48 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shirley

“Food is amazing! You can have a little of everything which is a major plus for my family!“

“We came with a bus full of school brownies. We called ahead and they were very accommodating and the girls loved the pizza. The staff are awesome. We will definitely come again“

“We had the Tex Mex truck at a work event. it was awesome! everything was delicious service was fast and organized. highly recommend this food truck for your next event.“

“Just got my pizza for my family , all the employees were nice ,service is great . Feel bad for the store , someone called order combo , after few minutes, she called back cancelled, but the pizza already in the oven . They given that pizza for free !“

“Great friendly staff and delicious food“

“Great 🥑“

“Good pizza that is ready fast! Wings are awesome too“

“The go to spot.... always the best!!!“

“We love going here- the owner is so friendly and they have great prices. The store is beautiful, they have amazing bagels, pizza, hero’s- and they have free delivery!!

Kid-friendliness: There are little tables you can sit down and eat with your family and watch tv“

“Nino's Pizzeria is more than just a place to grab a slice; it's a cornerstone of our community. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with the comforting aroma of freshly baked dough and simmering tomato sauce, a scent that instantly feels like home. But it's not just the delicious food that keeps me coming back. It's the warm, welcoming atmosphere, the friendly faces behind the counter, and the sense of connection that makes Nino's a truly special place.“

“Thank you for the spinach pinwheels, garlic knots, pepperoni knots, and vegetables with sausages. Your hospitality were great.“

“My husband and I love La Volpe! For a casual dinner in the pizzeria, a quick bite at the bar, or a romantic dinner in the dining room- we always have a delicious meal and wonderful service. We highly recommend this place for authentic Italian cuisine! It’s one of our favorite restaurants. 😊🤍“

“Great place with great staff. I recommend!“

“We had a catered party yesterday, with several recommendations to use Tony's Pizza. The food was delivered and set up for us. It was piping hot, had very generous portions, and most importantly delicious! Luigi was super friendly at the pizzeria, and great to work with for the follow-up. Thank you guys, for helping my son's 21st birthday be a huge success! The Sitler Family.“

“The pizza is always fresh and the owner Giovanni is a class act highly recommend“

“Amazing food, good presentation & great service! Thanks guys :) Tonight we had the Rustic fresh mozzarella and fresh tomatoes great balsamic sauce!!!!“

“Just had some amazing slices! 2 Grandma slices, 1 Chicken Marsala slice and 1 regular. Great taste and crust was cooked perfectly. Definitely recommend“

“Awesome pizza! Friendly staff, quick service, affordable and delicious! Tony's Wife“

“The BEST pizza in the world!“

“Absolutely delicious 🤤 was given a sample of the chicken bacon ranch today(they just gave me as a bonus 😍) it was really perfect. I also picked up some other special slices and they are just as good. All the staff is above and beyond polite and such a beautiful team. We always feel welcome and full. They are fast and have great pizza!“

“The service was great, Pizza was terrific & I’m looking forward to checking out their restaurant soon. Looks exactly how a nice NY Italian restaurant should look. !!“

“I enjoyed the grandma pizza—it had just the right balance of flavors that made it stand out. Unfortunately, the other slices I tried didn’t quite measure up to the same standard, leaving me a bit underwhelmed. Despite this, I’m still considering coming back because the service was genuinely attentive and friendly“

“Meatballs-tasted almost identical to when my Italian, childhood best friend’s grandma would slow simmer them ALL day long every Sunday!! The grilled chicken in the Greek salad was very moist and soft. Loved their 6 slice pizza too-great cheese and perfect amount of sauce that’s way less acidic than other local pizza, maybe partially because they use less sauce. Staff were very kind too. Highly recommend.“

“Visiting from South Carolina to celebrate my daughter‘s, sweet 16 and Bella Roma welcome our party of 20 to celebrate!! Their food and service was absolutely amazing!! Gabriella has got to be the best server we have ever had! Top notch service and hospitality!!she took care of our every need with a smile the entire time!! Thank you Bella Roma we will be back!!“

“I live local and my daughter's went there to have a slice for lunch and said we had to try it and we did and order at least once a week from them great food and beautifully decorated“

“My friend and I got gluten free pizza and it tasted great! There was a complication with my order and they called me and communicated and we came to a solution. When there was a an issue with delivery, instead of canceling my order they spent 15 minutes on the phone with me trying to find my address. Very kind people and great food!“

“BEST WINGS (simplest way to put it) Discovered them out East and now they're in Islip. Anthony's wings will ruin everybody else's. Crispy without being greasy and sauces are A+++. Go there.“

“ordered for the first time tonight , we got the pizza,pasta,mozzarella sticks, and salad daily special for $39.95, everything was delicious , and the delivery driver was nice , we will definitely be ordering again“

“I got to say this place is amazing. The buffalo chicken pizza was really good and the philly steak was awesome. This is my new pizza place“

“Best Sicilian slice around“

“Love his pizza like old school !! Crust is perfect ! Order every week … we tried a lot of places and crust around the corner is #1“

“Been going to Joel's bagels forever! Rolando and family are such beautiful people, warm, welcoming, and funny. I moved to patchogue some years back and began the hunt for a good bagel spot. I walked in and couldn't believe how friendly everyone was. Instantly it became my #1 go-to. The food is tasty and the people treat you like family. Now I'm a few towns over and worth the trip back each and every time!“

“pizza is great. Crust is super. eggplant chicken dishes are terrific. owners are there and extra friendly! Catering is super. very good catering menu available“

“Was out east today and stopped at Brezza for lunch. Pizza was very good and staff was friendly. found a new place to eat when in Wading River. Will be back for sure!“

“This is a wonderful place. We always get delicious food from them. The owner is very nice and professional. We are so glad to have a place that is so close to get great food from. Definitely give them a try and support a local family.“

“The owners are great. Very pleasant to deal with. I've been going there since they bought it about 22 yrs ago. Their dinners are very good, you can't go wrong with the penne ala vodka and a side of sausage. Love the antipasti, garlic knots are to die for. The neopolitan and Sicilian pies are great. Love the sauce they make for the dinners and pies. The only complaint I have is that they go light on the pizza toppings. I'd like to see more sausage, pepperoni, etc on the pies, not a few slices sprinkled about. Now I'm thinking about pizza. Maybe tonight.“

“We celebrated my son’s 3rd birthday and my daughter’s 4th birthday yesterday, and James was our host. WOW is all I can say! He was incredibly sweet, attentive, and nonstop the entire party. He was honest, suggested wonderful ideas, and checked in on both the kids and me throughout the entire event. He had a smile on his face the whole time, was professionally dressed, and truly went above and beyond. He made the party absolutely wonderful and unforgettable.

If you’re having a party there, request James—he truly makes all the difference.

Our party was at 11:00 a.m. right when they opened, so everything was spotless, and the food was boiling hot.

The only negative I’ll mention is that the doors opened at 10:45. We arrived at 10:30 because we were told we’d have 30 minutes to set up, which ended up not being the case and caused us to rush a bit. That said, it was our only complaint, and overall the experience was fantastic.“

“The food here is quite good. The portions are big. Customer service is quite mixed. Some of the staff are exceptional,others are not. Offer a wide range of delivery options ranging from their free in house drivers,slice,Uber,door dash or grub hub.“

“Pennachio’s in Manorville is the best. Best food, best service, best background ambiance. I’ve been there several times, over the last few years, and am delighted inspired and amazed every time. World class Eggplant Parmesan. Ridiculous Veal Franchese, Insane cannoli. If you are on your way to or from the Hamptons, it’s totally worth the detour on Route 111.“

“Excellent food and staff was awesome!“

“My family and I love this restaurant the food is amazing the service is great very clean We get all the catering food for any occasion from this restaurant We are placing the catering order for our Christmas party from this restaurant Carlos Pizza in Manorville“

“The best!! Freshest salad shrimp cheese all goodies mixed in!“

“The pizza is soooo good and crunchy ,not dry .. I love this pizza place 😊it’s worth the drive“

“My wife and I went in to give this place a try and were very pleasantly surprised. The service was very good, the restaurant is neat and clean. The FOOD is exceptional. We have been back a few times and we are always trying different meals with the same result… absolutely delicious.“

“The best Italian around from the best family in the business! It was so nice to dine here again after quite some time and it was even better than I remembered!“

“I ate pizza, bread sticks, and cinnabon bites until I almost puked. No joke, this is the best fast food franchise pizza around. Not sure why Dominoes and Papa John's get more love when Pizza Hut clearly has better and tastier food. Prices are reasonable too. I actually go out of my way to this Medford/Patchogue location bc they closed the Centereach restaurant years ago. Please Pizza Hut, open a location in the Selden/Centereach area bc Papa's John's just doesn't cut it.“

“Great food n better staff“