23 Best Italian Restaurants near Sylvania

“My wife and I decided to get dinner here for our anniversary on a whim after driving by it daily, and it wad a great decision. The food, the atmosphere, and especially the service were phenomenal and we can't remember the last time we came away this satisfied with a dining experience.“

“We were in Toledo for the marathon and popped in for dinner. Very crowded but we got seated within half an hour. Great staff,and friendly service all around, Kim our waitress was excellent, very attentive, friendly and on point.great crowd of people. My wife had grilled mahi which came with a really nice sauce; I had eggplant Parmesan which was quite tasty. The soup was quite nice. Our mussels were good, but the sauce was just way too lemony to the point where it dominated the dish and left the mussels clamoring for attention. Similarly, my side dish of fresh spinach was tasty but way over salted (and I love salt). Apart from those little suggestions, no complaints.“

“Wonderful little Italian restaurant in a strip mall in Maumee. We were fortunate to catch live piano playing during our Tuesday evening dinner. Surprisingly good wine list for such an out of the way location. Good food, good service and good atmosphere.“

“I haven't been here in several years, but they didn't disappoint! Just love the hot mama bread and Stromboli ? Tasted just like I remembered!!!! Waitress was exceptional, although I don't remember her name. Definitely will be back“

“My dad and I had the best meal in as long as we can remember. We had lettuce wraps, Tuboui, and split the Cabob dinner. Still could not eat it all and need to take home. At the end the Turkish coffee was soo good and rich in taste. Best coffee.“

“First time here and it’s in my opinion, the newest hidden gem in the area. Fresh taste, great quality, very flavorful, and very reasonably priced. Our server Teri was outstanding. Being Sicilian decent and an amazing cook myself, this place is a 10/10. I love the variety of choices on the menu. I also love the quaint atmosphere of the restaurant. We will be back sooner than later.“

“I ordered a pizza from the facili. Did and ask for extra cheese and toppings? Usually facilities don't take the time to make your request. Great, but Philip. And this facility from the cooks to the delivery. Was phenomenal thanks, guys. I will be ordering from you again soon.“

“Great award winning pizza ? they had no dine in today. Might want to call first if you want to dine in. The pizza was delicious cooked perfectly. Nice sweet sauce. Don't drive by. Get in there and try some pizza..........“

“Needs a little updating inside but the pizza was pretty good. Our server was kind, helpful and prompt. We'll go back to try another pizza or maybe some pasta.Vegetarian options: Choose your own pizza has several vegetarian options. Egg salad sandwich and typical apps are also vegetarian.“

“I was overly impressed with everything from the fast delivery and the food......WOW!!!!! Thick crispy crust on the pizza was spectacular!!!!! Fold over Italian was okay. Delivery driver followed my specific directions precisely also!!!! Definitely ordering pizza from them from now on!!!! Great job to all of you ?♥️“

“Super cute little restaurant with AMAZING food!Vegetarian options: The veggie sautee sandwich is one of the best sandwiches I've ever eaten! I don't like mayo or mustard, but they were so kind to replace those with pesto per my request. They have a lot of vegetarian options here, so I'm definitely coming back to try more on their menu!“

“Tyler and the crew are top notch, this location reminds me of why Vitos is a toledo pizza staple. You can not go wrong when this crew is together. The Italian fold over sub we had was worthy of advertisement, the Packos pizza was everything and then some!!!! Unfortunately they don't deliver to my neighborhood but it is so worth the 5 min drive to pick up their creations“

“Decent experience! No complaints. We got this DELICIOUS pink prickly pear cocktail, and holy crap, I wanted a pitcher of it hahaha. It was bright and colorful and refreshing. Food was great too. My girl friend got the fried lasagna which apparently she gets every time she comes here lol and I got the stuffed ziti fritta which was cheesy and delicious too“

“Our server Greg was amazing and made the experience wonderful. He was so attentive and so accommodating. Will definitely be back just for the excellent service. The entree seemed to have been sitting out for some time as the food wasn't hot so I took a star off but the service, soup and salad made up for it.“

“Gonna be honest, it’s Sidelines sports bar but upscaled for Italian dining. I wasn’t expecting anything fancy and they definitely met+exceeded expectations but it’s not a fine-dining experience either. They left a tablet on the table when they sat us but never explained what the tablet was for and our server didn’t use it? She just took it back after our food order was put in. Table bread was the best thing on the menu. Also highly recommend the Bedford Mule, even if you’re not a typical Moscow Mule fan.Parking lot is small so don’t let a full lot trick you into thinking there’s a huge wait. We got sat right away and there were only 2 open spots when we pulled in. The party ahead of us only waited because they were large.Got the pesto rigatoni chicken and it was delicious. Will definitely be back some time in the future. :)Wish there were more appetizer options. The Arancini was good but would like to see something simple like mozzarella sticks or something too. :)“

“ordered the deep dish pepperoni on 4-26-2023, which is as good as any Detroit-style pizza I've had. I talked to a bot when I called in my order which was a bit awkward and I ended up ordering an extra side of wings, but it was ok! 'Cause it all tasted great.“

“Edit:2024 thought with a coupon we would try em' again. So much better than last visit. Everything was so much better very pleased. Must have caught them on a bad day 2 years ago. Yeah give them a tryEdit 2022: my meal was a giant pile of mush toped with a absurd amount of some plain (spaghetti??) Sause. Not going backGreat name recognition food & service good. I would go back. My fault for having sky high expectations (I was thinking 5 stars). Gave them 3“

“I usually order Hungry Howie’s but they don’t deliver to my address so I pick up my pizza. Tonight I didn’t feel like going out in the cold so I decided to order from Marcos for the first time… Our pizza was awesome!! We’ll be ordering again!!“

“I always get pizzas from Vito's and usually always satisfied other than I ask for them to cut it in squares and they don't so with that being said I live at Collingwood Nebraska and that is not far from South Detroit and they will not deliver I'm disabled do not have a vehicle so there you “

“Hands down the BEST pizza you can get in Toledo! ?????? Gino's Italian Delites in Toledo, Ohio on Eastgate has and will ALWAYS be the ONLY "Gino's" pizza we support! They have the BEST customer service and the BEST tasting pie I've ever had (and I have had a lot of pies in NYC). They are a family favorite that we have been going to for YEARS! Their service is impeccable and the food is one of a kind! I am always proud to support such an amazing a small business, family owned business like Gino's Italian Delites that is locally loved my SO many! ?????? You seriously can't beat it! Fresh made dough, double convection pizza oven instead of a conveyor and LOADS of cheese!!!! Just look at that cheese pull in my photos! We got an XL pepperoni and extra cheese pie, a large deluxe with extra cheese and a large pie with ranch instead of marinara (the Alfredo sauce is bomb too!!) with extra cheese, extra mushrooms, onions and green peppers. My family requests this when we have pizza night and it is well worth the drive to go pick it up! (Photos: menu, location/website, our order - extra large pepperoni with extra cheese, large deluxe with extra cheese and the cheese pull, large with ranch, extra cheese, extra mushrooms, green peppers and onions and look at that cheese pull!!!) You can't beat the ooey, gooey, cheesy pizza pie LOADED with toppings that Gino's Italian Delites brings to your palate! Thank you, Gino's fam!! The Fields' family loves you!! ❤️??❤️??❤️☺️“

“The pizza was delicious we were very happy with it and my husband isn't the easiest to please, the only reason I gave it a 4 instead of 5 is because we ordered a large pizza and it was pretty small. Other than small size it was awesome!!“

“My company has ordered catering from Piada on multiple occasions for our office and each time has not disappointed. The staff loves the delicious food and gets incredibly excited when they see we are catering them again. Our company would love to give a special shout-out to Tristan, the local sales rep for Toledo, as each time we’ve ordered, he has ensured we have everything we need to be able to provide for such a large volume of staff. Overall a 10/10 on food and customer service. We will absolutely continue to order from Piada.“

“I ordered POLLO PICATTA Grilled Chicken Breast, Herb Linguine Pasta, Artichokes, Capers, Prosciutto, Lemon Butter, Della Casa Salad washed down with Forbidden Sour. Friendly courteous service. Cool Cozy atmosphere. Reasonably priced food with good portions ????“