50 Best American Restaurants near Fort Erie

“My experience was fantastic. We went there on November 20, 2025. Our wait staff was over the top. He kept checking on us. The only thing that I wasn't happy with was that they don't let you keep the itemized receipt at the end of your meal. My Fish dinner was out of this world and Haley's roast beef sandwich was also excellent. Everyone treated us so nice there.“

“Between myself, the wife and father in law.... we could not find fault with the food. Everything was tasty and even though the waitress tried to warn me about the heat level of the Ring of Fire sauce, she was not condescending.

Needless to say the sauce was rather hot and had me gasping for air, but none the less was extremely tasty. The next time I'm down the area I will certainly be stopping by.“

“Nice to sit outside and view lake Erie
Little dark inside but lovely woman who served me made me feel welcomed . Free pool
Nice flowers outside.
You can really feel the old history in this place. Was surprising ,
It's rustic but because of the nice woman she made it feel homey and friendly
Not food today as not much of a menu but will try but she makes soup im told in fall ..which i love so I'll keep posted if I do“

“A quaint little place on the river… great vibe, delicious food and Lauren was a blast to have as a server… she really made it a great experience!“

“Place is amazing. Food is always great. Great specials. Portions are always big and the price is reasonable. Staff is just so darn nice as well! I go every week basically!“

“Wow, Very impressed with the food and service. First time there and it won't be the last...“

“Best food in buffalo hands down !“

“Beautiful atmosphere, hand crafted cocktails, fresh seafood, amazing desserts and attentive servers. What more do you need to know. If you haven’t tried this place yet, what are you waiting for?“

“We stopped in on a Tuesday because we were shopping in the area and are so glad we did! The waitstaff was friendly and attentive, the ambiance was nice (maybe the music could be lowered), and the food was amazing! I had the duck two ways and it was gorgeous and perfectly cooked. He had the enormous pork chop, also cooked perfectly and juicy. Great cocktails and apps as well. Highly recommend.“

“What a great atmosphere! The food & drinks were absolutely amazing 🤩 Thank you!“

“Great food ! Came out fast and was hot and fresh. Definitely would recommend The Place if you are looking for a good meal at a reasonable price.“

“We had a delicious meal and our server was wonderful. What a charming and cozy atmosphere.“

“Every time I’ve eaten at the Phoenix 269 the food was incredible- the service is perfect. I love the atmosphere and the patio. It’s a cozy, family run business that makes you feel like your eating with family! I had the shrimp dish / it was delicious. The ice cream pie was unbelievably good! I’ll be back.“

“Excellent food, excellent service, extremely clean and just a bright. The Beef on Weck was so tender.“

“the smoked turkey&rib plate was more filling than I expected. the flight of bourbon was educational.our server was spot on too,Justinnothing to complain about,oh and clean rest rooms too.plan on returning too.trying to post this.“

“Bacchus…THANK YOU for a wonderful meal with great service. We thoroughly enjoyed our entrees of Lobster tortellini, shrimp puttanesca and pork chop. The octopus app was delicious too. Service was outstanding and the valet driver even remembered our car! Impressive! We’ve dined here many times and will continue to do so!“

“Came here a few months ago to get fish fry and couldn’t find the name to write a review. Turns out I followed the shop’s page on facebook!
Anyway, their fish fry is great especially for the price of $12!! I 1000% recommend giving it a try on a friday!
Customer service was great the man who served me seemed so happy to help us and he was so welcoming!
Def gotta circle back to try their ice cream ☺️“

“This is such a cool, new and chill restaurant and bar. I really enjoying old fashions, and I know how difficult it is to make one and always make it the same. The bartenders have such great skills and training that I couldn’t even tell which ones made them, as they each tasted the same and amazing.“

“My girlfriends and I have not been to Iron Tail in a while, but we decided to go on a whim the other night and it did not disappoint!! The drinks were fabulous, food was great and the staff was on point!! Definitely recommend this place 👍🏻“

“This small business has a great family vibe. The food was ahmazing! the meatballs with ricotta are like no other. Their chicken, stuffed mushrooms, and roast beef were cooked and seasoned to perfection. They have a lot of seafood options, clams and scalops too. The owner and chef, Mark is out and about interacting with patrons and even plays the harmonica for you! He is very talented, he vame out to play happy birthday for someone across the restaurant and even came over to our work christmas party to play some christmas music. It is a gem of a place, if you are in kenmore and want dinner or just a glass of wine at a quiet bar or a warm friendly place, they are wonderful. I highly recommend them for dinner and small business dinner parties.“

“Even though I had to pay for parking across the street, it was worth it. Good food. Very nice workers. Even liked one of the friendly workers who was in a singing mood! 😂🙂“

“love red top, love to stop and have a hot dog“

“Have been going here forever. It’s been a while and still top notch! Warm, charming atmosphere, consistent, fantastic service. Great place for a date, we had a great night , thank you!“

“The food was delicious, the server was fantastic and the mimosa was perfect for my breakfast. 10/10 recommending anyone to visit.“

“Best place in town. The food is fantastic and always consistent. Reasonably priced as well.“

“I literally love this charming establishment, you'll find the best big breakfast menu with affordable prices. The generous portions and delightful flavors will leave you satisfied, while the warm smiles and welcoming atmosphere created by the employees make you feel right at home. Their genuine warmth and attentive service truly enhance the dining experience. It's a breakfast haven where delicious food, friendly faces, and wallet-friendly prices come together to create an unforgettable morning meal.“

“Awesome food! Great service LOVE it here!“

“Omg! The food was wonderful! My granddaughter even ate all of her food and never usually does. My hubby couldn’t even finish his dinner! Everything that we ordered was delicious and I’m very picky about eating out because so many establishments change their food because of the economy. Spot on! Great experience!“

“Growing up in south Buffalo Texas hots was a staple for the neighborhood and since it’s random closing Jimmys is the only place that has a special sauce not only close to them but better. The employees and atmosphere of the business is genuine, welcoming and overall a very good experience. Truly happy to have found Jimmys and can’t wait to go back!“

“The Celtic Menu was planned for this week and a friend and I ordered the Seafood light cream soup and Fall salad with romaines, toasted hazelnuts, grilled orange slices,et cetera to start ! Each was so very delicious ! Before that we were given their complimentary amusebusce ( sp.? ) of their homegrown cherry tomatoes, flavored butter and asparagus. The breadbasket had Irish soda bread,and one other roll. My entree was two pieces of beautifully fried fish, and shoestring French fries,and Cole slaw. Best that I’ve ever had ! Another entree was a lamb pasty with vegetables. The crust was marvelous and the lamb gently seasoned. We could not resist the ‘pot pie’ on a light,crust with delicious vegetables. 2 desserts were offered but we must leave room for those on another visit ! The chef takes time to come out to the tables to check about the food,and the staff is VERY attentive . This was a wonderful experience, as every time we attend ! Treat yourself !“

“Played course since the 70's - weekend trips!!!!!“

“I found this place by chance while coming back from Niagara Falls, and it was such a pleasant surprise! The atmosphere is very welcoming, the service is excellent, and the prices are very affordable. It’s a cozy spot to relax and enjoy with friends or family. Definitely a place I’ll return to and highly recommend!“

“You have got to appreciate a restaurant that offers a few things done exceptionally well over countless options that are just okay. Swiston’s has top-tier souvlaki and roast beef sandwiches. Incredible items at incredible prices.“

“Always an amazing experience at Vice. Service is always on point, the food is fresh and the cocktails are some of the best in Buffalo.“

“Like a light at the end of a dark tunnel, Rodney’s came to the rescue! We initially went for lunch at a very new, trendy new spot on Lakeshore Road. After a 20 minute wait, we were seated. The place was so loud! No band. No loud music. Just loud everything else. People talking, dishes clanking and who knows what else, it was so loud. There’s no way you could carry on a conversation without shouting. So we left right away. Next we tried a popular seafood restaurant nearby and were treated like second-class citizens just by inquiring how long the wait was. Out of there. Rodney’s was almost across the street so we went there. Best idea ever! Our hostess was friendly. Our server was a hoot. Funny, helpful and got everything exactly right. The food was excellent too. A cozy, clean spot right by the lake. I recommend Rodney’s highly.“

“Great Place before or after Sheas!“

“Excellent food will definitely be our regular go to. Our waitress Tatiana was very professional and sweet.We highly recommend The Delaware you won't be disappointed.“

“Went to Betty’s today for a little brunch/lunch today! We had Brian as our server, he was super attentive, gave great recommendations, and kept our waters refilled (huge plus). The portions were perfect if not bigger than we could eat. We enjoyed the patio and being able to eat outside. Definitely will be back!“

“On the phone Alex is especially great. He was very accommodating.“

“We had Easter brunch today and it was fantastic! Both of my kids loved it! So friendly and nice! And super reasonable! Already looking forward to their normal brunch on the weekends!! And the 2nd floor is so pretty and airy ❤️“

“Went to celebrate a friends job promotion and had a wonderful time here. I had the P250 burger, which was not only reasonably priced for this place but very delicious. Really enjoyed the shoestring fries as well and trying a different appetizers that were ordered for the table. Though I’m completely blanking on our servers name, he was fantastic and so accommodating for our party.“

“Went there before a play for dinner at Shea's Buffalo. This place is on the Chippewa bar strip, so we were not expecting much. Walking inside, it looks like a typical party/cocktail bar, brick walls, long bar, and tables opposite the bar with plastic chairs and Formica tables, so you are sitting in the bar. At 5:30PM on restaurant week before a nearby playing of Hamilton, we were the only diner's there (and only 4 others at the bar). Now the good part.... one of the best meals I have had in a long time!!!!! Waitress/bartender was prompt, attentive and friendly. The special for restaurant week that we had was $35 for soup/salad (I had soup), Duck with asparagus, yams, sprouts and and pie for dessert. This meal was fabulous! Perfect portion and perfect flavor. The caramel/peanut butter pie was luscious! On top of all this, we were there during happy hour, so $3 a beer. I highly recommend trying this place to eat, just don't expect a cozy, intimate atmosphere. You won't be disappoints, and you won't be broke.“

“Hoak’s was such a cool place to visit right on Lake Erie. I had the chicken dinner and a bowl of their French onion soup. The soup was pretty good, a little too much pepper. The chicken was meh. Their blue cheese is homemade and very good. There aren’t really any healthy options at this restaurant. The service was pretty good. Sat right away and got our food right away. It was cool seeing all the photos on the walls of the history of the restaurant.“

“We love Big John!!!“

“Exceptional banquet hall!“

“This place is special. The service is next to none !!outstanding!! The food is extraordinary to say the least!! Period!! The cocktails are unique and their nuances are more than refreshing. Jake Strawser the owner is the real deal and honestly a pleasure to call my friend. There are now two Ian’s that will not disappoint you. Ian the exemplary Chef and Ian the wonderful Barman!!! Make your reservations now. Trust me.“

“Service was fantastic !!! Food and drinks were great .“

“Friendly staff…yummy food“

“From out of town. Recommended to us by Island Shipping Center. Was spot on. Great food,service and atmosphere. Highly recommend.“