Explore West Islip's best Mexican restaurants, handpicked by Restaurantji.
“I drive 15 minutes out of my way in both directions to come here. The restaurant has a simple, but clean and friendly atmosphere. The staff is always friendly and the service is on point.I usually get the west islip lion burrito. Its got everything you wouldn't put in your every day burrito, but it hits the spot every time.I also get the meatless nachos which is loaded with toppings. Its almost impossible to get a nacho chip with nothing on it. Their empanadas are delicious as well.Just after writing this review, I noticed there was bacon in the burrito I ordered. I don't eat pork, so I called the restaurant to ask how to handle it since I don't live close. Not only did they make me a new one, but they drove all the way to my house 15 minutes away just to get my order and gave me a piece of tres leches cake. I've never had tres leches cake I've liked, but this cake is delicious.You guys are awesome. Thank you“
“been waiting to try this place for YEARS since i first heard abt it. its like an elevated chipotle bowl LOL. solid meal and huge portions.I got the fat boys barbacoa and my friend got the hawaiian. Mine was lacking a little sauce so was a bit dry but overall, enjoyable anyways. My friend’s shrimp was so good. Might come back to try their shrimp + fish tacos.“
“Okay so I ordered 30 mins before they closed and when u tell you that food was FRESH. I have my new taco spot the birria tacos were bomb I drank the damn consume haha. The mozzarella sticks my kid got were delicious and so were there fries. Love the churros! Definitely ordering from here again. You can taste the love and care in their food. Food is reasonably price. Definitely hit them up ! I’ll be back for sure.“
“My boyfriend took me here for my birthday and it’s was incredible. The food was so delicious. The atmosphere was beautiful. I got a chicken burrito and he got the skirt steak and we both loved our meals. The guacamole was outstanding. I highly recommend this place.“
“Great experience and surprise! I loved my food choices recommended by one of the owners who is a ray of sunshine! Scrumptious warm baked bread with a spicy guava sauce! Shrimp Stroganoff with mushrooms rice and stick potatoes was delicious! Yucca fries were amazing. Cannot wait to come back!“
“Had a very pleasant experience. Great dinner food. Had the turkey club panini and the veggie burger. I'd recommend both.The turkey club panini was a fresh take on turkey club. The tomato was still a bit cold which was odd, I thought it would be warm, but I had no issue with that. Good flavor.“
“I decided to give this place a try. I was surprised how much I enjoyed it. I chose a custom salad with adobo chicken and a slew of toppings and even a decent portion of guacamole on it for no extra cost. Their Chicken quesadilla was huge and well balance with my choice ingredients. There's absolutely nothing wrong with Qdoba, they do everything right. I believe prices to portion ration is fair. The only downside I think is that possibly they just don't stand out enough vs the competition. I definitely recommend this place.“
“Let me tell you the place is not too big it only had two tables. But I'm here to talk about the food is real authentic Mexican food really delicious & they even have Mexican products like the paletas my favorite is the mango with chile is sweet and spicy at the same time very refreshing. Now the service was good very respectful gentlemen.“
“We had a great time, both the hotel and the beach were very beautiful, the food was delicious, the staff was very kind and helpful, and there were many interesting activities (minigolf, Mediterranean city, Aquapark, etc). We will definitely come again :)“
“Amazing restaurant whether it's with friends or family! One of my best friends from college raved about this restaurant and it's easily a hidden gem! You wouldn't normally expect to have a Greek-Mexican fusion restaurant but this one is amazing! I highly recommend getting their stuffed poblano peppers (stuffed with Cauliflower as I'm vegetarian) - 11/10! They even have mocktails and I recommend the mango mule - which I absolutely loved! Will definitely be back here, but given today was Saturday, the restaurant was busy so you couldn't hear the conversation, but food and service are top notch! Also...Food Network...get here ASAP!“
“It’s like every other QDoba. They have a tendency to go a little light on the vegetable toppings though.Vegetarian options: Has Impossible Meat as a protein option. You can also go meatless.Dietary restrictions: You can fully customize your bowl to accommodate your diet. I eat here as vegan without issue.“
“Busy Saturday night wife and I sat at the bar to avoid a wait, the bartenders Katie and Sarah were very Friendly and excellent in attentiveness and service. The drinks were delicious and the food came out right away. We will be seeing them again sooner then “
“In the event you're down and quarantining with Covid or flu, do yourself a favor and order a delivery of Tortilla soup! It does the body good, is so healing and will help your throat. Just spicy enough with chicken and toppings included, a large order is good for a couple of meals. The mini enjoyed a large portion of Pork Nachos and a side of rice & beans.I've not been in the restaurant, but the delivery option made me happy!“
“Cute place, delicious food. The chicken enchiladas and chorizo taco were spectacular. I was a little upset that the menu said the enchiladas came with beans and rice and I didn't get any, but I already had enough food to fill me up, so it wasn't a big deal. Next time, I really want to try the beans and rice, though. ?“
“Al pastor taco, side a guacamole and chips. Are always a must!! The burritos are so Bomb. Best taco/burritos in the area. They also have fresh juices they make daily. Staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. Haven’t tried the carne asada that they recommended but I will be back.“
“Went here for the first time and wow have we been missing out!! The food and experience was beyond! Our waiter was such a nice young man who you can really tell he genuinely enjoys his job, which is very rare now a days! The food was DELICIOUS they have a very extensive drink and dessert menu which I personally REALLY appreciateI def recommend this restaurant, you won’t be disappointed!!! They even have a fresh guac cart where they make it directly in front of you at your table! SO FUN! I was obsessed with the tree leches cake I want to eat it everyday“
“I ordered online for the first time day. I honestly haven't been here since they first opened years ago! I wasn't a huge fan of it then, but I figured I would give it another chance! I'm so happy I did! My dad wanted a taco and I tried their quesadilla. Both were delicious! The quesadilla is massive and stuffed with everything you could possibly want. I had to save half of it for a later time. My dad's taco was also very full and he really enjoyed it. I'm so happy I decided to give them another chance...even if it was years later lol I'll definitely be stopping by again soon.“
“I ordered the Al pastor Mexico taco trio and a couple of beef tacos tonight 12/02/23. The food was delicious!!! The hot sauces both green and red.... delicious!! I ordered for take out and the order was ready quickly. The business is easily recognized as you drive up and passed. The place is clean and has a few tables for sitting down for a meal if you choose. I will certainly order from them again and I would recommend to anyone to give them a try! Well done ?“
“The food was amazingly delicious and authentic. The carnitas was nice and fatty and flavorful. What I didn't like was mostly the "no price posted because it can change" policy. There were no prices on the menu. I was told " $12 for 3 tacos and soda."". Then, when I was paying for my food, I was told soda was not included. I had to wonder if they had a different price for me because I didn't speak Spanish. The surroundings also were not the cleanest. Sidewalk was covered with dirt and debris, and the food truck was between an auto shop and a laundramat.“
“Everything is absolutely amazing here. The staff is incredibly sweet and willing to answer any questions. The food is absolutely delicious. Fresh made tortilla shells , everything came out hot and fresh. I can’t recommend this place enough. I can’t wait to come here again“
“Have cash! I loved my 3 tacos. I do wish they had spicier salsa. My husband had the torta milanesa de rez, he was disappointed that did not have avocado or cheese. Not sure if that is extra, but we are used to other places that do include cheese and avocado. He enjoyed it nonetheless. We came from out east in a snowsquall on the way. It was worth it. Ps. Yelp has wrong address. Foodie life ?“
“Ordered from here and the nacho bowl was amazing! Everything was really fresh and the ground beef had great flavor. I ordered pick up and it was ready in less than ten min. They also give discounts for Uber eats pickup and in person orders! Definitely going back.!“
“I just hosted my son's first birthday party at shrimpys burrito bar of east islip in their new event space and they did not disappoint! The owners Ryan & John were so accommodating allowing us to decorate, bring in kids entertainment and the food was absolutely delicious. Mikayla handled our event and everything was perfect from beginning to end. Everyone left full and happy! I would 100% recommend using their new space for events!“
“I was here once before. I ordered The Carney asada taco,w/ onion's Cambray and nopal Onions are chopped very fine Tasted like I was eating a Spanish pork chop. This is the best little gem. Hidden in the back. Amelia the owner is very sweet. The bottles on the table The green sauce was a little watered down but OK the other 2 bottles meh. I decided to get two. $6.00 .“
“Still feeling like a newbie in my own town I've wanted to get over to Gracia's for over a year. The hype was worth it. The food was excellent. Portions were plenty. The service was fantastic. We loved looking around at the ambiance and decor. I had a delightful red sangria with a Mexican combo that was a nice sampling and delicious. My teen son had the steak fajitas and the portion and taste was incredible. The Thursday mariachi two man band lead to the liveliness of the restaurant and added to the atmosphere and experience of Gracias. I can't wait to bring the remainder of the family. This place is Perfect for a date night, family night or girls night out. Looking forward to my next visit sooner rather than later.“
“Delish food,margaritas were delish too!!Steaks and shrimp ceviche was also very good . We also had creme brûlée for dessert ,amazing. We also loved the band that was playing. We will be back. Highly recommended!! we had a great experience!!!“
“This is not a bad place to eat. I ordered the bowl with all the fixings and a chocolate chip cookie for dessert, it's good. My family prefers Chipotle though, they like the taste of their food. I'm ok with this place, I like the ambience and seating area, and the servings of food are good.Vegetarian options: Guacamole, beans, lettuce, and corn.Kid-friendliness: Big open spaces, table side TV, chocolate chip cookies.“
“My f̲̲a̲v̲o̲r̲i̲t̲e̲ taco place. Definitely a need to go place. They are flavorful, perfect sized, and reasonably priced. The tex-mex chili is my fav in tacos, burritos, ect. Also the employees are so nice??????????Parking: It's small, in and out business so it's easy“
“The atmosphere gets 2 stars because the music is so loud that you can't have a conversation. Maybe they keep it loud to you get out of there quicker because there's always a wait of 45 minutes or more. Sad because we've been coming here since 2013, when you could sit and enjoy a meal without ear damage. :(“
“Went here during a lunch break with a good friend. First time for both of us. I got tacos and he got pupusas. Both were made right there and then, fresh. The service was awesome and quick! Place has parking available and easy to access. You want some good Spanish food, definitely check it out!Kid-friendliness: Kids can come and go, with no problemParking: Free parking available“
“Found my favorite place right next to my work place. I live spicy mango. This place is the best place for it. It was my first time here. The staffs were very friendly and very helpful in helping me decide. Will definitely be back and recommend it to other people.“
“Traveling from out of state and was brought to Salsa Salsa and I was AMAZED by my experience! They have an extensive selection of margarita flavors and a fabulous and fresh menu. Our group had ordered a traditional margarita, a black cherry margarita, and their seasonal "shamrock margarita" all of which were delicious and perfectly balanced in flavor. The staff was knowledgeable and a joy to interact with. The owner Chris took the time to chat with us and brought out many hot sauce flavors for us to try and gave us his recommendations. Our server Justin was friendly and attentive. I can tell this is an establishment run with passion and pride... Will definitely return next time I'm in town!“
“I get lunch from Vallarta at least once a week for several years now. The staff is friendly and the food is consistently delicious, with a larger menu than your typical fast-mexican spot. Strongly recommend skipping the chains and giving these folks a try!“
“Just left this place after finding it on local places to eat on Google. I must say I'm a foodie and can be critical of places but this place was excellent!! I wish I could give it 10 stars. Everything was fresh and tasty. Can't wait to be in this area again to try more stuff on the menu. Customer service was great as well. Thanks guys see you soon.“
“Stopped here for a quick bite and a birthday treat, the promo wasn't working so the employee helped comp a queso cup. Unfortunately there was a fire alarm going off from the building next to them which was driving business away but props to their team for still trying their best.“
“Honestly don't let the appearance of the deli fool you. The tacos are amazing . Lil whole In the wall spot in Farmingdale with great Mexican food. I was working in the area and was looking for some cheap eats and came across this place. The tacos were amazing and definitely not cheap, but we'll worth it. $15 dollars for 3 tacos. Delicious food and very kind workers! They have a good variety of snacks and hot food made fresh daily. The quality of chicken and freshness of the tacos was a 10/10! If ever in this area again I look forward to trying different food options. Amazing Mexican tacos!!! Love the authenticity of their Mexican food.“
“This restaurant is similar to a Chipotle or Moe's, as you come in and order at the counter and walk down the showcase choosing what you'd like. It's separated into two different departments. One is Mexican style options (salads, tacos, fajitas, etc...) and the other is frozen yogurt and traditional salads (Greek, Caesar, etc). The restaurant in itself is spacious and clean! And the staff was so helpful, friendly and patient. Here's what we ordered! A chopped Greek salad, a Vegetarian Iguana salad, a Lost Coast sandwich and a Diet Coke. The Greek salad was very large and filled with all different veggies. The dressing, a little too much, but more is better then skimpy. I'd ask for a little less dressing next time. The Iguana salad was filled, tasty, and hit the spot! Both salads came with tortilla chips which were a perfect complement to the salads. Now, the fish sandwich was fair. The fish was cold, not crispy and underwhelming for sure. But, the coleslaw on top was very good. The sodas are refillable which is a plus. Lastly, the prices were fair and decent. Overall, for a taco/salad joint this place holds the 5 stars well.“
“Still going strong and only better since they opened. They change tacos to seasons and they have something for everyone on the menu including vegan choices. Margaritas always on point and a chill relaxing spot to hang or grab dinner. A plus, The owner (JEFF) Is a sweet heart. only wants to please his customer and have them leave happy and wanting to come back. He is quick to get on anything you might need ! Go check it out you will be very happy you did!“
“Tool my mother for dinner for her birthday, and it turned out to be National Margarita Day. The drinks were great! The food was good too! They sang happy birthday and put a mariachi hat on her with a shot of tequila, all around good night. And they have live mariachi some nights too!“
“Food was great, very authentic. Refried beans were one of the best I've had. Most of the items were a bit too spicy for the little one but otherwise the adults loved it. Was a bit greasy feeling sitting inside though, they need better ventilation inside the restaurant.“
“As soon as I walked into the place. The lady at the front greeted me with kindness and welcomed me. She asked for what I would liked and made the food quickly. The tacos itself were perfectly made and watered my mouth with tasty flavors. I highly recommend and will return again! -Thank “
“This Restaurant is in the heart of Huntington Station. Very clean atmosphere and plenty of seating. Weekdays are more ideal for less crowd and weekends are more busy just like any eatery. Food is super fresh and they have so much variety to choose from. Sometimes I order food to go or if I'm in a rush they always have so much delicious options in the Deli section. Love that they have always fresh fruit cut ready to go and fresh juice. The staff and owner are always super accomadating to my needs. Constumer satisfaction is A+Also they have plenty of parking space in the back. It's always a pleasure coming here everyone very intentive.. I always have good experiences here and my tastebuds are always fully satisfied. :)Thank you!“
“Ordered takeout a couple of times before and went to their Easter brunch event (which was phenomenal). The staff were lovely / genuinely caring and you can tell, really wanted all of the kids (and adults) to have a great time. Love this place and will be going back. Thank you Madison and team!“
“Besito has done a great job transitioning to the south shore. The atmosphere is different from the Huntington location, but only in a way that makes it feel like it's always been in West Islip. The food is superb, and although the menu doesn't highlight this, their complimentary tortilla chips and salsa are homemade, and it shows. We have now been there three times, and we have yet to be disappointed by the food or staff. My last foray to their dining room, I indulged in the Arrechera (skirt steak). It was lightly marinated and cooked to my liking; medium rare. I was expecting it to be cooked correctly, but I was ill-prepared to find it so tender. Also, as an aperitif... I highly recommend their El Pepino Margarita. What a refreshing mix of fresh cut jalapeños, cucumber and high-quality alcohol.“