34 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carlisle

“We usually get the cassinos on verity in Middletown, but we are tanning at the nearby location (simply brown), so gave this a try. Service was exceptional. Pizza was well done as we asked and the soda was REALLY cold. So we were very pleased. The girl who waited on us was very attentive and friendly.“

“Demnika’s was an awesome local find!! The owner was actually serving dishes the night we grabbed dinner here. The food was delicious - really enjoyed the house made Italian dressing and garlic knots. The marinara was good but hoped for a bit more richness. The baked cheese on top of my pasta four ways made up for it though! Will definitely be back.“

“Ok guys, we just returned from Sunday lunch and the photos will show that the food smelled so delicious that I was overcome and forgot to photograph. Then as I began devouring I finally remembered to do so. I ordered the baked spaghetti with meat sauce, and my husband the lasagna. Both come with a side salad, and garlic knots. All I can say is… I tried both and…. YUMMY! There are plenty of fabulous pizza reviews from this establishment so I decided on the pastas. No regrets there. The pasta was Al dente, the sauce was incredibly flavorful, and the cheese was top notch and bubbly! Not only do you get fantastically made food, but also friendly family service. You can tell they really care about their clientele and their craft. This will be a frequented place for us. If you have procrastinated a visit here, wait no more. Don’t walk, run!“

“Great Pie! My family always has Pizza Friday. We have our favorites for sure. Pisanello's pies are always in the rotation. I also love getting the Reaper, it really is fun to see the expressions from folks that have never seen the size of this Big fella.“

“We have been wanting to try steel city for awhile. I’ve followed them on instagram for a good bit. Let me tell you, it was well worth the wait. We got a pepperoni and a margarita pizza. The crust was perfect, sauce was wonderful and just an all around great pizza, dare I say delightful. I’m so glad this building is finally being used. I’m born and raised in the Middie and I really try and support local restaurants. Give this place a try. Neat atmosphere with them being attached to NEW Ales Brewery.“

“Great little pizzeria and Italian kitchen. Not your average pizza place, they have chicken parm, stuffed manicotti, lasagna. I had the cauliflower crust personal pizza which is outstanding! Crisp crust savory seasoned sauce, generous toppings, perfectly cooked. Super friendly guys as well.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust pizza fantastic“

“The pizzas were good and the staff was very friendly. We looked it up before hand and it said there was dine-in seating. Technically there was as we did dine in, but that was just a few tables at the front people could sit at. It is not a large dine-in section so I personally felt in the way. The staff did not make us feel uncomfortable at all and told us we could dine in when I asked. Not my restaurant, but I can't imagine dine in is a big part of the business. I would recommend not advertising that. The menu has good options and I would like to try them again sometime. If you are around the area or if you have your own pizza bag to keep the food warm I would recommend checking them out for pick up or delivery of course.“

“I tried the Vienna lager and a Dunkel. Both beers were just right in the sense that they weren't overly hopped which is an issue I have at many breweries. I don't really like IPAs and the bitterness. These beers were sweet,flavorful and crisp. Pizza was pretty good, thick crust but crispy and made with freshly prepared dough. I just had their cheese pizza. Overall I enjoyed the experience, may have to stop in again sometime.“

“VETERN OWNED! Very good food! Great selection of beers! Love the pour your own concepts. Allows you to choose what you want to drink before committing to a full glass. Everyone is friendly, helpful and great to talk with!Kid-friendliness: Toys and games available to entertain the kiddos while you relax and enjoy.“

“Recently moved to the area and went here as we're still settling into our new home. The restaurant is in a great location along 741. The environment feels like an older sports bar/family restaurant mesh, but it's not dated at all. The restaurant was very clean and the staff was friendly and attentive.We ordered drinks, appetizers, sandwiches, burgers, a pizza, and children's meals. The loaded Saratoga chips were great. They're house-made potato chips covered in cheese, bacon, and paired with ranch dressing. The burgers were cooked to temp and very tasty. The chicken sandwich was phenomenal. The grilled chicken tenders were both flavorful and juicy. The mac and cheese was great!!We had heard great things about their pizza, but were honestly skeptical about it as we haven't had great experiences with restaurants that have a full menu and make pizzas. Thankfully, we listened to the masses, as the pizza was perfectly cooked and was absolutely delicious.We'll definitely be adding this restaurant to our list of regular dining options. We couldn't recommend this place highly enough.“

“Food is good, nice little place to sit and enjoy if you don't plan on carry out and the way my son and I were treated exceeded expectations. They were more than kind and friendly to my young son and they went beyond what was necessary to treat us well.Parking: Pending per busy hours but didn't notice any difficultiesKid-friendliness: Above and beyond. Need to note the weren't super busy at the time if day we visited so they may not be able to do what they did for every visit but they were very friendly to my 4 year old.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes I do believe so“

“I love the vegetable pizza, build your own calzone, fried mushrooms, and cannolis. The tiramisu is good as well. Have yet to try a menu item I dislike. Give them a try and you won't regret it. The owners are very kind and friendly as well!“

“I just had the best experience at Deweys in Austin Landing/ Ohio. Not only were they super fast and friendly, but I made a mistake with my order, I was not complaining about it, but they kindly put in an additional order Out of simple kindness. What a top-notch establishment and good hearted people!! Thank you Ryan and the whole Dewey’s team!“

“Rose took care of us and was very nice and helpful!! She checked on us throughput the meal and made us feel very welcome!Kid-friendliness: Rose was very nice to help with my toddler being picky helping to get what he needed as a side instead of having buy a whole meal for some meatballs“

“Best pizza in Dayton and I love eating there. Feels old school but certainly not old. Do yourself a favor and get pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese.Kid-friendliness: You seat yourself and all of the tables are made for large groups. There is an arcade as well.“

“I don't write reviews...but this place deserves one. Been going here for years! They know my order by heart.....and it's always wonderful!!! Everything we have ever tried is great...The Rhonda salad is our favorite. (Add pepperoni to it...u will see why) We love their pizza....best onion rings and chicken fingers this side of the Mississippi. The best part- is the people who work there. They work hard and always go above and beyond. Don't really get that anywhere...but u sure do here. Thank yall for being so kind to us through the years and always making our food top notch! ? ??“

“I lived across the bridge from this place my whole life. This is till this day 7 years later the best pizza I have ever had. Havnt been in so long since I moved but when I come back to town I am definitely going there everytime I need to eat. Not to mention my grandpa Terrence fella knew Ron directly and i remember him cleaning Ron's big red curtains from time to time. Their tavern cut pizza has me always asking other places here to cut it like they do. 1000% recommend“

“I cannot speak to the food that they have there as I usually don’t get there until after the kitchen is closed. But the bands are usually very good on the weekends. The clientele has always been Friendly. They have three dart boards that are soft tip two of them that connect online that you can play against people anywhere in the country. And drink specials that typically go all night long. The bartenders are always very friendly, and have smiles on their faces.“

“Can't complain about the quality of the food here great menu nice dining room ample big screens, the reason for the service rating is it seems Door Dash and other food delivery services take the front of the line and leaves you with a long wait, I've order many times and noticed since them services started it's a longer wait.“

“Nice to see lots of healthier meal options in a local pizza place. Have enjoyed the "Vegan Vibes" specialty pizza on two visits, cooked perfectly. Lots of draft beer options. Although website says "WATCH THE GAMES HERE!" (the reason I went there) there are no TVs above the bar, only one off of each end, not comfortably visible from most bar seats. The TV over the middle of the bar only displays menus and ads. Hopefully consideration will be given to more viewable TVs in the future. Will be back to try more menu items.“

“I used to live beside this place back in the late 90s and spent wayyyy too much $$ here, lol. But there was a reason for it, great food and great people. I revisited here again recently, and without a doubt, it's still great food and great people! Never had a bad experience here, ever.“

“Finally gave this place a try and it was great. Ordered a large pepperoni and the cheesy garlic bread. The large pizza is LARGE, and there's a ton of cheese. It's square cut but the slices are good sized, given the pile of toppings. Bread was quality too, heavy on the garlic which is a positive.“

“I like this style of pizza, I think it is Detroit style. It is thick but crunchy too. I tend to favor the Eugene Supreme as it has all the great pizza toppings on it. Jet's uses the most delicious sausage in their pizzas. They offer a big variety of pizzas for every taste including a gluten free option. They always get your pizza done in twenty minutes for pickup as we happen to be out of delivery distance.“

“Cassano's has been around and a favorite for our family a long time. The quality in general has always been consistently good. The pricing gets kinda steep compared to a lot of other chains however, which is really the only downside I can speak of.Their sausage isn't like your typical chunks you find at most other pizza places which allows for a better topping distribution. Light cheese with plenty of pepperoni that crisps up nice. The edges of the pizza where the cheese meets gets nice and caramelized.We got ours light baked so we could finish it at home for dinner. Turned out excellent once finished!“

“Rapid Fires Pizza on Miamisburg Centerville Rd. is a must-try for any pizza lover! The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, and they were happy to answer all of my questions about the menu. I opted for the Hog Heaven pizza, and it was absolutely amazing. It was like a meat lover’s pizza on steroids, loaded with all of my favorite toppings. The crust was perfectly cooked, and the sauce was flavorful and delicious. I will definitely be back to try more of their pizzas soon! #pizza #pizzalover #pizzalovers“

“This place has bluegrass music on Monday nights. We really enjoy going here and listening to music. I've tried the pizza and lasagna--they both are good. Their salads are really good as well. They do serve bottled beer and also have two liter bottles of soda available as well as fountain drinks. They don't have diet Dr Pepper though--if they did it would be perfect. We usually have a lady named Lindsey as our waitress-- she's always been fantastic! If every other waitress in ANY restaurant was one half as good as Lindsey, they would still probably be the best in their establishment. If I ran a restaurant I'd try to steal that lady.“

“Pizza is really Good and with the house made garlic butter that you can use on anything even bagels. There cheezy garlic bread is the bomb. The price for pizza is on the higher end. But the appetizers are decent priced. They also serve bottles of beer here.“

“Well times have changed, it is a different place then when I was a kid, or even when my oldest was. But I think they have done a great job of updating, still very fun for all kids, lots of games as nd lights and noise, my kid loved it. I also think the pizza has gotten better then I remember. So glad they made it through Covid and still here. Way to go.“

“It's been years since I have had Godfather's Pizza. It was good and made very well, but it just didn't have the same taste I remember. The servers and kitchen were amazing and did a great job. ?Parking: This is in a good size shopping center. There is a lot of well lit parking available.“

“By far one of the best assets in the community the Grill at 1320 has great pizza, amazing Dr Pepper Ribs and specials that are amazing. In the middle of 27 amazing golf holes you can enjoy lunch or dinner. The service is amazing and the atmosphere is of an upscale country club.“

“Might be nostalgia, might be an actual great place to eat. Either way I love Cassanos Pizza. Their thin crust with salt on the bottom is seriously top tier pizza. Toppings on the pizza are always above and beyond ingredients.Also, don’t sleep on their appetizers and especially their pizza hoagie with mushroom sauce.It is worth it to try if you have never had it for sure!Kid-friendliness: Kid friendlyParking: A lot of parking“

“I just want to say that since I have first tried Papa's, they've only gotten better. The service is always amazing, especially the guy at the front counter who always gives me the best deals and make sure that I don't spend a penny over what I'm supposed to! And hands up to all the pizza makers because thats some dam# good pizza:) it's one thing to impress me but it's another to keep me impressed;) thnx guys, there's hope in the world. I have not yet dined in, will keep you posted.“

“Been away from the burg for 35 years or so. I've tried a couple Ron's pizza since my return because it was always a town favorite and I grew up eating them back in the 70s Prices of gotten crazy that's for sure it's just a pizza but it's pushing $30 for the family size deluxe Totally different style pizza than what I've been eating for the past 35+ years on the West Coast where there are tons and tons of various pizza joints from low end to mid range to very high end pizzerias I'm still giving Ron's a solid four stars that's actually 3 1/2 More so for consistency than anything else“

“The best pizza there is and I'm sure it's because Sam made it. She's an absolute amazing pizza maker must try out if you have not. This Little pizza spot inside of the marathon gas station is so clean. I can't believe it because most pizza's shops inside gas stations are nasty“