 Reviews
Sag Pizza Pizza • $$
103 Main St, Sag Harbor - 6.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

San Marzano Pizza and 2 Garlic Knots
Sag Harbor Slice of Pizza
Tomato & Cheese Pizza
Summer Squash Pizza
Chopped Arthur Ave
Margherita Pizza
Neapolitan Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Truffle Pizza
Arugula Salad

“I ordered an Arugula and avocado that barely has avocado with very dried/dead leaf that I m not even sure if it is an arugula. Simply horrible. Will never come back again and won t recommended.“

3.7 Good111 Reviews

You May Also Like