50 Best Bakeries near Mayfield Heights

“The workers are always very nice and helpful! The cookies are always a great melt in your mouth sweetness, though it is true that it’s not everyones cup of tea. Everything in store is simple and easy to use and barely ever a wait time! 100% reccomend!!“

“I would like to give a big shout out to Devin Who works at the Mayfield giant eagle he really deserves to be employee of the month and get a big fat raise he is the kindest caring person every time I am there he greets hello good morning how are you can I help you with your bags to your car have a great day I would say he should be employee of the month every month and he really does deserve a big shout out thank you Devin for your kindness“

“I love this location but at certain times of the day. During the day the customer service is on point!!! But evening / night it’s trash. The younger employees be needing home training before they get a job because their customer service sucks. But anywho during the day, I love this location and the cookies!“

“I ordered two trays of cinnamon rolls for my granddaughter’s graduation breakfast, and I have to say THE BEST EVER!!! And not only were the rolls delicious, but the service inside the shop was so fun and friendly!! Best wishes for many many years of yummy success!! ❤️“

“No matter what we buy, it’s always delicious. And they have great coffee, too!“

“amazing croissants. I stop by every time I was at the house I had listed for sale on South Taylor“

“Interior is cute. Parking is easily accessible. Customer service was friendly.
Now, the desserts
The cookie I had was rather dry and lacking of the flavor I was hoping for in a "cookie butter" cookie.
The flavor of the peanut butter chocolate cupcake was very underwhelming but the texture of everything was great.
Now...this carrot cake.

Maybe carrot apple?
This carrot cake is moist...decadent...flavorful. Topped with a light cream cheese mixture and crushed nuts that dont distract from the flavor of the cake itself. The cream thats in the middle of the slice is perfect. Hands down best carrot cake I've had.“

“I purchased a cake to celebrate my nieces’s 40th birthday. The cake was simply gorgeous. Ordering was easy and pick up was flawless. However, what impressed me most was the flavor! It was devine❤️ It brought the celebration to another level! This will be my go to for cakes from now on!“

“I cannot tell you enough about this place. It is so good and the workers are very friendly and helpful. I've been there twice in 4 days. They have different cookies every week. They change them on Sundays. I have not been disappointed yet. I love this place.“

“I go there every week to buy food and/or baked goods. They have catered parties for me! Highly recommended!“

“Local small business. Everything is delicious!“

“Everything here is amazing! Such a family atmosphere too!“

“Had a luncheon catered. Everything was delicious and fresh! My favorite Italian store in the area. Everyone is very helpful and friendly.“

“It’s so good but sometimes it’s not good

Vegetarian options: Yeah

Dietary restrictions: J

Parking: Beach wood

Kid-friendliness: They love kids

Wheelchair accessibility: Yeah“

“Lizzie's is our favorite! It's difficult to find a place that's safe for folks with peanut and tree nut allergies, but Lizzie's is it! We love all the baked goods they offer and, even more, we love all the people who work here! Lizzie's is a warm, inviting space with DELICIOUS treats!! If you haven't tried it, you're missing out.“

“Two and Company has amazing, made from scratch, healthy food and the customer service is great! Not to mention you are helping a non-profit with a mission of full integration into the workplace for individuals who have cognitive disabilities. It's a real win for our community!“

“My wife and I wanted something a little different for our wedding cake - Tiramisu. We went to multiple bakeries and were told it wouldn't be possible to make a tiered cake out of tiramisu. When we approached Sophie La Gourmande, they were excited about our idea and made our vision come to life! Our cake turned out even better than we pictured, and of course tasted amazing. Would absolutely recommend them for your next event!“

“The owner is such a kind soul!I was blessed to meet Ella and May! Just as sweet.By the way…… THE COOKIES ARE AMAZING AMAZING DELICIOUS MOIST MELT IN YOUR MOUTH GOOD!

Kid-friendliness: Everything was at eye view to see what was being made.“

“The Chinese Cookies are just like the old days! So perfect!“

“I have been coming here since I was a teenager. I'm in my mid 40s now. I love their selection of produce and local products. Prices are always fantastic. Most people think that going to a market like this is more expensive than a supermarket but that couldn't be further from the truth. You also don't get the variety that miles offers anywhere else. From super hot peppers to winter squash, mushrooms to monstera deliciousa fruit. The staff is always great too. Love this place!“

“A trip to Cleveland’s east side isn’t complete without a stop at Davis’ Bakery. I went in for a rye bread (best this side of NY) and left with chocolate coconut bar, a bag of kichel and some peanut brittle. Hooray for me!!!!!“

“I had the pleasure of trying Anita's Sweet Treats' toffee cookies and strawberry cheesecake, and I must say, they were unlike any desserts I've ever tasted! ? ?
The toffee cookies ? had the perfect balance of sweet and crunch, and the strawberry cheesecake was an absolute delight – rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor. ??
Supporting local businesses like Anita's Sweet Treats is about more than just enjoying delicious treats; it's about helping dreams take flight. Anita's dedication and talent are truly exceptional! I can't wait to see her business grow and hopefully open her own bakery shop soon! ???

For anyone seeking one-of-a-kind desserts, do yourself a favor and try Anita's Sweet Treats. You won't be disappointed!“

“Old school donut and pastry shop. Everything I've tried has been amazing!!“

“Best donuts in the land! So many varieties, made fresh daily. Friendly place . They also do cakes and cookies. Their kid cakes are amazing!“

“I had me a Carmel Ribbon Frappe. Really good. I can't make it home with the cookies I eat all of them.“

“The sweet fix has a bit of work to do but they are on the right track. The desserts need a bit of refining due to the cake sponge was dry, but the frosting is done well. The decor is messy with all the dining tables covered in business papers and stocking items. It would be nice to enjoy the treats in the dinning area but this was not an option. The service is very friendly, courteous and inviting.

Vegetarian options: There are a few vegan item along side normal items.“

“Presti's is always the best place to get yummy treats in Little Italy! Parking can sometimes be a little hairy but it's worth it! Best Tiramisu and cheesecakes! Also, the affogato was a nice little treat!

Parking: You may need to park a little farther away but a short walk is worth it!“

“i recently went to bakery for first time. chocolate Babka is outstanding. worth the price. ❤️“

“UPDATE, November2024: sad to say that Archie's is closed now but they are looking for a new location.

Thank you for the wonderful cake for my daughter's birthday! Everyone was so excited and happy to be able to have a slice of deliciousness! And thank you also for the lovely and sweetest fabulous ladies that work behind the counter. I had the best conversation with them that actually moved me to tears and laughter ❤❤❤“

“We love Sweet Geeks!! My husband recently became a vegan and we found this local bakery. Everything in the store is delicious and the staff is amazing! We will always come back for more!“

“Thank you Sweeter than honeycomb for the beautiful cookies and smash cake for my granddaughters first birthday party. The cookies were amazing in how they looked and tasted. The smash cake was perfect and that also must have been delicious because my granddaughter dug right in! We definitely will be back!“

“Alecsi's is a family serving their Solon family and beyond.“

“About 39 years ago I was at a craft show and a gentleman had a heart issue, I did cpr-it was Mr. Baraona. He lived and I will remember always his wonderful family, and even more the Cassata Cake!! I went to his 50th wedding anniversary...what a nice memory of this family. Keep making that cake. I live in Florida now and I always will remember.“

“Heard about this place from a coworker. Not easy to find - the owner runs her business out of her house. Asian bakeries/patisseries are hard to come by in the Cleveland area so naturally I was excited to try and was not disappointed. Ordered a box of pastries as well as their green tea roll cake. Croissants are the best I’ve had in Cleveland. So many flaky layers, perfect texture, just the right amount of sweetness. Green tea roll cake was also phenomenal. Had bits of red bean and the cream was light and airy. The cake itself was soft and moist. Will be coming back. Highly recommend“

“Absolutely delicious! 1st time customer, 10/10 will visit again“

“A trip to Cleveland’s east side isn’t complete without a stop at Davis’ Bakery. I went in for a rye bread (best this side of NY) and left with chocolate coconut bar, a bag of kichel and some peanut brittle. Hooray for me!!!!!“

“I took my mom to the Giant Eagle in Chesterland for her Covid vaccine.!she received the second shot. I told the folks there but I’d like to just tell everyone, that they did a great job. Very organized, very minimal wait time. Very knowledgeable of the whole process. Very very courteous. I can’t say enough good about the pharmaceutical staff as a Chesterland giant eagle.“

“Cute cafe in a quaint Cleveland neighborhood. The staff was friendly and the food was delicious.“

“I stopped in at Easter to buy chocolate for making buckeyes. First time in since the new owner took over. She was very pleasant. The store is neat and clean and was very well stocked. I'm so glad I have a baking/candy supply store like this near me. I highly recommend.“

“Great pizza and desserts!“

“First time ordering from L+P this week(3 challah, shortbread cookies, and a cake bucket). The challah are beautiful and taste great- we tried all of them. I made my husband hide the cookies so I didn't eat them in one day, and the cake bucket is delicious (What a steal!). You can taste the time and love that goes into these items. Looking forward to our next order!“

“These cookies were so tasty and beautifully made!! They were a huge hit at my wedding shower! 10/10 recommended!!“

“From the moment of ordering over the phone to eating the cake it was A plus service. NADINE was very professional and told her some things I wanted in the cake and wanted her to do most of the creativity for my girlfriends birthday cake. Which you can tell by the pictures she definitely is good at what she does. Communication and the product was superb ?. Definitely recommend and will be back again.“

“Ordered a gluten-free strawberry casada cake for my 33 year old nieces birthday...she never had casada despite being a pastry chef! It was awesome! She loved it too because it wasn't overly sweet! Great job 0:-)“

“The staff are quick, efficient, and some of the friendliest around.“

“Best bagels and doughnuts in the area and an awesome staff. Highly recommended for breakfast, lunch or anytime.“

“Amazing food, friendly fast service and a very nice unique cafe and patio.“

“Very friendly staff. Nice selection of molds. I love the variety of flavorings they offer. The hours are a little inconvenient for those who have jobs aside from baking so I can't get there as often as I'd like. They are very resourceful too.“

“I recently had breakfast at Edwin’s Bakery and it was fantastic! The food was delicious, with generous portions and a great variety of options. The prices were incredibly reasonable, making it a great value for the quality and quantity of food. The staff was friendly and attentive, and the atmosphere was cozy and welcoming. I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a tasty and affordable breakfast!“

“Totally agreed with Candise Bivens‘s comment from below. The ladies at Payne avenue are rude and not friendly at all. I like the service at Cleveland heights location wayyyy better.“