45 Best Bakeries near West Islip

“Great long distance experience! Needed a sympathy delivery but didn't want to use the "usual' online method. I'm from NYC, now live in Tampa, but still like to use local when possible. Found these guys on google maps and called. The girl in catering (wish I can remember name) was awesome. She nailed it! My Babylon friends were greatly surprised with the basket and it's ingredients! Price was right, no higher than any 1-800 company and the quality was fantastic! I hope this email is seen by owner/mgmt and commends the gal that helped me! Oh, and only gave 4 stars since it's only been one phone call/order and I've never entered the place. If I am ever in NY again (doubtful) I'd make them a stop!“

“Once I tried crumbl while away I've been hooked. Been to this location 2x and safe to say I'm addicted! It smells amazing when you walk in! You can order on the app for pick up. Cookies are always fresh and the workers are friendly.“

“Absolutely incredible! Everything is perfect from here! I would say the Linzers are top tier! The Linzers are just perfect surpringly light with great jelly. You would expect a lot of these desserts to be very heavy but they actually are not crazy. Everything is just flavored perfectly you would thing a brownie crammed with a rainbow cookie would be very rich surprisingly it was just right. They really hit it out of the park with everything. My only wish is that you could get smaller portions of the regular cookies I didn't feel like shelling oit $20 for a pound while I was already trying all this other stuff. Maybe a half pound option or make like an uncut brick of tricolor cookies.“

“Got my baby shower deserts here. I asked my friend to pick them all up. We went to the shop in person before ordering. Ambiance is nice very cute but I wish they have a restroom. Service is good but to order for my party, I had to contact them thru instagram. All the food items I got were great. I also ordered some customized baby shower themed cookies which are $4.50 each.“

“Amazing experience here! Ordered a cake last minute for our engagement photos… Wanted something vintagey and sweet. They went above and beyond and it looked PERFECT and tasted just as good! The staff were SO nice and accommodating. The shop is beautiful and clean. I will 100% be back for future events. Honest people that do great work. I HIGHLY recommend them!“

“An unfortunately overlooked gem right in the middle of deer park. Charming, cozy, and straight up delicious, this cafe has the right stuff to give the cafe chains a run for their money.Immediately upon walking in, my partner and I were greeted warmly, as they insisted we try their award winning gelato. The wide spread of homemade unique flavors made deciding a difficult but happy struggle. The fresh espresso coffee and pastries were simply delightful.Should our stomachs be allowed, we would have eaten everything. We look forward to returning and trying something new.“

“One of the reviews used "cute and cozy" already. Spot on. If you haven't seen it decorated for Christmas please go today. The baked goods look and taste amazing. The coffee was so fresh and flavorful. It is a hidden gem of main street. Sneak around the corner for a coffee and treat on your next walk. Bring the kids to see the decorations. Absolutely love this shop.“

“Best. Pie. Ever. Go. Now. Me and my boyfriend just stopped in because we were curious and found the most charming little seating area and outdoor garden with a delicious menu. We tried the pulled pork pie pocket (insane + must try) and the mini pies which are truly the perfect size. they have such a variety of everyday staples that are made right in their own farm behind the back. GO NOW.“

“Finally got to stop here today. And let me say…What a treat!!! Taking something classic like a “whoopie pie” and just re-inventing it so damn well!! Moist Cake, creamy delicious filling, not over filled and hard to eat either.! Service was great and fast. It’s just a walk up window with the list of flavors. And as we were leaving with our order more and more people were lining up. Can’t wait to try the other flavors!!!Pictured : funfetti, choc peanut butter and cookies n cream!“

“Everything tastes homemade, fresh and absolutely delicious! Every single item I have tried did not disappoint, nothing is over sweetened or commercialized. They definitely use quality ingredients. P. S. The cookie trays last for weeks! Best bakery! I’d give them 100 stars if it were an option.⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Really cool! Lots of options and is open super late. Went in at 9 pm and they had so many options even late at night. This is the only barley I know open until midnight or late. Got the chocolate dipped cheesecake, good quality cheesecake, I do wish the chocolate it was dipped became more of a shell but it was super good and rich.“

“absolutely love this bakery! in the last two weeks alone i have purchased 2 speciality cakes from them- both perfect and delicious!! i showed vic a photo of what i wanted for both events and she truly brought my vision to life. i couldn’t have been happier and they were so delicious!!“

“We recently used Philly Pretzel Factory in Smithtown for a school event and ordered 750 pretzels from Craig. They were all individually wrapped and ready to serve. They were absolutely delicious and everyone loved them! I will definitely continue to buy pretzels from this location. The owner was easy to work with, prompt with communication, and super friendly. He even checked in with us during the day to see if we needed anything. Thanks Craig! Wishing you and your family the very best in your new endeavor here at Philly Pretzel Factory!“

“I am a cake decorator, as a hobby. When I can't make my own design, I have always looked for a bakery that could make what I see ... Whisk not only makes delicious, moist cakes but they are absolutely stunning and priced right. I just bought my second cake from them. One in March and went back and ordered again in April. We couldn't have been happier.“

“I have always thought that Cookies by Design was something special— mostly because they tasted as good as they looked. I was so happy that the delivery went smoothly because it was being delivered to a business— absolutely perfection!! Will definitely do this again! Thank you!“

“I don’t get to come here often but when I do, it is always such a delight. The bakery is clean and the staff always so kind and gracious. One of the few places you will find the sort of almond croissant you desire. Parking is small so careful with how you enter/exit. If you have not yet stopped into this bakery, it is small but mighty! Definitely recommend.“

“Too often we only comment when we have a complaint to make or if we are not happy with a service.I am going to change that pattern and let Stew Leonard's know about how happy I am with the customer service department in the Farmingdale location.In particular, Nadine has impressed me with her knowledge of the store polices, locations of items, and overall helpfulness she exhibits.Kudos to the store and Nadine.Arthur Langer“

“I like the products they make, they are fresh and good ? but I have a suggestion regarding the employees since as it is a public business, there are different people from different parts of the world with different customs, for example in my country, tell them love, my life, mommy ect for us it is not correct, I in particular do not like that, whoever accepts it is their problem, I hope that they as employees understand my opinion and my customs are respected, thank you“

“Very impressed! I said that 3 times inside the store, so that is saying much. First time in a Lidl and very happy with their fruit, bakery and overall prices. They also carry brand names so there are a lot of choices. Crazy how we got a whole Butterball Turkey for $13 total! I liked Lidl better than Aldi and we'll be back :)“

“They are absolutely amazing, family owned for years their cannoli’s are superb, all of their stuff are unbelievable, I would travel to the end of the earth for all their desserts. Happy Thanksgiving to you & family always…I’m“

“We were riding down Broadway in Amityville on our way to another eatery, looked to the left and saw the sign: THE CHEESECAKE STOP. We decided to swing in on our way back. We glad we did.Ada, the only one there when we arrived, said the recipes are her mother's.We decided on the PEACH SWIRL and the HOT CHOCOLATE flavors.We can taste the chocolate and the peach. Very smooth. Velvety.I got the single serve. My friend girl got the mini.There are plenty of menu choices.And there are seats inside and outside the eatery.“

“Immediately! Immediately I walked in and loved the atmosphere. I could tell right away it was Colombian. Very nice gentleman at the counter. I just didn't catch his name. Very friendly and welcoming.The place looked so nice. 100% I'm going back and possibly regularly. Looking forward to trying other menu items. ??“

“We got our wedding cake from Angela and it was AMAZING!! I would highly recommend getting a cake from her for any occasion. We ordered some tasting cupcakes to determine which flavor combo to go with and it was so hard to choose - the flavor and texture of her cakes are outstanding! Lots of compliments and questions where we ordered it from from our guests. Also, Angela was so helpful and easy to work with.“

“It's 530 close at 6. Short old lady is all bad attitude to customers. Plus, she wants to share it with younger girls. We not gonna get outta here until 7. Yak yak boo hoo..do us all a favor stay home play with the cat. Instead of ruining what has always been a pleasant experience.“

“Had an issue At the Melville store , with one item the manager was terrific. No questions asked was able to replace what I brought in and it was on Easter when they were very busy. They were pleasant kind and I Will always shop at uncle Giuseppe‘s.“

“this is my absolute favorite place to get macarons. jessica is such a gem, she informed me about all the flavors and was super sweet and even offered to sign me up for rewards for future purchases. great place & will definitely be returning!!“

“I came to the bakery on Easter Sunday early in the morning after going by a local bakery and seeing a huge line. I remembered someone recommending this bakery so I drove up the road and decided to stop by and give them a try. My first impression of the well decorated simple and the cakes and desserts really stood out. They even had a section for dog treats that were made for the pups. The customer service was exceptional. The young lady who helped me with my pretty large order considering I was going to two Easter festivities and was in charge of dessert was beyond helpful very patient and very welcoming. When I arrived, of course I took time looking at the cakes and desserts that they had to offer and I was unable to make a choice. I finally did make a choice and decided on the bunny cake, which is white or vanilla cake with chocolate and buttercream, and I also got a rainbow cookie cake, which was phenomenal not dry, it was delicious I also got the assortment of Italian pastry, platters with cannoli Napoleons and tarts, and those were delicious as well. I got a small box of cookies which were good as well as a box of assorted donuts, and linzor tart. I wish I would've taken pictures of everything that I purchased, but unfortunately I didn't. I must say everything that I tried. I had a small sampling at the different events. I went to that day and I must say I was not disappointed at all by anything that I purchased, the lobster tail was delicious. It was right amount of crunch. It was not soggy and the inside was just perfectly sweetened. I would recommend recommend and have been recommending this bakery to everyone I come across. I must say it's way better than it competitor which is down the road, but it's also a little slightly more expensive but like I've told everyone I rather pay a little more for gracious service a pleasant experience and a great product. Kudos I think I have my regular bakery and I hope to try other delicious treats from here very soon.“

“This was my second visit to this adorable shop. The displays are always filled with delightful treats and an amazing variety. Last time, we sampled one of each of their macarons. Perfection. From the feet on the macarons to the light but flavorful fillings, we knew we had to return for more treats. This visit the macaron shelf was filled with small individual cakes. We could not resist. We tried the carrot cake and red velvet cakes and I opted for a black and white cookie as well. Service was fast and the ladies at this shop are very amicable. I appreciate and value good service and this location is top notch. The store is clean and they have a drink station also. We will most definitely be coming back again. I just have to try the spritz cookies. I would like to perhaps get an assortment to try one of each.“

“Great little greek bakery. They also have packaged items from Greece and frozen foods. I took my 90 year old mother there, and the 2 women working in the store were super friendly and helpful. We found many items that aren't readily available in most stores. The baked goods were excellent, we bought baklava, galatobureko, spanakopita and tiropita. I recommend all of them. Again, the women working there were very friendly and helpful, beautiful on the outside and on the inside. My mother was very happy that we stopped at this place. Thank you for a great experience.“

“I live in Florida and was recently talking to my brother how you can’t get good crumb cake here. Entenmans is garbage and he told me about Brooklyn delight. I placed an order for four crumb cakes cakes and 12 muffins. Needed to try the crumb cake, Could not wait until the morning.I will say I’m New York City born and raised and have gotten great product from local bakeries for many years while living up there. This crumb cake is the very best I have ever had, haven’t tried the muffins yet but I’m hoping they be as good. Can’t get a good corn muffin down here so I’ll keeping my fingers crossed. I was concerned about the packaging and shipping. They did an absolutely great job. No damage to the product at all.“

“I recently went to lunch here with my boyfriend and we had Cherry as our server. SHE IS THE ABSOLUTE BEST!!! Super attentive, friendly, down to earth, and so sweet. One of the best servers I've ever had. Her food recommendations were also on point. We will definitely be back, and will be requesting her every time we come!“

“We made it back to Long Island after 6 years. So much has changed but not Cieslak's Modern Bakery. It has been our favorite for years and still is the best. Everything from their rolls, breads, cakes, donuts and other goodies are absolute delicious. All of their goods are super fresh and baked to perfection and the cakes are pretty as a picture. We had to put in an order for our return to Texas including our daughters favorites. We left with 3 boxes full of goodies. Crumb buns, raisin buns, and bear claws. We would've ordered more but there was no place to put it. Buttered rolls for our trip to the airport. One of our carry ons was our package from Cieslak's. Everything was fresh when we arrived in Texas and was demolished within 2 days. Thanks, Eileen and team! Cieslak's is a wonderful family owned business!“

“Europian way to make pastries, bread and cookies. Amazing taste of chocolate and fruits cakes. We took three different cakes to try and all three were good. One of them was legendary “drunk sour cherry” with cherries soaked in cognac and thick layer of chocolate on a top. Such a great combination! The second was with the layer of raspberries in jelly. Mild and slightly sour taste of raspberries makes you think that it’s still summer outside. The third one was plain soft cake with whipped cream and mix of berries and fruits: kiwi, blackberries, oranges, raspberries, strawberries and grapes. You will love it. Believe me. Delicious cake! We didn’t stop on cakes and took two different loaves of bread. One with seeds and the other one with onions and olives. It smells and tastes like authentic Italian bread. I was really excited to find this bakery on my trip to Long Island. The staff is very friendly and helpful. They give you chance to taste a piece of bread to figure out if you want it. My best recommendations to everyone who is looking for sweets and a good quality of bread.“

“Recently celebrated my daughter’s birthday with a custom cake. Being a Taylor Swift fan, she insisted on a Taylor Swift them and Cake Don did not disappoint. The cake was beyond my imagination. I would highly recommend Cake Don for custom cakes!“

“This is my go to deli, everything is delicious and fresh. I've been going here for over 10 years and the food never disappoints. From breakfast to lunch, you can't go wrong! Sam the owner is very friendly and accommodating. Highly recommended!“

“(Translated by Google) Good place but the new workers don't last long because the colleagues are envious and put new wings in bad shape so they don't last long(Original)Buen lugar pero las trabajadoras nuevas no duran mucho porque las compañeras son envidiosas y ponen en mal alas nuevas por eso no duran mucho“

“Awesome place. The interior is beautiful and smells great. Overall great interior, staff was very friendly, cookies were great!The inside is a bit small, but the general area is a bit tight.There are 2 tables for 2, when we went there was 2 available when we came about 2pm, and when we left 1 was taken.Great place all around!Wheelchair accessibility: Ground level, no stairs, ramp up the curb. Inside is small, but available“

“I was in search of a Colombian bakery and this one is excellent! I'm not an expert but I highly recommend the empanadas and the almojabana. Both were freshly made when I went in the morning. The almojabana was just perfection: crispy on the outside but soft and so cheesy on the inside. The empanadas were super tasty too: packed filling of potato and meat. The sweet pastries (got pineapple and guava) were standard but not as amazing as the savory goods.“

“THE BEST bagels ever. On Long Island and in New York. I’m not qualified to make that statement but from my personal opinion it’s the absolute best. I’m a local to the area and have been going here for years and recommend it to family and friends from out of town. It’s a great family run business as well.The bagels are soft and chewy, a perfect combo and the cream cheese is smooth and delicious. They put a good amount on there as well.Whenever we are back in town we always grab a bagel here. Highly recommend!“

“Here from out of town, happened to be within walking distance and glad I was! Authentic Salvadorian pupusas, yummy pan dulces. It was busy with Spanish-speaking patrons so I took that to be a good sign. If you don't speak Spanish, it would be helpful to know what you want going in. Don't bother with all the fast food in the area, this is fast and real, and good!“

“Got two cakes for my wedding, one tiered cake, and a small gluten free cake (since I have a gluten allergy). They were SOOOO DELICIOUS! I haven’t found a gluten free cake this good, like ever! Will 100% be ordering a gluten free cake from Campbell’s again! Thank you for making my wedding day so incredibly sweet, Campbell’s bakery!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free.“

“We ordered a heart shaped red velvet cake for our small get together because we got married and everyone loved it! It was moist and flavorful. Nikkie is so sweet. We will DEFINITELY 100% be ordering from her again! She gained a forever customer!“

“(Translated by Google) The best Colombian bakery in Brentwood!Good service, clean, tables for lunch.! Clean bathrooms, easy parking.!They sell everything, coffee. Fritters, stuffed potato, salpicon. Bonus Bread! Etc.!(Original)La mejor bakery colombiana de Brentwood.!Buen servicio, limpio, Mesitas para almorzar.! Baños limpios, fácil parqueo.!Venden de todo, café. Buñuelos, papa rellena, salpicón. Pan de Bono.! Etc.!“

“Hahns is the perfect morning stop for a fresh loaf of bread and pastries. It is also a good location for specialty requests or an afternoon snack. The entryway is accessible, clean and welcoming. The staff are friendly and kind, They suggested the crumb cake ,and pound cake and oh my! Outta this world.. traditional with yummy crumbs Worth every penny spent when i left here. They have an organized set-up and display of the most popular products. Costs are comparable with local Giuseppe's marketplace and other upscale bakeries in the area. A must try for a treat especially on holidays ! Order early.“

“Ordered a few items from Rio Dulce on Father's Day. The staff is super friendly and helpful. The food was packed well for my takeout order. The portions are generous, priced well. The good is very tasty. The Sopes and taquitos are made well and have great flavor. We will definately be ordering again!“