20 Best Ice Cream Shops near Shirley

“Carvel is classic. A nice, busy Carvel on William Floyd, on your way to the beach. They have all the basics Carvel has to offer. A nice staff and a clean Carvel. Nowhere to sit though. It's a take out and eat in your car Carvel, as usual.“

“We visit the Shirley store regularly (maybe too regularly 😜) and are always greeted by the lovely staff who are very quick and flawless with taking orders. I would give five stars if they didn't run out of the popular flavors so quickly.“

“Great waitress! Food made very good. Things were clean ! Waitress brought extra napkins and was on top of everything with out being asked ! She was also helpful and patient with us! She explained things clearly to us on how to get the app. because she recognized us from us getting ice cream cakes several times before!
The ice cream cakes great gifts that others truly appreciate! We especially love the chocolate crunch ice cream cake! Makes a big impression!
We dine in and take out!“

“First time visiting a Sonic. Ordered a featured burger, fries, pretzel w/cheese and a cookie dough, brownie blast. The burger was decent. Adding their sauce upped the burger's palatabiity. The star here was the pretzel sticks. Warm, a hint of salt paired well with the slightly spicy queso dip. The dessert blast was underwhelming. Cookie dough & brownie bites tasted stale & generic. Their was a decent wait for my food. Customer Service was exceptional.“

“Unique and fun experience! Delicious ice cream and friendly workers! Will definitely be back!! Coram location“

“just went for the first time, and it definatly won't be the last! owner was nice and ice cream was all amazing!“

“Perfect ice cream every time. Must give it a try please.“

“We went for the 1st time last night!! What a great place with friendly service. The ice cream was delicious and it was fun to watch them make it !! We will definitely be back :)“

“Simply cannot believe the negative reviews…I have been going here for years and I’m pleased with every experience. Probably upwards of 25-30 times since it’s been open.

Complaints about the prices? You control how much frozen yogurt and toppings go in your cup! It’s weighed! How about you take…less? Like, what?!

The owner is always lovely and efficient and the place is spotless. They seem to take so much pride in keeping it clean.

Will continue to patron this establishment and I absolutely recommend it.“

“Bernadette is not only a wonderful person that works extremely hard at her business but she provides absolutely the best ice cream on Long Island“

“Delicious breakfast, I really enjoyed it.“

“A clean Carvel in a busy shopping 🛒🛍️ center. May I suggest putting a couple tables with chairs. Up front by the entrance and exit doors. You certainly have the room for it. Also offer soda 🥤 as well my daughter's and I would love to sit and relax in this Carvel. 🍨 🍦.“

“I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream! And Carla Marla’s hears you! Delicious ice cream, hand scooped and some candy and many toppings there too. Cool off, slow down and enjoy some ice cream, all sizes and with whip cream, if you like!“

“I have been going to the Middle Island Carvel for many years. The store is always clean, staff friendly and professional.
Last week I ordered my son’s birthday cake. It was perfect! Not only did it look great, it was delicious. The ice cream was fresh, the “crunchies” were crunchy. The fudge topping was awesome.
Don’t buy Carvel in a supermarket. There is no comparison.“

“I love Anthony’s Pizza. Always my go-to. Friendly and delicious every time!“

“Food was great. Kind of disappointed that I wasn't offered a refill to go when I asked for a to go box for my food. Guess the waitress was super busy.“

“so yummy!!! so yummy!!!!!“

“What a nice place. We come here very often and the employees are always pleasant and helpful, especially Jennifer. They're in a great location at the East Wind Shoppes... go have fun and stop in here. I highly recommend it“