13 Best Sandwich Shops near New Carlisle

“I went in with my friends today to have subway pizza. The employee Chandu was very friendly and very welcoming. She always had a smile on her face and made sure we are happy with the food. Subway pizza here was the best I have had in a while.“

“Under new ownership. Great customer service and did a great job. I did not catch their names but it was a gentlemen and a lady working on 6/17/2025. Food was great and even listened to exactly what my picky kids wanted on their subs lol. 5*“

“Always great subs and fast service !! 🙂“

“Great service and attention to detail on my subs for me and the wife, thank you Kavi & Shruthi. My wife very pleased with the sandwich and over appearance was pleasing“

“I was SO impressed with the professionalism from the entire staff. I was painting next door, so I frequented this location several times over a week. Every time, I was greeted warmly, served promptly, and the food was top quality!“

“Cheyenne was our server one of the best service i’ve ever had. She was attentive and always willing to go the extra mile. If you ever find yourself was at this Subhouse and cheyenne is your server consider yourself lucky. I got the teezer burger which is always my go to with a side of fries and it never disappoints.“

“Nasty…..don’t wear gloves. Took the food cutter and start fanning with it. NASTY“

“This is the best subway in the area. The employees are nice, food is always good. My husband and I come here at least once a week. Last time we walked in one of the employees (I didn't get his name,) pulled out the bread we like before we even got up to the counter lol.“

“This Jimmy John’s location is excellent! The staff is fast, friendly, and always gets the order right. My sandwich was super fresh, well-made, and came out incredibly quick — exactly what you expect from Jimmy John’s at its best. The store is clean and well-organized, and the overall service feels consistently reliable. Definitely one of the better Jimmy John’s locations I’ve visited. Highly recommended!“

“My wife and I had a 2 footlongs for 12.99$ coupon. We both got the Chipotle Steak on wheat bread. The 2 young ladies were cordial and friendly. They did not bat an eye when I asked they go heavy on the onions, black olives and banana peppers. We then went home feeling so joyous this Subway treated us with beautiful reserve, as if we were customers which really mattered, sending us on our way with delicious delightful wonders to be consumed while watching television in our humble abode. I so wanted hug the young ladies and tell them they are both true and capable sandwich artists. We traveled back home in possession of 2 Subway sandwich’s which should be exhibits at the Dayton Art Museum.“

“It’s July 1st 2026 , around 6:30 I walked into Penn Statin with my grandson to eat A sandwich and some fries it wasn’t super busy at the moment that is until we sat down then it became extremely busy. There’s three people total and they’re working I could tell one gentleman was new he was kind of lost, but then there was Josh and Shay and I have never seen two people worked so hard to clear that rush .Josh was fixing orders that I believe the new man messed up. I can say that without feeling bad because he messed up mine. But these two people worked hard. I think they need a raise for sure they were trying to rake make it right for all their customers bravo Josh and Shay. I hope you have the fourth off because you deserve it after a night like tonight“

“I am not a local to Dayton so, I haven’t tried super Subbys. Decided to drive through a location with a drive thru. The woman taking the order was very friendly & patient with me. I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich & a side salad. The sandwich was delicious, loved the mayonnaise. Side salad was also pretty large & tasted fresh. Prices comparable to chain sub places. #supportlocal.“