37 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Milton

“Delicious pizza and cheesy bread!!“

“Cannot express how good our pizza & sandwich was from here. Highly recommend!!“

“Last 2 weeks we've ordered delivery, out here on Shiloh Road, pizza was awesome 👌 hot and perfectly baked, definitely will keep ordering!!!!!❤“

“Visited for the first time tonight and not only was our food delicious, but the customer service was top notch. While we live around 45 minutes away, we will be back and of course recommending to others!“

“Ok so we’ve dined at Old Scratch Troy location about 6 times since it’s opened. Waited a bit to give them time to really get in their groove. While I do recommend the place. Pizza is good, staff is nice (especially Amanda at the bar) and shareables are tasty. That said I would like to see the food’s taste be a little more consistent. My favorite dish is the fire roasted cauliflower but sadly it hasn’t been prepared the same way twice with the last two times it was barely seasoned at all once it was almost raw. Hopefully as training continues they will fix that issue.“

“Found this little gem on the internet. The food was absolutely fantastic. We all enjoyed the food. My friend tried lamb for the first time. She was in heaven. The server was great. My only complaints were the lamb was overcooked, but still juicy, and the kids running all over the place (and the boy that was hitting his brother with a belt, not hard, but still annoying).“

“Hoagie's was a staple for me in the 80s and early 90s when I lived nearby and worked in the Poe Avenue area. It had been a long time since I'd visited so I drove over (across town from Fairborn - about 25 minutes one way) and ordered when I got there. I got two pizzas, a whole Spider (one of my all time favorite sandwiches) and the stuffed garlic bread. I grabbed a Coke and sat outside on their patio in the lovely weather. 20-ish minutes later, they brought my order right out to me. It think it was about $40 and well worth it. The pizza was just as I remembered it - the big thing I love is their sauce has a great tomato flavor and isn't too sweet. Great crust and well topped. I ordered my wife's pizza light sauce and they did it perfectly. The Spider was everything I remembered and the stuffed bread sticks might be my wife's new favorite thing. They have a nice amount of inside seating and the staff was very friendly. While I was waiting outside, it was a constant stream of folks coming for pickup orders. Hoagie's is as good as I remember and it will be on our regular rotation going forward. I just made me happy to reconnect with some of those memories from my first job working in that area and to get back to Hoagie's. If you have the chance, you should go.“

“Marions pizza is one of our go-to pizza places in the Dayton Area! If you like a Dayton Style Pizza it's a must try!“

“Best Food ever“

“Went there for the first time tonight, and will be back! pizza was really good and the staff was great!“

“This place is awesome, and WAY better than Cassano’s. I didn’t get the server’s name, but her and the crew are awesome at this job. They were super friendly. I got a 13” Deluxe, a 9” Ham and Kraut, and a reuben sandwich, and it all tasted amazing! Piled with toppings, great flavor, and a perfect crispy crust. My overall rating is a 10/10, and I highly recommend it. Get your pizza here!“

“I eat pizza 3 or 4 days out of the week(sometimes more than once a day). I know these workers better than their parents do. I know when I roll up to the window and I see those familiar faces I’m about to have the most slaptastic pizza that’s ever come out of an oven forged by whatever 5 star gourmet chefs this location hires. Pizza FIRE. Bread twists FIRE. Loaded tots FIRE. Pasta? You better believe that’s FIRE. I didn’t even like Dominos pizza before I moved to Englewood. I love you Englewood Dominos workers. I don’t like you. I love you. FIRE.“

“We ordered the Stromboli’s today and they were delicious. We drove from Springfield and it was worth the drive….delicious food and friendly staff (Jeremy). We will definitely come back!“

“Pizza is good. You need to be more generous with your toppings for the prices you are charging. I will be back again. Thank you for the excellent service.“

“I have been there twice, I have had the Detroit 8 corner pizza, and the Eugene Supreme. Both were amazing, I’m the type of person that could eat pizza everyday (Totinos to high end) and not get tired of it.Staff very accommodating to any reasonable request. Their marinara pizza sauce is heaven. I would highly suggest to try it, I think you’ll like it. BTW the Detroit crust is heaven also.“

“Super big shout out to Jeremy at Fazolis,in Troy, OH. They provided Troy Christians Basketball team dinner and the boys are very blessed. Thank you again!“

“we love coming to eat there We drive all the way from West Chester.“

“my family always orders dominos. It would be nice if I could get the dipping sauces I paid for!“

“The pizzas are always good, but they are ALWAYS so short-staffed. If they had a full staff they would have pizzas done faster, and not a line of people waiting all the time.

The staff they have are kind and respectful, and I'm sure they work as fast as they can, but overall be ready to wait for your pizza for a while.

The pizzas I would rate 8/10
I would recommend.“

“Thank you Vandalia Dominos! Yesterday I placed an order and told them it was for our Vandalia Police Department! When I picked it up this afternoon they told me it was all donated!! Thank you for helping us thank our local police department!! Today- there are still good people! 💙💙💙 thank you!!!“

“I absolutely loved this place. They provided a gluten free, and vegan dairy free cheese options. The gluten-free crust was a wonderful texture that tasted like dough bread, rather than cardboard, like most glute free pizza crust options. They also offered a wide variety of veggie toppings that were so delicious. The best part is regardless of what you order. Your order is cooked and served within ten minutes or less. I highly recommend this pizza stop, especially for those with gluten and dairy sensitivities. However, due to the setup of the facilities, they can not guarantee no cross contamination. Therefore, I would not recommend going here if your allergies are dangerously severe.“

“Yes they are back up to speed with a force. Return of the chicken parmigiana and the turkey hoagie. I had not been there for a while. We ordered both the above and a pizza for delivery. All came piping hot in 35 mins as promised. Great job guys.“

“Always a good time with good food!“

“The hardest part about ordering at Domino’s is deciding what to get. I love the pizza, the sandwiches, and the brownies! The service has always been top notch too!“

“Customer service has gotten better and they seem to be cleaning the store better. Food was fresh and hot and I didn’t have a wait on a Saturday night.“

“Always good pizza! The staff are always friendly also!“

“We had a couple of drinks with onion rings and a 12 inch cheese pizza. Bartender was excellent, I thought the onion rings were greasy but my hubby loved them. Pizza was good tasting. It’s a cool light type home town bar, my favorite kind. I will be back.“

“Good review for Salmon pizza which is just great! Eating a whole pizza by myself ....bad review for me“

“Our delivery was here before expected. the order was 100% correct and hot. thanks!“

“the new manager, has really improved here in Vandalia, he listens to the cust and makes it happen everyone wanted the pizza buffet back, and it's back, ate there today w family, it was great. will dine there more often now. great value also for lunch buffet waitress was fantastic“

“This place was awesome! The staff were incredible and we enjoyed the food! They have a bar area and a family dinning room for any occasion. Had a great time talking with the wait staff and the young lady who brought our food out. they have a coney dog as an appetizer that comes with chili, cheese and I believe onions. The chili was fantastic and made right there in the kitchen. Comes in mild or spicy. The tenderloin was hot and crispy along with the potato wedges. The sweet tea was awesome as well. Really enjoyed this place and will be back soon! Thanks for a great time!“

“Enjoyed hanging with friends playing bingo and laughing. Wings were awesome“

“Excellent subs, beat any other sub place around“

“great food! but even a better staff super friendly and helpful!🍕🍕🍕🍕“

“I have loved this pizza my whole life every time I come home from vacation or other issues I get a pizza and always great. The young lady at the Tipp store is always so sweet and nice. She makes me feel like we known each other for years. I don’t know her name but she is expecting soon. I hope the company takes really good care of her. People like her are hard to find.“

“Perfect Pizza ever time for over 50 years !!! I never visit Dayton without getting a Cassanos Pizza EXCELLENT customer service!“

“To be honest, I didn't know it, but they are renovating the restaurant. We ate in the dining room but should have just taken it to go. It is dusty and messy inside. However, the food was great. It was hot and the pizza VERY good! The service was great, the lady that took our order was very kind and took great care of us. I am looking forward to seeing the place when it is finished. My recommendation, however, is to order food to go (or delivery) until the renovations are complete.“