13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Johnstown

“My husband accidentally locked his keys and phone in the car with the pizzas in the truck. Two hours later, the tow service unlocked the car. When he went in to thank them for using their phone to call me and let me know what happened so I could come in, they made us two new pizzas on them! Great customer service!! We never expected that, and were so pleasantly surprised.“

“Great pizza, never disappointed Stromboli absolutely delicious..Need to try some different. 5 stars in my eyes..“

“I wanted to give it two tries before I posted a review because every pizza shop goes through its high and lows. As a person who grew up on the OG Crenos in Zanesville, this place has lived up to the expectations.

Pizza is great, as always, but if you like a crispy crust, get it well done. This is something I do most places these days, though.

But the main point is the Italian sub. It’s so simple but so balanced. I don’t know how else to explain it, it’s just very good.

I’ve been to several different crenos locations, some that have not made it for whatever reason. So bravo to the manager of this store.“

“Super nice staff. On time loading for a ltl pickup. Has some overnight parking off to the right of the docks. Its easier to use the third driveway if u have longer truck or as I am picky about spinning tires and leaving black Mark's. Once loaded they bring paperwork out to u. Then its easier to go out second driveway from dock to turn left to the stop light. Good luck and be safe everyone. Would have given 5 star but no real people restrooms sucks. Plus could use an address # on bldg, I may have missed it but didnt see. Thanks for the timely loading and great staff.“

“Ordered online ahead of time for carryout. Pizza was ready on time, and absolutely delicious!
Nice job on the toppings, sauce, bake, got everything right including the dips. Yay for putting on plenty of pineapple! Thank you

Pepperoni sausage not pictured, eaten immediately ha“

“Great News to report. I graduated in 1991. Eagles Pizza was our hangout spot. I have lived away from Eagles Pizza for many. Dennis the owner is a great man. He is coming near where I live. And bringing the famous Taco Pizza. Try one!!! U rock Dennis and Eagles Pizza!!!“

“Good people making good pie for the right reasons. It’s thin crust. Yet still has a nice chew. Good ingredients. If your in the area, give them a try!“

“This is by far the best pizza in licking county. It has been very consistent. The pizza is always loaded with toppings l, the cheese is great as is the sauce. The pick up orders are always ready upon arrival and the service is always above average.“

“Celebrating my granddaughters 5th birthday!!“

“Traveling through from Michigan where we have very few Sbarro locations outside of malls. Delicious food, very clean restaurant, and an employee with a wonderfully positive and friendly demeanor. Kudos to him (and whoever hired him). This young man deserves a raise. Talked about their freshly shredded cheese and the freshness of the entire process. He sold me on an old favorite! A+ visit, thanks for having us!“

“Love the lunch special! Great food and fast & friendly delivery! My office orders lunch from here at least once a week!“

“08/15/2025 - First time visiting this Roosters with family and friends. It was very busy and the wait was about 30 minutes. I ordered their seasonal Blue Margarita that was very savory. I also ordered my favorite pizza of theirs which is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza which is always delicious. Great service from the hosts and our server. Nice size outdoor patio that you may also dine at (weather permitting). Standard franchise Roosters decor. Spacious parking with tight parking (usually in the evening). Decent prices. Enjoy.“