26 Best Bakeries in St. Catharines

Edible Options Bakery • $
395 Ontario St Unit 2, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Our Week at a Glance
Peanut Butter Ball
Cashew Cheesecake
Cinnamon Raisin
Chicken Pot Pie
Chocolate Chip
Whoopie Pie
Hot Dog Bun
Bagel Day
Focaccia

“THEE BEST gluten free (&dairy free) anything that I’ve ever tried. Their pizza buns & Nanaimo bars are 👌🏻💯. It is so wonderful to have options!!!!“

4.7 Superb112 Reviews
de la terre bakery Bakery • $
55 Geneva St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Breakfast Sandwich Egg and Peameal Bacon
Salmon Sandwich and Salad
Veggie Breakfast Sandwich
Herb and Chive Croissant
Focaccia French Toast
Chocolate Croissant
Various Delectibles
Fresh Baked Goods
Chicken Shawarma
Ham and Cheese

“We have been picking up sourdough here weekly, they have a great number of options on the daily and special breads that come out as well. It's nice to find a real good crusty sourdough! My fiance loooooves their mini pecan pies, I loved there cruffins. We would pass on the cookies in the future as we prefer soft cookies and there crispy but that's more of a preference as the flavour was also great. All around a fantastic place.“

4.5 Superb214 Reviews
Sugar + Butter Baking Co Bakery • $
11 Summer St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Mocha Latte
Drip Coffee
Cookies

“Discovered this hidden gem today in st. Catharines. Walked in to a delicious smelling spot. The lavender latte and cream cheese stuffed pretzel were a yummy morning treat. Wide variety of treats and drinks. The man behind the counter was welcoming, friendly, and patient while I decided what treats to get for me and the kids. Reasonable prices.“

5 Superb62 Reviews
The Keto Crumb. Bakery • $
30 Church St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

NY Cheesecake Cinna'Roll Lemon Square
Muffins Brownies Bagels Sourdough
Peanut Butter Chocolate Cupcake
Goat Cheese and Berry Scone
Cheddar Jalapeno Bagels
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Salted Caramel Square
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Blueberry Cupcake
Everything Bagels

“The staff here are super sweet 🙂🥰. They have a great variety of healthy food/treats and drinks. They also show some great art as well. Great place 🧁☕🦋“

4.7 Superb90 Reviews
COBS Bread Bakery • $
111 Fourth Ave, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Wild Blueberry \u0026 Custard Danish
Raspberry \u0026 Custard Danish
Spinach \u0026 Feta Croissant
Sourdough Sunflower Flax Loaf
Lemon Blueberry Scone
Blueberry Lemon Scone
Raspberry Scone
Whole Wheat Bun
Sourdough Loaf
Cape Seed Loaf

“Generally, lines are very long most of time (not if you cone early) but all products are very good. Cinnammon toast is excellent. There is very little chive in the garlic chive twist. Lemon curd cruffle is a little deceiving from the outside (could have been more filling)“

4.5 Superb135 Reviews
The Frosted Cupcake Bakery • $
524 Lake St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Cupcakes

“The Frosted Cupcake created our daughter's salted caramel wedding cake. It was DELICIOUS, BEAUTIFUL, and exactly what she wanted. Thank you for putting the ‘icing’ on the most wonderful wedding day! Highly, highly recommend Trudy and this amazing bakery. You won't be disappointed.“

4.6 Superb97 Reviews
St. Joseph Bakery Bakery • $
53 Facer St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Loganberry Syrup
Turkey Sandwich
Portuguese Tart
Pastel De Nata
Great Pickles
Sugar Waffles
Deli Meat
Salami

“Fabulous subs, friendly staff. Such a great little hidden gem:):)“

4.6 Superb97 Reviews
Itty Bitty Pie Company Bakery • $
353 Lake St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Shepherds Chipotley Buffalo Cauliflower
Strawberry and Coconut Cream Pie
Strawberry Cheesecake
Fruit Pies
Taco

“The best Mini Pies. Absolutely delicious.“

4.7 Superb60 Reviews
Preston Pies Bakery • $
214 Lakeport Rd, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Steak Pie & Pork Pie
Chicken Pot Pie
Empire Cookie

“OMG so thankful to our friends for sharing Preston Pies to us!! Steak & mushroom or steak & cheddar enveloped in that delicious crust!., The best, thank you!!“

4.6 Superb58 Reviews
Niagara Food Company/ Sweetie Pie's Bakery Ltd. Bakery • $
BEHIND NEW WAVE POOLS, 23 Hiscott St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Apple Pie

“Love the dark chocolate pecan pie. Sweet potato casserole was also amazing.“

4.9 Superb35 Reviews
Mitchell's Bakery and Marketplace Bakery • $
209 Carlton St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Leave the Gun Take the Cannoli
Butter Pecan Tarts
Cheese Trays
Pulled Pork
Fruit Trays

“Everything! We buy buns, cinnamon rolls, frozen Cannelloni. Spinach dip with pumpernickel bread, yum . Mini pizzas“

4.1 Good130 Reviews
Bone Apple Teeth Bakehouse Bakery • $
57 Ventura Dr., St. Catharines

“Their cookies are delightful! I love their fun shapes and colours, as well as their variety of flavours. They're just sweet enough with a nice texture. It's wonderful to find a vegan bakery with such style and flair to their products!“

4.8 Superb13 Reviews
Cakes By the Lake Niagara Bakery • $
38 Beachaven Dr, St. Catharines

“Sandra was so great to deal with. she accommodated my request and made the best tasting cupcakes for my daughters 16th birthday. Everyone loved the different flavours and gorgeous decorations. Also a very reasonable price too. I would order with Sandra again for my next occasion.“

4.7 Superb14 Reviews
Your Bakery Bakery • $
33 Lakeshore Rd #1a, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Cheese Danish
White or Whole Wheat
Black Forrest Cake
Mini Cream Horns
Sausage Rolls
Sausage Buns
Brownies
Cookies

“Very well priced bakery with super friendly staff. Their items are more on the sugary side, so be aware of that if it doesn' fit your palette.

The staff are always very kind and patient, and it always smells amazing inside. Everything is freshly baked and is not out more than a day. I visit often.“

4.2 Good39 Reviews
Scott's Classic Kitchen Bakery •
16 elanoredale cir, St. Catharines

“We ordered 100 tarts from Scott for daughters wedding. Scott individually wrapped an assortment of tarts including Skor, Turtles, Raisonette, etc. We used them as favours at each table setting and the rest were left on a tray by the door. There were none left! Guests are still raving about the most delicious butter tarts they ever had!! A big hit at the wedding! Thanks so much Scott! Will definitely be ordering from you again!“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Mrs Fields Pretzel Maker Bakery •
221 Glendale Ave, St. Catharines

“I’m surprised to see this Mrs. Fields Cookies & Pretzels location rated only 3 stars — I had a full 5-star experience! The staff were friendly, upbeat, and went out of their way to make me two fresh pretzels — the classic butter and salt. They came out warm, golden, and absolutely delicious! You can really taste the difference when they’re made fresh. Highly recommended for anyone craving a tasty snack while at the Pen Centre. I’ll definitely be back!“

3.7 Good3 Reviews
Caffe Gatti Cafe • $
3 Race St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Pear & Gorgonzola Pizza with Walnut & Gorgonzola Salad
Flatbread Homemade Pizza with Fresh Toppings
Strawberry Pecan Goat Cheese
Regular Coffee and Biscotti
Apple Pie with Custard
Breakfast Sandwiches
Prosciutto Sandwich
Lavender Lemonade
Pear Gorgonzola
Mini Cheesecake

“Went above and beyond! I live in Ottawa and my daughter is studying at Brock. I called around a few days ago looking for a way to get her a birthday cake. One of the staff at Caffe Gatti said she would deliver it personally as I was worried about the condition if it went through a delivery service. Arrived today for her birthday and she is very excited to try the Lemon Cello w berries with her friends. Thank you! Very pleased!“

4.5 Superb96 Reviews
Fiesta Empanada Bakery • $
142 St Paul St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Empanadas by Fiesta Empanada
Spinach \u0026 Feta
Chicken Empanada
Baked Empanada
Spinach & Feta
Beef Empanada

“5 stars!!!! The best empanada! 😍“

4.8 Superb48 Reviews
Balzac's Port Dalhousie Cafe • $
9 Lock St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Black Coffee and Ginger Molasses Cookie
Cactus Leaves Salad
Cafe Canadian
Butter Pecan
Carrot Cake
Margherita
Cookies

“Clean and friendly barista“

4.3 Superb95 Reviews
Tim Hortons Donuts • $
440 St David's Rd, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Oreo Donuts

“So disappointing when they just toss it in a bag on a warm day like today! Usually don't go to this Timmies but it was close to work! probably won't go back“

3.6 Good105 Reviews
Tim Hortons Food • $
275 Geneva St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Chicken Habanero Loaded Bowl
Blackberry Yuzu Lemonade Quencher
Slow Cooked Chicken Wrap
Fudge Brownie Iced Latte
Mango Starfruit Infusr
Double Toasted Bagel
Blueberry Sour Cream
Spider Doughnuts
Sea Salt Wedges
Mocha Latte

“the staff are very friendly and polite very clean“

3.4 Good174 Reviews
Tim Hortons Coffee Shops • $
260 Lake St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Farmer's Breakfast Wrap
Chocolate Glazed Timbit
Chocolate Chip Muffins
Vanilla Iced Capp
Croissant

“I typically only use the drive through as i'm in a rush in the morning, but the locations I go to on both geneva street and this one on Lake st are always friendly and efficient, and the lines aren't too bad through the drive through.“

3.3 Good142 Reviews
Tim Hortons Cafe • $
498 Ontario St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Medium Double Double Coffee and a Muffin in a Brown Paper Bag
Large Regular Coffee Sesame Bagel and Cream Cheese
Raw Croissant
Donut

“big kudos to your staff for serving a gentleman who walked up to the window in the rain. Not everyone has a car. But they should be able to get a Tim's! ☕❤“

3.3 Good143 Reviews
Tim Hortons Food • $
333 Ontario St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Maple Bacon Farmer's Breakfast Wrap
Chicken Bacon Ranch Grilled Wrap
Sausage Breakfast Sandwich
Bacon Breakfast Sandwich
Vanilla Creamy Chill
Coffee and a Muffin
Ice Cap and Muffin
Peach Quenchers
Sugar Cookie
Hash Brown

“At around 10:45am, I placed my order via drive thru at this location., And I went to the drive thru window and tried to use my Tim offers from the app, it didn’t work. I waited there at the window for over 4 minutes trying to scan the QR code that didn’t work at all. As I was in a hurry, I had to cancel order and leave as the offer didn’t work.. Later I checked that particular offer and found out that offer applies only for delivery order. It was completely my fault for not checking it properly. I apologize for what I did. The staffs were very friendly, tried to explain me. Really sorry about that.“

3.2 Average140 Reviews
Tim Hortons Coffee & Tea • $
353 Lake St, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Banana Real Fruit Chill Medium
Ymmm Spicy Thai Soup

“Tim Hortons never disappoints! Whether I’m grabbing a quick coffee on the go or sitting down for a snack, the experience is always enjoyable. Their coffee is consistently fresh and flavorful, and the selection of donuts and Timbits is always a treat. I love their breakfast sandwiches—delicious, affordable, and served quickly. The staff are friendly and efficient, even during busy times, and the atmosphere is cozy and inviting. It's the perfect spot for a quick pick-me-up or catching up with friends. Tim Hortons truly delivers quality and consistency every time. Highly recommend!“

3 Average104 Reviews
Tim Hortons Coffee Shops • $
525 Welland Ave, St. Catharines

Customers` Favorites

Turkey Bacon Club Sandwich
Junior Bacon Cheeseburger
Farmer's Breakfast Wrap
Grilled Breakfast Wrap
Chocolate Chip Muffins
Cherry Cheese Danish
Donut Multi-Pack
Sea Salt Wedges
Hash Brown
Croissant

“El café riquísimo El pan Hamburguesas con papas“

3 Average143 Reviews