50 Best Mexican Restaurants near West Islip

“So authentic and great service! The worry dolls were an added bonus as I was there with my daughter. Perfect birthday, love the philanthropy also! Guacamole was the best I’ve ever had.“

“This place has quickly become one of our go-to spots. The food is seriously worth every penny. Everything tastes fresh, full of flavor, and the portions are solid. My boyfriend is from California and he’s pretty picky about Mexican food, but he says this is the closest he’s had to back home. That alone says a lot.

It’s the kind of spot you try once and then it just becomes part of your regular rotation. Definitely recommend if you’re craving something satisfying and legit.“

“Was in with my daughter for dinner and just wanted to say we had the BEST experience! First time dining at Rocco’s Tacos and couldn’t have had a better experience. Our server, Erica, was phenomenal! Service and food was outstanding! LOVED the guacamole she made and she was sweet as can be and we took her advice on everything to order - her recommendations were great and we left full and very happy! We will definitely be coming back soon!!“

“This restaurant exceeded all of my expectations! The tacos were hands down some of the best I’ve ever had, and the drinks were just as amazing. Everything was packed with flavor and absolutely worth trying.

My only minor complaint was the wait time for both the food and drinks, but honestly, once everything arrived, it was completely worth it. The quality more than made up for the delay.

I would 100% come back and highly recommend it to anyone looking for incredible tacos and great drinks! 🌮🍹🙌“

“This is my first time ordering food from Fat Boys Burrito for my meetings (grilled chicken burritos, bang ban shrimp tacos, guacamole & chips). Their food is absolutely delicious. The variety of dishes offered, quality service and presentation is exceptional! I will definitely be ordering again. Thanks Tony and team!“

“At first glance you see this taco truck but when you notice that the line is long it could only mean that the food is delicious and it was waiting about 7-10 min but they give you a pager so you can wait in your car or outside they do have seats to eat or wait right there at the location will be going back soon“

“excelente servicio...la comida riquísima....ambiente muy cálido...buena música. en fin todo es excelente“

“Right Coast Taqueria provided our lunch for our Teacher Appreciation week in Smithtown. The faculty raved about the food and presentation!! They accommodated food allergies. Great business to work with!!“

“Never disappoints Great portions and staff Love the music and the atmosphere food comes out fast and hot love the decorations in the place overall a great experience“

“the food was good, but they need a better air filter system the smell of burning isn't appealing while you eat. the place was clean, the servers were great. it was just another version of taco bell mixed with chipotle. but this is just my VYI's keeping it real view,we enjoyed the bowls, plenty of food in each. we will go back next month to try their salad.“

“This is our go-to restaurant, what a gem. Delicious food, super friendly people, and Juan makes the best margaritas that I have ever had! We highly recommend this spot, make sure you try one of their specials.“

“Best mexican grill on long island. Food is delicious, prices are fair, portions are perfect and staff is fast and pleasant. If you're craving filling and satisfying mexican food don't even THINK about going anywhere else. I heard about it from a friend and I just got my family hooked on it too, my siblings are going with their partners later this week to introduce it to them too.“

“This place is absolutely amazing!!!!! Jim the manager was such a nice guy and made me feel so welcomed. The food is absolutely delicious!!!!!! 10/10 recommend! The store is very clean and professional! All employees here deserve a pat on the back for making this experience so perfect! Thanks again!!“

“Restaurante familiar, Rica comida 🌮“

“WOW
THIS RESTAURANT WAS SO CLEAN! THE STAFF WAS SUPER FRIENDLY & AS ALWAYS THE FOOD WAS FRESH. CLEARLY THE BEST IN IT'S CLASS COMPARED WITH CHIPOTLE & OTHERS OF THAT ILK! WAY TO GO LOVE HAVING MORE OF THESE TOI GET MY FIX“

“tonight, 6/6/26,we went for dinner at Mesita in Amityville, NY, Everything was perfect for a great dining experience. We were greeted by friendly smiling faces at the door and shown to our table straight away. We were then met by our waitress Myra, who promptly showed us a list of specials and a drink list.I had a glass of their red Sangria and my wife had one of the custom drinks, both excellent, Our meals came, both huge and more than enough for 2 meals for each of us, and I will say both meals were awesome.Please visit this awesome establishment that brings you back in time to a very authentic Mexican experience, you wont be sorry“

“Amazing food great service“

“Food was absolutely delicious. Everything was hot and fresh. It’s the true authentic flavors that will make you crave this place time and time again. The staff were super friendly and you can taste the care as well as passion they put into their food. It’s a 1000 out of 10! So so so so good.“

“The tacos, the nachos, the burritos, the quesadillas, this is the place you never knew you needed!! By the way they have more yummy choices, I just haven’t gotten through them yet!!“

“Love it there always a good time“

“awesome menu items great service“

“Nice place and attendants“

“Picked up lunch and it was delish!!! Thank you!!! Queso is fantastic!“

“great food and strong drinks !! love this place“

“Decided to try the mobile drive-thru pickup line for the first time, and it couldn’t have been easier. My order was ready exactly when it said it would be, the pickup process was quick and seamless, and everything was fresh and made perfectly. It’s so convenient to grab your food without even leaving your car. Great food, great service, and an amazing experience every time!“

“Some of their food is not the same and I noticed that it’s on certain days when they have the younger ones working in the kitchen. They need to have quality control when the more experienced cooks are not working..“

“I love this place. The food is so Fresh and Delicious and most importantly consistent. The owner and staff are very accommodating and there are plenty of Veg. Options.“

“Great local restaurant with a ton of options on the menu. The food was unanimously amazing, the service was pleasant, and the restaurant was clean and comfortable. My wife and I split the Bandeja Paisa platter and it was so much food we had a full serving left over to bring home. My toddler’s cheese quesadilla was delicious. Looking forwards to eating here again soon!“

“Today I came to visit and have a quick bite! The burger was phenomenal! And what made the burger even better was the outstanding service from Thomas! His energy and attentiveness makes me want to come back! I live in Huntington but would come back just for the service alone! Thank you Peter Pan for a great early dinner!“

“This place is great for authentic Mexican food. I ordered a chorizo taco and Cubana sandwich. My friend ordered a couple tacos and and a tostada. (See photos)On a Sunday afternoon it was very busy, which I didn't really expect, but I took it as a good sign. My friend that took me there has been there several times, it is currently her favourite taco spot ??“

“Great food. Centereach location is where I go frequently. Staff is great.“

“I cannot believe I lived in west Babylon for 7 years and only tried this place 2 years ago. I passed by so many times. The food is fantastic and my wife and I keep going back for more. Try the burbon chicken with anything. It’s not a dine in place, so just take out and I promise you will be back. Food is affordable and I highly recommend their taco salad that’s served in a crunchy bowl…. Or their nachos!“

“I was looking for a authentic Mexican cuisine it not always an easy place that I like and I don’t usually like a place but they proved to be authentic Mexican grill restaurant I’ll be back once more for some more delicious food 🥘 yuuuuum“

“this was my second time there and enjoyed the food and the strawberry margarita. Their guacamole is the best ever! The lady's room was very bright and clean. The manager Manuel was gracious and pleasant. Looking forward to going there again“

“Son ricas las Tortas y los tacos 🌮, se los recomiendo 😋😋😋“

“Exelente Servicio y deliciosa comida.!! Recomendado el 💯. Bendiciones.!“

“A Hidden Gem in Huntington Station!
La Hacienda is more than just a restaurant – it’s a full experience. The food is absolutely delicious, with rich, authentic Latin flavors that make you feel at home. We tried the tacos, wings, and quesadillas during Happy Hour and everything was top-notch. The tamarind margarita? Next level! 🍹🔥

The vibe is lively and welcoming during the day, and at night it transforms into a full-on party with DJs, great music, and amazing energy. The bartenders are friendly, professional, and truly add to the atmosphere.

We also love that they offer affordable lunch specials and even have a deli takeout option for busy days. Whether you’re coming to eat, celebrate, or dance the night away, La Hacienda is the place to be.
Highly recommended – this spot never disappoints!“

“Nachos are loaded and delicious!“

“The tacos are amazing the empanadas delicious i have taste everything in the menu i give it two thumps up“

“The chef Francisco is a fine chef and his food tastes great. I have eaten here about 5xs already and he never disappoints. I highly recommend the tacos 🌮. I have also eaten the skirt steak which was delicious. He has a very nice presentation on all dishes. They also have fresh baked breads and the waitresses are all very nice and friendly. The dining area is nice and there is music playing and sometimes live entertainment. I want to try every dish on the menu. The restaurant has the potential to be a real gold mine because the food is definitely on point.“

“The food here is amazing, like actually some of the best tacos I’ve ever had. Just be warned that the online ordering system on their website is not connected in store, they will not receive your order and you will have to re-order in store. Also none of the employees speak English, but that’s pretty expected for anywhere with authentic delicious Mexican food!“

“Checked them out today. I tried the steak taco...it was absolutely delicious ! Staff was friendly, restaurant is clean everything's was fresh . Definitely worth checking out“

“This is my favorite Qdoba. They always have fresh and filled toppings. Everyone's extremely nice and always seems like they're in a good mood.

I'm nobody special and rarely leave reviews. However my recent visit was because Uber Eats stole my delivery order...and my tip. Was still craving Qdoba and decided to drive there.

I happened to mention the experience to another customer in line, and the Manager stopped everything she was doing to ask me who the driver was, so she could ban him. They also really went out of their way to make it right even though I didn't ask for it. Thank you for your display of absolute kindness. In a world of dying customer service and forced tipping; If you're going to give anybody your money, it's this place.“

“On every visit, the staff has been attentive and friendly and, on some occasions, have gone above and beyond to accommodate. I stopped by to take advantage of a promotion they were running for their 1 year anniversary, I had driven by several times on this day, and they had lines out the door each time, when I finally stopped in to take advantage, the staff was still friendly despite having been run ragged all day. Kudos to the team for enduring what was surely an exhausting day! Keep up the good work, team!“

“Omg spicy mayo on a burrito? Yes!! Everything’s great, steak is the best anywhere. Good portion and prices Accommodating and very nice staff What can I say. I eat here 2-3 times a week Ask for the spicy shrimp!!“

“Such lovely service! My first time coming here last night. I was in the mood for a burrito and I most certainly picked the right spot! It was clean and the service was impeccable! I ordered the all American burrito and it was so delicious and the steak was so tender. They even gave us a complimentary empanada which was so delicious. When I go back I will definitely be ordering a bunch of those. Thank you for a lovely experience, amazing customer service and food :)“

“Los recomiendo asen rica comida“

“Amazing Deli! Food is delicious and staff is welcoming and friendly. Definitely will be going back!!“

“Excellent food and an even better experience thanks to our waiter, Yadhier. He was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was perfect throughout our meal. The food was delicious, and his outstanding service made the visit even more enjoyable. Highly recommended!“