12 Best Sandwich Shops near New Carlisle

“My boyfriend and I came here the other day and had a great experience. The women making our sandwiches were so nice and did an excellent job. I'm sorry I didn't catch their names. I haven't been to a Subway in a long time because the ones where I used to live were very disappointing but these were absolutely delicious, packed full and made with care. Thank you!“

“Under new ownership. Great customer service and did a great job. I did not catch their names but it was a gentlemen and a lady working on 6/17/2025. Food was great and even listened to exactly what my picky kids wanted on their subs lol. 5*“

“Always great subs and fast service !! 🙂“

“I stopped in tonight after work to grab dinner for myself and a coworker...Sangita and Kavi were so nice. They prepared our subs just as we wanted. They weren't sloppy and sliding all over. They smiled, laughed and joked with us. They were very pleasant. Service like that is rare. Thank you Sangita and Kavi for a nice experience! :-)“

“I was SO impressed with the professionalism from the entire staff. I was painting next door, so I frequented this location several times over a week. Every time, I was greeted warmly, served promptly, and the food was top quality!“

“House Pizza is good. No complaints. I ordered online and went to pickup. I was told it would be 5- 10 minutes. Okay. 10 minutes later, someone comes out and asks what I ordered. I tell them. They apologize and now need to make a new pizza for me.....I know stuff happens. Seems like the ball got dropped a few times. I'll be back!“

“Nasty…..don’t wear gloves. Took the food cutter and start fanning with it. NASTY“

“I gotta say the past few years this location really went downhill and in the past two months the turnaround has been quite impressive. This location couldn’t even remember cheese on a sandwich before. And haven’t had any issue in A Few months now keep up the great work“

“I went to JJ on Saturday and it was amazing. I never leave reviews, but I just have to. Thank you to the awesome staff for being so friendly and upbeat and making two delicious Totally Tuna sandwiches! I had an ‘Unwhich’ and it was beautifully wrapped and didn’t even fall apart. Unfortunately I am not able to remember your names, but there were two gentlemen and a lady. Thank you again! You are awesome and the best experience I have had at any take out place!“

“I am not a local to Dayton so, I haven’t tried super Subbys. Decided to drive through a location with a drive thru. The woman taking the order was very friendly & patient with me. I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich & a side salad. The sandwich was delicious, loved the mayonnaise. Side salad was also pretty large & tasted fresh. Prices comparable to chain sub places. #supportlocal.“

“Huber heights has been severely lacking in the subway department. They are either not open or not fully staffed or they don’t have anything available. EXCEPT this one!!! I went today for the first time in forever and they were fully staffed (4 people were behind the counter working on orders), the veggies were fully stocked, they were baking fresh bread, and all of the workers I spoke with were EXTREMELY nice! When subway was franchising out I feel like every other owner did not do well. This store was clean, fast, and exceeded my expectations. Thank you!“