47 Best Pizza Restaurants near Jacksontown

“Owner was SOOOO sweet. My family came on a Monday when they was closed. They was having a marketing/family eating event. She came out and seen us on our motorcycles and offered us to eat there FOR FREE!! ABSOLUTELY AMAZING HOSPITALITY ❤“

“wonderful food, great atmosphere and kind staff! haddock and onion petals are the way to go! all the food looks yummy!“

“If you like Hawaiian pizza and jalapeños, you NEED the Cosmo Kramer from pizza nerds in your life! hands down the best Hawaiian pizza I've ever had. I ordered through Doordash and selected extra cheese and extra pineapple, which can sometimes be hit or miss on doordash, and they DELIVERED. PACKED with flavor, I could write a poem about it. Haven't tried my almond cookies yet but very excited. Thank you for making my Friday night!“

“The best pizza in town! Not to mention the torpedo sub! Always amazing!“

“great spot! great beer and good food. Joe in the kitchen is the man!!! literally you can taste the difference when hes on the line. Chris on the pizza station makes a slappin pie too! love this place. show these boys some love !!! they deserve it“

“Friendly staff, and great pizza.“

“It’s great food!!!!! Check it out you won’t be disappointed!!!!“

“Service was wonderful and quick! Willing to help and make sure our pizzas were just right! Never had a woodfire pizza before and let me tell you..it was DELICIOUS!! I loved the option to custom make it with unlimited topings!! Highly recommend and can't wait to come back!! Oh and loved how affordable it was!“

“Great service awesome foot“

“Tried this place for the first time today and it had a very close to home vibe. Definitely some of the most friendly staff I've ever encountered at a pizza place and the pizza was great! Definitely will be back!“

“Best Stromboli ever!! Totally worth the drive from Warsaw!“

“If you are familiar with cheshire market, I would put one of his Italian subs up against theirs any day! Very good.“

“Dirko’s provided outstanding assistance providing food for a local family. With a short notice. Their employee’s were extremely helpful and the pizzas were delicious. If you’ve not tried Dirko’s, give them a call. Thanks so much! Kim ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Moved to Pataskala 3 weeks ago. We met my niece and nephew at Pizza Cottage, my nephew’s suggestion from previous visits. We ordered 3 different pizzas. All amazing! Even reheated ar home, wonderful! We’ll be back for sure!!“

“Just stopped this evening and picked up a meat lovers pizza on way home from work , it was perfect you guys get it right every time. Thank you!“

“The best pizza ever! Yum!“

“New to the area, so trying all the local spots. 2 weeks ago I ordered a tomato and mushroom. Crust was good and baked properly, but the canned tomatoes and mushrooms made it so bland, threw most of it away. My husband had a meat one, he said it was fine.“

“I drive from Cambridge at least once or twice a month specifically for Debra’s. There’s no other options for pizza for me 😊. Do yourself a favor and try a slice as soon as you pick it up and get it in the car. The taste is unbelievable!!!“

“Note: I'm Not a food critic nor a 'foodie'; if you want such a review, move to NYC. However, I grew up in Nerk & was in town for the holidays & decided to give Alley Cat a try... My wife ordered a 12" Veggie pizza & I got their Full-sized Philly Steak sub & a Full order of their Cheesy Garlic Bread. ALL were EXCELLENT !! One of the Rare exceptions where website/app pics posted by a restaurant Actually matches what you receive as your order. All the ingredients were fresh & the pizza had enough cheese on it to go well with all the veggies that they lavishly heaped on the pie. The crust was a happy medium between not-too-thin & a hand-tossed; it passed for thin in my wife's discerning eyes. Order was ready for pickup at the specified time; owner & chef were very friendly & even called to verify one of my special requests, which most restaurants would've blown off & just made it the way they wanted to. They are the most recent owners, who rely on the Slice app to receive orders, since the original website was not transferred to them in the transfer of ownership.“

“Creno's Pizza Company is a longtime old-school pizzeria chain. The pepperoni pizza is so good! his is the best spot near SPI Spot. You can always try nicely cooked Pepperoni, pizza salads and blt - a special offer of this pizzeria. Creno's provides food delivery for the convenience of its clients. Classic crust with sweet sauce and toppings that go edge to edge.“

“Just picked up a blt pizza and it is fantastic, will definitely be back“

“Great food and great service at Mill Dam Restaurant! Shoutout to Ricki—aka ‘the tender bar lady’ according to my son 😂—for being awesome and making our visit even better. They stay busy, so pack your patience… it’s worth it!”“

“Great pizza, friendly service and very reasonable prices!“

“We have been there three times now and everything has been delicious. The meatballs are delicious and we have had them as an appetizer, on a sub, and on a pizza. The tomato sauce on the pizzas is the best pizza sauce I have had in a long time. Plus the service is amazing! Everyone is so kind and helpful. We will be back soon because I want to try every speciality pizza.“

“our new fav in Newark . The sauce is the best , try it you won't be disappointed“

“I had the dawg pound burger and loved it. I can't wait to try another menu item next time.“

“Very good pizza, we order at least once or twice a week! Great friendly staff and a lifesaver for when I’m to tired to cook after working all day!“

“The quality of the food has went down. As if no one cares about the name anymore.“

“R.I.P. B-dubs! I will never go back there again for wings now that I’ve found Don & Sue’s… hands down the best place for wings in the Newark-Heath-Granville area. Only wish I had found this place earlier. It’s so cool. Very well decked out with a hometown sports vibe. And the food is on point. Great garlic cheese bread, great onion rings, great pizza and now great wings. They have an “extra saucy” option, but there’s no need. My wings were drenched in Carolina Gold (my fav). And to top it all off, Harley was the greatest, nicest, sweetest server I’ve had the pleasure of meeting in ages. Whoever is running this place is hitting on all cylinders. Absolutely my favorite Newark restaurant by far.“

“There's no eating here, unless you're in your car.

Pretty simple pizza joint, you come in, order, and leave. If you're placing one you'll have to wait around or come back later.

Staff are friendly and do their job. ...yeah no real notes here but the food is good. They currently do a discount special for meals before 3pm daily.“

“Fast delivery, delivered piping hot, tastes fantastic! Beat pizza we’ve had in a long time!“

“driving home from OSU, Wexer, remembering that when our daughter lived at Miller sport, we loved this pizza 🍕. ate inside, lots of people waiting for take, a lot of delivery orders going out, and yet we got our pizza and salad in less than 20 minutes...hot and wonderful.“

“I love this pizza. The recipe has been consistent and excellent for many years. This place is super clean, and the staff is exceptionally nice. however, remember when going to pick up this great food, take CASH“

“Excellent Pizza 🍕 Good fast delivery!YAY I didn't have to cook dinner! With a 50% Off WITH Vip CERTIFICATE... Thanks for the certificate I got in the mail. Two XL pizzas for the one price!🍕“

“great food for inexpensive price.“

“Fast and easy service.“

“I always order from here and the food gets here piping hot and on time. Not tonight, waited 2.5 hrs for a pizza and it got here cold!! Called them and waited on hold 10 minutes for a manager who never came to the phone. Definitely not happy!!“

“I live in Mount Vernon Ohio and I drive all the way to North just to get their Pizza. Their Pizza is completely covered in pepperoni and cooked to a crispy perfection. We finally got a Pizza Cottage in Mount Vernon where I am from in the service is horrible as you can see on the reviews I live 10 minutes from Mount Vernon Pizza Cottage I ordered a pizza they told me it would be ready in 20 minutes this is when they very first opened at 11:00 in the morning. I got there within 10 minutes was very surprised that my pizza was ready. When they handed me the Box through the window I found it odd that it was cold. When I got home the pizza was cold as though it had been refrigerated overnight and they didn't even take the time to reheat it it just gave it to me as a cold leftover from last night I'm not joking it was literally refrigerated cold the pizza crust was super rubbery from being stored in the refrigerator. The customer service there is appalling. I will continue to drive to Newark from Mount Vernon to get the greatest Pizza in the world from that Pizza Cottage. Even by the time I get home from there my pizza was hotter than it was from Mount Vernon where I lived 10 minutes away nor have I ever been given cold leftover night pizza from Pizza Cottage of Newark. I would recommend them a thousand times over great customer service very clean restaurant great food always. Mount Vernon is the worst I would never recommend it to anybody not with their childish behavior on the inside nor their cold leftover pizza they didn't even bother to heat up before giving it to me when they first opened. Hopefully it closes down before it gets Pizza Cottage a bad name“

“EXCELLENT PIZZA AND VERY FRIENDLY SERVICE.“

“Friday my daughter & I both had our first Papa Boos experience! 🤩🤩 Alysa and Skye were our servers (sorry if I spelled your names wrong) they were super! Food was BOMB! 🤤 View was to die for! We went home and promptly told my husband we needed to go up once the kids got out of school! 🥰“

“We were in the area (Heath, OH) and decided to get quick lunch. The place is fairly clean and the food was good considering it's kinda fast food and cheap fare. Our cashier Alex just stood up the most. He was kind, patient and informative (we haven't eaten Fazoli in 5-6 years). He takes his job seriously and you can see that. We really appreciate his service.“

“I accidentally ordered 15 minutes to close which if anybody knows how the business is that sucks to get an order so late right before closing everyone there was super kind to me and I kept apologizing, but they were insisting that it was OK. They were very nice to me. The food was fantastic, and all of the staff was very welcoming and appreciated my remorse. Definitely get pizza from this place.“

“As a member of the Guernsey Valley Old Car Club, I visited the restaurant today and enjoyed my meal. My only complaint was that the music, (I grew up in a musical family), was too loud for us to have much of a conversation during our visit. I will still definitely come back again.“

“Great service indoor ordering“

“My wife and I just ordered dominos she had a free pizza from rewards and we both got wings.I would like to thank the team and our friendly driver for our delicious dinner.Thanks again will order again real soon.“

“We were so glad to hear that Pappy's Pizza was BACK!!!! When the original place closed, I was devastated! That Pappy's great flavor ruined my taste for any other pizza joint! Now that they are back, we will continue to make that trip from Columbus to Heath instead of wasting our money on local, mediocre pizza!

I do wish they would keep up their FB page. That is an easy way for customers to spread the good word!

Signed
-Two Happy Pappy's Customers!“