Home
NY
Shelter Island Heights
Italian Restaurants

14 Best Italian Restaurants near Shelter Island Heights

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Italian Restaurants near Shelter Island Heights.

Showing 14 of 14 restaurants

Italian · $$$$
1 Léon 1909

4.3 Superb 144 Reviews

29 West Neck Road, Shelter Island Heights
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Slow Roasted Chicken
- Clams and Sausage
- Bone in Ribeye
- Roasted Fluke
“We visited on Saturday evening during the Thanksgiving holiday weekend. From the moment we entered through the front door, we were welcomed by big smiles, big smells of delicious food, and what felt like a warm hug from a good friend. Classic and palette awakening cocktails. Try the brandade fritters and the best Caesar salad I have ever enjoyed. Sea bass was fresh out of the waters that surround the east end. The burger and the roasted chicken. For sides we ordered the onion gratin, romanesco and French fries. Surprise banana split for dessert. Delicious! See you again soon. Happy Holidays!”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
2 Maroni Southold

4.7 Superb 87 Reviews

54195 Main Road, Southold · 3.96 miles
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Toasted Marshmallows over Chocolate Mousse
- Ribs with Gummi Bear Glaze
- Chicken Parmigiana
- Penne Ala Vodka
“Went to Maroni for the first time today....we split the chicken parm, the chicken milanese, and the penne ala vodka. All of it was amazing!! I can't even choose which I liked best, as all three were so great. Had the meatballs as well, and they were also perfect. One of the best meals I've had in a while, and I have nothing but good things to say.”
Menu
Italian · $$$
3 Touch of Venice

4.4 Superb 190 Reviews

28350 Main Road, Cutchogue · 8.37 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Grilled Shrimp in Scampi Sauce
- Linguine Con Vongole
- Linguine with Clams
- Rigatoni Bolognese
“The food is amazing and the staff is incredible. We had a blast there last evening. Can’t wait to go back!”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
4 Cappelletti Restaurant & Take Out

4.4 Superb 140 Reviews

3284 Noyack Road, Sag Harbor · 6.26 miles
- Take-Out
Customers’ favorites
- Fried Calamari
- Marinara Sauce
- Eggplant Parm
- Garlic Rolls
“We love going to Capelettis — it’s a charming local restaurant that always makes you feel welcome. The owner and chef, Luigi, always greets you with a smile when you walk through the door, which makes the experience feel very personal and special. He is an amazing chef — the pasta fagioli soup is the best, and everything is always delicious. The staff couldn’t be nicer, and the whole place has a very homey, local feel. One of our favorite spots — we highly recommend it.”
Menu
Italian · $$$$
5 Tutto il Giorno Sag

3.9 Good 287 Reviews

16 Main Street, Sag Harbor · 6.47 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Fried Calamari and Fried Vegetables
- Ravioli with Wild Mushrooms
- Panna Cotta w Berries
- Spaghetti Bolognese
“Good food 🥘 nice ambience”
Menu Order
Italian · $$$$
6 DOPO La Spiaggia

4.0 Good 221 Reviews

6 Bay Street, Sag Harbor · 6.55 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Rigatoni with Sausage and Peas
- Tiramisu
- Burrata
- Milanese
“Delicious and great atmosphere”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
7 La Capannina

4.6 Superb 179 Reviews

364 Montauk Highway, Wainscott · 10.96 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Cheese Pizza Slice
- My Favorite Pizza
- Pizza Margarita
- Pepperoni Pizza
“great staff and great food. The Chicken Franchaise is delicious”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
8 Il Capuccino

4.1 Good 92 Reviews

30 Madison St, #PO1438, 30 Madison St, Sag Harbor · 6.68 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Veal Parmigiana with Garlic and Oil Linguini
- Chocolate Lava Cake with Vanilla Ice Cream
- Basket of Hot Garlic Rolls
- Mozzarella Tomato & Pesto
“I have been going to Il Capuccino since it opened, with bring your own wine and red and white plastic tablecloths. Loved it then and love it now. A superior experience!!! ❤️”
Menu Order
Wine Bar · $$
9 Alpina

4.5 Superb 151 Reviews

45 Front Street, Greenport · 1.28 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- House Made Swiss Sausage
- Cacio E Pepper Agnolotti
- Classic Wiener Schnitzel
- Chartreuse Soufflé
“Shared the duck and veal entrees which were both phenomenal. The duck was nice and crispy on the outside and perfectly medium in the middle. Fatty, fresh, delicious. The veal was chopped and mixed in with mushrooms in a delicious creamy sauce. That dish came with what is basically a German pasta on the side. We put the pasta in with the sauce so it would soak up all the flavor. Didn’t leave anything left on either plate. Will visit again next year when I’m on vacation”
Menu Order
Pizza · $$
10 Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant

4.4 Superb 116 Reviews

1271 Noyack Road, Southampton · 8.95 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Seared Local Calamari
- Meatball Sliders
- Eggplant Sliders
- Arugula
“Pellegrino‘s is some of the finest Italian food on the East End. It also is a cool place to hang out with a casual vibe with no pretense.. as a local realtor when people ask me, what’s a great restaurant in the north sea area Pellegrino is always the first to come to mind. Great food fantastic service a small, but vibrant bar area or what you’ll find here. They make a great pizza. I cannot recommend this place more highly. Stop in for a bite you will not be disappointed.”
Menu Order
American · $$$$
11 Vine Street Café

4.3 Superb 417 Reviews

41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island · 2.11 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Hot Bread Fresh Out of the Oven
- Spicy Tuna Tartare Tacos
- Crispy Calamari Salad
- Lobster Bouillabaisse
“Excellent food and wonderful service! The staff goes above and beyond and is extremely attentive to their patrons. The food was delicious. We cannot wait to go back!!”
Menu Order
Italian · $$
12 Michelangelo Southold

3.9 Good 212 Reviews

53345 Main Road, Southold · 4.11 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Cheese Slice Pizza
- Eggplant Parmesan
- Chicken Parmigiana
- Chicken Piccata
“The food is excellent and the pizza is even better. There once a week. You will be pleased.”
Menu Order
Pizza · $
13 Roma Pizzeria

3.9 Good 124 Reviews

31455 Main Road, Cutchogue · 7.93 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza
- Pepperoni Pizza Pie
- Marinara Sauce
- Cheese Pizza
“Born in New York and grew up in Huntington. This is my First time at Romas and visiting mom from Virginia, my son has never been to any authentic New York pizza joints. So when we tried Roma’s, he had the Sicilian and he told the owner “it’s the best pizza he ever ate”. Coincidentally the owner knows Tony from our local pizza place in Virginia. Real glad we got up for some real New York pizza before leaving to go home in little ol’ Virginia.”
Menu Order
Pizza · $$
14 Sag Pizza

3.7 Good 293 Reviews

103 Main Street, Sag Harbor · 6.55 miles
- Take-Out
- Delivery
Customers’ favorites
- San Marzano Pizza and 2 Garlic Knots
- Sag Harbor Slice of Pizza
- Tomato & Cheese Pizza
- Summer Squash Pizza
“I ordered an Arugula and avocado that barely has avocado with very dried/dead leaf that I m not even sure if it is an arugula. Simply horrible. Will never come back again and won t recommended.”
Menu Order

Italian Restaurants Nearby

You May Also Like

All articles

September 19, 2024

Una Pizza Napoletana Pizzeria Named Best in the World for 2024

Una Pizza Napoletana, a popular spot in New York, has just been named the best pizza in the world by the 2024 Italian 50 Top Pizza ranking. This is a major victory for owner Anthony Mangieri, who has already earned the title of best pizza in the U.S. for three years in a row.
July 12, 2024

Italian Pizza Chain Rosso Pomodoro Makes Its American Debut in Denver

Naples-born Rosso Pomodoro has landed in Denver. The Italian pizza franchise just opened its first U.S. location in the city's Central Park neighborhood at 29th Ave Town Center. "It has long been a dream to introduce our brand of authentic Neapolitan-style pizza to every corner of America,” CEO Nicola Saraceno shared his excitement.
June 26, 2024

100-Year-Old Pizzeria Seeks New Owner, Bans Pineapple

Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana, a 100-year-old Coney Island eatery, is looking for a buyer or partner to keep its legacy alive, but it has one important condition. Totonno's has made it through fires, floods, and even COVID, but there's one thing they'll never tolerate: pineapple on their pizza.