50 Best American Restaurants near Sloatsburg

“Food is fresh and presented wonderfully. A little on the high priced side. The price matches the ambiance though. You have to plan to spend when you go but will enjoy the experience completely.“

“Love Rhode's, always sit at the Bar, the Bartenders are great, always smiling and they hustle to provide drinks for the entire place and with the Bar & rest of the seating on the 1st floor and seating outside those Bartenders/Ladies never let ur Beer 🍺 run out, yes the have alot of Beer to choose from..... Food is always great. Go on the website, when they have a live band at night it's really a great night..... So if were riding or out with the GF in the Truck, Rhode's gets my vote.... 👍 💜“

“Sunrise Family Restaurant is hands down one of my favorite places to eat! I’ve been going there for a while now and it never disappoints. I like to call it a hidden treasure in the neighborhood. The minute you walk in, you feel like part of the family — the staff is so warm, welcoming, and truly wonderful. The menu is HUGE, the food is always delicious, and the prices are more than fair. If you’re looking for a new go-to spot, this is it! Do yourself a favor and stop in — you’ll feel right at home and leave with a full belly and a big smile!“

“We threw a drop-in Buffet dinner for family and friends at Houlihans for 30 to 35 people. The room is spacious and accommodated everyone comfortably. Our server Eileen was excellent and the food was delicious. Michelle who assisted with the catering was very detail oriented and help me plan a great event. Sebastian the manager as extremely gracious and helped ensure our guests were taken care of. I would definitely do it again and highly recommend..“

“Great place. Food and service are awesome .“

“You going to get a consistent meal at the Lantern. I usually will order ahead and pick up through the drive through. Today, we ate in, and can I just say the staff was amazing. Queen DD was so sweet and the gentleman whose name I forgot to ask, but assume is management of some sort, was SO KIND. Absolutely fantastic experience with them today. Thank you so much for your patience and kindness towards us! Yall made my little girl’s day with that itty bitty ice cream cone.“

“Great place with excellent food and service.“

“:Absolutely love The Grill in Greenwood Lake! The father-daughter team running the place couldn't be friendlier or more welcoming. The food is always delicious and consistently good, and the prices are just right. Highly recommend stopping by for a great meal!“

“Excellent family restaurant and sports bar. One of our go-to spots to bring the kids for a great meal at a great price.“

“Take out is absolutely amazing!“

“We hosted a surprise 60th birthday party this past weekend and it couldn’t have been more perfect. From the first call to set it up to the moment we walked out the door, the staff made sure it was such a great experience. The people who work there are so attentive and kind. The managers Bryan and Kelly were so helpful in planning our party and Ivan is a rockstar. He took care of our party of 20 and made sure we had everything we needed. We never had to look for him, he was always checking on us and providing excellent service. He truly is so great at what he does. We had a sit down lunch in their cottage room which was so nicely decorated. the space was perfect. We felt like we were in our own restaurant. It was cozy but spacious and they were so accommodating with how we wanted it set up. We were able to bring balloons and decorations and the staff even helped us set up. They had a curtain up in the doorway so we were able to really surprise the guest of honor. Our lunch was delicious. We chose to do the seated option with 3 shareable apps and we picked a menu of 4 main meals from their party menu. Most of us ordered the shepherds pie and it was some of the best we had ever had. The presentation was cute. It came in a skillet which was served on a board with Irish soda bread. It was so delicious. The show stopper was the shareable Irish egg rolls. We couldn’t stop talking about them. The drinks were really good and the bar staff was really attentive to the party. The kids ordered from the long kids menu and they really enjoyed theirs as well. The pricing was very reasonable and worth every penny. We were able to bring our own cake and they cut it up and served it for us which was so nice. I can’t thank them enough for how special they made this experience. Everyone in our party had such an amazing time. The staff here are incredible. I would absolutely consider them for your next party.“

“My Hoagie was excellent ❤️“

“Patrick and his staff were amazing, as always. His daughters work with him and assist in Ensuring everything is running smoothly. Patrick does his very best never to lose a customer. I have noticed this on many many occasions, he is gracious and although a group may have walking on a Saturday pm @ 7 demanding a table, Patrick always manages to keep everyone happy and satisfy everyone's requests. It is an art and very obvious he has been in the hospitality industry, in management levels for quite some time. He is an asset to F&O, and all of Upper Saddle River patrons or those that have been to F@O speak so highly of Patrick, and enjoys being there on days they know he is working. He keeps a tight eye on tables and guests and ensures people are well taken care of.“

“CHECK THIS PLACE OUT!!! MY WIFE AND I CELEBRATED MY 30TH BIRTHDAY HERE AND WE VERY MUCH ENJOYED!! DEFINITELY RECOMMEND“

“Was here recently and had a wonderful experience! Jessica, our bartender, recommended a delicious margarita flatbread “pepped up” and it did not disappoint! She also convinced me to try the Pumpking beer for dessert and that was a delicious surprise! We will definitely be back on Mondays and/or Fridays to see Jessica and try more of her recommendations! She made us feel so welcomed and the service was top tier!“

“From start to finish we had an amazing meal. The service is impeccable and the food is delicious and imaginative. Beautiful ambiance too.We have had a perfect dinner every time we have been here and can't wait to come back!“

“I lived in Waldwick for many, many years and one thing i miss is going to Bagel Nosh. I worked in NYC and would pick up bagels to bring in for corporate functions. The staff and owner are fantastic! The bagels are the best! I have even flown back to NJ, gotten a car and drove to Bagel Nosh just so i could fly back to my new state with Bagel Nosh Bagels. The bagels are the best!“

“Just my favorite place , until I move there I will drive 1 and a 1/2 for them“

“Absolutely amazing. Julia was our waitress and she was very attentive but not overbearing like others can be. She knew when to come and check on us and when we just wanted to be. Food was as always, delicious.“

“Taco Tuesday is real real tasty , I love the pork and the shrimp tacos. the burgers are delicious , they cook them just the way you like them , onion rings yum yum , Thursdays is prime rib night … cooked to perfection, different sides to choose from , I always get the baked potatoe and the salad it comes with … is real good also , ya gotta try it. Oh I forgot Greg is a great bartender.“

“Great burger and fries great server definitely coming back with the girls“

“The staff and food were absolutely amazing!“

“So good! We have been in construction for the last 9 months. All of which was supposed to take 4 month. We haven't been able to cook and Moms Kitchen has been our go to for quite a few nights. Gave us our home cooked meals when we couldn't handle fast food or take out. We can recommend enough and will for sure be our staple for future dinners.“

“Great dogs. And friendly too Support this business!“

“I had the Yucca Pizza wow it was delicious!!! I 10/10 recommend!!!“

“+Food is amazing! The gyro platter filled with tender meat, moist rice, fresh salad, warmed pita, delicious tzatziki sauce and enough for 2 meals- if you're average weight woman anyway! The owners are super friendly, accomdating and generous- got there earlier than expected for pick-up and they gave me free hummus for waiting when it was my fault for coming ahead of time!! What??!! We'll be back for sure! Gotta support great local eateries like this!!“

“Great food, great location, owner and family are extremely friendly. I highly recommend it for all.“

“😋 We eat at this restaurant whenever we travel from VA. to RI. Every meal is delicious! Everyone is friendly. We love this place!😎“

“Great carribean food like nowhere else, and the host of a great Wednesday jam that’s been going on for over 20 years.“

“The atmosphere is awesome! The food was soooo good!!! What made it even more amazing was our server Briana!!! I couldn’t decide what to try and she recommended the spicy buffalo chix sandwich with sweet potato fries! She was on point with that recommendation!! I’m a foodie so definitely coming back!!“

“We chose to have a small wedding at Tree Tavern! We planned for months as we loved the set up of the outside. We came and tried food and drinks, and every person we encountered were extremely nice and helpful. They helped us every step of the way. The options we had for the food was amazing. We got to customize it to how we wanted and then pick a very nice drink package. The pricing was outstanding. They helped with the set up and take down of the wedding and honestly helped us with every little detail. We couldn’t have asked for a better wedding day or a better venue for our special day. If we could do it over again we wouldn’t change a thing. Thank you to Mike, the wonderful owner. Joyce who helped us plan everything and Vicky who helped us pick out all our drinks. Tree Tavern is a place we will come to again and again. The atmosphere is beautiful and the people are great. They helped make our wedding day magical. This place is definitely deserves more than 5 stars!“

“A Great night at the Cove Castle last night. My girlfriend and I attended the History of Greenwood Lake event at the Cove and it was very enjoyable. Bob, Andrea, Chuck and the entire crew made the experience exceptional. The setting and view of the lake from the second floor dinning room was beautiful. The food was delicious and the presentation was excellent. Drinks were large and reasonably priced. In Bob's 5 years at the Cove Castle he has transformed the place into a fine place to dine, drink and enjoy top notch entertainment. Can't wait to return to "The place to go" on Greenwood Lake.“

“Great place to watch the game. Plenty of TVs and they have the NFL package. They even put up the out-of-town game for us with sound.

Vegetarian options: Fried Zucchini Sticks, Vegan Vegetable Doumplings, Veggie Tacos, salads, grilled cheese“

“I love everything about this place! The food is outstanding and the staff are amazing! Shout out to Christa, who is the soul of the place, and Cory, who goes above and beyond (crayons & paper for my little one). The cafe is a second home to me :-)“

“The Philly Cheesesteak is the best! Good price for the amount of food you get!Breakfast is ok typical diner type food. I'm not a fan of eggs so the options are more limited for me to pancakes, waffles, etc. so we usually do lunch instead.They are open for dinner now during the week but post the specials on Instagram. They used to have a website and it no longer works, I really wish they would fix it because in this day and age usually if you don't have a website you don't last long as a business.“

“This is my favorite place for great home-cooked food! Everything they make us top drawer and the staff is always attentive, warm and welcoming! It's everything you could ask for! Always looking for a reason to go back here and relax...“

“They now have computers in their hands with gets the food to you faster“

“Stumbled upon this gem and haven't looked back, since before covid, during covid and to this day! My favorite pub, I recommend all, never disappoints! Love the ambiance, love all the wait staff especially Theresa, feels like a visit with a friend! We go all seasons but especially love the deck in warmer weather! GO, you won't regret it!“

“Best pizza for last 30 years! Comfortable, Friendly. Always a favorite!“

“We came her from out of town with unsure expectations. We were pleasantly surprised. Not only was the food delicious, but the atmosphere was comfortable and enjoyable. Lindsey, our bartender and server was pleasant, attentive and friendly. Would definitely recommend.“

“I had a great weekend at the Marriott Park Ridge decided to stop by the pub for dirty martini(DELICIOUS ! LOVE THE EXTRA JUICY OLIVES) but the one thing I will say is the salads are super super super fresh. Everything had flavor. I loved the salad dressing. (Also thanks for the extra extra feta cheese like I asked.??) the shrimp here was delicious grilled to perfection the shaved Parmesan cheese *chefs kiss * thank you for adding onto my weekend. I will be back ordering the same meal lol!!

Dietary restrictions: Pescatarian“

“Javier Martinez is such an excellent waiter. Perfect timing for each course, tremendously charismatic n kind. He gave us such great service! The food is absolutely amazing too! Everything Ive ever eaten here has been very flavorful, cooked perfectly and extremely fresh. All of the staff do a really great job. -“

“The best chicken pot pies in New Jersey and New York.The food is quality and large portions.The staff is friendly and accommodating. The other thing is the price for what you get is incredible.“

“I work in Montvale, NJ and I hear wonderful things about this place. During my lunch hour, I placed an order over the phone and spoke with Emily who was attentive, accommodating and was able to get my custom order perfect. Upon picking up, ammon greeted me quickly and confirmed my order right away. The vegetarian sandwich was amazing and Emily suggested I add the roasted peppers in lieu of the cromini mushrooms. It was amazing and I will be ordering from here again.“

“Food was delicious. Customer service very polite and all wore masks and complied to covid 19 rules. am stuffed😊“

“I just want to say thank you so much, to my server Rachel for providing such a great experience for me and my husband. Great customer service, super attentive made sure we was good at all time. I would definitely recommend this place to my friends and family. Thank you Rachel you rock!“

“Food was absolutely delicious. The prosciutto flat bread pizza was perfect and had an abundant amount of arugula. Also had a daily special skillet of shiitake mushrooms, grilled chicken, poached eggs & feta that was to die for! Definitely try this gem.“

“Everything you’d want in a BBQ joint and Bar. This is the best BBQ I’ve had anywhere in the Northeast and I think it just became my new favorite Restaurant in New York! It’s seriously that good! I highly recommend going on Wednesday night for 75¢ wings but also don’t forget to get the Duck Fat Mashed Potatoes, Sweet Corn Brûlée and Beer Cheese Macaroni! Oh yeah and their Brisket and Ribs are also absolutely incredible. Go and go often so you don’t miss out on their deliciously creative specials like Pork Belly Lollipops!“

“I'm impressed! It was easy and pretty quick and the girl running the register was kind and patient and walked us through the menu like a pro. We waited at some of the tables and admired the To-Go lockers that make it really easy to order ahead and pick things up. They have a TV for sports and another TV to show you the upcoming orders. I like that because you know they haven't forgotten about you! They also have a reward program with points and stuff. We brought our wings home and loved them. They pack them in great boxes with air holes and clear tops so you can see what everything is and they gave us plenty of napkins and wipes. The wings travelled very well and were great! The fries weren't the best, but maybe they don't travel as well. We will definitely be back to try some of the other food on the menu too!“