18 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shelter Island

Shelter Island Slice Pizza • $
3 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch with Marinara Sauce
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

“Totally worth the trip! Best pizza ever. So great to see Frankie and his team“

4.6 Superb43 Reviews
Pellegrino's Pizza Bar & Restaurant Pizza • $$
1271 Noyack Rd, Southampton - 8.15 miles

Customers` Favorites

Seared Local Calamari
Arugula
Pizza

“Good food, friendly spot, big fan. Been coming here for years. Here's my 1 suggestion: for the takeout ...why not offer online ordering? I have to call for take-out, which usually results in the line being busy (in the summer). If I can't get through I have to go elsewhere, which stinks because I live close by. Then, if I do get through, have to provide my credit card info, which is very 2006. Maybe ownership simply doesn't need the takeout biz and prefers it this way, and that's fine, but remains frustrating nonetheless. Just my .02 cents.“

4.6 Superb36 Reviews
Brick Oven La Capricciosa Pizza Pizza • $$
135 3rd St #24, Greenport - 2.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pasta Con Chicken & Broccoli
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Italian Chicken Noodle
SM Chicken Parmigiana
Meatball Parmigiana
Caesar Salad Large
Mac&Cheese Pizza
lg Cheese Pizza
Pasta Primavera
Fried Calamari

“Everything is delicious at this restaurant and you get generous portions too.“

4.5 Superb47 Reviews
La Capannina Pizza • $
364 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott - 9.56 miles

Customers` Favorites

My Favorite Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Eggplant Pizza
Margarita Pie
Fried Calamari
Chicken Parm

“great staff and great food. The Chicken Franchaise is delicious“

4.5 Superb43 Reviews
Pineneck Pizza Pizza Takeaway • $$
3360 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor - 5.11 miles

“Great pizza! Love the Buffalo chicken pie!“

4.6 Superb25 Reviews
American Pie Pizza Delivery • $
2044 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton - 9.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Parmigiana Hero
Meatball Lasagna Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Garlic Knot Sliders
Pepperoni Stromboli
Grilled Chicken
Grandma Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Brooklyn Pie
Clams Casino

“My husband and I shared the buffalo chicken slice, regular slice and the grandma.
Let me start with the buffalo slice. It was piled high with chicken. Everybite was a pieces of chicken with just the right amount of buffalo sauce. I would recommend it.
The regular slice was very good. The crust was flavorful. The cheese was quality and the sauce like mama use to make
The Grandma was fantastic. Thin and crispy right amont of cheese with nice tomato flavor.
If you are in the area go here.

Parking: Located in a strip mall there is plenty of parking. Including handicap parking close by.

Kid-friendliness: Tables, bar seating and booths make this child seating fun. They have all kinds of drinks: waters, sodas, and juice. What kids doesn't like pizza.

Wheelchair accessibility: The space is small but wheelchair accessible. Bathroom is definitely large enough for a wheelchair.“

4.4 Superb49 Reviews
1943 Pizza Bar Pizza • $$
308 D, Main St, Greenport - 2.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

White Pie with Mozzarella & Garlic Added Caramelized Onions
Caesar Salad with Crispy Croutons & Shaved Parmesan
Nonna Lucille’S Wood Fired Meatballs
Goat Cheese Stuffed Piquillo Peppers
Classic Margarita Pizza
House Margarita Pizza
Spicy Fennel Sausage
Prosciutto Pizza
Mozzarella Pizza
Meatball Pizza

“Had lunch here last Thursday! Our server James was terrific! The pizza was great!
My nickname is Bobbie Pizza & my girlfriend Susie slice gave it a 4.8 pepperoni's out of 5 on our pepperoni rating scale for pizza! We have been to over 100+ pizzerias/restaurants over the last eight years! 1943 is definitely a must place to eat if you're in town!
???“

3.8 Good110 Reviews
Brix & Rye Cocktail Bar • $$
308A Main St, Greenport - 2.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Italian Scallion Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza

“So fun. Such a great vibe.“

4.9 Superb30 Reviews
Roma Pizzeria Pizza • $
31455 Main Rd, Cutchogue - 8.18 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Pie
Marinara Sauce
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Salad

“Born in New York and grew up in Huntington. This is my First time at Romas and visiting mom from Virginia, my son has never been to any authentic New York pizza joints. So when we tried Roma’s, he had the Sicilian and he told the owner “it’s the best pizza he ever ate”. Coincidentally the owner knows Tony from our local pizza place in Virginia. Real glad we got up for some real New York pizza before leaving to go home in little ol’ Virginia.“

3.7 Good45 Reviews
The Pizza Place Pizza • $
2123 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton - 9.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Caldo de Gallina

“1 word CLEAN .FOOD IS SUPER SUPER GOOD.“

3.4 Good21 Reviews
Sophie's Seafood • $$
730 Main Bayview Rd, Southold - 5.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Marinated Strip Steak with Steamed Vegetables and Mahesh Potatoes
Baked Seafood
Pretzel

“I want to rate this 3 stars out of 5. The food is amazing but customer service not that great. My family was in from out of state and wanted to get take out and I instantly thought about this place. my fiance got the food and came home and my order was missing the cheese on the burger. So, I unfortunately couldn't eat with my family and neither did my fiance because he had to eat his food while driving 20 minutes back to get my food fixed at the restaurant and then 20 minutes back. However, I would still recommend you guys to other people. I would just suggest checking your order before leaving“

4.3 Superb56 Reviews
Sag Pizza Pizza • $$
103 Main St, Sag Harbor - 5.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

San Marzano Pizza and 2 Garlic Knots
Sag Harbor Slice of Pizza
Tomato & Cheese Pizza
Summer Squash Pizza
Chopped Arthur Ave
Margherita Pizza
Neapolitan Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Truffle Pizza
Arugula Salad

“I ordered an Arugula and avocado that barely has avocado with very dried/dead leaf that I m not even sure if it is an arugula. Simply horrible. Will never come back again and won t recommended.“

3.7 Good111 Reviews
Harbor Market & Kitchen Pizza • $
184 Division St, Sag Harbor - 5.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fish Tacos

“My sister and I had the best brownie yesterday we purchased at Harbor Market and Kitchen! They were moist fudgey, chocolatey perfection. ❤️“

3.4 Good33 Reviews
Rolling In Dough Pizza Caterers • $$
308 Main St, Greenport - 2.71 miles

“Love love love the food is always amazing the staff is great 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕“

3.8 Good14 Reviews
Southold General Cafe • $
54180 Main Rd, Southold - 4.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich Display
Quiche

“The first time I tried the pretzel croissant I became addicted! All of their croissants are amazing... Their coffee is awesome too! So glad it opened in Southold. Lately, they've been making the pretzel croissants into egg sandwich which I'm sure is delicious too, but I prefer to ask for it alone :) Whoever is making these croissants, thank you Chef!!!!“

3.9 Good45 Reviews
Michelangelo Southold Italian • $$
53345 Main Rd, Southold - 4.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Slice Pizza
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Piccata
Pepperoni Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Fried Calamari
Eggplant Pizza
Grandma Pizza
Garlic Knots

“The food is excellent and the pizza is even better. There once a week. You will be pleased.“

3.8 Good61 Reviews
17

Isola

Isola Italian • $$$
15 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights - 1.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Olives and Flatbread
Chicken Parmigiana
Oysters Rockefeller
Pasta Bolognese

“Kayla and I had an amazing dinner Steak night. Kayla's steak was out of this world delicious. I had the Swordfish which was tasty and delicious. Thank you Brad for treating us like family. We will be back again soon.“

3.7 Good32 Reviews
Porcos Country Deli and Pizza Deli • $
926 Noyack Rd, Southampton - 8.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tuscan Half & Half Ultra Pasteurized
Submarine Sandwich
Grilled Chicken
Chicken Fajitas
Chicken Cutlet
Southampton
Turkey

“Walkable from Southampton Shores. Good stopping point em route to Sag Harbor or North Haven/Shelter Island.“

3.4 Good31 Reviews

You May Also Like