50 Best Mexican Restaurants near West Islip

“So authentic and great service! The worry dolls were an added bonus as I was there with my daughter. Perfect birthday, love the philanthropy also! Guacamole was the best I’ve ever had.“

“This place has quickly become one of our go-to spots. The food is seriously worth every penny. Everything tastes fresh, full of flavor, and the portions are solid. My boyfriend is from California and he’s pretty picky about Mexican food, but he says this is the closest he’s had to back home. That alone says a lot.

It’s the kind of spot you try once and then it just becomes part of your regular rotation. Definitely recommend if you’re craving something satisfying and legit.“

“I ordered from this place thinking it would be a one-time thing, and I was definitely wrong. This spot has, by far, the best tacos, bowls, Nachos and burritos I’ve ever tasted. Everything was packed with care, and the service was fast and friendly when I went to pay.
They do not have a place to sit and eat since it's a food truck not sure if they do in the summer time

Tip: Paying cash is cheaper than using a credit card since the card fees are added to your order. They do take Mastercard visa and Amex“

“Go here immediately. Rocco’s is one of our favorite restaurants!! The food is beyond good we’ve been to every location in Florida and this is our 4th time to this location!! Thank god they opened in NY!!! I’m celiac and they truly take such good care of me everytime we come. Our waitress Sam is literally the best and so personable. We came here when they first opened to celebrate my birthday and since then, we ask for her everytime we come in!! If you’re gluten free, get the wings they’re the best I’ve ever had. Tastes even better when the service is great. I’m in the restaurant industry as well so having a great server truly makes the experience 10x better.“

“This is my first time ordering food from Fat Boys Burrito for my meetings (grilled chicken burritos, bang ban shrimp tacos, guacamole & chips). Their food is absolutely delicious. The variety of dishes offered, quality service and presentation is exceptional! I will definitely be ordering again. Thanks Tony and team!“

“First time dining here and overall a really solid experience. The food was enjoyable — the lemon orzo soup was comforting, the lamb gyro taco had great flavor, and the chicken kebab skewers was cooked well. Drinks were a standout, especially the dirty raspberry martini, which was excellent.

The vibe is casual and relaxed. There were a couple small service hiccups, but nothing that took away from the meal. Overall, we enjoyed it and would definitely come back again.“

“Right Coast Taqueria provided our lunch for our Teacher Appreciation week in Smithtown. The faculty raved about the food and presentation!! They accommodated food allergies. Great business to work with!!“

“excelente servicio...la comida riquísima....ambiente muy cálido...buena música. en fin todo es excelente“

“awesome menu items great service“

“the food was good, but they need a better air filter system the smell of burning isn't appealing while you eat. the place was clean, the servers were great. it was just another version of taco bell mixed with chipotle. but this is just my VYI's keeping it real view,we enjoyed the bowls, plenty of food in each. we will go back next month to try their salad.“

“Never disappoints Great portions and staff Love the music and the atmosphere food comes out fast and hot love the decorations in the place overall a great experience“

“This is our go-to restaurant, what a gem. Delicious food, super friendly people, and Juan makes the best margaritas that I have ever had! We highly recommend this spot, make sure you try one of their specials.“

“This place is absolutely amazing!!!!! Jim the manager was such a nice guy and made me feel so welcomed. The food is absolutely delicious!!!!!! 10/10 recommend! The store is very clean and professional! All employees here deserve a pat on the back for making this experience so perfect! Thanks again!!“

“What an awesome restaurant! Have been dying to try the new Mesita in Amityville. The decor is so beautiful inside, love the high ceilings and lighting. Went for a special birthday dinner and had a wonderful time. The food, margarita flight and service were all outstanding! Such a fun atmosphere, perfect for a romantic dinner or girls night out. Cannot wait to go back.“

“I found this after my midnight workout driving down DPA coming home from the gym. Little pricey(but what isnt) but all in all, the food was down right delicious. Then a week later, I got a craving for it again. Mix and match what you want in the wraps or bowl, LIttle of this , little of that, put that sauce here on the side. The hot salsa has a kick.“

“Love it there always a good time“

“Restaurante familiar, Rica comida 🌮“

“Amazing food great service“

“Hands down the best authentic Mexican food in the area! The staff is so kind and helpful, and they deliver!! I don’t live around the area but I work in Lindenhurst and I’ve struggled to find authentic Mexican food and I am so glad I found this place!“

“I love this place. The food is so Fresh and Delicious and most importantly consistent. The owner and staff are very accommodating and there are plenty of Veg. Options.“

“Picked up lunch and it was delish!!! Thank you!!! Queso is fantastic!“

“Some of their food is not the same and I noticed that it’s on certain days when they have the younger ones working in the kitchen. They need to have quality control when the more experienced cooks are not working..“

“The tacos, the nachos, the burritos, the quesadillas, this is the place you never knew you needed!! By the way they have more yummy choices, I just haven’t gotten through them yet!!“

“Every time I go to this restaurant, I am greeted warmly by staff that are genuinely happy. The food is always perfect and delicious and prepared the way I like it. The restaurant is always clean and the food is always fresh. I am looking forward to my next visit.“

“Great local restaurant with a ton of options on the menu. The food was unanimously amazing, the service was pleasant, and the restaurant was clean and comfortable. My wife and I split the Bandeja Paisa platter and it was so much food we had a full serving left over to bring home. My toddler’s cheese quesadilla was delicious. Looking forwards to eating here again soon!“

“This place is great for authentic Mexican food. I ordered a chorizo taco and Cubana sandwich. My friend ordered a couple tacos and and a tostada. (See photos)On a Sunday afternoon it was very busy, which I didn't really expect, but I took it as a good sign. My friend that took me there has been there several times, it is currently her favourite taco spot ??“

“I cannot believe I lived in west Babylon for 7 years and only tried this place 2 years ago. I passed by so many times. The food is fantastic and my wife and I keep going back for more. Try the burbon chicken with anything. It’s not a dine in place, so just take out and I promise you will be back. Food is affordable and I highly recommend their taco salad that’s served in a crunchy bowl…. Or their nachos!“

“great food and strong drinks !! love this place“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
We hired Cochinita Porky Food Truck for our annual neighborhood Halloween parade and block party, and they did an amazing job! The service was fast, the food was made to order, super fresh, and everyone loved it. The kids especially enjoyed the playful pig-themed truck with its glowing LED eyes — such a fun touch! 🐷✨
I highly recommend them for any private event — delicious food, great people, and an awesome vibe!“

“this was my second time there and enjoyed the food and the strawberry margarita. Their guacamole is the best ever! The lady's room was very bright and clean. The manager Manuel was gracious and pleasant. Looking forward to going there again“

“Great food. Centereach location is where I go frequently. Staff is great.“

“The employees should find another place to store their aprons. It's crazy how they would interrupt our lunch and make us stand up so they can diflg for their aprons under the booth seats. Also, they wouldn't even excuse themselves and ask nicely, they just gave us an awkward stare. Probably because not knowing english, but it was kinda rude.“

“Son ricas las Tortas y los tacos 🌮, se los recomiendo 😋😋😋“

“Nice place and attendants“

“A Hidden Gem in Huntington Station!
La Hacienda is more than just a restaurant – it’s a full experience. The food is absolutely delicious, with rich, authentic Latin flavors that make you feel at home. We tried the tacos, wings, and quesadillas during Happy Hour and everything was top-notch. The tamarind margarita? Next level! 🍹🔥

The vibe is lively and welcoming during the day, and at night it transforms into a full-on party with DJs, great music, and amazing energy. The bartenders are friendly, professional, and truly add to the atmosphere.

We also love that they offer affordable lunch specials and even have a deli takeout option for busy days. Whether you’re coming to eat, celebrate, or dance the night away, La Hacienda is the place to be.
Highly recommended – this spot never disappoints!“

“Checked them out today. I tried the steak taco...it was absolutely delicious ! Staff was friendly, restaurant is clean everything's was fresh . Definitely worth checking out“

“The food here is amazing, like actually some of the best tacos I’ve ever had. Just be warned that the online ordering system on their website is not connected in store, they will not receive your order and you will have to re-order in store. Also none of the employees speak English, but that’s pretty expected for anywhere with authentic delicious Mexican food!“

“I just got done sobbing uncontrollably for 15 minutes because I realized I forgot half of my Pueblo Burrito in my purse. This place has me considering exposing my self to listeria so that I can tantalize my taste buds one more time 😭

On the real, Vallarta is not talked about enough. We love their chicken and steak platter, kids chicken quesadillas, nachos and OBVIOUSLY the Puebla Burrito. It’s so fresh and healthy.

Kelly in the front is the most lovely person to yap with and the guys in the back are always smiling. If you live further than 5 min away don’t even bother calling your food order in because it will get cold, they make it so fast.

Cuando estás allí, eres de la familia.

WE LOVE YOU VALLARTA 🫶“

“Omg spicy mayo on a burrito? Yes!! Everything’s great, steak is the best anywhere. Good portion and prices Accommodating and very nice staff What can I say. I eat here 2-3 times a week Ask for the spicy shrimp!!“

“Food was delicious and the service was great. We have been there twice and planing to make it a regular restaurant for weekend dinners. Highly recommend you try it out.“

“Los recomiendo asen rica comida“

“Amazing Deli! Food is delicious and staff is welcoming and friendly. Definitely will be going back!!“

“On every visit, the staff has been attentive and friendly and, on some occasions, have gone above and beyond to accommodate. I stopped by to take advantage of a promotion they were running for their 1 year anniversary, I had driven by several times on this day, and they had lines out the door each time, when I finally stopped in to take advantage, the staff was still friendly despite having been run ragged all day. Kudos to the team for enduring what was surely an exhausting day! Keep up the good work, team!“

“I’ve only ever used Uber eats to order my food, but I will say I always enjoyed a hot, delicious meal from Mamey. I will definitely continue to order from them.

I always get steak in my orders and I really like it. A few things I’ve had and loved are the steak taco salad with a side of guacamole & the steak tortas with a side of chipotle sauce. Both are so delicious. The tortas travel pretty well but the bread does get a bit soggy, even so it’s so delicious. The taco bowl never disappoints.
Also we love the Tres leches and Horchata! Definitely appreciate you mamey!!“

“I heard about this place from a friend and I decided to make the trip to see if it is worth the hype. Let me just tell you, it was sooo worth it! I live about three hours away from there, but after this experience, I would gladly make this drive again.

The moment I arrived, I was blown away by the atmosphere. There was good music playing, everyone was incredibly friendly, the energy was amazing, and even though there was a long line, the service was quick as I was able to get my food quickly.

Now, about the food, to me this was truly life changing. it's hard for me to find authentic flavorful Mexcian food where I live, this feels like finding a hidden gem. Every bite just made me want more. I loved it so much that I went back and placed a second order before leaving! (Had to take one for on the road!)

I'll definitely be returning every chance I get. Honsetly, they need to open a location closer to me because if I lived closer to them, you would see me there every day. If you are considering coming here, I'll tell you this: STOP THINKING ABOUT IT AND GO!!! YOU WON'T REGRET IT!!!“

“Each Mexican restaurant makes their dishes differently. I went with my family and we ordered a Cuban cake. They were different from other cakes I've tried. That's why he said it's different because the tacos are just as great as many I've tried.“

“the pineapple salsa is phenomenal not as good as the avocado salsa which they took away and it makes me so upset because it was my favorite but I'm so glad they have the pineapple salsa now it is my favorite it is amazing I take home at least10 of the to-go cups every time I go there and ask for extra chips they're amazing I'm going to enjoy laying in bed tonight eating my chips and pineapple salsa thank you“

“So fun!
Just be careful with bartender. I had one drink and she tried to charge me for 3. I’m a good tipper so I didn’t respect the hustle sorry girl. But the club was nice, music was great. The crowd was mixed. Went to see DJ Adonis. He was great!“