50 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Sand Lake

“What a great time we had at June Farms!! We had the pleasure of spending the morning with Trevor, who escorted us around the farm in a golf cart! We learned so many new things today about the farm animals. My children ages 27, 5 and 2 years old all equally enjoyed our morning, what a great family experience. Thank you for the memories. Trevor was great!!!! We can’t wait to come back again.“

“***2024 Update***Under new ownership Crossroads has completely turned around food quality is very good and the service has been great. Highly recommend checking them out!“

“Iam from canandaigua ny, my brother lives nearby and told me to try your spot, I’ve been hooked every sense, your pizza is amazing that is my go to every time I visit“

“we are new to the area in Cohoes and have found that that cute little nook has the best pizza I have tasted in 10 years. Very welcoming, accommodating and friendly. They even sell brownies!“

“Food is absolutely incredible and the service is even better. I recommend 3 Brothers to everyone.“

“Ordered 2 cheese pizzas, each was $10 which was a good deal. The guy gave us 11 plates which was funny because it was just two of us each eating one pizza LOL. But it was good, took about 20 mins to be prepared but it was also the middle of a snow storm so they were probably low on staff, so it's possible they're usually quicker.“

“My husband and two of our friends went for dinner tonight. The drinks were on point, our calamari was delicious, I had the chicken Milanese which I loved, my husband had the casarecce. Our friends had the bolognese pasta dishes and we were all quite satisfied. Can’t wait to come back and try the pizzas!! Highly recommend!“

“Delicious and always consistent! Their Sicilian pies have a great cheese pull and crispy base! The sauce is delicious and full flavored. The toppings are chef's kiss. Staff is always moving and pleasant!“

“We love their pizza. Ordered from them last night for delivery, the pizza was running a little late but we didn’t notice. Much to our surprise, the delivery driver had 2 pizzas. There was a mistake on the pizza we ordered so they corrected it and gave us the mistake pie. Completely unnecessary but, we were able to feed some friends as well. Thank you. Pro tip: get their homemade bleu cheese.“

“I frequent here often and the food is delicious- reviewing the posts here all I can say is because the food is soooo good I can see them struggling with deliveries occasionally- they're that popular!!“

“Very good it was 30_ 35 for there largest pizza and cheese bread...... We had the smallest piece we could find in the box and we got full.... This pizza is gonna last us days..... Best pizza I ever had .. And I love pizza I would highly recommend it ❤“

“Had our Christmas Eve dinner catered by Patricelli's. Everything was perfect! Very good food and delivery person was very helpful getting everything into the house. I will definitely call them next time we need an event catered and would highly recommend them!“

“Best Pizza in town! As a certified pizzaholic, I should know!“

“Best pizza in the 518 ✋🏽s down.“

“Decent pizza, not the best but far from the worst. Ingredients seemed good but pizza was a bit undercooked (lacking crispnesss but no raw dough or anything extreme).
Biggest gripe was the lack of seasoning.

Staff was nice, and the pricing was reasonable.

--edit(bumping up my review from 3stars) I found myself going back due to lazyness and extreme temps.

They have a large array of seasonings available to the left of checkout and the guy working there was very friendly and was willing to toss my by-the-slice order in the oven to reheat/crisp it.

With seasonings and a little oven TLC the pizza was actually quite good.“

“Outstanding.“

“I had a great slice of pepperoni and the customer service was excellent, too“

“We used Carols to cater a baby shower— not only were the options great, they gave us a good price, all the food was fresh and delicious, and it was exactly the right amount of food for the number of guests. I would definitely use them again and recommend for anyone looking for good local catering options!“

“We recently celebrated our 49th wedding anniversary, which was a good choice. We found the staff to be polite and friendly from when we entered until we left two hours later. The environment was pleasant and easy with a touch of class. The half-chicken "Picata" ordered was "mm-hmm good" served with an exquisitely savory sauce, prepared by Chef Jake, who is a rising star and a compliment to Troy's fine dining experience. My wife and I also appreciated and thought it "cool" that the owner "Vic" took the time to talk with us. Enjoyable evening and location!!!“

“I love Michals so we have been going there for oh God at least 20 years. You can’t go wrong with their food and let me tell you the family that owns this restaurant is a pillar of our community and just wonderful people and their food is delicious. best garbage bread I’ve ever had best meatballs I’ve ever had and their prices are very reasonable Danny and Melanie love this place. You gotta try their Philly cheesesteak one of the best around.“

“All the groups were outstanding. We especially liked the jazz band.“

“Moved back to my hometown and was so happy the Zotto’s reopened a new place. The best pizza, and wings around. Brunswick needed this place!!! All the waitresses were amazing and welcoming too!!“

“Great food, great service, eat here!“

“Wow the pizza is amazing! I ordered the gluten free pizza and it was incredible. Husband and son got the regular pizza and it was also delicious! Cool atmosphere and the outdoor area is neat!“

“This is my go to for boneless wings, especially the PBJ. I have been known to drive 1/2 hr to get these wings.
Red sauce is good
I haven't had a bad meal here
We always get our food to go and eat at home
Staff are so friendly and accomodating“

“Food on time great hospitality took their time to make sure what I ordered was correct and took time to make my order in a fashionate way to meet my standards. Very respectful & understanding also food was at the right temperature not too cold & not too hot. 10 Outta 10. I would recommend to other customers based off my great experience“

“As out-of-town visitors we leaned on our friends suggestions and came here for dinner. Wow! Delicious! The chicken parmigiana sandwich was delicious. The pizza was a huge favorite with the younger and older kids. The spaghetti sauce was extra special and we ended up taking some to go to dip bread in at home. We enjoyed the food so much we were back three days later. We highly recommend this place.“

“This morning my GF 14 year old grandson had 2 full sized donuts and the Philly cheesesteak sandwich from here. His review: “If I get to choose my last meal, this would be it. “ ❤️“

“Pizza and wings are Great! Customer Service was excellent. We will definitely be ordering again.“

“They have 4 vegan pizzas and 2 vegan appetizers (mozzarella sticks and jalapeño poppers). I had the appetizers and both the vegan Florentine and vegan Fra Diavolo pizzas. Highly recommend to grab the pizza to the Albany Distillery Company and grab some drinks too!“

“My Aunt accidentally called this shop meaning to call another pizza place. They were so friendly about it that she decided to try them out. She got wings and pizza, and we all thought it was pretty good! My Aunt said good prices as well so an overall good experience“

“I can't believe I've lived here for a year and have not tried GOOMBAS. their food is so good and the best out of the other pizzerias right around here. Five cheese specialty pizza was BANGIN' My new spot ! can't wait to try more!“

“Great food and service given the circumstances.“

“When I tell you, and listen carefully- these stuffed shells are literally the BEST stuffed shells I have ever had in the entirety of my 27 years of existence. I can’t believe I didn’t have to pay $25 for this because it’s worth $25+, and I would pay that, to experience the feeling I got upon taking the first bite. I was in pure awe. But aside from that, here (and Amante’s) are literally the best pizza restaurants in the capital region. Easily the best. I am never disappointed“

“Wow hands down the best pizza I have had in years. My husband bought me a mushroom slice and it was seasoned so perfectly. The last good pizza I have had was 29 years ago in Groton CT. So to say it is the best in years is saying a lot. I don’t think you will be disappointed“

“Everything I get at steak out is perfect. I just got fantastic tuna sub from there.“

“Hard to believe NYC is famous for its pizza when a place like Roman exists upstate. I love the city, love a good number of slices I can get there, believe me, and I'm the pickiest eater you'll ever meet. But this place is a whole other world. Been heading here for about a decade, usually delivery, always on time and hot and ready. I'll die on the hill that the cheese pizza here is the best in the state, especially with crushed red pepper. The buffalo chicken pizza is EXTREMELY good, but best hot. The wings are hit or miss, yeah, but they're not Roman Wings!! Great service, great humor, fun place, you gotta check it out, dude.“

“Absolutely amazing! Troy Pizza and Gyro is hands down one of the best halal spots in the area. The food is always fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. Their gyros are loaded and juicy, the pizza has that perfect crispy crust, and everything tastes homemade and satisfying.

The staff is friendly, respectful, and they take pride in their service. It’s rare to find a place that delivers both quality and consistency every time.

As someone who looks for halal options, I really appreciate that they’re 100% halal — no worries, just great food. Highly recommended for anyone craving delicious, filling meals in a clean, welcoming environment!“

“Best Pizza Ever. Took my whole family to eat highly recommended“

“This place is really a nice stop to take a break to eat! Many options for food“

“Bacchus has been the best most under-rated pizza in the area…in NY..for years. However something changed recently. I don’t know if it was a one-off but their flour or dough changed. Not in a good way. What happened?!?“

“Dang this place has not let me down so far. Week after week their pizza has been consistently perfect. Today we got the meatball parm sub (added peppers) & holy crap was that good. The sub roll was to die for. Will be trying the whole menu from here out.“

“Never disappointed in their food ! The red garlic parm wings 🤤 are my favorite , round cheese pizza , the red garlic parm specialty pizza the bestest ! Subs 😂 I can’t even open my mouth wide enough they give you so much meat 🤤 honestly I never got a bad thing from them anything I ever got was amazing !“

“This is a new place that sells pizza which is decent I wouldn't say it's traditional Italian pizza like from Italy but considering how bad the pizza is in the Capital District this place definitely is on par with with all the decent places“

“Great staff clean place excellent food and staff“

“A native Vlietian, went back to Rusty’s after 20+ years. Was always one of my favorite wings in the area. Even if though they are under new management, it didn’t disappoint at all. Same great Buffalo flavor, also had the classic garlic parm and we all loved it. They even cooked to the perfect crisp. Will definitely go back when I’m back in town visiting family.“

“I've been ordering pizza from them almost a decade now. Customer service has always been the same. Nice and welcoming. I don't venture too much in their menu. My family's go-to choices are always delicious. I've gone to both latham and east greenbush locations and must say that I prefer greenbush. The service is more accommodating (in my opinion). All this to say that I appreciate their business and would recommend them to your family both as dine in and take away food options.“

“5 stars across the board. The new owner Sarah is awesome and super friendly and they definitely know what they’re doing when it comes to pizza. Ever since the new ownership this place is top notch. The pizza is incredible. I highly recommend I can’t say it enough. Definitely the best pizza shop on this side of the river“

“Buffalo garlic parm wings were knocked out of the park tonight!!!“

“I went there tonight for the first time...ordered my pizza in house, waited the stated time, went back in, paid and enjoyed it out in the car..the establishment has a spacious lot for customers...had heard of Dante's pizzas awhile back...decided to finally take a drive out (I live about 40 minutes from there)... I must say, I was impressed. in particular, was the freshness of what I was eating [8 cut pepperoni, mushroom and hot peppers)..the sauce was balanced and on point. the peppers were in two rich varieties, appeared to be freshly sliced, and pepperoni was a tasty, mild Margherita style that was generously offered. I've had pizza from a good number of well-respected pizza places in the capital region- and this pizza had had a very nice composition and the crust was nearly perfect in every way.. It had the proper donenese, the nice receding gumline that floated away to Fluffy, pillow like outer crust. The crust had a good crisp to it but not overly done...just overall great balance with finer ingredients for sure...I will definitely go back again. I would say that this pizza can compete with some of the most popular pizzeria's in the Tri -city area. I really believe that!!.. it was really good... in my opinion.“