50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bexley

“Best gluten free crust ever. By a ton. Yum!“

“Delicious NY-style pizza! Whenever I want pizza, this is my go-to. The customer service is very nice when I pick up my order. I ordered delivery once, and it was also a great customer service experience. Five stars!“

“When are you guys going to come into this century and sign up with GrubHub or DoorDash? You'd definitely increase your profits. Driving to pick up food is old school, LOL!!“

“I always enjoy Little Italy, the food is always good and decently priced.
I am only giving 4 stars because I went with my whole family. 9 people. And my older mother in law paid the bill.
Mom realized the next morning that the bill she paid was not even ours! She paid like $160 plus a tip that was over $30. Turns out our actual bill was only $110 and so our tip would have been significantly less as well.
It took several calls and a few days wait but a manager DID refund the difference. But overall I'm disappointed that could've even happened. The orders weren't even similar.“

“The Pizza, Subs and Wings are SCARY Good!“

“Someone recently mentioned this place in a pizza group on FB. I decided to try it today & I'm glad I did. Probably the best non-deep dish pizza in Columbus. The prices were good as well. There's also plenty of nearby parking.“

“Good pizza. Sausage was delicious 😋“

“Relaxing, entertaining & fun. The food is adequate.“

“Re. the Grandview location - Great food. But, building is just fair. It is freezing in there this time of year (late Fall/Winter). With the high ceilings, any heat never makes it to the patrons inside (please learn to use your ceiling fans to help with this). Also, having doors that open straight to the outside doesn't help. Each time they are opened, it is a blast of cold air for half the establishment.“

“A standard classic since the 80s. The food is fantastic. Their subs are delicious. My all time favorite is the Turkey sub. It is scrumdiddlyumptious. You have the ability to choose a thin or hand tossed crust. All the toppings are fantastic. Sides are also great. My biggest complaint is their closed lobby on Monday and Tuesday till 4pm. Other days they open at 10 or 11. Do expect overly friendly wait staff but the food is so good you will not care. I have been going here since the 90s. Their prices have raised significantly over the years. It used to much less. I will pay them because the food is worth it. I could see why some may shy away. You can rack up $50 just with two people ordering a sub and large pizza and drinking soda. Just keep that in mind. I feel one of the best pizza places in Columbus since they opened. You ability to choose crust and style of sauce and spiciness of tge sauce is paramount.“

“I stopped in on my way home to order and pick up a 10" BBQ Chicken Pizza. The lady who took my order was very pleasant and efficient. The owner came through the dining area and stopped to tell me about the restaurant. I had planned to eat the pizza in the car on the way home, but it was so loaded with fresh and delicious ingredients that I was afraid that I would spill it on myself. I wisely decided to eat the pizza in my car in the parking lot. I really like BBQ chicken pizza, and this was the best I'd ever had.“

“Best pizza I have ever had“

“Fantastic Stromboli’s and high quality to detail, give it a try!!“

“After working with the front and back staff for over a year I get to see how everything is running as far as receiving all the foods and produce in the back I know everything is kept very clean and organized in a busy kitchen with all the preps and cooks working together. Out front we have a bunch of young awsome experienced ladies always working together and keeping all the customers Happy and Full. The Food and staffs are second to none😎“

“We are from out of town and wanted to try a local pizza place. It WAS AMAZING! The food tasted GREAT, the service was exceptional. We even bought a giant jar of jelepenos to take back home. Next time we sre in the area, we will be stopping here again!“

“Great News to report. I graduated in 1991. Eagles Pizza was our hangout spot. I have lived away from Eagles Pizza for many. Dennis the owner is a great man. He is coming near where I live. And bringing the famous Taco Pizza. Try one!!! U rock Dennis and Eagles Pizza!!!“

“A huge shout out to Romeo’s for absolutely nailing my lunch order today! Everything was perfect!“

“Love Dewey’s!! Their house salad is my favorite.“

“Was up here for work and tried this place on a whim and was not disappointed had the loaded pep and cheese 10/10. Next time I’m in area will definitely be back.“

“The food is great - we’ve tried most of their pizzas and the antipasti salad is to die for. Unfortunately I can’t speak as highly about the staff. On several occasions, usually on Sundays when they close at 7, I’ve gotten my food close to 7 but NEVER after 7. I’ve placed orders for pick-up at 6:45 and if I wasn’t there at 6:45 on the dot I’ve been called being harassed to get my food because they close at 7. Today I went in at 6:50 and they had already put everything away, taken out the trash, and sanitized everything and gave me lip about wanting to place my order (1 pizza and 1 salad). They proceeded to loudly complain to each other while making my order. Closing at 7 means you stop taking customers at 7 - not that staff gets to walk out the door and lock it behind them at 7.“

“Very good pizza and bosco sticks, amazing customer service!“

“I’ve been going to Rubino‘s for about 40 years. The pizzas is great. I love the thin crust and how the store hasn’t changed a bit. Looks just like it did in the 80s.“

“I don’t want to remove a star because your pickle pizza is dreamy but you made me waste money on those stupid for profit parking lots that don’t even use the funds to repair the lots. The parking is like 11 dollars we found another one for 6 bucks for two hours walk up to Slammers and it’s locked. Everything says it’s open, the web site, Google, the door sign itself… we’re not rich, just wanted to have a beer and pizza after a really bad day and tried To call but there’s no way to leave a message… just boo that wasn’t cool. Next time make a sign when you don’t feel like opening up during your normal hours, think of your customers. *waaah*“

“So Bazemore Pizza Co. Is located inside Pointe Tavern in Upper Arlington Ohio.

Italian Sub - This was thee best take on a classic sub I have ever had. I’m still trying to figure out how something so simple and yet it tastes so complex? Like the taste of Bazemore’s Italian sub was absolutely F’n phenomenal! The bun had a crispy crust and the inside was warm and delight, everything inside was straight magic!

The Margarita Pizza - 1st off, full disclosure I should note that I came here mainly because the place was featured on One Bite and the fact Dave Portnoy gave it an amazing review. So yeah, I had to come and it’s worth the drive from Westerville to Upper Arlington. Just look at the picture! If that doesn’t tell you what it tastes like, then nothing will!

Chicken Wings - Classic Buffalo, Dank Dust Dry Rub (🔥 my favorite), Juli-Q (2nd fav)

Italian Meat Balls - These MF’ers melt in your mouth, just get them!

So I actually got to meet Billy & Todd, great guys. I just need them to move closer to my side of town.“

“I absolutely LOVE Pies and Pints. The pizza is AMAZING and the staff is incredibly friendly and nice. I tried the white pizza once and won't get anything else. Absolutely incredible!!!“

“We ordered from the new store in Galloway, Ohio. Pizza and sub was very hot and delicious. I highly recommend trying their food.“

“The Don Corleone w/ sausage and my delicious date Judy.“

“Best pizza in the entire WORLD“

“We've been ordering Frankie's for many years. It's our go to for guaranteed great pizza. The burnt ends are astounding! So good!! I'm not usually a fan of smoked food but the smoked wings are crazy good. Meaty with the perfect amount of seasoning. It's really hard to find good onion rings but theirs are better than anywhere else. Tried the Dub Sub (Italian sub with double meat and double cheese) tonight and it is the best Italian sub I've ever had. And the funnel cake fries - yum! The only problem is deciding which items to get when we order since we can only eat so much! 😀“

“Not sure how this doesn't have five stars across the board. We drove from almost ten hours away and after scouring places to eat we decided to stop here. The crust is crisp, not soggy or tough with good flavor and thickness. You can't go wrong with fresh ingredients like the mozzarella and mushrooms (fresh not canned, wowee!) either. We also tried Gina's Gem and between the beautiful focaccia and the dip being creamy while also sweet with a small back burn to it, you really can't go wrong. The bar is a great place to sit, no spoilers, but the walls and shelves are filled with awesome and hilarious things that make good conversation. It's a shame this wonderful place is so far from home but we're hoping to make it a yearly tradition. Thanks for the great food, staff, and atmosphere!“

“Very good pizza! Friendly, clean, and quick service. We highly recommend!“

“Amazing pizza and wonderful people !!!“

“Good food pleasant environment.“

“This crew knocks it out of the park every time.“

“Classic Columbus Pizza! Worth the trip.“

“Who can I message about our pizza tonight?“

“Ordered the bourbon chicken pizza from here recently and it was incredible. Highly recommend it and I will definitely be ordering from here again soon.“

“Friends and I went out for a fun time at Forty Deuces and it was phenomenal. We had VIP seats and hats off to the servers that checked on us regularly through the night and attended to our needs before we even realized we needed anything. Also for the venue, dancers, and band. Wow! You all clearly work so incredibly hard and it’s great to see it come together as a show. I look forward to future visits.“

“Tyler’s is amazing! If I could have it everyday I would!“

“We had really good pizza this afternoon. The 12 inch classic was perfect! It was nice having real fresh toppings on our pizza. The cinnamon dough(cinnaBrenz)with cream cheese was outstanding! Thank you to the man making the pizza who recommended this. We will definitely be coming back. 🍕 Anthony and Amanda“

“Stopped in for pizza...it was amazing. We will definitely be back“

“I love romeos. Their pizza is delicious! My only complaint is they got rid of their dine in which was cool. They had a party room with a hockey table and Need for Speed arcade cabinets (HP2 and U1). All that’s sadly gone but the pizza is still worth buying alone!“

“I met a friend here for dinner on a Monday night. We shared the stuffed peppers and lemon cream cake. It was more than enough for us to split. The prices seemed fair to me and our server was very warm and hospitable. The interior is casual and the noise level was moderate. I found it homey and pleasant. I would be glad to go back and try some of their other foods.“

“This pizzeria used to be a Columbus taste landmark, and the golden formula of crispy crust and sweet sauce still works... But lately, the quality control has been a roller coaster: a late-night order of XL pizzas was as dry as cardboard, and the bitterness of the chicken wings dipped in the panna cotta oil went straight to the sky 😩 The misery of the sauce bursting out of the pouch was even worse... Luckily, when veteran employee Jennifer was in town, the fresh-baked pepperoni pizzas still pulled off a half-meter waterfall of cheese.... When Jennifer is in town, the freshly baked pepperoni pizza still pulls out a half-meter waterfall of cheese! We recommend avoiding the weekend rush and locking in the classics, after all, only your wallet knows the pain of stepping on a $50 mine. Boss, get a new frying pan in the back room, don't let the old fans' memories stay in that leaking bag of garlic sauce! 🍕💔“

“Hands down this place has the best pizza in the State and maybe the country. I watched the Netflix special on the famous pizza makers in America, they missed this one!!!! It is perfect! Stromboli’s and calzones kick it up a notch as well! Great food, great customer service. I drove by 15 or more pizza places to great here. No reason not to!!!“

“Their pizza is as good as it always has been. The shop is very tiny, you're walking into the kitchen when you go in for pickup. But the staff is very friendly, the pizza is reasonably priced, and we've never had an issue making an order online or not getting what we paid for. Excellent Columbus style pizza.“

“I got a pizza today and unfortunately it was over cooked. Crust was way too crunchy and cheese burnt, but this is the first bad pizza I’ve gotten from here in all the years I’ve been going“

“Ordered from the W. 3rd location lastnight. The food was great!! Fast delivery, food was hot on arrival and the price was good as well!! Definitely recommend!“

“I love Mexican food I recommend eating here. My family tried the beef and chicken birra enchiladas. We all loved it, even my three cats. 😋“

“Great food and people would Definitely go back“