28 Best Seafood Restaurants near Webster

“Castaways on the Lake was fantastic from start to finish! We started with the Coconut Shrimp appetizer, which was perfectly crispy and packed with flavor. We also tried the Beach Dragon, and it was absolutely delicious with just the right combination of flavors.
For dinner, the crab legs were a standout—sweet, tender, and cooked perfectly. The Shore Platter was equally impressive, offering a generous variety of fresh seafood that was prepared beautifully and full of flavor. Every dish arrived hot, fresh, and presented with care.
The highlight of the night was the homemade Key Lime Pie. The creamy, tangy filling paired perfectly with the buttery crust, making it one of the best desserts we've had in a long time. Great food, wonderful service, and beautiful lake views make Castaways on the Lake a must-visit. We can't wait to come back!“

“I’ll preface this by saying that I’ve had garbage plates from Dogtown & Nick’s (the OG). I got a half-plate, which was still a huge portion weighing probably four pounds, with mac’n’homefries and cheeseburger topped with the cinnamon (mild but tasty) meat sauce and “a little bit” of onions, mustard, and ketchup. This was BY FAR the most delicious garbage plate I’ve ever had. I will ABSOLUTELY be coming back here. And it’s less than a 10-minute, quick’n’easy drive from Rochester General Hospital (so skip the Wolfgang Puck despite the convenience). I will add that the young woman who took my order was kind and friendly. The meal “to-go” was ready in less than 4 minutes. And the food was delicious, not at all greasy—literally PERFECT“

“Happy Cinco de Mayo!
I didn't eat, just popped in for a quick, tall frosty beer. they have these ice cold clay mugs which are really fun. The chips and salsa were delicious. Very friendly staff. I had a nice visit.
I will definitely be back for a hearty meal soon.“

“I highly recommend the Tuscan seafood pasta, it had plenty of crab, lobster, scallops, clams and mussels. Fantastic!!“

“BANANA PUDDING = ORGASMIC Wish I could eat that everyday of my life seriously. Everything we get from saucey is always banging but that pudding though 🤤👀“

“celebrated my sisters 30th, the food was incredible. i plan to return asap for valentines day! I highly highly recommend“

“The atmosphere was was great. Our waitress Bella( at the Rochester one) was amazing. Very knowledgeable and friendly sling with our hostess and other table help. Was a great experience. The only thing I was disappointed in ( which wasn’t any of these peoples doing) was my porterhouse steak. For the money, it should have been a nice cut. It was an end cut, one that even some stores don’t use…let alone a very upscale restaurant. It was also supposed to be med rare n was med. I didn’t send it back because st least it was pink, but it was well past med rare. My crab cake was very good. The lobster and crab mac and cheese was also very good. I’d definitely recommend and go back. Just not sure if I’d get the porterhouse again. Probably go with just the filet.“

“Fantastic food as always!! Duck was cooked perfectly!“

“Went right at opening and the owner and staff were taste testing dishes for the evening. It was great to see how much the owner and staff cared about the food.. Lily was the server and she was knowledgeable on the wine and food selection. I noticed they do allow bringing your own wine if that interests you. The oysters came predressed, which I didn't like at first but changed my mind once I ate, just don't put lemon on the vinegar dressed ones! Mussels were awesome, could've drank the broth. Octopus was actually a pasta dish served in a red sauce, doesn't say this on the menu, I only ordered because I saw the staff sample it. The clams looked amazing but was unfortunately too full to try. All in all great experience and will be back!“

“We went to this wonderful restaurant today for the first time, and it was unbelievably great! The man who waited on us answered all of our questions, the environment is warm and inviting, the service was the best ever, service was great, and we were not hurried in any way. Prices are reasonable and the quantity of food is spot on for hungry people. And of course, don't forget the desserts. There is a whole case of desserts to choose, and they were DELICIOUS. We will definitely go back and go back again and again.“

“Brought my daughter for the first time and she loved it!“

“Приготовтесь что места для маневра на грузовике мало.Парковаться на док нужно будет с дороги.Supervisor очень приветливый человек.Он организовал погрузку за 45 минут.Грузят вручную(Translated by Google)Get ready that there is not enough room for maneuver on the truck.You will need to park on the dock from the road.Supervisor is a very friendly person.He arranged the loading in 45 minutes.Loaded manually“

“Clean bar rest and food was straight fire. highly recommend.“

“great food and service we will be returning“

“Amazing service and lovely atmosphere. Steaks were awesome and perfectly cooked. One lobster tail was a little overcooked, the other one was cooked perfectly. Would definitely recommend and will be going back“

“Our first time here and we will be back. This was one of the best restaurant experiences we have ever had. Thank you for the delicious meal, hospitality and the lovely environment. 🤍“

“Dinner tonight was fabulous. Fresh, great quality. I had the French dip, which I honestly must say between the beef, bread, couldn’t be better! I had the homemade mashed as a side. Excellent! The garden side salad was perfect combination of vegetables nicely prepared. My guest ordered the cottage pie all I can say is wow and it was also said to be very delicious and beautifully done. I haven’t been in some years it was pleasant to be back. The bar drinks looked amazing as well! You can’t be disappointed here! Our server Hailey was friendly and provided great service. A big thank you for not changing All these years and keeping it amazing as it always has been!“

“Been our weekend staple for breakfast for years! Staff is friendly, fun and always attentive! Comfortable and welcoming. Never disappointed!“

“Went for a cozy couples date night. Just what we wanted. Great small plates and paninis. For us the paninis were a meal. Fantastic cocktails and wine selection. The service was informative. attentive, conversational and not obtrusive. We'll be back, with friends!“

“Celebrated my mother's 100 birthday there with 31 people in Family Style Dine In Dinner. It was Perfect, everyone and I mean everyone enjoyed the meal. My mother cried. Thank You Donna Perlo and your wonderful ❤️ staff.“

“Delicious! My wife and I were checking out the menu during the Canal Days when the owner stepped out and introduced himself. He was great to talk to and suggested we try the special. She had the special (turkey BLT wrap) and I had the beef on wick. Food was delicious and the service was top-notch in our book.
We will definitely be stopping in on our next visit to Fairport :)“

“Oh my God, I forgot to write a review! Tony put on the most amazing ice breaker for our class of ‘75. Excellent food, drinks & service. One of the best experiences I’ve ever had! I’d give them 6 stars if I could. 😘🤩🥳👍🤜🏾🤛🏻✊🏽🙏“

“The best fish fry’s/ baked fish dinners available in roc city. Best staff and ownership you could ask for. Always fresh!!“

“The atmosphere and food is so good. Excellent service and wonderful dining experience all around.“

“Absolutely fantastic food, service, quality and the photos on the wall are a whole lifetime! It’s wonderful! ♥️💕“

“Great service (I think Frank was our server), excellent food, fantastic cocktails. Highly recommend the chefs table if you’re on a date. It’s a little show to watch while there. If it’s still on the menu get the tuna crudo, it was the best bite of the night!“

“The staff was amazing! Tim and Alana went above and beyond! Highly recommend!“

“Several of us old guys rotate a monthly dinner. Tonight six of us dined at Porterhouse. Service was on point. Shawna was great. We order family style and pass plates around. Apps we had were Artichoke French, arancini and pot stickers. All fantastic. Entrees were salmon, strip steak and braised spareribs. Sides of mashed potatoes, root veggies and a great rice. Three bottles of red. Five after dinner drinks. $100 per person including tip. All six plan on returning. Highly recommended.“